Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DS21 threatened DD18

485 replies

Safarigiraffe · 25/05/2022 22:30

Today when me/husband were at work DS was in the bathroom & DD had just got ready to leave to go to college. DD knocked on bathroom door & asked my son to hurry up as she was on a tight schedule to get the bus to leave, DS said to her no you have to wait and DD became agitated and started shouting at him to hurry up.
DS then came out the bathroom shoving daughter back in the stomach hard shouting/swearing & intimidating her so DD at this point was very visibly upset & shaking as it wasn’t like my son to react on this way and went to the bathroom to which DS then pushed the door open again shouting/swearing in her face.
DD was at college crying on/off all day, now we have spoken to DD & to DD saying this must never happen again, DS is refusing to apologise & DD never wants to speak to him ever again saying she now feels uncomfortable to be in the house with him however we both work and can’t take time off. (DD is at college DS at Uni)
Can anyone advise of the best way forward here
Many thanks to everyone

OP posts:
Soontobe60 · 26/05/2022 06:27

Stompythedinosaur · 25/05/2022 22:51

If your dd had been assaulted by an adult man who she wasn't related to, would you consider repeatedly leaving her alone with him because he had been told by his mother not to do it again, even though he did not appear to see anything wrong with assaulting her?

I don't think you would.

Either he recognises the severity of the jncident and commits to change, or you have to safeguard her by asking him to leave.

What you have described is your dd experiencing domestic abuse.

What she has described is siblings having an argument. I really can’t believe some of the comments on here! One sibling is trying to get ready in the bathroom, the other sibling is yelling at them to hurry up, first sibling comes out of the bathroom and pushes them out of the way. Both were angry, one person started the row.

Overthewine · 26/05/2022 06:23

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the poster's request.

LaLoose · 26/05/2022 06:13

When we were similar ages my brother did this to me. My mum took his side and it was all played down as sibling trouble. I was made to feel I was overreacting. I have never forgiven my brother or my parents. It was 30 years ago.

YanTanTetheraPetheraPimp · 26/05/2022 06:13

This is a normal occurrence in my house 😂 it’s just fighting siblings!
You allow physical violence and call it ‘normal’ ? 😳 I definitely wouldn’t.

So OP, your son refuses to apologise, doesn’t accept responsibility for his behaviour, considers it ‘sorted’ and that’s that? What about your DD? She sees him completely getting away with it, is in danger of it reoccurring and possibly escalating and you not dealing with it?
Poor girl.

Portiasparty · 26/05/2022 06:04

I'm afraid you're minimising this. Even the title of your OP is misleading. Your son assaulted your daughter, he didn't just threaten her. This is not just siblings jostling with each other. This is the stronger, male sibling physically assaulting the more physically vulnerable, female sibling.

I often wonder how men from non-violent homes become abusers and it always seems to me to be a sense of entitlement. They don't actually think they've done anything wrong. This is what you're allowing in your house. A strong word is nothing. He hasn't even accepted responsibility or apologised, and you're just allowing it to stand. I think you're being very unreasonable. Protect your daughter and make sure your son understands that actions have consequences. You can build your relationship with him once he has moved out and you have protected your daughter.

BadNomad · 26/05/2022 05:55

Will you be this supportive if/when he starts being this aggressive and nasty to girlfriends? It's sad that you don't think your daughter deserves better than this, that she just needs to ignore what happened to her until her aggressor moves away voluntarily. Great life lessons for them both.

Yellowpens · 26/05/2022 05:34

Mother to an adult son here with a daughter who has suffered at his hands over the years.

Stop thinking of him as that little boy who was lovely. All children grow up into adults and it sounds like your son has passed that threshold now. He is confident enough to behave that way in your home knowing he can get away with it. My son was a lovely little boy but as an adult I cannot say he is lovely and I was in denial for a long time. I accept the facts as they are now and not as I want them to be.

Before long he will be fronting up to you and your husband. Are either of you prepared to protect yourselves should he rear up towards either of you? Do you have the strength between you? An angry/aggressive 21yr old male is very powerful physically and you'd be surprised how intimidating that is to manage in the moment. The shouting, banging around against walls and furniture, the panic coursing through your veins trying to protect your other children. That sounds similar to what your daughter experienced with the shouting, door-pushing, aggression, physical assault. It's a surreal, traumatising experience and alway stays with you.

I WISH I had protected my daughter from the psychological and physical violence she suffered at the hands of her older brother from the beginning, rather than several episodes later, then perhaps she wouldn't be in counselling now to help her deal with the trauma. We took exactly the same stance as you are now, often. In the end we had to make that break with him and I was forced to call the police to have him removed. My daughter took time to trust me and her father again as she didn't know if we would protect her in the way she needed us to in the future.

Violence is violence regardless of relationship and this event WILL stay with your daughter. If it becomes a regular occurrence then she may begin to lower her expectations of future partners and end up accepting similar behaviour from other males. Our daughter has sailed dangerously close to this situation and all we can do is support her financially with counselling and with regular reaffirmation of our commitment to her.

She is far from being recovered. She has achieved academically but in relationships it is a very different story and we have traced it right back to the toxic relationship with her brother but more importantly our lack of decisive action right from the beginning.

The role as a mother often means taking difficult decisions to protect all of your children. I am broken-hearted that the lovely boy I raised grew into someone I never imagined but I will forever hold myself responsible for the trauma my daughter experienced at the hands of her brother because I was the only person who could have protected her from it in the first place.

Good luck.

LaBellina · 26/05/2022 03:42

My male, older cousin behaved to my younger, female cousin in a similar matter, my uncle refused to step in and social services stepped in (alerted by younger cousin’s school) and she left the family home and was placed in another, safer home, as it was no longer deemed a safe place for her.

Your DC are a bit older but my point is that under no circumstances is this acceptable behavior, out of character or not. A grown man should not put his hands on a female no matter if she’s family and she has every right to be very upset about this. She shouldn’t have shouted at him but his response was so disproportionately agressive that I think it’s very unfair to treat them as equally at fault. I understand it’s very hard if this happens between your children but as a mother it’s your job to protect the (fysically) weaker one from the agressive behavior of the strongest one.

expat101 · 26/05/2022 03:14

If DD was ready and just wanted something from the bathroom she left behind, why did she need DS to get out? Could she not have just asked him to pass the item out to her?

Seems a lot of escalation for such a small matter. Are you sure there haven't been issues before?

Moser85 · 26/05/2022 02:58

ThreeLittleDots · 26/05/2022 01:57

He is still your son so your responsibility

He literally isn't. He's a grown ass man, albeit behaving like a little bollix. It's not up to OP to fix her son. He doesn't seem to give a flying fig!

I disagree.

If he really is a little bollix and this behaviour is going to get worse or escalate then I think the mother should absolutely take some responsibility and try to fix him.

If not then other women will be likely to suffer at his hands.

But this has been one incident, and out of character for him, so she actually has a very good chance of helping to ensure he's not going to do it again.

Murdoch1949 · 26/05/2022 02:47

There is a degree of over reaction by some, saying kick your son out. This was a one off occurrence between siblings. If it was a chain of physical outbursts, shoving, hitting etc, it would be totally different, but it was once. You have reassured your daughter, and she needs to understand that you believe her and have told her brother this is unacceptable. The 4 of you need to sit down and discuss what happened, how each of you feel about it and how you intend to move forward. Lines need to be drawn so everyone understands what happens next. There is obviously something troubling your son, maybe he's struggling at uni, maybe something else, you need to continue to try to get him to.open up. A further small matter, an agreed bathroom rota may prevent further outbursts connected to access. I wonder if posters would have been so judgemental if it were 2 sons pushing & shoving?

Readtheroom · 26/05/2022 02:45

Im really surprised and glad that people are being so supportive. I thought yelling parents, name calling and fighting among siblings was normal hence why there isnt support for it by police.

Coyoacan · 26/05/2022 02:43

I also think you should kick your son out and that the reason he is acting out of character in a violent manner is because he is probably using drugs.

Kicking him out now just might make him think twice next time he feels like assaulting a woman.

mathanxiety · 26/05/2022 02:03

Your daughter needs to feel safe in her own home. So do you. So does your H.

That is the bottom line here.

If you don't give your son a deadline by which he has to leave you are telling your daughter that while you love your children equally, you are prioritising his comfort over her feeling of being safe.

If your son won't apologise or even agree to discuss his wildly inappropriate behaviour, then he needs to be told to leave. What he did was massively disrespectful to you and your H as well as to your sister. This is your home. You need to assert your absolute authority within it.

Your daughter should not feel obliged to spend time under the same roof as a person who physically attacked her.

You will have no choice about throwing him out if she makes a police report about this domestic violence she has been subjected to.

Adult men do not assault women and get away with it. I don't care that she's his sister. He is an adult male and he shoved a woman in the stomach, screamed in her face, intimidated her. If he'd done it to a stranger he'd be in a police cell currently.
YY to this ^^

LetitiaLeghorn · 26/05/2022 02:02

What does your daughter say she wants to happen?

ThreeLittleDots · 26/05/2022 01:57

He is still your son so your responsibility

He literally isn't. He's a grown ass man, albeit behaving like a little bollix. It's not up to OP to fix her son. He doesn't seem to give a flying fig!

Eightiesfan · 26/05/2022 01:43

OP, if this behaviour is out of character, do you think your son could be using steroids? I work in a school and have seen normally polite students start acting in an aggressive way. It’s very obvious as it coincides with bulking up, which is explained away by their constant working out.

Plus summer is time that a lot of young men start using as they want to look good on holiday and/or festivals and for them it’s an easy fix.

Maytodecember · 26/05/2022 01:39

Safarigiraffe · 25/05/2022 23:26

I don’t want to kick my son out as it was very very out of character for him & my DD said that he’s never reacted that way & she was very shocked

As he’s trying very hard to close the matter down I’d be concerned why he behaved like this. Drugs? Viewing porn? In some sort of trouble?
He needs to understand that a. He never assaults any female and b. He risks police action and the consequences of that.

blueshoes · 26/05/2022 01:38

This reply has been deleted

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

Cinnamon1991 Yes, why make up a scenario that is not true. The son never said she swore at him much less 'every swear word under the sun'. That is YOU trying to find ways to blame her. Ask yourself why you are doing this and excusing his behaviour. A lame 'not that it give your son any right to lay a finger on her' is not a get out of jail free card. You have completely minimised his behaviour and sought to muddy the waters and throw smoke screens at her behaviour by making stuff up.

SammyScrounge · 26/05/2022 01:35

Derbee · 26/05/2022 01:08

I know everyone likes man bashing on here, so it was always going to go your DD’s way. Your DS obviously needs to control his temper, whether he’s living with your or not.

BOTH DS and DD need to learn to behave like respectful adults. Shouting hurry up at someone who is in the bathroom is unacceptable behaviour. Pushing and shouting back isn’t the appropriate response, but she should learn to behave too.

if they can’t behave, they should both move out

DD is to be punished for being assaulted? What an strange way of looking at things.

lameasahorse · 26/05/2022 01:30

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

lameasahorse · 26/05/2022 01:29

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

Cinnamon1991 · 26/05/2022 01:18

Also just want to add...though your son is clearly in the wrong, is your DD a total saint? Like someone else mentioned. She shouted at him to get out? What exactly did she shout at him? If it was simply...'hey hurry up I need to get so and so' then ok she is not to blame. However if she was calling him every swear word under the sun then yeahhh she is ALSO to blame. Not that it gives your son any right to lay a finger on her but she definitely also needs a stern talking to.

blueshoes · 26/05/2022 01:15

Safarigiraffe · 25/05/2022 22:30

Today when me/husband were at work DS was in the bathroom & DD had just got ready to leave to go to college. DD knocked on bathroom door & asked my son to hurry up as she was on a tight schedule to get the bus to leave, DS said to her no you have to wait and DD became agitated and started shouting at him to hurry up.
DS then came out the bathroom shoving daughter back in the stomach hard shouting/swearing & intimidating her so DD at this point was very visibly upset & shaking as it wasn’t like my son to react on this way and went to the bathroom to which DS then pushed the door open again shouting/swearing in her face.
DD was at college crying on/off all day, now we have spoken to DD & to DD saying this must never happen again, DS is refusing to apologise & DD never wants to speak to him ever again saying she now feels uncomfortable to be in the house with him however we both work and can’t take time off. (DD is at college DS at Uni)
Can anyone advise of the best way forward here
Many thanks to everyone

Shouting hurry up at someone who is in the bathroom is unacceptable behaviour.

So you are saying she deserved to be physically assaulted for this? That is in effect victim blaming. Classic abuser's excuse that she made me do it.

Since when is physical assault by a larger older male on a younger teenage female ever justified. You need to give your head a wobble.

Cinnamon1991 · 26/05/2022 01:13

Contrary to what everyone is suggesting here...I would absolutely not kick your DS out. People here suggesting some cop out option. He is still your son so your responsibility. You kick him out and he becomes a fully fledged abuser, most likely chugging down all sorts of drugs and getting random chicks knocked up. It is the easy way out.

If you need to send your DD to live with a relative for a few weeks. But your son needs active intervention. You need to sit him down BOTH of you and ask him why he thinks this behaviour was appropriate. Why he thinks hitting a woman just cos his delicate little buttons were pushed is appropriate. This is where your husband needs to talk to him man to man and establish what it means to be a real man. He also needs therapy it looks like so get on that asap if you can afford it.

He is quite clearly going through something...drugs, depression, porn addiction (which makes you do weird things and act violently) whatever it is you need to get the bottom of it. Simply throwing him out the house is a very stupid impractical and cowardly thing to do as a parent and I am shocked at the number of people who see this as a permanent solution. Yes throw him out the house...basically guaranteed outcome of him being a total thug. Look it's a shitty situation but you two need to act like parents and do what needs to be done to help him realise this is not the way. Professional help should be sought if needed.

Meanwhile make sure your DD keeps her distance well away from him, send her to a close relative or even on college dorms to keep her safe. That behaviour is psychotic and he needs to be put in place by whatever intervention necessary. You should carefully monitor his habits and behaviours by the way. A lot can be deciphered when an adult child is rude, distant, cold and abusive. This is when professional help is needed.