Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Who will win between Johnny Depp and Amber Heard defamation case

681 replies

Egtermekaar · 25/05/2022 14:49

If you were jury in this case, how would you decide?

I think Johnny Depp will win because he had strong, reliable and consistent evidence of "his" case

I hope MN will allow debate about a matter of public interest.

OP posts:
Cantanka · 26/05/2022 18:59

I have done a complete about turn. I have been Team Johnny for so long because I think Amber Heard sounds fairly unpleasant.

However:
a) I believe he did abuse her because our High Court has made findings that he did. I didn’t watch that trial obviously, but the footage from America is not filling me with confidence as to the quality of justice being dispensed on that court. The whole thing is coming across as a farce. I do however have the highest respect for the decision of our high court. You don’t hoodwink a High Court judge easily, and Amber Heard persuaded Nicol J.
b) I agree that he is trying to ruin her. Having dragged all this up in England, he is now making her relive it all again when he has already lost once (albeit against the Sun not Amber, but the same issues at heart)
c) the rank misogyny which means she is getting a much harder time than him with the public. He’s still Mr Popular but her name is now dirt.
d) fundamentally, I don’t like to see anyone torn down and ruined in the way Amber Heard has been, especially if it’s because they’re an abuse victim (which I believe she is) speaking out about abuse.

SunnyShiner · 26/05/2022 18:57

The crying with no tears was very irritating. I hope Johnny gets justice.

FloorWipes · 26/05/2022 18:49

Without a crystal ball it’s hard to know the effect, if any, on other cases. I can still imagine though that the effect could be positive because this case feels educational. I see AH as the primary abuser and of course I can’t know but I think she probably does have a cluster B personality disorder. I’ve been in a relationship with someone who I’m pretty sure had such a disorder/significant traits and although the dynamic was textbook in many ways (and also relied upon my own characteristics and vulnerabilities which I now understand but didn’t then), no one had ever taught me about it so I couldn’t recognise it. A high profile case exposing this dynamic could be a positive thing. People can recognise it in their own lives if it’s something they’ve experienced.

Geneva12 · 26/05/2022 18:46

Amber has just admitted that she wrote the op-Ed about Johnny so I would say that Johnny will win, seeing as this trial was about whether it not she actually wrote it about him.

Midlifemusings · 26/05/2022 18:09

SameToo · 26/05/2022 18:06

Whatever happens, abused people everywhere will be at further risk as a result of this case.

It is doing irreparable damage to the credibility of victims testimony and will likely dissuade those who were thinking of speaking out from doing it.

There are no winners here.

I don't think so entirely. What people objected to was the outright lies. A truthful victim has no relationship to this case. I have seen the opposite online with people praising Depp for coming forward as a victim and how that opened doors for others.

SameToo · 26/05/2022 18:06

Whatever happens, abused people everywhere will be at further risk as a result of this case.

It is doing irreparable damage to the credibility of victims testimony and will likely dissuade those who were thinking of speaking out from doing it.

There are no winners here.

Agrudge · 26/05/2022 17:56

PollyDarton1 · 26/05/2022 17:39

I agree with this entirely.

I'm neither "Team" JD or AH, but the rhetoric that JD is somehow a saint after talking about fucking a rotten corpse baffles me.

Has anyone actually said hes a saint?

worriedatthistime · 26/05/2022 17:47

@Midlifemusings it is by many on here , hes a man so automatically guilty by many on here
They are both pretty awful in different ways and was a very toxic relationship

PollyDarton1 · 26/05/2022 17:39

tabulahrasa · 25/05/2022 15:09

Who I think will win and what I’d decide if I were on the jury are two different things tbh.

I think he’ll win, because he’s got better lawyers, more money and for some reason loads of public support.

But I’ve watched a fair bit of the trial - mostly unwillingly tbh, but it’s being pushed on every social media platform I’m on.

But, I’m clearly watching a different trial to everyone else as I see a vile man, with a history of violence, drug and alcohol problems - who writes messages in his own blood FFS, it’s not exactly a stretch to believe he hit her.

He’s repeatedly taking her to court, including purposefully picking a state that neither of them have anything to do with just so he could get all that footage of “his side” out.

He had plenty of public support from the industry, he could have literally said it was a volatile relationship, done a quick visit to rehab and it’d have blown over, he’s the one doing damage to his career.

She doesn’t come across particularly well, but, I believe he hit her.

I agree with this entirely.

I'm neither "Team" JD or AH, but the rhetoric that JD is somehow a saint after talking about fucking a rotten corpse baffles me.

Midlifemusings · 26/05/2022 17:32

tabulahrasa · 26/05/2022 17:26

“JD’s admitted to being a drug-addled drinker, but that doesn’t make you violent”

He’s got a previous assault charge, plus charges for trashing hotel rooms, another ex testified that he’s verbally abusive and throws things during the U.K. case.

He’s had violent incidents going back decades.

Those incidents are from 80s and early 90s. He pled guilty and took responsibility and apologized and paid restitution.

Midlifemusings · 26/05/2022 17:29

Thankfully Amber's daughter is too young to know about any of this.

I feel for Whitney. Any time they pan to her, she is pretty much emotionless. None of Amber's dramatic testiomony moves her or upsets her. She seems either medicated or numb or just dead inside when it comes to this. SHe has a huabdn and two little kids - I also hope she can move on and find peace and happiness.

No one better launch an appeal...

tabulahrasa · 26/05/2022 17:26

“JD’s admitted to being a drug-addled drinker, but that doesn’t make you violent”

He’s got a previous assault charge, plus charges for trashing hotel rooms, another ex testified that he’s verbally abusive and throws things during the U.K. case.

He’s had violent incidents going back decades.

Midlifemusings · 26/05/2022 17:26

AdamRyan · 26/05/2022 17:21

Was just about to say the same.
Powerful men get away with being abusive and sexually violent all the time. This whole trial just exposes the "mens lives are ruined" bullshit imo

Powerful men have gotten away with being abusive and abusing their power.

That means nothing when it comes to this specific case.

A generalization isn't applicable to each individual.

HintofVintagePink · 26/05/2022 17:22

AliceMcK · 26/05/2022 17:04

I think you have summed it up perfectly here.

Absolutely agree.

Having survived DV, it turns you inside out and hollows out your insides. You crumble, then resist, then crumble further, then resist, and on and on until there is nothing left.

Amber is detestable. Mentioning threats against her baby is just another emotional manipulation.

Grantanow · 26/05/2022 17:21

I don't care one way or the other. Wealthy people having an affordable spat.

AdamRyan · 26/05/2022 17:21

Windbeneathmybingowings · 26/05/2022 16:31

Hollywood would have binned him long ago if he was as stoned and savage as Amber says.

History proves this untrue. Look at Harvey W and Bill Cosby. How many decades did that take.

John Lennon also. Still seen as a folk hero.

Was just about to say the same.
Powerful men get away with being abusive and sexually violent all the time. This whole trial just exposes the "mens lives are ruined" bullshit imo

LampLighter414 · 26/05/2022 17:08

Team Jonny all the way

Amber is a fame hungry attention seeker (don't like my opinion? I hope you argue the same when MN constantly slags off Meghan Markle because she is not white)

AliceMcK · 26/05/2022 17:04

MyneighbourisTotoro · 25/05/2022 17:33

I see a woman who is abusive and likes to goad her partners into a fight, this was a toxic relationship and JD has always been vulnerable and has had difficulties with drink and drugs due to an abusive life growing up and AH also abused the same substances.
In my opinion if he ever did abuse her then it was in retaliation from her relentlessness, it doesn’t excuse the behaviour but she is clearly an awful person who repeatedly took advantage of him.
I say this as someone who has been abused and had to live with someone constantly pushing for fights and degrading me. It’s soul destroying, some people snap, others become a shell of their former self.

I think you have summed it up perfectly here.

Windbeneathmybingowings · 26/05/2022 16:31

Hollywood would have binned him long ago if he was as stoned and savage as Amber says.

History proves this untrue. Look at Harvey W and Bill Cosby. How many decades did that take.

John Lennon also. Still seen as a folk hero.

Butitsnotfunnyisititsserious · 26/05/2022 15:33

it’s a sad day for dv survivors when we see public support for the abuser and the ( likely ) victim vilified.

If he wins, it'll be a good day for dv survivors such as myself. She's not a victim. She's the abuser.

Supersimkin2 · 26/05/2022 15:12

JD’s admitted to being a drug-addled drinker, but that doesn’t make you violent. He might be high-maintenance and a prima donna to boot, but the fact remains it’s bloody unlikely anyone turns into a wife-beater at 50. Fat & fucked up & Fifty.

Amber’s a liar, busted too many times to count. Her verbal abuse was startlingly cruel - unprovoked and to her DH’s face. She threw the first punch in every way.

‘They’re both ghastly’ seems to stay as the majority verdict - but I suspect Depp is fundamentally ok, cos Hollywood would have binned him long ago if he was as stoned and savage as Amber says.

AchatAVendre · 26/05/2022 14:54

tabulahrasa · 25/05/2022 15:09

Who I think will win and what I’d decide if I were on the jury are two different things tbh.

I think he’ll win, because he’s got better lawyers, more money and for some reason loads of public support.

But I’ve watched a fair bit of the trial - mostly unwillingly tbh, but it’s being pushed on every social media platform I’m on.

But, I’m clearly watching a different trial to everyone else as I see a vile man, with a history of violence, drug and alcohol problems - who writes messages in his own blood FFS, it’s not exactly a stretch to believe he hit her.

He’s repeatedly taking her to court, including purposefully picking a state that neither of them have anything to do with just so he could get all that footage of “his side” out.

He had plenty of public support from the industry, he could have literally said it was a volatile relationship, done a quick visit to rehab and it’d have blown over, he’s the one doing damage to his career.

She doesn’t come across particularly well, but, I believe he hit her.

I agree with all of this. He's just a drug-addled, bitter spoilt ageing actor and I do believe perfectly capable of throwing his toys violently out of the pram.

Hideous to see the courts entertain this circus. I cannot believe the way that some of those lawyers are behaving in that court room, laughing and sniggering at certain testimonies. The questioning too, so leading, so many allowances made for it be leading...I mean I know its an adversarial legal system but I think defamation actions like these show the real benefits of inquisatorial systems.

Hijklmno · 26/05/2022 14:50

If he’s your typical abusive male then he’s done a classic and manipulated everyone into believing him, armed with more money and better lawyers.

it’s a sad day for dv survivors when we see public support for the abuser and the ( likely ) victim vilified.

Neither of them have done themselves a favour by airing all this to the world.

Midlifemusings · 26/05/2022 14:43

AdamRyan · 26/05/2022 14:37

Amber hasn't taken respsonibility for anything, didn't hand over her phones or any original photos and texts, refused to follow court orders to hand over what she did have, and hasn't owned any part of any of it.
This is just untrue.
She spoke to Depps psychologist
She has submitted all the photos/texts
On the stand she admitted to drugs and hitting him
His team basically object as much as they possibly can to everything coming from her side. Depps team have disallowed a load of her medical and photo evidence. They basically made it impossible for her to talk about her injuries.
I'm not sure what you are expecting from her?

She was court ordered to talk to Depp's psychologist - that was not optional or her choice. And she didn't fully cooperate with the interview.

Read the motion on the pictures. She absolutely did not submit any original photos or texts. Her team missed the deadlines and didn't use an approved format. She said she no longer had any of the phones from the time of her marriage and all she submitted was what had been backed up or saved on other devices.

She didn't take responsibility for hitting him at all. She twisted to make it seem it was defensive and she was fighting to save her sister's life.

Her photos were not allowed because they didn't submit photos that could be validated. Had she chosen to submit photos that could be validated - they too would have been approved. Depp's team were also not allowed to submit non validated photos.

I think if you count objections - you will not find that his team objects any more than hers.

AdamRyan · 26/05/2022 14:37

Amber hasn't taken respsonibility for anything, didn't hand over her phones or any original photos and texts, refused to follow court orders to hand over what she did have, and hasn't owned any part of any of it.
This is just untrue.
She spoke to Depps psychologist
She has submitted all the photos/texts
On the stand she admitted to drugs and hitting him
His team basically object as much as they possibly can to everything coming from her side. Depps team have disallowed a load of her medical and photo evidence. They basically made it impossible for her to talk about her injuries.
I'm not sure what you are expecting from her?

Swipe left for the next trending thread