Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Expectation at work around working hours?

139 replies

Hop27 · 26/05/2022 09:11

We are back in the office FT and have been for a while. Contracted hours are 8:30-5, however EVERYONE works more as and when required to meet deadlines, get through workload.
My boss has started complaining about everyone's timekeeping, apparently coming in late (8:15) and leaving early (5:15/30), I walked in at 8:05 and it was noted that I was 'late' lots of jibes about working part time if you leave at 5.
He wants to sit everyone down and explain the expectation is that everyone works 8-5:30/6pm - everyday and that it's respectful to ask permission to leave early or arrive late. He keeps going on about how flexible he is and will support everyone to work flexibly. Confused
If he isn't in the office he'll call after hours to see how your day was. I was on the train at 5:45, he called I answered and you could hear the disdain in his voice 'so you can't really talk because you've already left for the day and your on public transport' ....
AIBU (I doubt very much I am), I love my job but seriously how is this the way to treat people it's archaic. We are trying to hold an intervention about how ridiculous he is being!
(FWIW he is unhappy at home, it's common knowledge and uses work as an excuse not to go home)

OP posts:
DogsAndGin · 26/05/2022 14:14

What industry are you in OP? The only industry I’ve seen this is sales/recruitment - they want their office filled with people who are obsessed with making as much money and commission as possible, and that does mean working outside of your contracted hours.

Herejustforthisone · 26/05/2022 14:05

Set him on fire.

Or arrange that meeting and demand to know when the new contracts are being drawn up.

ThatsGoingToHurt · 26/05/2022 13:59

It sounds like where I used to work! Except we weren’t in the office full time. My firm wanted to pay 20/30% below the going rate and demanded people be back in the office 3 days a week even though site visits and meetings easily took up 2 or 3 days per week and most people were going into the office for 2 days and only doing one day from home! They were also notorious ‘Teams watchers’ and you would get comments that you were ‘not available’ if your green light went to amber. Managers wanted access to everyone’s diaries so they could ‘check where you were’. Needless to say people have left in droves…

Wexone · 26/05/2022 13:46

Reminds me of an old boss that pulled me up cause i was 10 mins late a few mornings. Nothing was said for the extra hour or so i did most eves. Or the fact that i had come in some Saturdays to help out as production ran 24/7 issues would come up. That was the start of her nit picking so needless to say i didn't stay too long after. In my line of work there is always emergencies and the need to step in after hours or the weekends. But i expect it back when i need something. Needless to say i didn't stay too long there and heard after she was fired shortly after i left too. I am now with a company who is flexible, if we work over our hours we get it back, and we get recognized if we go above and beyond. If i need to leave early for a doc appointment or come in late one day there is never an issue. Everyone works different. What you are describing above is not flexible. You need to have a serious chat with your manager, he cant go on like this. He will loose - not might- will loose staff over this

theemmadilemma · 26/05/2022 13:36

LookItsMeAgain · 26/05/2022 13:30

Mine says the latter to...but it is assumed both on the employers side and on mine that the extended hours would only be required say to get a project over the finish line and not as a regular occurrence. If it were to be regularised, then the employer has in effect changed the terms and conditions of my contract by stealth.
I would want to be financially compensated for the change in the t&c of my contract, and if my manager wasn't open to negotiations, I would get on to my union and see what could be done.

I'm not a lawyer but I would know when I'm being taken for a ride!

Exactly. Being told you are expected to work from X to X outside of your contractual hours is in no way to be interrupted the same as:

you may be expected to work different or additional hours to fulfil business needs

Plus, that senance usually contains an 'occassionally' in most contracts I've seen.

LookItsMeAgain · 26/05/2022 13:30

minipie · 26/05/2022 10:29

What exactly does the contract say?

Is it “working hours are 8.30-5” end of?

Or is it “working hours are 8.30-5 but you may be expected to work different or additional hours to fulfil business needs” or something like that?

Mine is the latter. I am a lawyer and contractual hours are kind of irrelevant tbh, everyone knows that the real hours are whatever it takes to get the job done.

I expect many professional/managerial roles have similar contractual wording unless you’ve specifically negotiated fixed hours.

So what does yours say..?

Mine says the latter to...but it is assumed both on the employers side and on mine that the extended hours would only be required say to get a project over the finish line and not as a regular occurrence. If it were to be regularised, then the employer has in effect changed the terms and conditions of my contract by stealth.
I would want to be financially compensated for the change in the t&c of my contract, and if my manager wasn't open to negotiations, I would get on to my union and see what could be done.

I'm not a lawyer but I would know when I'm being taken for a ride!

theemmadilemma · 26/05/2022 13:22

That's obscene, and it's clearly become a cultural expectation.

Both myself and my team do unpaid overtime, on occassion, when required, and we're encouraged to take the time back, with a lot of focus on work life/balance.

But regardless you need to challenge this formally like @Dishwashersaurous said. Don't dance around it. He's formally telling you your hours are different and longer than your contract. So where's the contract change?

Franca123 · 26/05/2022 13:19

@SlightlyGeordieJohn i get paid significantly more than 50 per hour as do lots of the people I manage. My industry has a culture of 9 - 5 and pays very well.

Crunchymum · 26/05/2022 13:11

Were you there before March 2020? What was the situation before lockdown?

I assume everyone was more willing and able to work longer hours when it was WFH?

Franca123 · 26/05/2022 13:08

And I'm paid a lot, not because I work long hours but because I deliver. I have a wealth of experience and skills. My team are set objectives and I protect them from unreasonable demands. What is the point in hiring great people and then burning them out? I want them on top form so I get the best out of their big brains. If that means skiving on Friday afternoon to recharge - great. If that means picking their kids up from school - great. If that means a 10am start - great. So long as they're on top of their work.

Franca123 · 26/05/2022 13:00

I've rarely worked beyond my contracted hours and have been promoted above those doing overtime more than once. Set your boundaries and be firm with them. And look for another job if this twat is bothering you.

Workingmygoddamnhoursonly · 26/05/2022 12:58

I worked in a school and got told off by the head for leaving 5 minutes earlier than she would have for a meeting at another school.

Prior to this conversation i always started work when I arrived (10-15 minutes early) and never complained when my unpaid lunch break was interrupted because I was the first aider.

so I did the mature thing and sat in my car for my lunch breaks and until 2 minutes before my shift.

donquixotedelamancha · 26/05/2022 12:57

Of course I do. I'll tell you what, champ, when you run your own division of your company, you organise it how you like. Until then, please don't try to tell others that they are doing it wrong.

Yeah, that's definitely not the sort of thing a toxic boss would say :-)

There's an awful lot of people trying to convince themselves that unpaid labour is the only way to have a highly paid job. It's not true

Yes, the irony is that most well paid jobs either charge (a fortune) by the hour or are salaried and trusted to organise their day to get things done, not clock-watched.

Presenteeism is shit management in the vast majority of situations.

fdgdfgdfgdfg · 26/05/2022 12:51

SlightlyGeordieJohn · 26/05/2022 10:04

You shouldn't judge how other employers value their staff from how you value yours.

I value all of my staff greatly, look after them as well as I can, and yes, they all tend to do more than their contracted hours.

Professions with a culture of extra hours also tend to be those with the highest pay. My staff, I think, put in 50-60 hours per week each on a 37 hour contract (there's no clocking in or out so I can't be certain), but even at the higher end of that scale they are still getting at least £50 per hour.

I can't see that someone doing 37 hours per week on £12 an hour is really winning the "game" as you put it.

Well, the people doing 37 hours a week probably actually have a life unlike your staff, so they're winning in that way.

I've always stuck to my contracted hours religiously. I don't have work email on my phone, I'm out of the office on time etc. If there's some disaster happening then yes, I'll work whatevers needed to solve the problem, but if that's happening more than once every 3 months or so, then something is very wrong with the company.

Doesn't seem to have hampered my career, I'm CTO of a medium sized business, and I hold my employees to the same standard that I work. You work your hours, occasionally yes you might have to work late, but you'll be compensated and recognised for it.

As far as I've noticed, the people who work 50 hour weeks are the ones who waffle on in meetings, have long phone calls etc. Which is fine, if thats how you work then great, as long as the work gets done.

If the work can't be done in 40 hours a week, then either you can't work efficiently or there's too much work, which is the companies problem to solve.

ToDoListAddict · 26/05/2022 12:51

I took a job once that was stated to be 9-5.
Some reports were due that day, which I completed and put on my managers desk for checking before lunchtime. She knew they were there.
At 5 to 5 I said to her, I'll send those reports tomorrow then.
She started looking at the reports (which was going to take longer than 5 minutes) but at 5pm I got up and said, bye see you tomorrow!
My colleagues were amazed that I was leaving on time with work unfinished.
Overtime wasn't paid and I wasn't going to wait around for her - the reports went the next day and the clients didn't complain.
I didn't stay there long once I learned that they expected a large amount of free overtime worked! The job just didn't pay enough to warrant that much dedication!

Dinotour · 26/05/2022 12:49

SlightlyGeordieJohn · 26/05/2022 10:49

Of course I do. I'll tell you what, champ, when you run your own division of your company, you organise it how you like. Until then, please don't try to tell others that they are doing it wrong.

Hey champ, how about you/your company employs enough people as to manage the workload without expecting lots of unpaid overtime as standard. Yes your expectations are wrong and I feel sorry for those who work for you.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 26/05/2022 12:44

There's an awful lot of people trying to convince themselves that unpaid labour is the only way to have a highly paid job. It's not true

You're absolutely right - it sounds so daft when you put it like that. It kind of reminds me of these phishing scams where they promise you will definitely receive a guaranteed payment of $3million, but you will have to pay them a $6,000 admin fee before they can release the funds!

Dinotour · 26/05/2022 12:44

orwellwasright · 26/05/2022 11:42

Very much enjoying the arsehole bosses insisting that working extra hours is the only way to have a successful career.

They would say that wouldn't they 😆

Thankfully in my industry this actually quite discriminatory expectation is fading. For those who have to leave at a certain time due to caring commitments (not just children) etc they have been sidelined for promotion and progression unfairly for far too long- its a horrible attitude that dedication to the role is supposedly in how many hours you work for free (like a mug). We should be normalising and encouraging doing your hours.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 26/05/2022 12:41

I wouldn't be happy with an hours king or queen who only does 9 to 5 but I wouldn't tell them off.

Would you feel the same about a client who paid you an agreed amount (whether hour-based or task-based) to deal with the figures for one financial period but then also thought it might be nice for you to make a good early start on the next period on an (unpaid) goodwill basis - just to show your dedication and that you aren't one of those dreadful 'work as agreed' kings or queens?

Edderkop · 26/05/2022 12:33

"You are going to get a lot of people agreeing with you but they will mostly be coming from a point of view of paid lower salaries and not concerned about career progression"

There's an awful lot of people trying to convince themselves that unpaid labour is the only way to have a highly paid job. It's not true

SlowHorses · 26/05/2022 12:32

Managers like this are idiots and is the very worst of middle managers. They should care about business outputs and outcomes rather than presenteeism, but they’re too stupid to understand the difference - of the many reasons the UK is arguably the most worked country in Europe with some of the lowest outputs. People can be in the office 8-6pm but working inefficiently and drinking tea/chatting all day, vs someone who gets their work done on time.

I’ve worked above my contracted hours for years, it was expected in my role/industry and seniority. In return I was very well paid and got a lot of flexibility, so it worked both ways.

However in this instance I’m not reading there was a pressing business deadline or customer project etc. - it’s just because he is a little
micro manager control freak who thinks this is the only way to exert authority.

I would 100% let him crack on with organising that meeting. Take copious notes and then follow up with a few emails of your own. It’s not comfortable but you either head this off now or you’ll be heading off to another job as it will grind you down.

ZenNudist · 26/05/2022 12:23

You are going to get a lot of people agreeing with you but they will mostly be coming from a point of view of paid lower salaries and not concerned about career progression. I am not sure what you mean by professional services because that's what I do (qualified accountant). We work long hours for high pay but at the junior levels you are working long hours for the promise of higher pay and its a bit exploitative.

I expect my staff to get the work done and that means a bit of overtime sometimes. I wouldn't be happy with an hours king or queen who only does 9 to 5 but I wouldn't tell them off. I know one she got promoted to manager but she's not going any further particularly fast.

It sounds as if you need to suck up the accepted hours to avoid the catty comments. If you are well paid you can absorb this. It depends on what you want out of your employer. I expect flexibility out of mine (for medical, child related and domestic reasons as well as leaving early for leisure when I need to or buggering off for a long lunch) and occasional treats (meals out, days out, bonuses). My company get a lot out of me but I wouldn't work well (or this hard) in an inflexible environment where someone is breathing down my neck.

I guess I'm saying you might need to get a new job.

starfishmummy · 26/05/2022 12:12

I've done jobs where I did my contracted hours and also jobs where starting early/staying late to get the job done were the norm - but we were either getting the time back or being paid extra for it.

I've also had the nightmare bosses in different jobs - one where I wasn't arriving early enough ignoring my late finishes, another ignoring early starts and saying I wasn't staying late enough!!

Dixiechickonhols · 26/05/2022 12:12

You sound young and capable. If it’s a small industry you may just be better jumping ship now to new firm. Dealing with boss/hr is very draining.
Don’t be tempted to do anything that could backfire on you. If you simmer with resentment you risk blowing up at work and facing disciplinary.

Crumbleburntbits · 26/05/2022 12:02

@Hop27 the main union for the construction industry is Unite. I’m sure they would be able to help you.