Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DS21 threatened DD18

485 replies

Safarigiraffe · 25/05/2022 22:30

Today when me/husband were at work DS was in the bathroom & DD had just got ready to leave to go to college. DD knocked on bathroom door & asked my son to hurry up as she was on a tight schedule to get the bus to leave, DS said to her no you have to wait and DD became agitated and started shouting at him to hurry up.
DS then came out the bathroom shoving daughter back in the stomach hard shouting/swearing & intimidating her so DD at this point was very visibly upset & shaking as it wasn’t like my son to react on this way and went to the bathroom to which DS then pushed the door open again shouting/swearing in her face.
DD was at college crying on/off all day, now we have spoken to DD & to DD saying this must never happen again, DS is refusing to apologise & DD never wants to speak to him ever again saying she now feels uncomfortable to be in the house with him however we both work and can’t take time off. (DD is at college DS at Uni)
Can anyone advise of the best way forward here
Many thanks to everyone

OP posts:
Laiste · 26/05/2022 11:12

But he wont apologise. The OP is asking for what to do next.

CaptSkippy · 26/05/2022 11:11

Branleuse · 26/05/2022 10:59

I find it quite odd when people try and liken family member dynamics between children or siblings to intimate partner violence or stranger attacks.
They dont come from the same power dynamics or for same reason, therefore they are dealt with differently.
Both these siblings are adults in law and if they are finding the situation intolerable then they are not obliged to live there.
If someone was harrassing another person in a student houseshare to get out of the bathroom, then i bet it would have a fair chance of blowing up too.
The reason she didnt deserve to be shoved is because noone should shove anyone, but in law they would very likely take the tack that this was an infortunate escalation of immature sibling rivalry.

I wouldnt allow the son to just say its sorted and to leave it, because its serious. Boys and young men need coming down on like a ton of bricks if they square up to a woman, but i think kicking him out would do more harm than good, and long term harm too.

Yes, they do. Men are physically stronger than women and they are privileged over women. In this case he is even a couple of years older than the woman he assaulted (his sister). The power dynamics don't change just because they are not in a romantic relationship.

Laiste · 26/05/2022 11:11

Who here has said she has done nothing wrong?

ICannotRememberAThing · 26/05/2022 11:11

Laiste · 26/05/2022 11:09

@ICannotRememberAThing he wont apologise.

As I said. He should.

Innocenta · 26/05/2022 11:11

@Branleuse The power dynamic is that he is male, stronger, and older. She is afraid of him.

That's all you need to know to understand who has the power. Physically, she is inherently less powerful and more vulnerable. Only in very unusual circumstances (eg a severely disabled man and very fit woman) would this not be the case.

ICannotRememberAThing · 26/05/2022 11:10

Laiste · 26/05/2022 11:06

ICannotRememberAThing - ''I don’t think violence should be condoned in any situation but ...''

Another but.

No one is condoning the daughters shouting.

They are actually. It’s as if she has done nothing wrong.

Laiste · 26/05/2022 11:09

@ICannotRememberAThing he wont apologise.

ICannotRememberAThing · 26/05/2022 11:08

BadNomad · 26/05/2022 11:05

It's actually quite scary how so many people are dismissing this. Are these are the mothers who stand by their wife/child-beating sons? The ones who say, "He wasn't like that growing up. He's probably having a breakdown from stress. He was never like this with any other woman. She must have pushed him too far."

They should both apologise. Her for her unacceptable shouting and him for his wholly unacceptable aggressive response.

Laiste · 26/05/2022 11:06

ICannotRememberAThing - ''I don’t think violence should be condoned in any situation but ...''

Another but.

No one is condoning the daughters shouting.

BadNomad · 26/05/2022 11:05

It's actually quite scary how so many people are dismissing this. Are these are the mothers who stand by their wife/child-beating sons? The ones who say, "He wasn't like that growing up. He's probably having a breakdown from stress. He was never like this with any other woman. She must have pushed him too far."

Lweji · 26/05/2022 11:04

What worries me is that he is refusing to apologise.
He needs to apologise to her and to both of you (the parents). That would be my condition to allow him to stay for now.
He was being incredibly selfish. At no time with my brother or sister did we refuse to grant access to the bathroom for anything, particularly if meant missing a bus.

ICannotRememberAThing · 26/05/2022 11:04

wellhelloitsme · 26/05/2022 11:02

If your 18 year old woman on the street approached a man or woman (quietly going about his daily business) and started shouting at them to get out of her way, hurry up - what would happen? She’d get a full on mouthful at best.

... and if he shoved her it would still be physical assault.

How odd to equate someone shouting to hurry up in the household's bathroom with someone running up to a stranger and shouting at them to hurry up. They aren't remotely the same thing.

They are not the same thing.

She was aggressive (shouting)
He took it to the next level (physical)

Neither is acceptable.

Laiste · 26/05/2022 11:04

@Branleuse - Boys and young men need coming down on like a ton of bricks if they square up to a woman, but i think kicking him out would do more harm than good, and long term harm too.

What does coming down like a ton of bricks look like with a 21 year old man? If it's not asking him to leave?

And have you read the post above yours?

ICannotRememberAThing · 26/05/2022 11:02

Laiste · 26/05/2022 10:54

He should have retaliated physically to your shouting? Is that what you're saying? You deserved it?? The age old excuse for male on female violence. ''But she was out of order so i put her in her place''. Dear god.

I hope you don't have daughters.

Its ok that I shouted my mouth off and he just stood there and took it?

I don’t think violence should be condoned in any situation but neither should verbal abuse/ shouting.

wellhelloitsme · 26/05/2022 11:02

If your 18 year old woman on the street approached a man or woman (quietly going about his daily business) and started shouting at them to get out of her way, hurry up - what would happen? She’d get a full on mouthful at best.

... and if he shoved her it would still be physical assault.

How odd to equate someone shouting to hurry up in the household's bathroom with someone running up to a stranger and shouting at them to hurry up. They aren't remotely the same thing.

Laiste · 26/05/2022 11:01

ICannotRememberAThing · 26/05/2022 10:58

If your 18 year old woman on the street approached a man or woman (quietly going about his daily business) and started shouting at them to get out of her way, hurry up - what would happen?

She’d get a full on mouthful at best.

I imagine if there was reasonable concern for safety then a man might be excused for shoving a strange woman out of the way in the street.

But that isn't the scenario so what's it got to do with anything?

ThreeLittleDots · 26/05/2022 11:00

I do think if DD is ok with it, then it could be resolved without resorting to that, but she has to be the lead on this, her safety matters more than his feelings

She's not ok with it! OP reports DD saying she feels uncomfortable with him and never wants to speak to him again! He is unrepentant so there's no other option, is there?

Branleuse · 26/05/2022 10:59

I find it quite odd when people try and liken family member dynamics between children or siblings to intimate partner violence or stranger attacks.
They dont come from the same power dynamics or for same reason, therefore they are dealt with differently.
Both these siblings are adults in law and if they are finding the situation intolerable then they are not obliged to live there.
If someone was harrassing another person in a student houseshare to get out of the bathroom, then i bet it would have a fair chance of blowing up too.
The reason she didnt deserve to be shoved is because noone should shove anyone, but in law they would very likely take the tack that this was an infortunate escalation of immature sibling rivalry.

I wouldnt allow the son to just say its sorted and to leave it, because its serious. Boys and young men need coming down on like a ton of bricks if they square up to a woman, but i think kicking him out would do more harm than good, and long term harm too.

mistermagpie · 26/05/2022 10:58

Thelnebriati · 26/05/2022 10:48

My brother used to do things to make me late for work. He thought it was funny to bully me and he used to get away with it. I'm NC with my whole family now.

Same here.

My brother was a bully my whole childhood, I remember my dancing teacher pulling me aside when I was about 8 because I was covered in bruises from him pinching me.

I left home to go to uni at 18 and came back in the first summer, he was a year older than me but still living at home. My mum and dad were on holiday and during that time he physically assaulted me - pushed me up against a wall and choked me - because I was moaning about him leaving the place a mess and not feeding the cats. I never even told my parents because they had ignored or minimised his behaviour so much in the past.

I have literally never been alone with him since and we now haven't spoken for nearly a decade.

I do think you need to be very honest with yourselves about whether this really is out of character for him and what the sibling relationship is normally like. But don't excuse or minimise it, it doesn't matter if your daughter was being a complete pain in the arse, he had no right to react that way.

Laiste · 26/05/2022 10:58

This guy is 21 years old. We're not talking about 11 or 12 year olds.

ICannotRememberAThing · 26/05/2022 10:58

Sebastianthecoo · 26/05/2022 10:50

I’m so shocked by the victim blaming and excusing on this thread.

If an 18 year old woman was similarly assaulted in the street by a 21 year old man would that be ok?

If this was a husband and wife would that be ok?

I grew up in a house where ‘it was just siblings fighting’ and I’m NC with my brother (it was drugs in his case) and I would be genuinely terrified if I had to be alone with him now.

I won’t accept any level of violence in my home, it’s domestic abuse.

If your 18 year old woman on the street approached a man or woman (quietly going about his daily business) and started shouting at them to get out of her way, hurry up - what would happen?

She’d get a full on mouthful at best.

Laiste · 26/05/2022 10:56

Sqeebling · 26/05/2022 10:50

It sounds like DD was being a pain and shouting and banging on the door so he lost it a bit

I'd just let them deal with it between themselves

If he ''lost it a bit'' with a future girlfriend or wife ?

I can imagine the scene. Well officer it was ok when i lost it a bit with my sister so i thought ....

purpleboy · 26/05/2022 10:56

perenniallymessy · 26/05/2022 09:46

If he refuses to apologise then he needs to leave.

If it were my son I would let him stay on the condition that he gave a genuine apology, recognised that would he did was incredibly wrong and was fully aware that if he did anything like that again he would be out and you would be making a police report (I would also keep a written record of what happened and pictures if your daughter has any injuries to back up a future report).

I would make it very clear that these steps are for his benefit as well as the rest of his family as he cannot continue with this behaviour if he wishes to have a good life. I would also make attending an anger management course a condition of staying.

Reassure your daughter that you are putting steps in place to ensure he will not do this again. For a period of time perhaps your son could be out of the house when neither you nor DH are there (he can study in the library, then get a job once term ends).

Yes, 21 is an adult but our brains are still not fully formed until our mid twenties. I think he still needs some guidance about how to behave as an adult. I would worry that kicking him out could alienate him to the point that his behaviour escalates and he feels justified in his anger. At this age I think it is fixable.

This is how I would deal with it too, although I think you need to understand how your dd is feeling. If she is scared to be in the same house as him alone, then that puts a different slant on it and he would need to be seriously remorseful for his actions, and DD to be fully on board with him staying in the house.

Sibling abuse is very real and rarely taken seriously, as many posters on here have expressed their lives and relationships with their family have suffered because of abuse not being taken seriously.

It sounds like there is something going on with your son, and I do think you and your DH need to get to the bottom of it, saying it's all sorted is not acceptable and he needs to understand there are very real consequences for assaulting someone.

As a pp showed when turned to involve a husband and his wife everyone would be taking this a lot more seriously, my personality would allow me to offer the person a second chance, my DH has never been violent in any way to me, if this scenario occurred it would be so out of character I would give him the chance to rectify with a heartfelt apology and the promise that any signs of subsequent violence would without discussion be the end of our marriage, the remorse would be the first step though, if there was no remorse there would be no second chance.

I understand posters saying kick him out, but I do think if DD is ok with it, then it could be resolved without resorting to that, but she has to be the lead on this, her safety matters more than his feelings.

Laiste · 26/05/2022 10:54

ICannotRememberAThing · 26/05/2022 10:44

Laiste

I used to wind my brother up big time. He never retaliated verbally or physically but he should have done. I was out of order.

He should have retaliated physically to your shouting? Is that what you're saying? You deserved it?? The age old excuse for male on female violence. ''But she was out of order so i put her in her place''. Dear god.

I hope you don't have daughters.

Sqeebling · 26/05/2022 10:50

It sounds like DD was being a pain and shouting and banging on the door so he lost it a bit

I'd just let them deal with it between themselves