Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Teachers should have guns

120 replies

Smartsub · 25/05/2022 17:25

This was put forward (by a colleague) as a serious solution to prevent further tragedies in US.

I don't know how American teachers would feel, but I can't imagine any teachers wanting a gun in their desk.

However, AIBU to think that if this did happen, it would increase, not reduce tragedies, either students getting hold of a teacher's gun or a teacher themselves, in a MH crisis?

OP posts:
araiwa · 26/05/2022 01:42

American teachers are not funded adequately enough to be provided with pencils, paper etc for the classroom.

I doubt they can afford guns

DrippyLongstocking · 26/05/2022 01:32

an* absolutely abysmal society.

DrippyLongstocking · 26/05/2022 01:02

emmylousings · 25/05/2022 23:25

Thankfully, this is probably one of the few social trends where we don't follow the USA. Along with regressive abortion rights, hopefully. Great country, but so fucked up in lots of ways.

Workers’ rights are another area of divergence. The way low-skilled workers are abused in the US is disgusting. No paid vacation, wages that it’d be generous to describe as ‘poverty wages’, zero paid maternity leave, etc.

And of course healthcare, for-profit prisons and the rest of it.

Lots of wonderful individuals, and absolutely abysmal society.

newusernamelouise · 26/05/2022 00:56

Shootings are much more common statistically in High Schools than elementary schools. Most high schools have a permanent police officer now who is stationed at the school. Also a lot of churches now have armed security people as church shootings have risen. Very sad.

GoodJanetBadJanet · 26/05/2022 00:35

Fucking no-one should have a gun!

Thank goodness we live in the UK.

This!
It's absolutely insane.
Let's remedy by adding MORE guns!!
WTF.

WhatsInAMolatovMocktail · 26/05/2022 00:30

If it wasnt such a serious subject, I'd be tempted to say it sounds like one of the lunatic Cunning Plans from Blackadder.

It is a completely ludicrous idea to give teachers guns. It doesnt even need discussion.

The way to stop people shooting each is to take guns away. Not add more guns.

HollowTalk · 26/05/2022 00:17

When I was teaching I knew one or two very unstable teachers. I don't think those guns would be actually used for protection!

crosstalk · 26/05/2022 00:14

@Agrudge

A child under 14 in the US is 20 times more likely to die from a gunshot wound than any comparable high income country (eg don't compare it to Guatamela or actively war torn states).

Why are military level and police level guns allowed to individuals in the States anyway? Proper hunters aren't going to be using repeaters or handguns. Why are gunshops allowed to sell to most anyone? why are the US police hindered in hunting down gun toting villains by the ease by which gun numbers are shaved off and rifling not a way to track bullets?

A teacher in a classroom is hardly going to be able to lock and load (unless they do it every day and the gun is just on the safety catch) against a random person, won't be able to get the head shot (though could go for the legs) and would unless doing weekly practice would likely miss and/or injure someone else.

Wandering off the point slightly - as a former pistol shooter - would as I got older and less accurate be rated on my ability as a gunman or the fact I was teaching well?

MattoMatto · 26/05/2022 00:06

debbrianna · 25/05/2022 23:55

No they will use it to kill black students/pupils.

Yes, if you think about how police have been called on black students in their schools for minor issues - or nothing at all - it’s hard to imagine how this is not a likely outcome.

MattoMatto · 26/05/2022 00:02

People will find a way.

This is a terrible argument against gun control. ‘People’ often aren’t that motivated - gun killings are often spontaneous decisions (let’s not even get into accidents). And whether planned or not, guns are both horribly efficient and tricky to safely remove from an attacker.

I once saw someone try to argue that people will kill with their bare hands if they really wanted to - let’s all try to remember how many mass stranglings we can remember.

debbrianna · 25/05/2022 23:55

No they will use it to kill black students/pupils.

Nothingiseverything · 25/05/2022 23:43

Just what America needs, more guns!

It is insane that they are all walking around with them. It is insane!

Readtheroom · 25/05/2022 23:40

The people going into schools and shooting are human beings with mental health problems, if they dont have a gun theyre going to use anything they can think of to be a very harmful weapon

LetitiaLeghorn · 25/05/2022 23:35

Dividos · 25/05/2022 23:31

No way!

I would be horrified if a teacher had access to a gun in the classroom 😱

My students would have been horrified if I'd had access to a gun in the classroom. And one or two would have been very nervous... 🤨

Agrudge · 25/05/2022 23:32
  • alot more people
Agrudge · 25/05/2022 23:32

Cameleongirl · 25/05/2022 18:46

That’s the whole point, @Agrudge . People are unpredictable and can suffer from poor mental health or have anger issues, so we shouldn’t routinely have access to firearms.

We don’t NEED give in our everyday lives in 21st century America-yes, a few people hunt, but the vast majority don’t.

If it's not guns they use ,it would be something else. Maybe using a car to mow down people .

Imaging taking one of the big American cars to Vegas and then suddenly deciding to mount the kerb you would kill alot people people.

But nobody would be wanting the big cars banned

People will find a way.

Dividos · 25/05/2022 23:31

No way!

I would be horrified if a teacher had access to a gun in the classroom 😱

emmylousings · 25/05/2022 23:25

Thankfully, this is probably one of the few social trends where we don't follow the USA. Along with regressive abortion rights, hopefully. Great country, but so fucked up in lots of ways.

BorisJohnsonatemyhampster · 25/05/2022 23:20

Unfortunately gun controls will only be brought in when the children or grand children of people like Ted Cruz or Tucker Carlson are killed with guns.

President Reagan was very against stem cell research until he was diagnosed with dementia.

The NRA have a lot of money to spend on ensuring everyday people can buy assault weapons. However, they have a conference this week and guns are not permitted inside. Fine for you and yours to be shot to death but not them and theirs.

DrippyLongstocking · 25/05/2022 23:10

DrippyLongstocking · 25/05/2022 23:09

Mass shootings are very rare in Canada, to the point where it’s hard to even find statistics. There were 3 mass shootings in total between 2010 and 2014.

Sorry, 2000 and 2014 (so about 1 every 4-5 years).

DrippyLongstocking · 25/05/2022 23:09

MrsTerryPratchett · 25/05/2022 20:49

This. There are as many guns in Canada yet Canadians manage not to carry out several school shootings a month. Why is that?

Canada has had more than it's fair share of mass shootings.

A combination of fewer guns and more social care is what's needed.

Never ever going to happen.

Mass shootings are very rare in Canada, to the point where it’s hard to even find statistics. There were 3 mass shootings in total between 2010 and 2014.

Brefugee · 25/05/2022 23:04

Only people who haven't fired guns, had to fire guns or seen gunshot wounds come out with piffle like this.

MelonsMelonsMelons · 25/05/2022 23:01

Yes, the obvious solution to the situation is…… more guns.

growandhope · 25/05/2022 23:00

this assumes that every teacher in the US is a well-balanced, restrained, mentally well individual who will only fire in dire situations. How does he propose to guarantee this or does he just assume this is the case. You could be handing a gun to a maniac.

XenoBitch · 25/05/2022 22:30

Awful idea. That is fighting fire with fire. Knife crime is a huge issue in the UK. Would you say it is appropriate for people to carry knives to protect themselves from other people with knives?
You also have the issue of a teacher potentially having to shoot a student. That is a huge burden to have to deal with. And the need for specialist training too.. not only so they know what body parts to aim at, but also to avoid shooting other people too. No one goes into teaching expecting to be taught that.
Start from the ground. Better mental health support for teens, and training for teachers to be able to spot issues and signpost them. Proper support for students that are being bullied, and punishments for the people bullying them.
No one wakes up one day and decides to shoot up a school.