Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

School work remainly at school at the end of year.

167 replies

jkbabymassage · 25/05/2022 21:33

I just found out that at the end of the academic year my daughter who is in Yr 1 won't be allowed to bring her exercise books and school work home for us to keep and cherish. And that she won't even get them at the end of her time at primary school..that they will be archived? Apparently it's some stupid safeguarding thing? But what about parental rights and my daughter's rights? Surely the work belongs to her and we should take ownership of it? My mum to this day cherishes work that I brought home from school. It's made me both sad and angry that the best that I'll get is a quick peek in them on the odd parent's evening and then it will just all collect dust in some archive box somewhere. Anyone else had this at their child's school?

OP posts:
SnowyPetals · 26/05/2022 08:49

I have never heard of a school keeping the books, most can't wait to send them home! The safeguarding does seem to be specific to your school, so maybe there is a particular situation there?

Boymumsoymum · 26/05/2022 08:34

Did I suggest she print it off and take it into school? No. I just said she's right. I just really don't understand why people are attacking the OP for what is fundamentally a really simple, reasonable request? Most schools do just send books home at the end of year, it's really not a big stretch to assume, they might, is it? I didn't make a 'personal attack' on MissMiss, any more than MissMiss made a personal attack on the OP by asking if she is one of 'those' parents??

jkbabymassage · 26/05/2022 08:21

MissMissICantDoThis · 26/05/2022 06:24

Teacher here.

I think safeguarding is a non-issue as books should not have images or names in them unless permission has been given.

Schools still have an obligation to protect teachers from harm and abuse and this is a typical catalyst for parental complaints.

To be fair, anyone that states that they pay their taxes for that exercise book and is therefore entitled to it is a classic example of one of "those parents".

Are you one of those parents? It might be why you got the safeguarding speech.

I wouldn't be surprised if some of the more accommodating parents were privately handed some of their children's books on request.

Not at all one of 'those' parents. I trust the teachers to teach. I would just like to have some school work keepsakes. And yes I mentioned that I pay taxes but only in argument against a suggestion that the school is keeping the books because they paid for them. Which is ridiculous. It's a few exercises books?

OP posts:
Sherrystrull · 26/05/2022 08:11

Boymumsoymum · 26/05/2022 07:23

MissMiss the OP didn't start out saying 'ive paid my taxes for them'. She simply said she wanted some of her young child's work to treasure and cherish as she grows up. And people immediately jumped on her claiming this was unreasonable and entitled. How many parents out there still treasure that cute bit of writing their child did in school where they described mummy as their superhero or wrote something funny about Daddy?! Huge numbers. Yet people acted like OP is 'entitled' and 'that parent', you included. Do you think teaching is still the right job for you if you've reached the point where your first assumption is that a parent is going to be difficult? Maybe be mindful of that. Maybe the parents you are finding hard work, actually weren't initially, but your back was up, right from the outset, and that has dictated your relationship with them?!

It's a rather large stretch to suggest @MissMissICantDoThis shouldn't be a teacher. She speaks a lot of sense and you've jumped to conclusions and made a personal attack.

MissMissICantDoThis · 26/05/2022 07:45

*· Today 07:28

www.tes.com/news/who-owns-childs-work-not-teacher-or-school oh and the OP is right. The work is her child's, school would have to have a pretty good reason to not send ANY of it home. Yes everyone understands they keep samples for Ofsted or other reporting but there should never be a situation where every last bit of a child's work is withheld from them.*

Oh yes OP, please print this off and take it into your school, that will help your case 🤣🤣🤣🤣

I mean seriously?

KatherineofGaunt · 26/05/2022 07:37

jkbabymassage · 25/05/2022 23:11

But what about the content of the books? I know my daughter is proud of her work particularly her writing book. Do you think she feels that the book belongs to school? No. It's HER work. HER book!

It's wonderful she's proud of her school work.

But she doesn't own the books just because you pay taxes and she has no rights that are being infringed by the school keeping them.

Not all schools keep books. If you want your daughter's, go in and have a discussion about it. Just don't demand them because you "pay taxes". Those same taxes pay for many things but that doesn't mean you get to demand private treatment at the hospital or one of the school's computers or any other number of things. Quite frankly, I believe that people who use the line that they pay taxes to demand that public servants should do or give them anything they ask are people who look down on public sector workers and should never be pandered to.

MissMissICantDoThis · 26/05/2022 07:33

As a parent to 5 children and a teacher, I can confirm that I was speaking from both sides of the coin.
Do you have experience as a teacher @Boymumsoymum
OP did go on to make that statement and I picked up on it as it is often used as a way to try and belittle teachers.
My point is that SLT would have made it a school-wide policy (probably to stop parent complaints) and OP should consider the relationship with the teacher as I have Saif (and others) if approached, I would try and support a parent but that support wanes quickly if the former approach is used.
Relationships work both ways.

Boymumsoymum · 26/05/2022 07:28

www.tes.com/news/who-owns-childs-work-not-teacher-or-school oh and the OP is right. The work is her child's, school would have to have a pretty good reason to not send ANY of it home. Yes everyone understands they keep samples for Ofsted or other reporting but there should never be a situation where every last bit of a child's work is withheld from them.

easyday · 26/05/2022 07:27

How weird. I was just looking in my sons folder for his motorcycle registration and came across a 'this is my family' book he had done in Y2. Such sweet little drawings.
I also kept and framed some of their art work - my dd is hoping to go to art school so have lovely paintings through the years.
While I quickly thumbed threw and tossed their exercise books (my dd has kept many of hers though), it's a wonderful thing to have some of their work. Maybe you can ask to go in and select a few things?

Boymumsoymum · 26/05/2022 07:23

MissMiss the OP didn't start out saying 'ive paid my taxes for them'. She simply said she wanted some of her young child's work to treasure and cherish as she grows up. And people immediately jumped on her claiming this was unreasonable and entitled. How many parents out there still treasure that cute bit of writing their child did in school where they described mummy as their superhero or wrote something funny about Daddy?! Huge numbers. Yet people acted like OP is 'entitled' and 'that parent', you included. Do you think teaching is still the right job for you if you've reached the point where your first assumption is that a parent is going to be difficult? Maybe be mindful of that. Maybe the parents you are finding hard work, actually weren't initially, but your back was up, right from the outset, and that has dictated your relationship with them?!

letsnotdothat · 26/05/2022 07:22

My DC have been to two different schools in different areas and I was surprised when we moved here and they didn’t come home with a heavy bag full of books in July. They also don’t show you their work at parents evening here which is odd to me, the books used to be lined up to browse through while you waited at their old school.

I have their old books from reception-year 2 ish in the loft which DH thinks is completely bonkers because he thinks we’ll never look through them again.

LaMarschallin · 26/05/2022 07:18

You won't be allowed to keep and cherish her school work?

Ah well. At least you did see her have her first taste of icecream.
OMG, you did... didn't you?! Shock

MissMissICantDoThis · 26/05/2022 07:17

Sorry MissMiss are you actually saying 'more accommodating' parents would be treated differently?! Are you actually a teacher? I really wish schools would stop treating parents who care about their child's education, and occasionally hold school to account, as 'pushy' and 'those parents'. You sound incredibly unprofessional

There are parents that hold the school to account and rightly so and then there are parents who go on an all out offensive because their child didn't get enough lines in the school play. It is about managing parental expectations unfortunately. Over the years, I have been fortunate to have fantastic relationships with parents but I can count a small number who have made it impossible. They are probably the reason people are not able to have access to books. If you have a good relationship with the teacher, there is nothing wrong with asking if there is something they could do - but starting with "I pay taxes for those books" is not going to be the way to go.

CorpseReviver · 26/05/2022 07:14

But what about the content of the books? I know my daughter is proud of her work particularly her writing book. Do you think she feels that the book belongs to school? No. It's HER work. HER book!

I'm confused. Does your 6-year-old child pay taxes? I thought that's what conferred possession of the cherished books.

PrivateHall · 26/05/2022 07:13

underneathleaf · 25/05/2022 21:43

There's no way a school could store all those books. I can barely store the maths and English books my small class have already filled this year. I'd press to find out more. As a teacher I sort of feel the other way sometimes - I hate to think of all that hard work going into books (both the kids' and mine) just for them to be binned at home!

That is quite an odd way of looking at it. Surely the DC aren't doing the work for the sake of filling a book - they are doing it to learn? That learning isn't undone by the book going in the bin surely?

girlmom21 · 26/05/2022 07:09

I pay my taxes so that schools can buy exercise books. The work in the books is my child's. When the school no long needs them..the books/work is hers!

Oh OP GrinGrinGrin

Is JK Rowling allowed to confiscate my Harry Potter books if she wants because I've read them so don't need them and the work is hers anyway?

PriamFarrl · 26/05/2022 07:08

My rights.
I’m entitled.
I pay my taxes.

I think that’s a line on the bingo card.

ChiselandBits · 26/05/2022 07:08

Please don't write off 'sadeguatding' as an excuse. I teach older kids but I've had more than a few kids disclose bullying via a piece of writing that has then been used and recorded in the evidence chain. Ditto home abuse / neglect. It's a real thing. And dont be that 'I pay my taxes' parent. Does that mean you pay the teachers' salary and and can demand X? I really hope not, but there are loads like that out there.

SpringIntoChaos · 26/05/2022 07:06

jkbabymassage · 25/05/2022 21:49

I mean the school surely can't refuse to let my child keep her OWN work? Yep, they threw the 'safeguarding' tagline at me. I have no idea what they meant, not sure the teacher did either to be fair. I think it's ridiculous. I can see why they might want to keep her work so they can see her progress through her education but not even to let us have it when she leaves in Yr 6? I really want to know if this policy is a national thing so just something weird that my child's school is doing?

No it's definitely NOT something we all do 😱 Christ...where would we put the thousands and thousands of books we fill up???

At my school, we keep the previous years books 'for a bit' in case evidence is needed for Ofsted (it NEVER is!!) then send them home. Usually around Easter 🙌🏼

Iamnotthe1 · 26/05/2022 06:55

@jkbabymassage
But what about the content of the books? I know my daughter is proud of her work particularly her writing book. Do you think she feels that the book belongs to school? No. It's HER work. HER book!

Just as a side note here, all work completed by a child or staff member as part of their learning or teaching is seen and treated as the property of the school. Personal feelings would not come into it when determining whether a child, parent or staff member had a 'right' to something.

That being said, many schools choose to send books home, minus a few here and there for sampling/modelling purposes.

If you don't understand the school's reasoning or their response of 'safeguarding' then ask for it to be explained to you again in more detail. However, don't go in talking about 'rights' as, no, neither you nor your child have any legal right to the work completed as part of schooling.

parrotonmyshoulder · 26/05/2022 06:38

‘Schools still have an obligation to protect teachers from harm and abuse and this is a typical catalyst for parental complaints.’

Yes, it is very, very likely to be for this reason. Not just your books but a whole school wide decision. Parents may have a lot of time to go through their one child’s book with a fine tooth comb, noting every uncorrected misspelled word, teacher error, unmarked sentence, perceived ‘boring’ task. Often, they fail to remember that the teacher will have had 29 other books to mark (as a tiny proportion of the work they have to do in the rest of their working day).

Perhaps you could ask the school to consider photocopying a ‘best’ piece of work for your child. Do they ever bring home a finished piece that was on display, or something like that?

Boymumsoymum · 26/05/2022 06:35

Sorry MissMiss are you actually saying 'more accommodating' parents would be treated differently?! Are you actually a teacher? I really wish schools would stop treating parents who care about their child's education, and occasionally hold school to account, as 'pushy' and 'those parents'. You sound incredibly unprofessional

MissMissICantDoThis · 26/05/2022 06:24

Teacher here.

I think safeguarding is a non-issue as books should not have images or names in them unless permission has been given.

Schools still have an obligation to protect teachers from harm and abuse and this is a typical catalyst for parental complaints.

To be fair, anyone that states that they pay their taxes for that exercise book and is therefore entitled to it is a classic example of one of "those parents".

Are you one of those parents? It might be why you got the safeguarding speech.

I wouldn't be surprised if some of the more accommodating parents were privately handed some of their children's books on request.

PriamFarrl · 26/05/2022 06:03

jkbabymassage · 25/05/2022 22:17

My child's right to keep her own work? My right as a parent to see it and choose to keep some of it if I wish? What right does the school have to keep it all when they no longer need it?

That’s a lot rights you are banging on about there.

Beachhuts90 · 26/05/2022 05:45

If one of my Y1 parents asked to take photos of their child's books I'd make an appointment for them to come in after or before school. However we send a lot of stuff home including everything that has been on a display, which is mounted on nice card and is the best of each child's work.