Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask what makes the perfect town centre?

62 replies

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 25/05/2022 19:30

Following on from the "town centres are dying" thread, I wondered what would you want, and more importantly use if your council put in a new town centre.

I buy most of my groceries at Aldi and use the car as I buy a lot in one go, so I wouldn't use generic supermarkets in the main town centre. But I would use somewhere I could walk to and buy lunch (even if just Greggs), with a nice spot to sit and eat after I've purchased. Maybe a small green space so we could sit and chat and eat.

I love buying books (especially second hand) so would love a second hand shop dedicated to books.

A general shop with post office and Amazon Locker would be useful to me. As would a good sized car park (free or validated by the local shops).

I'd love to have a place I can buy really lovely greetings cards for birthdays, and even better if that shop also sold nice little token gifts to go with the cards.

I'd like a shop that sells cheese and wines and ales etc that aren't available on mainstream supermarkets.

Problem with all of this is that I wouldn't ben there more than once a week so it wouldn't be cost effective.

What would you need or want from your local town centre?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
TheRealShedSadie · 26/05/2022 13:32

I think many shops and buildings in towns and cities are largely owned by landlords who just want income from rents. In my city, private owners own huge ‘portfolios’ and evidently don’t give a monkeys about anything other than financial return.

I know some small businesses who have wanted to rent empty shops but have been declined as they can’t afford the full rent. Landlords can sit and wait it out for a better return, or just write it off and let the building decline.

starlingdarling · 26/05/2022 12:41

Thelnebriati · 26/05/2022 10:51

Accessibility, facilities like toilets and benches, and feeling safe walking around.

Toilets are a good point. It's impossible to find public toilets in our town centre. The few we had closed down because of covid and were never opened again.

Open spaces with benches where people could meet would help too. Basically nice spaces where people could gather without having to spend money so the town has more footfall. I meet friends often at a park in summer. We sit around and chat, head to the kiosk for some lunch then sit around some more. If we went to town we'd pay to park, go straight to a cafe, have an hour or so for lunch then leave.

Thelnebriati · 26/05/2022 10:51

Accessibility, facilities like toilets and benches, and feeling safe walking around.

Polyanne · 26/05/2022 10:49

Me too, I’d love a small independent cinema that showed films which the big chains don’t show. Foreign language films, black and white movies from the 1950s, etc. There’s one in the city but it would take me best part of an hour to get there so I don’t bother very often.

OversBo · 26/05/2022 10:45

And I’d use an independent art house cinema.

OversBo · 26/05/2022 10:44

Not very interested in hanging out in town centres as I don’t enjoy shopping, but a revamp of the sports centre and library would be nice.

onthefencesitter · 26/05/2022 10:37

Also zero waste shop!

onthefencesitter · 26/05/2022 10:35

I live in London but I like my high street to have: Gail's, a bubble tea shop, space nk, clothes shops like Boden, Joules, White Stuff, Seasalt, Moshulu, boots/superdrug, bookshop, good restaurants including decent authentic Chinese restaurant, sushi bar, Franco Manca/decent pizza place, a pub you can get a decent Sunday roast and sells good food and has a garden for Al fresco dining, second hand clothes shops, large supermarket, Caffe Nero, independent cinema that also shows lower budget indie films, library, food market. Of course in London, it would have buses and the tube within walking distance.

I have a love/hate relationship with independent shops. I really want to like them but they don't really sell things I like. Exception for family owned restaurants...

letsnotdothat · 26/05/2022 09:20

I live in a village so going off the closest town to us which is a lovely historic market town with massive potential, they need more coffee shops imo. I know I’m a basic bitch but I enjoy Costa or Starbucks and there isn’t one at all. They have ‘independent’ coffee shops which most people probably claim to prefer but they’re rubbish. Love the idea of a second hand bookstore, I go in the charity shop there purely for books and I’ve got some real bargains over the years. More places to sit would be nice, it would be lovely to have a coffee shop with ample outdoor seating. They have no clothes stores anymore aside from a really old fashioned chain, can’t remember the name but it’s one my Gran shops in so that’s annoying. I like H&M and Zara but realise I’m expecting too much from a small town Wink. They need to demolish the vile high rise flats too, they’re an eyesore.

perenniallymessy · 26/05/2022 09:14

Town centres really need lots of shops selling those little things that you need but are disproportionately expensive to buy online due to postage costs.

Craft shops selling yarn and haberdashery, they often run classes too to teach people good old fashioned skills like fixing or taking in your clothes. A good hardware shop where you can get a small bag of the exact type of screws you need, or specialist cleaning products. A nice stationery shop. Plus a nice covered market area.

Agreed that there need to be people living in the town too. Most towns feel too corporate these days and they can be a bit dead at night.

Lincslady53 · 26/05/2022 09:04

I think the days of a traditional town centre are dead, never to return. We live in a 'village' of about 2,500 residents. We have no empty shops, and can get everything we need in the village. We have a new Aldi due to open later this year, and hopefully it will not kill off the other local businesses. We have 2 large towns 8 miles away in opposite directions. 2 large cities about 35 miles away, and a massive out of town centre about 35 miles away too. Since Covid we have not visited either city, been able to get everything we need locally or online. We have visited one of the 2 towns a couple of times a month. But a quick drive in, pick up what we need and out again. I would not drive in just for a cup of coffee, unless I had other business to take care of. If other people have our way of living the businesses in the towns would not be sustainable. You have to sell a lot of coffee to cover the overheads.

BlueTitSmilingAtMe · 26/05/2022 08:59

Yours sounds great OP. I'd like practical things too though - places that sell DIY items and homewares etc. I used to live in a very pretty historic town with loads of lovely little coffee shops and nick nack type places but if you wanted to buy eg a lunch box or a potty or a hammer you had to drive to an out of town retail park.

Also some kind of theatre/arts venue that uses its grants to support local creatives.

Speaking of retail parks imo you need free parking and proper access for disabled people. Not everyone can ride a bloody bike!

glasshouse · 26/05/2022 08:50

hattie43 · 26/05/2022 07:49

Tbh I think town centres are not used anymore as we go to out of town malls and online shopping .

Town centres like mine are dated with empty shops and a poor demographic . There's no point resurrecting a high street as the area is disadvantaged.
I'd turn it into really nice flats and housing with pavement cafes and bars so people could stroll out and enjoy cafe culture .

Totally agree. All these lovely deli's, artisan bakeries and butchers are all very well if you have the money to support them. Unfortunately many town centres are run down because people do not have any spare income and this is only going to get worse.

I think town centres need to be refocussed on more residential and small business units, providing services. Think about what people want to do rather than buy. We need to provide facilities for all ages, especially young people. There is a reason they are just hanging around street corners. Access needs to be easy, whether that be by frequent, cheap public transport; safe cycle storage or car parking.

Business rates also need to be looked at, gouging those who are hanging on by a whisker is not a long term sustainable model.

Unfortunately all of the above is expensive to provide so I think most small town centres will be left to rot.

Justkeeppedaling · 26/05/2022 08:30

I would like our town centre shops to be open at times I could use them - ie later in the evenings.
So many women (traditional shoppers in ye olden days) work the potential footfall is limited in the day time.
I think that if small town centre shops opened until 8pm like our local small Sainsburys does, their takings would increase. Even if they just this a couple of times a week and opened late in the morning to compensate.
I'd certainly take a stroll down our high st to buy dinner when I finish at 5. I already dash out to sainsburys at the same time at least a couple of times a week for stuff for a meal, or something we've run out of.

DreamingofItaly2023 · 26/05/2022 08:26

Ooh yes I forgot having a really good covered market with lots of local businesses.

itrytomakemyway · 26/05/2022 08:25

Mary Portas said all of this in her TV series - and that was 15 years ago.

There are some towns that are really lovely to visit, have good, interesting, attractive places to shop, eat and sit - and they are thriving. Those towns that went for the out of town shopping model are the ones who have lost their high streets. It is just so sad to see what were once thriving places dying on their feet.

Sadly though, a lot of what we are all asking for here costs money. Local councils need to have the money to keep the green spaces looking lovely. Nice, old buildings cost money to maintain. In my High Street our historic buildings are falling apart because they are owned by corporate landlords hundereds of miles away. No one is looking after the buildings. Damaged slates on the roof get left, gutters are not cleared, broken downpipes are not replaced. It is only a matter of time before they start to fall apart - I do worry someone will get hurt if parts of the roof start to come off.

The lovely independent shops often sell expensive items. The tons I know that are doing well are in affluent areas, or have a good tourist trade. Those towns that rely on local custom where the average income is low will never be able to have lovely delis, independent bookshops and cafes selling wonderful handmade cakes. And it is going to get worse. These luxury shops will be amongst the first to go when people have to make cuts to their spending.

It's so sad, but could have been avoided if people had really listed to what Mary Portas was saying.

DreamingofItaly2023 · 26/05/2022 08:23

Nice bookshop, zero waste shop, good bakery, cinema, theatre, cafes and restaurants, really good adventure playground, picnic space, water park, library, museum. Buses that run more regularly and a train station.

Not interested in any chain shops or supermarkets as do online shopping and click and collect. Basically I would like town centres to be nice places for families and individuals to relax, play, eat, enjoy culture and potter around interesting independent shops.

To be fair our local town is pretty much this and it is very nice although heaving with tourists in summer but can’t complain about that as it brings in the money needed for the town :) Could do with better public transport however.

TheRealShedSadie · 26/05/2022 08:19

My favorite town has loads of independent shops, little garden to sit, a nice mixture of cafes and pubs. A proper butcher, two bakeries, shoe shop, pet supplies and a craft shop. Not posh, not fancy, just ordinary and affordable. Feels like a proper community and welcoming.
it’s hugely popular with visitors who love it because it’s unique and not full of chains like everywhere else. There’s also reasonable parking and a regular bus from rural surroundings.
Sadly it has become, for all these reasons, a second home paradise, so local services like the post office have started to close as the local residents dwindle out of holiday season.

My local city centre is awful. £10 to park, full of cheap chains and a wasteland at one end due to shop closures. Not a nice atmosphere sometimes to walk through. Lots of drug and alcohol problems sadly. I only go when I have to.

Fairislefandango · 26/05/2022 08:13

The only thing my local town (in the NW of England) is missing really is a department store. It used to have one, but not a very good one, and it closed down a few years ago. I'd kill for a John Lewis, but it's not a big enough town to merit one.

There is plenty of parking, umpteen lovely cafés, a Waterstones, a sewing/knitting/craft shop (yay!), a few clothes and shoe shops, including a couple of independent ones, a nice library, a fairly big Boots etc. The town centre is relatively busy. It benefits from being on the edge of an area which is a major tourist destination.

Spitescreen · 26/05/2022 08:12

www.pps.org/article/the-power-of-10

I always think this is sensible — the idea is that places thrive best when the people who use them have a minimum of ten reasons to be there, which could include places to sit, places to eat, public art to look at, somewhere for children to play, a market or shops to buy things at, nature/history to encounter etc etc. It also considers things like — is the place (which could be a park, square, town centre, market, or city district) easily and safely accessible? Is it easily used by children, elderly and/or disabled people? Can you get there on foot or public transport? Does it feel safe for women? Is it used at all times of day by multiple types of people? Are there enough places to sit? Can you buy food/coffee? Is it kept clean and litter-free? Are facilities maintained? Are there interesting things to look at, or a lot of ‘dead space’ (blank walls, empty shopfronts etc)?

perenniallymessy · 26/05/2022 08:08

Free or reduced parking for shoppers (up to about 4 or 5 hours), good bus services for office workers and shoppers without cars. Plenty of bike lanes and secure bike parking around (plus specific parking for eg cargo bikes).

Maybe zoned areas, so people can head towards the types of shops they like. So KFC/McDs, pound shops etc towards one area; independent cafes, delicatessens and fancier clothes and home shops in another area. I like both ends of the spectrum.

Things to do and services- cinema, restaurants, library, decent post office.

TangoWhiskyAlphaTango · 26/05/2022 08:04

@lakielady I thought we lived in the same place until you mentioned Homebase so it can't be.

I also live in a historic town which is thriving. It is pedestrianised at weekends, has lots of independent shops, a beautiful indoor market that has stalls from a gin bar to street food to the usual meat and veg. Once a month it holds a local farmers market in the square. The town leads onto the river with a massive amount of green space and park for children. We have a lot of visitors though and I think that adds massively to the economy here. Still have M&S, Sea Salt, Whistles, New Look, Joules etc so plenty of clothes shops if you like those places.

IbizaToTheNorfolkBroads · 26/05/2022 08:01

My local town centre is lovely:
Aldi, Lidl, police station, health centre/cottage hospital, swimming baths/sports centre 10 mins walk out of town through a park
Big CoOp and small Sainsbury’s in town
Lots of independent shops - books, toys, health food, cheese, butcher, baker, clothes, gifts, cards, walking boots/running shoes, bikes, retro shop, hippy shop. Bridal shop. Computer shop. Chemist. Interiors bits. A few “naice” charity shops. Post office. Park. Trendy and traditional hairdressers, several physios! Sadly the music shop and shoe shop have closed.
Cafes, bars, restaurants

it’s about 8 miles away (which is about 20 mins drive) and great for popping in, or pottering. It’s a bit of a rural centre and has a big car park to accommodate us bumpkins.

balalake · 26/05/2022 07:58

No McDonalds, no KFC, a range of independent shops, good public transport to get there.

starlingdarling · 26/05/2022 07:56

Free parking would be a good start but I think it might be too late. The council parking in our town centre costs £7 for the 4 hours I spend at the hairdresser. Not really tempting to go and browse in shops in town when the retail park is free. We also have nice bars,restaurants and cafes outside of the town centre with free parking so meet friends at one of those. Our local town centre has lost most of its shops and I'm not sure any new ones can be tempted to open.