Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Who will win between Johnny Depp and Amber Heard defamation case

681 replies

Egtermekaar · 25/05/2022 14:49

If you were jury in this case, how would you decide?

I think Johnny Depp will win because he had strong, reliable and consistent evidence of "his" case

I hope MN will allow debate about a matter of public interest.

OP posts:
BeyondPurpleTulips · 25/05/2022 19:50

For libel the onus is on the claimant to prove, not the defendant. So it is up to JD to prove he didnt abuse her, rather than her to prove he did. (Same for the counter-claim I would presume, though I'm less sure of that)

I believe her, and I think she has "won" in the sense of who proved what legally. That said, I'm less sure of the jury finding her way. I don't hold my breath for anything in that country.

BobbinHood · 25/05/2022 19:36

LetitiaLeghorn · 25/05/2022 19:20

That still leaves 8 incidents even if those 2 were dismissed. And his team were denied leave to appeal. His behaviour in even bringing this case at all backs up that he’s an abuser.

But as I said @BobbinHood, the judge believed her. So each point he believed her on, added credibility to the others. He only believed her over the Hicksville trailer because he said it was in line with Depps usual behaviour. Which Heard had told him about. But it was a lie about the trailer. If he'd known she lied on 3 points, maybe that would have undermined his rulings on the other points. And I haven't gone through all the incidents the judge ruled on, so I could probably find things to discredit those as well.

She lied over things. We now know she has because we've heard it in court. Neither we nor the uk court knew it at the time but Depp did. Why wouldn't he want everyone to know his side of the story? And why is he wrong to want her lies exposed and be exonerated in a small way?

What’s the point dragging someone through the mud to be exonerated for one thing when he’s done equally bad things and worse? His stated aim was to destroy her, not to clear his name because he knows he can’t do that because he is not innocent. And he’s succeeding in that with the help of social media manipulation and people who are taken in by his reputation and are letting that cloud their judgement.

I genuinely feel like I’m watching a different trial to other people. Even his conduct in court has disgusted me throughout.

DorothyZbornakIsAQueen · 25/05/2022 19:28

There are no 'winners' here.

In fact dd was telling me a boy pushed one of her friends the other day and when she told him he had hurt her he told her to 'stop being an Amber Heard'

Regardless of who is telling the truth, this trial has been a disaster for female victims of domestic abuse and a massive win for misogyny.

LetitiaLeghorn · 25/05/2022 19:26

BigFatLiar · 25/05/2022 19:08

Depends who's on the jury. I suspect it'll boil down to the women saying she's obviously a victim and the men saying he's the victim.

People make up their mind fairly quickly and ignore the evidence (though they won't admit it)

I watch a YouTuber, who is a lawyer, who goes to the trial to watch the jury. There are 9 jurers and he said most of them look like they've made up their minds and just look bored most of the time. Some testimony seems to wake them up but it could be in Depps favour or Heards favour so no particular bias one way or the other.

He's definitely biased towards Depp, though, and he thinks it could go either way, so I think Heard's side is probably doing better than most people think. He said things that seem a big thing to us watching, they don't seem to even take on board. That's why I don't think we can predict anything.

LetitiaLeghorn · 25/05/2022 19:20

That still leaves 8 incidents even if those 2 were dismissed. And his team were denied leave to appeal. His behaviour in even bringing this case at all backs up that he’s an abuser.

But as I said @BobbinHood, the judge believed her. So each point he believed her on, added credibility to the others. He only believed her over the Hicksville trailer because he said it was in line with Depps usual behaviour. Which Heard had told him about. But it was a lie about the trailer. If he'd known she lied on 3 points, maybe that would have undermined his rulings on the other points. And I haven't gone through all the incidents the judge ruled on, so I could probably find things to discredit those as well.

She lied over things. We now know she has because we've heard it in court. Neither we nor the uk court knew it at the time but Depp did. Why wouldn't he want everyone to know his side of the story? And why is he wrong to want her lies exposed and be exonerated in a small way?

BigFatLiar · 25/05/2022 19:08

Depends who's on the jury. I suspect it'll boil down to the women saying she's obviously a victim and the men saying he's the victim.

People make up their mind fairly quickly and ignore the evidence (though they won't admit it)

OldWivesTale · 25/05/2022 19:07

tabulahrasa · 25/05/2022 15:09

Who I think will win and what I’d decide if I were on the jury are two different things tbh.

I think he’ll win, because he’s got better lawyers, more money and for some reason loads of public support.

But I’ve watched a fair bit of the trial - mostly unwillingly tbh, but it’s being pushed on every social media platform I’m on.

But, I’m clearly watching a different trial to everyone else as I see a vile man, with a history of violence, drug and alcohol problems - who writes messages in his own blood FFS, it’s not exactly a stretch to believe he hit her.

He’s repeatedly taking her to court, including purposefully picking a state that neither of them have anything to do with just so he could get all that footage of “his side” out.

He had plenty of public support from the industry, he could have literally said it was a volatile relationship, done a quick visit to rehab and it’d have blown over, he’s the one doing damage to his career.

She doesn’t come across particularly well, but, I believe he hit her.

Yes. I can't believe I'm watching the same trial as everyone else. He's awful. I've seen enough video evidence - never mind anything else - to see that he's clearly abusive.

BobbinHood · 25/05/2022 19:00

LetitiaLeghorn · 25/05/2022 18:05

But we already know that one of the findings that the uk judge made in the Sun's favour has been proved to be wrong. And we know that there is now contradictory evidence over another incident that would probably mean he'd find it not proven.
The UK judge took AHs testimony at face value and believed her version over Depps. And we now know by doing that he believed at least two things that were definitely not true. And because he believed one thing, he said in his ruling, that supported her claims in the other facts.

That still leaves 8 incidents even if those 2 were dismissed. And his team were denied leave to appeal. His behaviour in even bringing this case at all backs up that he’s an abuser.

LetitiaLeghorn · 25/05/2022 18:50

AdamRyan · 25/05/2022 18:23

And then another three who upheld the verdict and refused Depp leave to appeal 🙄

But the original trial was done with one judge.
The appeal judges held that lying over the donation wouldn't have changed the outcome and it was the fault of Depps team not to challenge her over that.
But we now know that she lied over more than one thing at the trial. She even gave false evidence to the Sun's lawyers so they lied at the appeal.

PurplePansy05 · 25/05/2022 18:46

I think they are both disturbed in different ways and their relationship was highly toxic and dysfunctional. I also think they should've gone separate ways and address their issues privately, individually in order to rebuild their lives.

Instead, we have a distasteful media circus playing out in numerous courts now. I don't even want to read about either of them ever again, it's just too embarrassing.

I don't find either of them reliable or believable so it's a tough call regarding who might win this, IMO.

PeekAtYou · 25/05/2022 18:45

I think this case is disastrous for DV victims though. It really has reinforced to me the need the public has for "perfect victims" in either party's case.

I wouldn't go to the police over a rape/sexual abuse crime either because the threshold for others to believe you has probably been raised even higher.

Remainiac · 25/05/2022 18:42

JD is/was a global figure with a huge fanbase. For someone like that, the only court that matters is the court of public opinion and in that court he appears to be the winner.
The pair of them were in a mutually abusive relationship- he’s got problems caused by his addictions and she’s a nutcase. Unfortunately, unlike JD, she doesn’t have enough social capital to overcome her disadvantages so she loses big time, no matter what the jury decides. Her career is over, his may or may not recover a bit, but he won’t be the force he was.

locok · 25/05/2022 18:32

I think this case is disastrous for DV victims though. It really has reinforced to me the need the public has for "perfect victims" in either party's case.

agree with this point.

locok · 25/05/2022 18:31

And I personally disagree that he hasn't been harmed by the allegations.

locok · 25/05/2022 18:30

What he is currently doing regarding taking her to court and choosing to that in the way he has, confirms to me that he is an abusive piece of shit person. He is doing what many abusers do: using the courts to hurt his ex. He didn’t have to take this to court in at least 2 different countries, he was always going to be ok because he is Johnny fucking Depp. Rich, white, male and incredibly popular- he has God like status to many people it seems, his career would have been fine, long term, or at least not adversely effected by AH’s allegations.

I'm not sure what I think, I do KMs testimony is very helpful to JD. However I don't understand the above narrative. Why shouldn't anyone take someone else to court?

FoxesEat · 25/05/2022 18:24

I think the jury will find in JDs favour. In my mind he should lose, since I think it's been proven his behaviour was emotionally abusive but since it's also well proven AH was physically abusive and has found to be dishonest about other aspects of the case I can see the jury going his way.

I think this case is disastrous for DV victims though. It really has reinforced to me the need the public has for "perfect victims" in either party's case.

AdamRyan · 25/05/2022 18:23

And then another three who upheld the verdict and refused Depp leave to appeal 🙄

lassof · 25/05/2022 18:13

Depp has clearly won the real game.
I think they may both lose in court. If they won, I would give them a dollar each for hurt feelings.
Depp will find his way back into film

LetitiaLeghorn · 25/05/2022 18:12

@MarshaBradyo And I probably am a bit naughty saying this because it's stirring a bit, but the judge's son works / worked with Dan Wooton on TalkRadio. I'm sure that didn't influence the judge but you can see how conspiracy theorists would have a field day.

KleineDracheKokosnuss · 25/05/2022 18:12

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

^^this. Her own evidence is that she hit him. The evidence of the witnesses indicates he was hit, screamed at and gaslit by her. She’s been shown up as a liar.

LetitiaLeghorn · 25/05/2022 18:08

@MarshaBradyo No, it was just one judge.

MarshaBradyo · 25/05/2022 18:06

LetitiaLeghorn · 25/05/2022 18:05

But we already know that one of the findings that the uk judge made in the Sun's favour has been proved to be wrong. And we know that there is now contradictory evidence over another incident that would probably mean he'd find it not proven.
The UK judge took AHs testimony at face value and believed her version over Depps. And we now know by doing that he believed at least two things that were definitely not true. And because he believed one thing, he said in his ruling, that supported her claims in the other facts.

I admit that I haven’t really followed any of this but was there a jury for the U.K. trial?

LetitiaLeghorn · 25/05/2022 18:05

BobbinHood · 25/05/2022 17:17

I haven’t seen all the evidence. But from what I have seen, he should lose. She may well be abusive too but that’s not what is on trial and it doesn’t mean that he isn’t. He lost the libel case against the Sun and they had a really high threshold to meet. Hopefully even if he wins he’ll never be employed again because he’s shown himself to be a disgraceful excuse for a human being.

But we already know that one of the findings that the uk judge made in the Sun's favour has been proved to be wrong. And we know that there is now contradictory evidence over another incident that would probably mean he'd find it not proven.
The UK judge took AHs testimony at face value and believed her version over Depps. And we now know by doing that he believed at least two things that were definitely not true. And because he believed one thing, he said in his ruling, that supported her claims in the other facts.

PeekAtYou · 25/05/2022 17:58

JD has won. Although this isn't what the trial was about, he's proven that he was the victim of abuse and will get work again.

Amber won't get £50m even if she wins the case. She'll never work in Hollywood and will be trolled indefinitely even if she wins. Her case is full of holes and discrepancies and if the jury are like the public then they will like JD's lawyers and experts more.

It will be interesting to see if Amber faces legal consequences in Australia or the UK due to the lies that she told. Her donating £7m was one of the reasons that the judge believed her

Algarythmnmadness · 25/05/2022 17:38

Butitsnotfunnyisititsserious · 25/05/2022 15:57

I agree. The outcome is in essence, irrelevant. JD did what he set out to do, prove AH has lied and exaggerated on many occasions and that she has been violent towards him. AH will be lucky if she works in Hollywood again, knowing how high public dislike is for her, it would be an indicator that a film starring her would not do well.

Totally agree, JD has achieved his objectives. A win for him in court would just be the cherry on the cake

Swipe left for the next trending thread