Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DS21 threatened DD18

485 replies

Safarigiraffe · 25/05/2022 22:30

Today when me/husband were at work DS was in the bathroom & DD had just got ready to leave to go to college. DD knocked on bathroom door & asked my son to hurry up as she was on a tight schedule to get the bus to leave, DS said to her no you have to wait and DD became agitated and started shouting at him to hurry up.
DS then came out the bathroom shoving daughter back in the stomach hard shouting/swearing & intimidating her so DD at this point was very visibly upset & shaking as it wasn’t like my son to react on this way and went to the bathroom to which DS then pushed the door open again shouting/swearing in her face.
DD was at college crying on/off all day, now we have spoken to DD & to DD saying this must never happen again, DS is refusing to apologise & DD never wants to speak to him ever again saying she now feels uncomfortable to be in the house with him however we both work and can’t take time off. (DD is at college DS at Uni)
Can anyone advise of the best way forward here
Many thanks to everyone

OP posts:
MrsLargeEmbodied · 27/05/2022 07:00

we dont know he was hogging the bathroom

Cinnamon1991 · 27/05/2022 00:46

@jaffacakesareepic well than in which case kick the son out. I am sure OP will not feel an ounce of responsibility when she learns he is a total whack job in his 30s. I suppose the fact that the daughter will be with a relative 'temporarily' maybe say 2 weeks till the situation is de-escalated just flew over your head.

If this was MY son abusing MY daughter, I would try this solution first. If my daughter was uncomfortable with living with her aunt for 2 weeks then I would move out with her. But in no means is my son being kicked out without me trying to resolve his 'psycho' tendencies.

But sure simply 'kick him out'...that is the solution to all the problems I suppose. It is quite clear this solution suggested by so many of you is not appealing to OP as she doesn't seem to respond positively to any of the posters calling for this amazing solution. 🙄

jaffacakesareepic · 27/05/2022 00:19

Cinnamon1991 · 26/05/2022 23:36

@CPL593H I will tell you why...i wish people read my advice before attacking me. This situation is not ideal and from the vibe OP is giving she doesn't really wanna kick out her son. This is STILL her son, it's not as simple as 'kick him out'....and then what? You kick him out you lose him forever, he will most like continue to be on the deviant path he is and become a full on abuser. They will feel like shit parents and at that point no intervention will work because it would be too late. Or try to intervene with professional help and intervene themselves, try their best to put their son on the right path through professional help etc. This way atleast there is a chance you can help BOTH children.

Explaining the situation to her DD and I am sure she would understand. You tell that girl you love her, her safety matters and so this is a temporary thing until they as parents set DS straight. I am not saying anyone has to follow my advice honestly. If you are ever in the situation as OP and wish to kick your son out by all means go for it. But from the tone OP is giving so far I can tell she doesn't want to kick out her son while also wishing to safeguard her daughter...hence this is what I came up with. If you don't agree with me then that's fine. It was just one of many solutions. Also I had a relative who was in a similar situation and when I was a lot younger me and my friends would be 'why doesn't she kick him out' but now having children of my own I know it's not as easy as that to just kick out a deviant child without atleast trying.

That relative is now doing well and intervention worked and now all sibling get along which is why I suggested it. Rather then kick him out right of the bat. Obviously if intervention fails and he continues to exhibit violent tendencies then hell yeah...kick him out. But atleast you would know you tried.

Im sure the daughter would understand too

Im sure the daughter would understand that its more important to keep an aggressive son living at home than her
Im sure the daughter woukd understand she was less important
Im sure the daughter woukd understand that if she dares complain about being assaulted she risks loosing her home
Im sure the daughter woukd understand that if men shove she should keep her mouth shut in future

Plenty there for her to understand

ThreeLittleDots · 26/05/2022 23:49

Cinnamon, the parents can't force the son to get professional help. He isn't sorry and he doesn't seem to care. Hardly a candidate is he?!

wellhelloitsme · 26/05/2022 23:43

This reply has been deleted

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

Absolutely. Awful suggestion.

lameasahorse · 26/05/2022 23:43

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

Cinnamon1991 · 26/05/2022 23:36

@CPL593H I will tell you why...i wish people read my advice before attacking me. This situation is not ideal and from the vibe OP is giving she doesn't really wanna kick out her son. This is STILL her son, it's not as simple as 'kick him out'....and then what? You kick him out you lose him forever, he will most like continue to be on the deviant path he is and become a full on abuser. They will feel like shit parents and at that point no intervention will work because it would be too late. Or try to intervene with professional help and intervene themselves, try their best to put their son on the right path through professional help etc. This way atleast there is a chance you can help BOTH children.

Explaining the situation to her DD and I am sure she would understand. You tell that girl you love her, her safety matters and so this is a temporary thing until they as parents set DS straight. I am not saying anyone has to follow my advice honestly. If you are ever in the situation as OP and wish to kick your son out by all means go for it. But from the tone OP is giving so far I can tell she doesn't want to kick out her son while also wishing to safeguard her daughter...hence this is what I came up with. If you don't agree with me then that's fine. It was just one of many solutions. Also I had a relative who was in a similar situation and when I was a lot younger me and my friends would be 'why doesn't she kick him out' but now having children of my own I know it's not as easy as that to just kick out a deviant child without atleast trying.

That relative is now doing well and intervention worked and now all sibling get along which is why I suggested it. Rather then kick him out right of the bat. Obviously if intervention fails and he continues to exhibit violent tendencies then hell yeah...kick him out. But atleast you would know you tried.

lameasahorse · 26/05/2022 23:18

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

CPL593H · 26/05/2022 22:59

Cinnamon1991 · 26/05/2022 22:00

@blueshoes oh get over yourself. If you even read what I wrote I strictly condemned the son's behaviour and told OP to send her daughter to live with close relatives till he is sorted via professional intervention. I also mentioned that if her DD only shouted 'get out, hurry up etc' then she is totally not to blame. The account of the scenario came from her DD. If I swore at my bro I wouldn't really admit it to my mother. So the advice here was to talk to both children to specify the events. Stop getting your panties in a twist.

@Cinnamon1991 Can you explain why it should be the daughter who has to leave the house rather than him? He hasn't denied what he's done, the parents believe that she's telling the truth, but she has to be the one to leave. Why?

wellhelloitsme · 26/05/2022 22:34

Isahlo · 26/05/2022 22:30

Your son was bang out of order but your daughter does need to know, if someone is in the bathroom and they’re using that space, and have told you to wait that is the end of the story,
you don’t get to get aggy about that. It’s part and parcel of sharing a home

your son was a massive twat, and needs repercussions but important to address bathroom entitlement as a separate issue

Did you miss this bit?

My DD only wanted to grab something out the bathroom to leave she wasn’t wanting to use the bathroom as she was already ready

If he had just passed her what she needed then none of this would have happened. She was just trying to get the bus on time!

blueshoes · 26/05/2022 22:30

cinnammon1991: Stop getting your panties in a twist.

Panties Grin Love it

Isahlo · 26/05/2022 22:30

Your son was bang out of order but your daughter does need to know, if someone is in the bathroom and they’re using that space, and have told you to wait that is the end of the story,
you don’t get to get aggy about that. It’s part and parcel of sharing a home

your son was a massive twat, and needs repercussions but important to address bathroom entitlement as a separate issue

blueshoes · 26/05/2022 22:28

Aubriella · 26/05/2022 18:06

My brother is aggressive too, the first time he slammed a door into me (after screaming at me), I called the police (despite my mum begging me not to). Like a coward, he left the house.

The police were really good and took it seriously. I decided not to take it further but it scared my brother the fucker and he never pulled that stunt again.

Always call the police in the face of aggressive behaviour.

This has been my experience as the female in the house subject to aggressive male behaviour. It stopped it in its tracks and he never tried it again. We have a good relationship now.

TheCatterall · 26/05/2022 22:22

But it’s not ‘all sorted’ is it?

he hasn’t and is refusing to apologise or really discuss his over reaction.

even if she was rushing or annoying him his reaction was unacceptable.

will he do that to future partners. Would he do it to his mother.

bet he wouldn’t do it to his dad…

The possibility of him doing drugs in the bathroom whilst she was interrupting him does sound feasible. That or he’s an aggressive dickhead with women?

Cinnamon1991 · 26/05/2022 22:00

@blueshoes oh get over yourself. If you even read what I wrote I strictly condemned the son's behaviour and told OP to send her daughter to live with close relatives till he is sorted via professional intervention. I also mentioned that if her DD only shouted 'get out, hurry up etc' then she is totally not to blame. The account of the scenario came from her DD. If I swore at my bro I wouldn't really admit it to my mother. So the advice here was to talk to both children to specify the events. Stop getting your panties in a twist.

Sugarplumfairy65 · 26/05/2022 20:10

Safarigiraffe · 25/05/2022 23:26

I don’t want to kick my son out as it was very very out of character for him & my DD said that he’s never reacted that way & she was very shocked

Would you advise your daughter to kick a boyfriend out if he assaulted her like that?

Stop making excuses for him! He's abusive!

billy1966 · 26/05/2022 20:04

Aubriella · 26/05/2022 18:06

My brother is aggressive too, the first time he slammed a door into me (after screaming at me), I called the police (despite my mum begging me not to). Like a coward, he left the house.

The police were really good and took it seriously. I decided not to take it further but it scared my brother the fucker and he never pulled that stunt again.

Always call the police in the face of aggressive behaviour.

Well done you.👏👏👏

That is exactly what should be done with thugs.

Puts manners on them and makes them think twice.

Mothers allowing their daughters be assaulted or bullied by male siblings are utter scum and deserve everything coming to them in the future, as their daughters mature and gain perspective.

billy1966 · 26/05/2022 20:00

NiqueNique · 26/05/2022 17:12

I think some people are definitely being deliberately obtuse...unless there are a lot more really dumb people in the world than I had thought.

It has truly been eye opening to read the sub culture of idiocy that happily defends, questions, and explains away any thread that involves males violence on MN.

I have no doubt some are males posting, but it is very clear that there are many women for which a slap here or there isn't the end of the world, and those that are appalled by this are somehow "up themselves".

jaffacakesareepic · 26/05/2022 19:06

ancientgran · 26/05/2022 16:43

@Safarigiraffe These two posts don't add up.

No as she went into the bathroom to close the door he pushed the door open stopping her from closing the door
My DD only wanted to grab something out the bathroom to leave she wasn’t wanting to use the bathroom as she was already ready

If she only wanted to grab something why did she need to close the door?

Why is this even important?

In at least two houses ive lived in I had to close the bathroom door to get into the bathroom cabinet, simply because of the room layout

So, even ignoring the fact that most people would want a barrier between them and someone who just got aggressive with them, she might not have had a choice

Claiming this means her story doesnt add up when you dont know the room layout etc is clutching at straws to victim blame

Mumwantingtogetitright · 26/05/2022 19:02

Well this thread has been quite eye opening in terms of seeing how many people are so eager to minimise violent behaviour when it suits them. It explains quite a lot!

MeridianB · 26/05/2022 18:32

Agree with all PPs saying this man’s behaviour is appalling.

If you’re serious about impressing on him how totally wrong this is then you have to really mean it. He has to know it’s totally unacceptable. His “it’s sorted” attitude is disgusting and suggests he is really comfortable and confident that there won’t be any consequences. Shame on him.

Aubriella · 26/05/2022 18:06

My brother is aggressive too, the first time he slammed a door into me (after screaming at me), I called the police (despite my mum begging me not to). Like a coward, he left the house.

The police were really good and took it seriously. I decided not to take it further but it scared my brother the fucker and he never pulled that stunt again.

Always call the police in the face of aggressive behaviour.

Branleuse · 26/05/2022 17:52

Laiste · 26/05/2022 11:04

@Branleuse - Boys and young men need coming down on like a ton of bricks if they square up to a woman, but i think kicking him out would do more harm than good, and long term harm too.

What does coming down like a ton of bricks look like with a 21 year old man? If it's not asking him to leave?

And have you read the post above yours?

They need it making very very clear that they cant act like that. They need to understand how to not react when angry.
Most people I know with older teenage or young adult children, especially boys have had to deal with aggression (if theyll admit to it), and anger is something many young people need to learn how to manage appropriately. They dont get booted out of home the first time it happens. Yes its distressing.
I was bullied by my brother and we are NC now. Its not ok, but we deal with the hand we are dealt. If your child gets pissed off and aggressive one day, you work out how to get it through to them. You dont just abandon them. Theyre still your kid. It sounds like somethings going on for him, but that is absolutely not the right way to deal with someone annoying you, because as people say, in any other situation he would probably be dealt with by the police and possibly have a record.
Families who say theyd kick their kid out at first incident of aggression, I think probably wouldnt in reality, and if they did, then i think thats a cop out.
If the other family members are genuinely in danger, then thats another matter

wellhelloitsme · 26/05/2022 17:26

@ancientgran

Doesn't make sense to me. She wanted to go to college so why would you go in the bathroom and shut the door, she's have to come out at some point. If she wanted to get away from him it would be better to forget the bathroom and leave.

Makes perfect sense to me. If a man has shoved me and is literally shouting and swearing in my face I would want to get away from him as quickly as possible, for example jumping into the bathroom and locking the door.

Unfortunately for OP's DD, her brother managed to open the door again and continue shouting and swearing in her face.

Amazing you think everyone would think clearly when faced with an aggressive man bigger and stronger than them squaring up to them, especially if them doing so is a shock.

WDTABNONONO · 26/05/2022 17:25

It's not OK to hit our at someone because they are shouting and swearing at you.

I cannot tell you how many times someone has done that to me but I never felt the need to shove, hit or otherwise touch them.

I may have sworn back, told them to shut up etc but not assaulted them.

The test is would a police officer arrest you and charge you with an offence solely based on you shouting (non discriminatory of course).

No, they'd warn you and get you moving.

Would they arrest and charge you for shoving someone hard? I expect so!

Because it's a sibling has no barring. Those that say there is no power imbalance because they are siblings - hello, he's a male and he's older - of course there is.

Id have much more sympathy for this girls brother if he sincerely apologised and agreed he may need to seek help for his temper. If he did this I feel a stern talking to would be enough at this stage.

But he's not acknowledging what he has done and he's not apologising. He's disrespecting his parents as well now as he's shutting down communication. This is what would make it tip it for me for wanting him to move out as he clearly doesn't care.

Evening If I felt I wasn't in the wrong, if I had made someone feel so frightened of me and sad you bet I'd apologise!

Id investigate into whether he is taking drugs if his behaviour is normally completely unlike this. But if he won't seek help and admit to what he's done you need to put the more vulnerable person first, which is your daughter, OP. .