Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DS21 threatened DD18

485 replies

Safarigiraffe · 25/05/2022 22:30

Today when me/husband were at work DS was in the bathroom & DD had just got ready to leave to go to college. DD knocked on bathroom door & asked my son to hurry up as she was on a tight schedule to get the bus to leave, DS said to her no you have to wait and DD became agitated and started shouting at him to hurry up.
DS then came out the bathroom shoving daughter back in the stomach hard shouting/swearing & intimidating her so DD at this point was very visibly upset & shaking as it wasn’t like my son to react on this way and went to the bathroom to which DS then pushed the door open again shouting/swearing in her face.
DD was at college crying on/off all day, now we have spoken to DD & to DD saying this must never happen again, DS is refusing to apologise & DD never wants to speak to him ever again saying she now feels uncomfortable to be in the house with him however we both work and can’t take time off. (DD is at college DS at Uni)
Can anyone advise of the best way forward here
Many thanks to everyone

OP posts:
NeverDropYourMooncup · 27/05/2022 15:16

I reckon that the first female many abusive men ever assault are their sisters.

And they get away with it.

After all, once it's OK to push and shove a young woman and corner her whilst screaming and shouting at them so they are terrified, it's not that much of a leap to do the same to the next female that irritates them. Especially when Mummy says she won't punish him but hopes it doesn't happen again.

CPL593H · 27/05/2022 15:09

MrsTerryPratchett · 27/05/2022 14:29

Its not a pleasant place to be when you think your parents would cut you off or throw you out if you made a mistake

I think that's the crux of it. He doesn't think he made a mistake. He hasn't acknowledged it or apologised to his sister. If he'd said, "shit I'm so sorry that was a step too far, it won't ever happen again" he'd have a different reception both from his sister, and from MN.

In this scenario, you're asking a young woman to live with an unrepentant man who assaulted her.

Or still worse, leave her home so his parents can work on his issues, as one poster suggested.

The lack of apology is the crux for me. An immediate and heartfelt one and reassurance that he knew he was in the wrong would indeed change this to my mind. The absence of remorse and the ridiculous "sorted" thing very much indicates he thinks he did nothing wrong.

My younger brother was a clear foot taller than me when he was 18 (and I'm not petite) I would have been absolutely terrified and incredibly upset had he shoved me in the stomach and continued to shout and swear in my face. I would however feel exactly the same had his sister been the physical aggressor.

HangOnToYourself · 27/05/2022 15:01

I just wanted to say I'm glad you have taken this seriously OP. I lived with a violent and abusive brother who was 2 years older than me for my teenage years. Despite living in absolute terror and frequently sporting black eyes nobody helped me and it was brushed off as normal sibling squabbling. I grew up to be a very anxious adult and I burst into tears at the slightest confrontation due to the behaviour I had to put up with. Please protect your daughter.

Onlyforcake · 27/05/2022 14:59

But he did act violently. Even if the 18 year was channelling a pestering whiny younger teen drama llama a 21 year old shouldn't be using a physical response.

lameasahorse · 27/05/2022 14:56

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

Derbee · 27/05/2022 14:53

@MrsTerryPratchett you said woman, plenty haven’t

Derbee · 27/05/2022 14:52

@wellhelloitsme if the son is in a position of everyone accusing him of being violent and needing to be kicked out/seek professional help, he may not have a reasonable space to discuss what happened.

Or he might be a massive shit who needs to leave the home. But it CANNOT be black and white to a forum of internet strangers who don’t know any of the people involved

MrsTerryPratchett · 27/05/2022 14:50

Derbee · 27/05/2022 14:40

They are BOTH adults. The language here is telling. MN forums will always be ready to condemn men.

MAN, MALE

YOUNG GIRL, DAUGHTER

Both adults, but god forbid we imply that an ADULT FEMALE also has behavioural standards to uphold. People are infantilising her, and trying to widen the age/power dynamic between 2 siblings who have had a totally inappropriately expressed fight.

I said young woman, because she is.

wellhelloitsme · 27/05/2022 14:48

Derbee · 27/05/2022 14:47

@lameasahorse we only have the daughters side of the story. Kids (although these 2 are technically adults) are never forthcoming about what they may have done in a sibling fight/fallout. We actually have NO IDEA exactly what happened. Neither does the OP.

Before accusing the son of being a violent woman beater and domestic abuser, it would be more realistic to sit them both down and find out what happened, and what steps need to be taken to ensure it NEVER happens again.

Not hearing one side, turning against one of your children, and kicking them out of the house without a discussion.

Don't you think it's likely if it didn't happen the way DD said it did, DS would have spoken up instead of saying he won't apologise and won't discuss it? He'd be keen to defend himself if she's lying.

Derbee · 27/05/2022 14:47

@lameasahorse we only have the daughters side of the story. Kids (although these 2 are technically adults) are never forthcoming about what they may have done in a sibling fight/fallout. We actually have NO IDEA exactly what happened. Neither does the OP.

Before accusing the son of being a violent woman beater and domestic abuser, it would be more realistic to sit them both down and find out what happened, and what steps need to be taken to ensure it NEVER happens again.

Not hearing one side, turning against one of your children, and kicking them out of the house without a discussion.

lameasahorse · 27/05/2022 14:42

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

Derbee · 27/05/2022 14:40

They are BOTH adults. The language here is telling. MN forums will always be ready to condemn men.

MAN, MALE

YOUNG GIRL, DAUGHTER

Both adults, but god forbid we imply that an ADULT FEMALE also has behavioural standards to uphold. People are infantilising her, and trying to widen the age/power dynamic between 2 siblings who have had a totally inappropriately expressed fight.

MrsTerryPratchett · 27/05/2022 14:29

Its not a pleasant place to be when you think your parents would cut you off or throw you out if you made a mistake

I think that's the crux of it. He doesn't think he made a mistake. He hasn't acknowledged it or apologised to his sister. If he'd said, "shit I'm so sorry that was a step too far, it won't ever happen again" he'd have a different reception both from his sister, and from MN.

In this scenario, you're asking a young woman to live with an unrepentant man who assaulted her.

Branleuse · 27/05/2022 13:07

wellhelloitsme · 27/05/2022 11:59

@Branleuse

He won't apologise or discuss it. Which sounds to me like he doesn't give a fuck about what happened. Hard to believe a man who doesn't give a fuck about it won't do it again IMO.

I couldnt say either way, but ive never been a one strike and youre out kind of person for my children.
People seem to have more compassion for a dog that bites someone if they can see even the slightest hint that it might have felt provoked, than they do for a young bloke that barged into his sister in a mood after being harrassed.

I actually dont even think that kicking her brother out is necessarily in the best interests of the sister. Its not a pleasant place to be when you think your parents would cut you off or throw you out if you made a mistake, and that would be a lot for her to carry if it affected their relationship.

If this was a guy with a history of bullying his sister, id say differently

Badgirlriri · 27/05/2022 12:56

Soontobe60 · 26/05/2022 06:27

What she has described is siblings having an argument. I really can’t believe some of the comments on here! One sibling is trying to get ready in the bathroom, the other sibling is yelling at them to hurry up, first sibling comes out of the bathroom and pushes them out of the way. Both were angry, one person started the row.

Exactly! Some of these posters are crazy! Man bashing agenda.

lameasahorse · 27/05/2022 12:42

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

chiangmai · 27/05/2022 12:32

What i find interesting is everyone screaming about the DS here being an abuser after a one off incident. We are dealing with two siblings, both adults, both got wound up with each other and one screaming and the other pushing his sibling. This isnt a DH /wife issue this is sibling relationship and you cant compare like for like. The OP isnt going to throw one of her kids out so lets be sensible about the way forward following a one off incident.

blueshoes · 27/05/2022 12:24

This.

As a grown man (and however immature a 21 year old is, he IS a grown man physically), pushing, shoving or in any way physically threatening a woman is a redline.

That is the ONLY lesson he needs to know. There is absolutely no justification for laying a hand on a woman. He needs to walk away. No excuse whatsoever, particularly from the 'she made me do it' apologists here.

This is a redline that is carved in stone.

wellhelloitsme · 27/05/2022 11:59

@Branleuse

He won't apologise or discuss it. Which sounds to me like he doesn't give a fuck about what happened. Hard to believe a man who doesn't give a fuck about it won't do it again IMO.

jaffacakesareepic · 27/05/2022 11:19

Cinnamon1991 · 27/05/2022 00:46

@jaffacakesareepic well than in which case kick the son out. I am sure OP will not feel an ounce of responsibility when she learns he is a total whack job in his 30s. I suppose the fact that the daughter will be with a relative 'temporarily' maybe say 2 weeks till the situation is de-escalated just flew over your head.

If this was MY son abusing MY daughter, I would try this solution first. If my daughter was uncomfortable with living with her aunt for 2 weeks then I would move out with her. But in no means is my son being kicked out without me trying to resolve his 'psycho' tendencies.

But sure simply 'kick him out'...that is the solution to all the problems I suppose. It is quite clear this solution suggested by so many of you is not appealing to OP as she doesn't seem to respond positively to any of the posters calling for this amazing solution. 🙄

The son is currently refusing to apologise or even acknowledging his wrongdoing but somehow two weeks without his sister is going to be sufficient to change his whole attitude?

And the test, move the teenage girl back in and sit back and wait and see if the adult male assaults her again.

Its not things flying over my head that is the problem here

The son is an adult. His adult actions have adult consequnces. Teaching him that if he assaults those he lives with he is no longer welcome to live with them until he sorts his behaviour out is a consequence for him.

Disrupting his sisters entire life whilst nothing changes for him teaches him his adult actions have no consequences for him. Im not sure what you think he is going to learn from that other than he can do what he likes and others pay the price.

Schools stop bullying by excluding the bully not the victim. Society stops violence (not currently well but thats another story) by excluding the agressor from society not the victim.

Branleuse · 27/05/2022 11:17

wellhelloitsme · 27/05/2022 10:55

Exactly this.

@Branleuse he didn't just push past her, he shoved her.

Ops son shoved his sister out of the way in an aggressive way when she was hassling him to get out of the bathroom. Id say he was more in the wrong than her, but Its not the same as a husband doing it to a wife.

Why isn't it the same? He's an adult. He's bigger and stronger than her. She wanted to grab something from the bathroom because she had to get the bus on time. He could have passed it to her. He escalated this to a ridiculous level, hurt her and frightened her. He then wouldn't let her keep the door shut to get away from him or de-escalate the situation, instead he burst in and continue to shout and swear in her face aggressively, frightening her further.

because theyre siblings that have grown up together and have lived together forever. They didnt choose them. It was one overrreacting when the other was being annoying.
You know there is a middle ground between him being an aggressive womanbeater that needs to be kicked out of his parents house for safety reasons, and him being an innocent boy who can do no wrong.
She was acting like a dick. He reacted by being even more of a dick.
We stay with our families usually until we are mature enough to go out into the world. He has done this acting like a bloody child and hes not. Hes too big. Id be fucking furious with him, but i also really really hate it when I get harrassed to leave the bathroom by people who should be more organised, and thankfully I can control myself , but sometimes it pisses me off more than others. I do not expect my 21 year old to have the same maturity as me. Family life can be bloody difficult

wellhelloitsme · 27/05/2022 10:55

Grumblemonster · 27/05/2022 10:23

Why are so many posters saying he shoved past her or shoved her out of the way? She says he shoved her in the stomach which sounds like an aggressive push with his hand or hands, rather than pushing past someone which would be more like jostling. Plus having got past her he turned around to push the door open so he could continue being abusive to her. He wasn't just trying to get past her to leave the bathroom because she was in the way. He was punishing her for her having the temerity to shout at him to hurry up.

Exactly this.

@Branleuse he didn't just push past her, he shoved her.

Ops son shoved his sister out of the way in an aggressive way when she was hassling him to get out of the bathroom. Id say he was more in the wrong than her, but Its not the same as a husband doing it to a wife.

Why isn't it the same? He's an adult. He's bigger and stronger than her. She wanted to grab something from the bathroom because she had to get the bus on time. He could have passed it to her. He escalated this to a ridiculous level, hurt her and frightened her. He then wouldn't let her keep the door shut to get away from him or de-escalate the situation, instead he burst in and continue to shout and swear in her face aggressively, frightening her further.

Grumblemonster · 27/05/2022 10:23

Why are so many posters saying he shoved past her or shoved her out of the way? She says he shoved her in the stomach which sounds like an aggressive push with his hand or hands, rather than pushing past someone which would be more like jostling. Plus having got past her he turned around to push the door open so he could continue being abusive to her. He wasn't just trying to get past her to leave the bathroom because she was in the way. He was punishing her for her having the temerity to shout at him to hurry up.

Branleuse · 27/05/2022 10:00

This reply has been deleted

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

Its ALL part and parcel of living together. Also being around people who you are going to see at their worst. When theyre premenstrual, when they havent slept, when they have mental health issues, when theyre in a rush.
Living with other people is generally pretty hellish. Becomes more so as they are getting ready to leave the nest. If it was all joy then kids would never move out.

I dunno, sometimes being on mumsnet makes me feel like im from a different world. Im glad times are moving forward so that violence and aggression are seen as serious issues that need to be dealt with, but my experience is that conflict is really normal in households between siblings. Ops son shoved his sister out of the way in an aggressive way when she was hassling him to get out of the bathroom. Id say he was more in the wrong than her, but Its not the same as a husband doing it to a wife.

This would have been normal for my grandparents, my parents, my own childhood, most of my cousins, my friends childhoods. Older sisters are just as horrible as older brothers. The sibling relationship is not like other relationships.

Maybe they used to have the right idea expecting kids to be out and already married and working by now rather than acting like stupid entitled kids, and then one demanding the other is kicked out.
Noones got any bloody resilience anymore. People are speaking as if this guy is systematically beating his family members up.
It just feels very unrealistic.
I wouldnt blame the girl for not speaking to her brother for a while. What I dont think is useful is for any child to demand their parent kick out another child.

I would say that its a sign they should be looking to move on though

HikingforScenery · 27/05/2022 07:23

Thinking of you OP. Hope you’ve managed to settle things between your children and this will never happen again. I’m sure you’ll do what is best for your whole family.
You sound like loving parents. Take care