Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DS21 threatened DD18

485 replies

Safarigiraffe · 25/05/2022 22:30

Today when me/husband were at work DS was in the bathroom & DD had just got ready to leave to go to college. DD knocked on bathroom door & asked my son to hurry up as she was on a tight schedule to get the bus to leave, DS said to her no you have to wait and DD became agitated and started shouting at him to hurry up.
DS then came out the bathroom shoving daughter back in the stomach hard shouting/swearing & intimidating her so DD at this point was very visibly upset & shaking as it wasn’t like my son to react on this way and went to the bathroom to which DS then pushed the door open again shouting/swearing in her face.
DD was at college crying on/off all day, now we have spoken to DD & to DD saying this must never happen again, DS is refusing to apologise & DD never wants to speak to him ever again saying she now feels uncomfortable to be in the house with him however we both work and can’t take time off. (DD is at college DS at Uni)
Can anyone advise of the best way forward here
Many thanks to everyone

OP posts:
mathanxiety · 28/05/2022 21:50

If DD had just banged on the door and not sworn, and DS had sworn back and pushed her, would that be different?

If DD had just shouted/sworn, and he had sworn and pushed her, would that have been different?

What you are basically saying here is that there are circumstances in which a man can push a woman - if she really annoys him, or disturbs something he's doing, for instance.

I'm just trying to get a feel for exactly the combination of behaviours your DD needs to avoid in order to not create the conditions in which she can expect her brother to push her.

Scianel · 28/05/2022 21:43

You've let your daughter down.

Branleuse · 28/05/2022 21:42

Its not condoning anything, just because you dont kick your kid out for it

Safarigiraffe · 28/05/2022 21:42

I don’t feel that my son should have used physical force he had been spoken to by both me/husband so my husband feels he’s more to blame for not only swearing back but using physical force even though DD18 started it all off by banging on door/swearing first - DS could have handled this situation better however so could DD as well by not banging on door & swearing when she was already ready for college and only wanted 1 thing from bathroom

OP posts:
mathanxiety · 28/05/2022 21:38

Is physical force justified in response to swearing, or could DS have handled this better?

wellhelloitsme · 28/05/2022 21:33

You're condoning a physical reaction by a stronger, bigger person to a verbal outburst by a smaller, weaker person.

The two aren't equal and it's sad for your kids that you think so. For your daughter, it's sad because she doesn't feel safe.

And for your son, because you've just taught him that sometimes, women deserve to be hit if they wind you up.

One more man with an increase potential (obviously not all come to fruition) to become abusive to women when he feels angry.

Good luck.

Safarigiraffe · 28/05/2022 21:25

Hi all just to update, needed to see how things would turn out with DS & DD many thanks for all comments. At the moment DS & DD are ignoring each other however without taking sides I feel both of them are equally to blame - DS for pushing & DD for swearing at him first so yes DS shouldn’t of pushed but equally DD needs to understand she can’t just swear & call him all names under the sun (and no I’m not condoning DS behaviour at all)

OP posts:
Aubriella · 27/05/2022 16:45

wellhelloitsme Grin

and they never return to the thread

Mumwantingtogetitright · 27/05/2022 16:43

I'm really not projecting anything. I don't have any experience of being on the receiving end of violence, thankfully. I'm just looking objectively at what the OP said and what I see is that the DS physically assaulted his sister.

If a man shoved a woman hard in the stomach in any other scenario, it would be regarded as assault, without question. I genuinely don't understand why the fact of it being a sibling relationship makes this ok? Would it be OK for a man to do this to his daughter, I wonder? For a son to do it to his mum? For a husband to do it to his wife? Personally, I can't see why any of these would be OK.

It seems to me that the people who are actually projecting here are perhaps the mothers of sons who believe that their sons would be capable of this behaviour towards their female family members, and they would rather not see it for what it is because they don't want to see their sons as potential abusers.

Don't people teach their children that violence is never acceptable (except perhaps in self defence)? If so, why is this OK?

wellhelloitsme · 27/05/2022 16:40

@Aubriella

Why do posts from women sharing their experiences make posters called 'Brian' insult and minimise their experiences? I wonder...

Quite.

I'm surprised they didn't throw 'hysterical' in there for a full house!

Aubriella · 27/05/2022 16:37

mynameisbrian · 27/05/2022 16:19

I think this thread is all a little OTT- if the OP had come on here and stated her DD was being regularly shoved , pushed by her big brother i would agree with the repsonses.
Howver a one off incident with no previous should be able to be sorted out between siblings with parents involved as required. Folks banging on about being abused in their own homes by brothers are projecting. The issue here is the son needs to be spoken to about assaulting his sister. As a mother of 3 boys they have been brought knowing assaulting woman whether that be physical or emotional is not acceptable. That includes their sister. So I am not minimising this situation.

Funny enough my DD would be considered the abuser in my house with my 3 boys. She is rude, arrogant and regulalry hogs the toilet and bathroom. Helps herself to peoples things. Her older brother has lost the plot it with her and he would have been viewed as being abusive when he lost it the once he did.
He isnt an abuser and i didnt throw him out. I dealt with my DD to talk to her about her attitude within the home.

Why do posts from women sharing their experiences make posters called 'Brian' insult and minimise their experiences? I wonder....

Innocenta · 27/05/2022 16:36

@mynameisbrian Wow. Among stiff competition, you may have taken the 'worst post of the thread' award.

MrsTerryPratchett · 27/05/2022 16:34

Folks banging on about being abused in their own homes by brothers are projecting.

'Banging on'. Thanks.

Coyoacan · 27/05/2022 16:31

Why can't people teach their children not to physically assault their siblings? It might be a starting place for the end of domestic violence in general.

It is terrifying to see how many women will defend a violent man.

wellhelloitsme · 27/05/2022 16:30

wellhelloitsme · 27/05/2022 16:21

Folks banging on about being abused in their own homes by brothers are projecting.

Was there really a need to describe people sharing their personal stories as 'banging on'?

As a mother of 3 boys they have been brought knowing assaulting woman whether that be physical or emotional is not acceptable. That includes their sister.

And yet when it happens to your sister, it was apparently deserved, he wasn't labelled abusive and you bollocked her...

Her older brother has lost the plot it with her and he would have been viewed as being abusive when he lost it the once he did. He isnt an abuser and i didnt throw him out. I dealt with my DD to talk to her about her attitude within the home.

To their sister that was meant to say.

lameasahorse · 27/05/2022 16:29

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

wellhelloitsme · 27/05/2022 16:21

Folks banging on about being abused in their own homes by brothers are projecting.

Was there really a need to describe people sharing their personal stories as 'banging on'?

As a mother of 3 boys they have been brought knowing assaulting woman whether that be physical or emotional is not acceptable. That includes their sister.

And yet when it happens to your sister, it was apparently deserved, he wasn't labelled abusive and you bollocked her...

Her older brother has lost the plot it with her and he would have been viewed as being abusive when he lost it the once he did. He isnt an abuser and i didnt throw him out. I dealt with my DD to talk to her about her attitude within the home.

mynameisbrian · 27/05/2022 16:19

I think this thread is all a little OTT- if the OP had come on here and stated her DD was being regularly shoved , pushed by her big brother i would agree with the repsonses.
Howver a one off incident with no previous should be able to be sorted out between siblings with parents involved as required. Folks banging on about being abused in their own homes by brothers are projecting. The issue here is the son needs to be spoken to about assaulting his sister. As a mother of 3 boys they have been brought knowing assaulting woman whether that be physical or emotional is not acceptable. That includes their sister. So I am not minimising this situation.

Funny enough my DD would be considered the abuser in my house with my 3 boys. She is rude, arrogant and regulalry hogs the toilet and bathroom. Helps herself to peoples things. Her older brother has lost the plot it with her and he would have been viewed as being abusive when he lost it the once he did.
He isnt an abuser and i didnt throw him out. I dealt with my DD to talk to her about her attitude within the home.

wellhelloitsme · 27/05/2022 16:11

Snoozer11 · 27/05/2022 15:40

Brother and sister have a spat.

... which brother escalates to physical violence.

They are not equal parties in this.

lameasahorse · 27/05/2022 15:44

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

madasawethen · 27/05/2022 15:41

OP I do hope you read the experiences of the many women on here who were abused by their brothers and their parents looked the other way.

Just because you haven't seen it doesn't mean you can say it's out of character.
For all you know, he has assaulted, pushed, slapped, threatened, intimidated girls he has dated. You really don't know.

For you to say even DD said it was out of character makes it seem you were more concerned about getting everyone to sweep this under the carpet, including your DD.

You've let this slide and let your DD down. She won't forgive you.

You wonder how entitled abusive men come about in this world, you and your DH can just look in the mirror.

Snoozer11 · 27/05/2022 15:40

Brother and sister have a spat.

jaffacakesareepic · 27/05/2022 15:28

NeverDropYourMooncup · 27/05/2022 15:16

I reckon that the first female many abusive men ever assault are their sisters.

And they get away with it.

After all, once it's OK to push and shove a young woman and corner her whilst screaming and shouting at them so they are terrified, it's not that much of a leap to do the same to the next female that irritates them. Especially when Mummy says she won't punish him but hopes it doesn't happen again.

Totally agree with this

Innocenta · 27/05/2022 15:27

@NeverDropYourMooncup Incredibly perceptive comment. I think there is so much truth in what you've said there.

jaffacakesareepic · 27/05/2022 15:26

Derbee · 27/05/2022 14:40

They are BOTH adults. The language here is telling. MN forums will always be ready to condemn men.

MAN, MALE

YOUNG GIRL, DAUGHTER

Both adults, but god forbid we imply that an ADULT FEMALE also has behavioural standards to uphold. People are infantilising her, and trying to widen the age/power dynamic between 2 siblings who have had a totally inappropriately expressed fight.

You are just picking words that suit you here

The brother has been refered to as a man, brother, son, male
The daughter as woman, girl, sister, daughter etc

But regardless its irrelevant if you think an 18 year old still in school/college is a child/teenager/adult

Men shouldnt assault women, calling her a woman doesnt make the situation any better