Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DS21 threatened DD18

485 replies

Safarigiraffe · 25/05/2022 22:30

Today when me/husband were at work DS was in the bathroom & DD had just got ready to leave to go to college. DD knocked on bathroom door & asked my son to hurry up as she was on a tight schedule to get the bus to leave, DS said to her no you have to wait and DD became agitated and started shouting at him to hurry up.
DS then came out the bathroom shoving daughter back in the stomach hard shouting/swearing & intimidating her so DD at this point was very visibly upset & shaking as it wasn’t like my son to react on this way and went to the bathroom to which DS then pushed the door open again shouting/swearing in her face.
DD was at college crying on/off all day, now we have spoken to DD & to DD saying this must never happen again, DS is refusing to apologise & DD never wants to speak to him ever again saying she now feels uncomfortable to be in the house with him however we both work and can’t take time off. (DD is at college DS at Uni)
Can anyone advise of the best way forward here
Many thanks to everyone

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
jaffacakesareepic · 30/05/2022 13:11

Safarigiraffe · 29/05/2022 00:23

No one deserves to be hit but no one deserves to be verbally abusive either so to me they are both at fault here but my son more for pushing

Oh well as long as its her own fault she got assaulted then who cares

In a few years maybe she will marry a man who slaps her around if shes a bit gobby

And she will stay, because shes already learnt from her parents that if she swears she is at fault so no one is going to defend her and she should just put up with it, just like she did at home

And so it continues through another generation

This poor girl. Shes known not to be a liar but the moment her son says she was swearing you've decided that makes it all okay and you can brush it all under the rug because why bother to believe her

CanofCant · 29/05/2022 18:10

Safarigiraffe · 29/05/2022 16:37

BadNomad - no where have I said that I’ve said to my daughter I don’t believe her - in fact I do believe her & my son has been spoken to

That's about as clear as mud OP. I hope you're on a wind up because if it's real you're making a real pig's ear of this.

ILoveAllRainbowsx · 29/05/2022 18:04

So if you believe your daughter then your son is a liar as well as physically violent.

I would chuck him out. He had crossed a line.

billy1966 · 29/05/2022 17:13

BadNomad · 29/05/2022 16:47

But can you not see then how you are saying that your son's physical response to verbal abuse is justified? She caused that to happen. It's her fault. And if you believe her as you say, then that means your son is lying to you. A thug and a liar is being treated the same way as the person he hurt.

This.

They can't both be wrong and both be right.

Only one person was assaulted, yes assaulted.

She was pushed and shoved deliberately and aggressively.

OP, you can't have it both ways.

Think about how you want your daughter to remember this episode.

Read @Belephant's post.
She was the one who was held responsible for her brothers lack of control, by her mother.

I understand you are struggling to do the right thing here.

But focusing on the long term message you want your daughter to get from you is key.

Do you want her to believe that any man has the right to assault her?
Even if she is shouting and swearing?

For me it is that simple.
I know that I would never want my daughters to think that.

Thankfully my husband would be as strong in his view of this.

BadNomad · 29/05/2022 16:47

Safarigiraffe · 29/05/2022 16:37

BadNomad - no where have I said that I’ve said to my daughter I don’t believe her - in fact I do believe her & my son has been spoken to

But can you not see then how you are saying that your son's physical response to verbal abuse is justified? She caused that to happen. It's her fault. And if you believe her as you say, then that means your son is lying to you. A thug and a liar is being treated the same way as the person he hurt.

wellhelloitsme · 29/05/2022 16:39

Safarigiraffe · 29/05/2022 16:37

BadNomad - no where have I said that I’ve said to my daughter I don’t believe her - in fact I do believe her & my son has been spoken to

And yet you said they were "equally to blame" despite believing her side of things therefore that believing that yes she shouted at him to hurry up, but then he shoved her so hard it hurt, followed her when she tried to get away then shouted and screamed in her face aggressively so she felt intimidated, refused to apologise for the above, refused to talk to you about it for days.

Equally to blame though?

Make it make sense...

Safarigiraffe · 29/05/2022 16:37

BadNomad - no where have I said that I’ve said to my daughter I don’t believe her - in fact I do believe her & my son has been spoken to

OP posts:
Belephant · 29/05/2022 16:27

This reply has been deleted

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

My younger brother used to have an awful temper as a child, and would frequently lash out at me even as we got into the teen years. I never ever hit back, but I'm sure I had a gob on me and I probably said things that annoyed him, yes. I actually have two quite noticeable scars from injuries he caused me, one when we were very young and one from when I was about 15.

It always went like this; me and my brother would argue, he'd end up hitting, pushing, or throwing something at me, I'd shout in pain and call for my mother, and my mother would storm in saying "Belephant!! What have you said now!"

Eventually she'd tell him off for being violent but it would always, always ultimately come down to "but this wouldn't have happened if you just wouldn't wind him up".

I really do believe that this is a major factor into why I accepted violent behaviour from a past partner - I distinctly felt like it was my fault. Very cliché, I know, but it's true. I am close to my mother now after many years, but this is one thing I will never probably be able to stop resenting her for.

For what it's worth, I get on with my brother now too but him being the golden child hasn't done him many favours either - he's clueless when it comes to functioning as an adult without help from others and he has a huge, almost comically exaggerated victim complex to top it all off. Nothing is ever his fault in his eyes, and any constructive criticism from absolutely anyone is tantamount to an attempt to ruin his life.

I imagine that my mother probably just didn't know how to deal with my brother's behaviour and thought blaming me would stop the situations arising. It didn't and it has helped neither of us as adults.

BadNomad · 29/05/2022 15:51

Unbelievable. Your daughter spent the whole day distraught and sobbing and even now refuses to have anything to do with her brother. But 4 days later, after your son finally opens his mouth, you're now telling her that you don't believe her. You're telling her that you think she's could be a liar. Wow.

Has she ever falsely accused anyone of hurting her before? Has she ever reacted so strongly to just a verbal argument?

If that girl never trusts you again, you only have yourself to blame.

lameasahorse · 29/05/2022 15:32

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

2bazookas · 29/05/2022 15:32

Ds's bag would be packed and on the doorstep.. just until I retrieved his house/car keys.
Then he'd be out the door and on his way to who knows or cares where.

Coyoacan · 29/05/2022 15:19

@ancientgran
Now you are arguing that it never happened but from your other comments I see that you actually think that men are entitled to hit women.

wellhelloitsme · 29/05/2022 14:52

Even if he shoved her is that assault? Ever been in a crowd trying to get on a bus/train/busy shop. Ever called the police if someone's elbow made contact with you? No of course you haven't, physical contact does not necessarily mean someone has assaulted you.

Come off it, they aren't comparable.

'Even if he shoved her' - in DD's version of events he didn't just jostle past her, he shoved her in the stomach hard enough that it hurt her and frightened her.

'Even if he shoved her' in the manner she described, that wasn't assault?

Of course that's assault.

If someone trying to get past me in a busy shop / train station etc shoved me in the stomach hard enough they hurt me and frightened me, I would consider that assault too yes.

MrsTerryPratchett · 29/05/2022 14:51

Even if he shoved her is that assault?

Yes. Your 'work' 'with' the police didn't teach you a lot did it?

MrsTerryPratchett · 29/05/2022 14:49

So she says he shoved her, he says he didn't. Maybe he doesn't need to learn to keep his hands to himself because he never touched her. You do realise that he is as likely to be telling the truth as she is?

Not all stories are created equal. She said at the time he shoved her. She was upset and remained upset.

He said something about it all being sorted at the time, didn't deny shoving her. Days later he comes up with a story about her screaming and shouting and him not shoving her.

If he'd said at the time, "I can't believe she'd saying this, I've not laid a hand on her" and seemed consistent and emotionally congruent, you'd have a point. His story seems just that, a story.

ancientgran · 29/05/2022 14:44

billy1966 · 29/05/2022 14:37

@ancientgran I am not going to ever condone shouting and swearing from anyone.

We'll just have to differ that someone who does this, is fair game to be assaulted.

In my home with 4 children in an around that age, that definitely can irritate each other at times, violence would never be tolerated.

It really is that simple in my home.

If one of my son's assaulted my daughters because she was shouting and swearing at him, I would not accept being told it was sorted, refusing to answer questions and then allow him to give me a version days later that excused his behaviour in HIS eyes only, all the while as he continues to live in our home.

There is no excuse for violence.

I appreciate many posters believe there are acceptable circumstances, and the sister shouting and swearing is one of those circumstances.

It isn't for me, nor will it ever be, and certainly not in my home.

I appreciate that that can be very difficult for some people to grasp.

In some homes, violence doesn't ever happen and would never be tolerated.

My children have never hurt each other deliberately.
They have annoyed, irritated, called each other names and teased each other on occasion, as children, but they have never laid a hand on each other, even the boys.

If they had, it would have been dealt with very firmly, so that they would known it was completely unacceptable at a young age.

As adult young men now, they have never had a physical fight with any of their large circles of friends and I have never heard of any of their friends ever being involved with a physical altercation either.

Lots of men live long lives without raising a hand to anyone, much less their sister.

Was she assaulted? How do you know that, does she just have to say it and it is true?

Even if he shoved her is that assault? Ever been in a crowd trying to get on a bus/train/busy shop. Ever called the police if someone's elbow made contact with you? No of course you haven't, physical contact does not necessarily mean someone has assaulted you.

The hysteria if a young woman says she has been shoved is ridiculous.

ancientgran · 29/05/2022 14:41

OlympicProcrastinator · 29/05/2022 14:16

I was very angry with my son I had a very strong talk with him and said this is not to happen ever again

I bet he was shaking in his boots. No OP they are not equally to blame. It doesn’t matter what she was saying he needs to learn he can’t put his hands on people because he doesn’t like the things they are saying or he’s going to have a lot of problems going through life.

Violence never comes ‘from nowhere’ it’s just that people often ignore the signs leading up to it. The minimising attitude you have toward your sons behaviour is unlikely to be something new.

I would ensure that he knows if he ever lays a finger on anyone in your house again YOU will call the police on him. I’d also give him his marching orders. If he’s big enough to push a woman around he’s big enough to fend for himself. Your daughter shouldn’t have to suffer him any longer.

That being said, you’d do well to find out why your daughter thinks she can get her own way by being verbally abusive. That’s not acceptable at all.

So she says he shoved her, he says he didn't. Maybe he doesn't need to learn to keep his hands to himself because he never touched her. You do realise that he is as likely to be telling the truth as she is?

I can't believe that people think the police would do anything about a brother shoving his sister as he comes out of the bathroom particularly when he says he never touched her.

billy1966 · 29/05/2022 14:37

@ancientgran I am not going to ever condone shouting and swearing from anyone.

We'll just have to differ that someone who does this, is fair game to be assaulted.

In my home with 4 children in an around that age, that definitely can irritate each other at times, violence would never be tolerated.

It really is that simple in my home.

If one of my son's assaulted my daughters because she was shouting and swearing at him, I would not accept being told it was sorted, refusing to answer questions and then allow him to give me a version days later that excused his behaviour in HIS eyes only, all the while as he continues to live in our home.

There is no excuse for violence.

I appreciate many posters believe there are acceptable circumstances, and the sister shouting and swearing is one of those circumstances.

It isn't for me, nor will it ever be, and certainly not in my home.

I appreciate that that can be very difficult for some people to grasp.

In some homes, violence doesn't ever happen and would never be tolerated.

My children have never hurt each other deliberately.
They have annoyed, irritated, called each other names and teased each other on occasion, as children, but they have never laid a hand on each other, even the boys.

If they had, it would have been dealt with very firmly, so that they would known it was completely unacceptable at a young age.

As adult young men now, they have never had a physical fight with any of their large circles of friends and I have never heard of any of their friends ever being involved with a physical altercation either.

Lots of men live long lives without raising a hand to anyone, much less their sister.

NerrSnerr · 29/05/2022 14:31

Badgirlriri · 25/05/2022 22:50

This is a normal occurrence in my house 😂 it’s just fighting siblings!

This is why so many women accept violence from men in their lives. It is just laughed off.

madasawethen · 29/05/2022 14:20

Calling the police on him wouldn't have been the reasonable thing to do.

Even if they just came out and talked to him, he'd know there were real consequences to his actions.

I guarantee if his father was shouting and cursing at him to hurry up and get out of the bathroom, he would not have come out and shoved his father in the stomach backwards and squared up in his face cursing and trying to intimidate him.

OlympicProcrastinator · 29/05/2022 14:16

I was very angry with my son I had a very strong talk with him and said this is not to happen ever again

I bet he was shaking in his boots. No OP they are not equally to blame. It doesn’t matter what she was saying he needs to learn he can’t put his hands on people because he doesn’t like the things they are saying or he’s going to have a lot of problems going through life.

Violence never comes ‘from nowhere’ it’s just that people often ignore the signs leading up to it. The minimising attitude you have toward your sons behaviour is unlikely to be something new.

I would ensure that he knows if he ever lays a finger on anyone in your house again YOU will call the police on him. I’d also give him his marching orders. If he’s big enough to push a woman around he’s big enough to fend for himself. Your daughter shouldn’t have to suffer him any longer.

That being said, you’d do well to find out why your daughter thinks she can get her own way by being verbally abusive. That’s not acceptable at all.

Coyoacan · 29/05/2022 14:04

Honestly, we have to teach our children to walk away from irritating situations rather than respond with violence.

ancientgran · 29/05/2022 13:12

billy1966 · 29/05/2022 13:01

I am not suggesting it is the same.

It is two brothers.

But the damage of not addressing what is happening in front of you is real.

Allowing it to continue.

Siblings do irritate each other, but allowing any physical violence to go unchecked can have long term consequences.

I don't think he was beating up his twin for years, but he was a bit of a dominant character in size and personality and Ithink that stemmed from unchecked childhood behaviour.

Insisting on respectful behaviour between siblings is a very good base for strong ties in adulthood IMO.

If you think respectful behaviour between siblings is a good thing how would you address the daughter's behaviour. We've heard lots about how awful the son is but banging on the bathroom door, swearing, shouting doesn't sound very respectful does it?

billy1966 · 29/05/2022 13:01

ancientgran · 29/05/2022 12:53

So that's nothing like the OPs situation is it. This is all out of character so not years of one getting hurt.

I am not suggesting it is the same.

It is two brothers.

But the damage of not addressing what is happening in front of you is real.

Allowing it to continue.

Siblings do irritate each other, but allowing any physical violence to go unchecked can have long term consequences.

I don't think he was beating up his twin for years, but he was a bit of a dominant character in size and personality and Ithink that stemmed from unchecked childhood behaviour.

Insisting on respectful behaviour between siblings is a very good base for strong ties in adulthood IMO.

ancientgran · 29/05/2022 12:53

billy1966 · 29/05/2022 12:37

It really is. Short skip from "you made me do it" and the victim changes their behaviour, living on eggshells.

A casual friend of mine had twin boys 25+ years ago.
One was sensitive, bright and creative, the other sporty, energetic and quite rough in his play.

Her quiet son was always being hurt by the other twin. Always crying and looked a bit miserable.

Her husband is a bit of a rugger bugger, and was very much that it's only rough play, and it will harden him up.

One son was very quiet in his teen years, the other was mr sporty confidence.

It appears a variation of it went on right through the childhood and teen years, as when I bumped into her a couple of years ago she mentioned the boys aren't close at all.

Since her quieter son has qualified as a doctor they have barely seen him.
She said something like he is too busy to visit.

He very much lives his own life now away from them all.

I wondered has she ever joined the dots.

So that's nothing like the OPs situation is it. This is all out of character so not years of one getting hurt.