Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Who will win between Johnny Depp and Amber Heard defamation case

681 replies

Egtermekaar · 25/05/2022 14:49

If you were jury in this case, how would you decide?

I think Johnny Depp will win because he had strong, reliable and consistent evidence of "his" case

I hope MN will allow debate about a matter of public interest.

OP posts:
Butitsnotfunnyisititsserious · 27/05/2022 05:30

SunnyShiner · 26/05/2022 18:57

The crying with no tears was very irritating. I hope Johnny gets justice.

Stops as soon as someone says objection as well.

SarahJane00 · 27/05/2022 05:24

Geneva12 · 26/05/2022 18:46

Amber has just admitted that she wrote the op-Ed about Johnny so I would say that Johnny will win, seeing as this trial was about whether it not she actually wrote it about him.

This is a defamation case so the elements to prove on the balance of probabilities are : 1. publication of 2. an actionable statement with 3. the requisite intent. Depp must prove by clear and convincing evidence that a defamatory statement was made with ‘actual malice’ (i.e knowledge that it was false and with reckless disregard of whether it was false or not’. This means the biggest hurdle for Depp is essentially proving the statements in Heard’s op-ed were false.

KatherineJaneway · 27/05/2022 05:17

I am not sure it matters if he wins, he's done what I suspect was the point of the legal action, air what he needs to in public. Get the public and industry back on his side as much as he can.

SarahJane00 · 27/05/2022 05:12

tabulahrasa · 25/05/2022 15:09

Who I think will win and what I’d decide if I were on the jury are two different things tbh.

I think he’ll win, because he’s got better lawyers, more money and for some reason loads of public support.

But I’ve watched a fair bit of the trial - mostly unwillingly tbh, but it’s being pushed on every social media platform I’m on.

But, I’m clearly watching a different trial to everyone else as I see a vile man, with a history of violence, drug and alcohol problems - who writes messages in his own blood FFS, it’s not exactly a stretch to believe he hit her.

He’s repeatedly taking her to court, including purposefully picking a state that neither of them have anything to do with just so he could get all that footage of “his side” out.

He had plenty of public support from the industry, he could have literally said it was a volatile relationship, done a quick visit to rehab and it’d have blown over, he’s the one doing damage to his career.

She doesn’t come across particularly well, but, I believe he hit her.

I disagree. I have watched every day and, as a lawyer myself, I think the evidence heavily weighs in favour of Johnny Depp. I will explain more about that below, but first - Virginia.

If Johnny Depp is telling the truth, I think it makes most sense for it to be brought in Virginia and televised.

First, Depp is suing Ms Heard for an op-ed she published in the Washington Post. Washington Post’s place of business is in Virginia so it’s a jurisdictional decision.

Second, if your interest is in speaking the truth and clearing your name (to help you to gain work again), you need to convince the right people to contract you again. In Johnny Depp’s case, those people listen to public popularity to gauge whether they will make good $$ by contracting him. Regardless of whether he wins (and I actually don’t think he will as the bar is significantly high being a unanimous jury to decide in his favour on the balance of probabilities - not beyond reasonable doubt), his interest is in telling his story to the world because those people affect his popularity, and by extension, livelihood. Also, if a public figure has made up significant lies about you and other things - and these are some of the most serious allegations - what better way to ensure their evidence is properly tested than by allowing the world to hear what they have to say and provide evidence if they know it to be untrue? We have seen the power of this now as multiple people have come forward with evidence to contradict Amber Heard’s testimony. This is fair (if Johnny is telling the truth).

Before this trial, I thought they were both nuts because of the fiasco in Australia with the dogs and also the media around their relationship. However, having watched the full trial (minus closing statements tomorrow), I do believe Depp, on the balance of probabilities.

Credibility is significantly important in a ‘he said she said’ scenario and I think Depp has come off more genuine and credible in his testimony. His story has been consistent and he has conceded where it’s not favourable to him (i.e. vulgar text messages in anger and drugs/alcohol abuse). These things aren’t absolute but they go to his credibility.

Amber Heard does not have a whole lot of convincing circumstantial evidence Depp sexually or physically abused her (the contrary exists though) and more importantly, we have seen her credibility shot to pieces because she has lied on several occasions (and not conceded on anything), under oath. Her stories often don’t make sense when you piece them altogether. For example (and there are many), her response to every question about numerous photos of her on the day/s following alleged significant abuse is that we can’t see bruising or swelling because she’s always wearing make up. In isolation, this may be plausible.. Yet, there’s evidence that (she denies) she tipped off the paparazzi that she would be at the courthouse and to get footage of a bruise under her right eye on a day she randomly doesn’t wear make up. Then in photos with her friends the following day, we can’t see a bruise again because ‘she’s wearing makeup’. Pieced together, this just doesn’t make a whole lot of sense/logic.

I don’t think either party will win (though if I was on the jury, I would be in favour of Depp at this point), but at least their stories have been heard (no pun intended).

LetitiaLeghorn · 27/05/2022 02:21

@Cantanka
You don’t hoodwink a High Court judge easily, *and Amber Heard persuaded

Hmm. He was hoodwinked over her donating $7m. He's spoke as if that portrayed her in a good light to him. We now know that was a lie and that she lied in the UK court about that. She even lied at the application to appeal by saying that she'd made a 10 year plan to pay the donations. The children's hospital said they knew nothing about a plan and had expected to have it paid in full ASAP.

Incident #3 was a claim of sexual assault and trashing a trailer. The judge found that she wasn't sexually assaulted. He did find that Depp trashed the trailer based on the fact this followed Depps usual behaviour. We now know from the owner of the trailer, that the trailer wasn't trashed. Just a $62 light fitting was broken. So Depp had not trashed anything but Judge Nicol found him guilty because he was violent on other occasions.

But in incident #1 the judge said there was really insufficient evidence to find him guilty as a one off event but because he, the judge, had found Depp guilty of other occasions, this fitted within the same pattern so he reckoned he was guilty of that too.

So out of 12 incidents, one was subsequently proved untrue and one had insufficient evidence to be true as a one off event. On both, he was found guilty without evidence. Instead the guilty finding on one, supported him being guilty on the other. A bit like you going to court for a speeding offence. And the police threw in another speeding offence without any evidence and you were found automatically guilty because they'd found you guilty on the 1st offence.

Incident #9 was the fight on the stairs. The judge found Depp violent but Heard was only violent in defence of her sister.

In court Heard stated that she was on a mezzanine level and Depp was on ground level. Whitney ,her sister, had come down the stairs, presumably from a higher floor, and was on the mezzanine with her. She and Depp were trading insults and he suddenly ran up the stairs to the mezzanine level. He grabbed Heard's hair and hit her in the face. They struggled and Whitney "threw herself in the line of fire" between them. Whitneys back was to the staircase and Depp swung at Whitney. Heard says she immediately thought of Kate Moss and stairs, and she swung at him to protect her sister.

But Whitney's account is different.

She says she was downstairs with Depp as he and Heard were exchanging profanities. (My word not hers!) Whitney then went UP the stairs to join her sister. She was stood with her back to the stairs. Depp ran up the stairs and struck Whitney from behind as he passed. (So coming up and behind Whitney and striking from behind would impel Whitney forward and away from the stairs.) Amber shouted, don't hit my sister, and she smacked him. Then Depp grabbed Heards hair and hit her.

So according to Whitney:
a) Heard hit Depp first; Depp retaliated
b) Whitney was pushed away from the stairs not towards them
c) Whitney did not throw herself in the line of fire
d) Depp did not turn on Whitney during a physical fight and go to strike her

If Judge Nicol knew these facts, who he would he say was the aggressor between Depp and Heard?

In incident #13. The judge concluded Depp had “assaulted Ms Heard as he had done on previous occasions when he was stressed”. But there was no evidence. Just another incident that the judge found to be true based on other incidents found to be true with no evidence. But Heard claimed were all similar and he believed her (remember the donation claim).

In incident #14 the judge believed her friends over his employees because he believed Depp's employees would be biased. But he also believed Heard's friends over 2 police officers who had no involvement with either.

So the judge based an assumption of guilt on his other assumptions and not on evidence. I'm not researching the other points. I think parsing 5 is enough.

Was the uk judge right? Maybe. But we know that the trashed trailer was a lie. And we know Heards own sister contradicts the claim the Depp was violent first and went to push Whitney down the stairs. So when people say the judge is very experienced and would never be hoodwinked, I think they're wrong. He was hoodwinked, the only question is by how much.

Krabapple · 27/05/2022 00:01

tabulahrasa · 25/05/2022 15:09

Who I think will win and what I’d decide if I were on the jury are two different things tbh.

I think he’ll win, because he’s got better lawyers, more money and for some reason loads of public support.

But I’ve watched a fair bit of the trial - mostly unwillingly tbh, but it’s being pushed on every social media platform I’m on.

But, I’m clearly watching a different trial to everyone else as I see a vile man, with a history of violence, drug and alcohol problems - who writes messages in his own blood FFS, it’s not exactly a stretch to believe he hit her.

He’s repeatedly taking her to court, including purposefully picking a state that neither of them have anything to do with just so he could get all that footage of “his side” out.

He had plenty of public support from the industry, he could have literally said it was a volatile relationship, done a quick visit to rehab and it’d have blown over, he’s the one doing damage to his career.

She doesn’t come across particularly well, but, I believe he hit her.

I agree with you. He is clearly an awful person (they both are).

TheBigPeach · 26/05/2022 23:54

I think JD will win but I think neither of them deserve a penny. One thing highlighted for me and I haven’t missed any of it, is that they are all making way too much money. What does he need all those houses for? Ridiculous. looks like he lost the run of himself with the success of Pirates and meeting AH all led to his addiction spiralling out of control.
I think his addiction worsened with her in his ear all the time, I’d imagine she was handing him that jar of cocaine.

the way people idolise him is ridiculous. He’s not perfect, I don’t think he was physically abusive but he’s not this perfect person everyone is making him out to be.
the nastiness towards AH on SM is out of control, it’s a constant flow on my newsfeed.
It makes me sad, I do think she was the abuser, but I don’t know.. it’s the hate people are spewing towards someone they don’t know, I just think it’s very sad and I feel sorry for her baby actually because she will grow up with that stigma surrounding her mother and I know how that feels to be guilty by association. Hopefully by time she’s older it will all be forgotten.

amoobaa · 26/05/2022 23:29

tabulahrasa · 25/05/2022 15:09

Who I think will win and what I’d decide if I were on the jury are two different things tbh.

I think he’ll win, because he’s got better lawyers, more money and for some reason loads of public support.

But I’ve watched a fair bit of the trial - mostly unwillingly tbh, but it’s being pushed on every social media platform I’m on.

But, I’m clearly watching a different trial to everyone else as I see a vile man, with a history of violence, drug and alcohol problems - who writes messages in his own blood FFS, it’s not exactly a stretch to believe he hit her.

He’s repeatedly taking her to court, including purposefully picking a state that neither of them have anything to do with just so he could get all that footage of “his side” out.

He had plenty of public support from the industry, he could have literally said it was a volatile relationship, done a quick visit to rehab and it’d have blown over, he’s the one doing damage to his career.

She doesn’t come across particularly well, but, I believe he hit her.

This exactly

AdamRyan · 26/05/2022 23:21

Yet it was her who positioned herself as a survivor, wrote articles about their marriage and, presumably, expected him to roll over and accept it.
Read the article. It's very banal and says nothing about their marriage. Yes he should have accepted it. Part of getting divorced is your ex talks about their perspective and its not the same as yours.

Doggyfish · 26/05/2022 21:57

She's clearly got issues but he is just repulsive. I can't get over people actually cheering and supporting him.

justfiveminutes · 26/05/2022 21:49

I think she'll win because I think she's proven that she's been on the receiving end of abuse, thus able to call herself a domestic abuse survivor.

But I think he was won public opinion and so he should. There marriage was toxic and they both did horrible things to each other. Yet it was her who positioned herself as a survivor, wrote articles about their marriage and, presumably, expected him to roll over and accept it.

I am not a fan of either of them, and believed her for years. But watching this trial live has been eye-opening. She is awful. She set this ball in motion and I am pleased it has backfired. She has been caught in too many lies to have any credibility at all.

tabulahrasa · 26/05/2022 21:28

Midlifemusings · 26/05/2022 20:14

She was listened to for 2.5 years before he took action.

And dismantling lies and no condoning abuse isn't the same as being torn to shreds.

She wasn’t listened to at all, all the pro Johnny depp social media campaigns started as soon as it was reported on and he had plenty of support from public figures too.

AliceMcK · 26/05/2022 21:27

tabulahrasa · 26/05/2022 17:26

“JD’s admitted to being a drug-addled drinker, but that doesn’t make you violent”

He’s got a previous assault charge, plus charges for trashing hotel rooms, another ex testified that he’s verbally abusive and throws things during the U.K. case.

He’s had violent incidents going back decades.

The assault was against a paparazzi who he’d asked to leave him and his pregnant partner alone, they didn’t so JD retaliated. You’d have to accuse every celebrity that defended themselves against the paparazzi of being violent if your claiming this makes him a violent person. Is Britney Spears a violent person, she did far worse by taking a baseball bat to the paparazzi…. I’d love to see you or any average person live with that in your face 24/7 and not retaliate.

same with trashing hotel rooms, I don’t agree with it but again I could rattle off dozens of celebrities who have trashed hotel rooms who have been in the media, especially some of our most esteemed music legends. Hotels that rent out these rooms/suites/floors to certain famous guests expect a lot of this, especially historically.

She also admitted he never hit her.

elephantbreathing · 26/05/2022 20:54

Slightly off subject but AH and Meghan Markle seem like a perfect BFF pairing. They come across similarly.

MrsHastingslikethebattle · 26/05/2022 20:39

Midlifemusings · 26/05/2022 20:28

It was the judge who put forward the motion to televise it.

The OP-ed didnt name him, shes got another husband then?
Amber admitted in court that the OP-ed wasnt 'just about him'.
She alerted media, has been caught out in multiple lies, she has no credibility.

MrsHastingslikethebattle · 26/05/2022 20:36

Hopefully Johnny will win.

Win or lose, he has set out to do...clear his name and expose her lies.

She clearly has issues. She has admitted hitting him on tape and witnesses have said she had physical fights with her sister and friends. She didnt seek any medical assistance after being hit repeatedly with him having rings on each other.
Used her 'bruise kit' but doesn't use it when leaving court after clearly alerting paparazzi.
Editing photos. Alerting media...its so clear what shes like.

Barking mad.

BanditoShipman · 26/05/2022 20:30

MyneighbourisTotoro · 25/05/2022 17:33

I see a woman who is abusive and likes to goad her partners into a fight, this was a toxic relationship and JD has always been vulnerable and has had difficulties with drink and drugs due to an abusive life growing up and AH also abused the same substances.
In my opinion if he ever did abuse her then it was in retaliation from her relentlessness, it doesn’t excuse the behaviour but she is clearly an awful person who repeatedly took advantage of him.
I say this as someone who has been abused and had to live with someone constantly pushing for fights and degrading me. It’s soul destroying, some people snap, others become a shell of their former self.

I have watched most of the trial and I agree with this.

he should win his case,

she has set back abuse victims years unfortunately

Houseoffools · 26/05/2022 20:28

She said the op-ed was about him earlier, I really hope Johnny wins.

Midlifemusings · 26/05/2022 20:28

moiraandthebebe · 26/05/2022 20:23

Legally, she should win. The OpEd didn't name him and she can prove he was abusive enough to call herself a survivor on the texts alone. He's manipulative, disgusting individual and anyone who stands with a man who jokes about raping a woman's dead body before burning her should be well away from any adoration. Those texts were sent in 2013 before the alleged abuse began according to Depp. He was talking about her that way when things were GOOD.

His aim is to publicly humiliate her. That's why it was televised. He's an absolute fucking prick and the Deppford wives need to get a grip. I don't think she's innocent but she's the only one paying for this here.

It was the judge who put forward the motion to televise it.

moiraandthebebe · 26/05/2022 20:23

Legally, she should win. The OpEd didn't name him and she can prove he was abusive enough to call herself a survivor on the texts alone. He's manipulative, disgusting individual and anyone who stands with a man who jokes about raping a woman's dead body before burning her should be well away from any adoration. Those texts were sent in 2013 before the alleged abuse began according to Depp. He was talking about her that way when things were GOOD.

His aim is to publicly humiliate her. That's why it was televised. He's an absolute fucking prick and the Deppford wives need to get a grip. I don't think she's innocent but she's the only one paying for this here.

Midlifemusings · 26/05/2022 20:14

Tillsforthrills · 26/05/2022 20:07

And so she deserves being torn to shreds and have her life ruined, right? And to not be listened to.

Even though he did the same. And had and always will have the power and money between them. Misogyny is alive and well.

She was listened to for 2.5 years before he took action.

And dismantling lies and no condoning abuse isn't the same as being torn to shreds.

Tillsforthrills · 26/05/2022 20:07

starlingdarling · 26/05/2022 19:28

for daring to verbally at least stand up to him.

She "dared" to stand up to him with more than her words. She said so herself.

And so she deserves being torn to shreds and have her life ruined, right? And to not be listened to.

Even though he did the same. And had and always will have the power and money between them. Misogyny is alive and well.

starlingdarling · 26/05/2022 19:28

for daring to verbally at least stand up to him.

She "dared" to stand up to him with more than her words. She said so herself.

AchatAVendre · 26/05/2022 19:19

Cantanka · 26/05/2022 18:59

I have done a complete about turn. I have been Team Johnny for so long because I think Amber Heard sounds fairly unpleasant.

However:
a) I believe he did abuse her because our High Court has made findings that he did. I didn’t watch that trial obviously, but the footage from America is not filling me with confidence as to the quality of justice being dispensed on that court. The whole thing is coming across as a farce. I do however have the highest respect for the decision of our high court. You don’t hoodwink a High Court judge easily, and Amber Heard persuaded Nicol J.
b) I agree that he is trying to ruin her. Having dragged all this up in England, he is now making her relive it all again when he has already lost once (albeit against the Sun not Amber, but the same issues at heart)
c) the rank misogyny which means she is getting a much harder time than him with the public. He’s still Mr Popular but her name is now dirt.
d) fundamentally, I don’t like to see anyone torn down and ruined in the way Amber Heard has been, especially if it’s because they’re an abuse victim (which I believe she is) speaking out about abuse.

Oh she has had her entire personality ripped apart in a public forum far more than any murder suspect does. And I suspect Depp knows that very well and that has been his aim as much as "clearing his name". Its revenge, on his part, for a woman not being head over heels adoring him at every given moment but for daring to verbally at least stand up to him.

Midlifemusings · 26/05/2022 19:04

I just listened to the judge read into record the list of jury instructions. It sounds like she will be reading instructions for an hour! There were dozens. I assume the jury gets a hard copy as well. No way to remember all that.

She gave each side 2 hours for closing starting at 9:00 am. They can use exhibits that have been entered into evidence. They can not use any video'd depositions in their closing. They can not use any written declarations. Only exhibits entered as evidence. Apparently the jury is not given copies of video'd depositions or any written submissions of evidence to use in their deliberations either. (If I understood that correctly). The lawyers seemed a little taken aback to not be allowed to use videos. They are both planning to use powerpoint presentations but she ordered that no text be written on them - only photos and exhibits.

Swipe left for the next trending thread