Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Who will win between Johnny Depp and Amber Heard defamation case

681 replies

Egtermekaar · 25/05/2022 14:49

If you were jury in this case, how would you decide?

I think Johnny Depp will win because he had strong, reliable and consistent evidence of "his" case

I hope MN will allow debate about a matter of public interest.

OP posts:
Tillsforthrills · 27/05/2022 15:20

AdamRyan · 27/05/2022 12:35

It seems you missed Adam Waldman refusing to answer questions as he didn't want to incriminate himself in a crime, and Johnny Depp attempting to get Amber Heards counterclaim thrown out by claiming Waldman was responsible for the smear campaign, which hadnothing to do with him.

Oh, and Heards expert showing the impact of the campaign on her career.

But again, this is about perspectives. His perspective is being portrayed as she bad mouthed him, he deserves to have his side heard. I'm saying, her perspective could be he abused and smeared her, she deserves to have her side heard.

It's misogyny to claim his perspective is more valid than hers. Because it implies two things: Men have more right to tell their story, women should shut up. And women who behave a certain way should expect to be abused.

www.google.com/amp/s/www.independent.co.uk/news/world/americas/amber-heard-johnny-depp-waldman-statements-b2086495.html%3famp

www.google.com/amp/s/www.businessinsider.in/entertainment/news/amber-heard-has-lost-up-to-50-million-due-to-abuse-hoax-claims-industry-expert-testifies/amp_articleshow/91771432.cms

www.google.com/amp/s/www.independent.co.uk/news/world/americas/johnny-depp-adam-waldman-trial-b2082930.html%3famp

Accurate.

Shame on all the misogynistic socially conditioned sheep that defend JD without any balance.

AdamRyan · 27/05/2022 12:35

justfiveminutes · 27/05/2022 11:21

"If someone abused me, for years, in private and then spent the time after we split up maliciously paying PR firms to destroy my reputation in public."

I must have missed that evidence in the courtroom.

It seems you missed Adam Waldman refusing to answer questions as he didn't want to incriminate himself in a crime, and Johnny Depp attempting to get Amber Heards counterclaim thrown out by claiming Waldman was responsible for the smear campaign, which hadnothing to do with him.

Oh, and Heards expert showing the impact of the campaign on her career.

But again, this is about perspectives. His perspective is being portrayed as she bad mouthed him, he deserves to have his side heard. I'm saying, her perspective could be he abused and smeared her, she deserves to have her side heard.

It's misogyny to claim his perspective is more valid than hers. Because it implies two things: Men have more right to tell their story, women should shut up. And women who behave a certain way should expect to be abused.

www.google.com/amp/s/www.independent.co.uk/news/world/americas/amber-heard-johnny-depp-waldman-statements-b2086495.html%3famp

www.google.com/amp/s/www.businessinsider.in/entertainment/news/amber-heard-has-lost-up-to-50-million-due-to-abuse-hoax-claims-industry-expert-testifies/amp_articleshow/91771432.cms

www.google.com/amp/s/www.independent.co.uk/news/world/americas/johnny-depp-adam-waldman-trial-b2082930.html%3famp

YourAWizard · 27/05/2022 12:20

tabulahrasa · 25/05/2022 15:09

Who I think will win and what I’d decide if I were on the jury are two different things tbh.

I think he’ll win, because he’s got better lawyers, more money and for some reason loads of public support.

But I’ve watched a fair bit of the trial - mostly unwillingly tbh, but it’s being pushed on every social media platform I’m on.

But, I’m clearly watching a different trial to everyone else as I see a vile man, with a history of violence, drug and alcohol problems - who writes messages in his own blood FFS, it’s not exactly a stretch to believe he hit her.

He’s repeatedly taking her to court, including purposefully picking a state that neither of them have anything to do with just so he could get all that footage of “his side” out.

He had plenty of public support from the industry, he could have literally said it was a volatile relationship, done a quick visit to rehab and it’d have blown over, he’s the one doing damage to his career.

She doesn’t come across particularly well, but, I believe he hit her.

100% this

DimplesToadfoot · 27/05/2022 11:45

Having seen the latest video , of Depp where depending on whether your team Depp or Team Heard he's either taunting Whitney or inviting Amber's lawyer for a fight, if he's brazen enough to do that in a court room then just what else is he capable of.

justfiveminutes · 27/05/2022 11:23

"He could have come out after the op ed and said something like "I'm aware of some of the issues amber had in her life prior to meeting me, and commend her for using her voice for victims of abuse"

Well she didn't leave it at the op ed did she. For how long was he supposed to ignore her retelling of the narrative that painted herself as an abuse victim and him as the abuser? I certainly believed that narrative. But this has proven that she was far from a victim.

justfiveminutes · 27/05/2022 11:21

"If someone abused me, for years, in private and then spent the time after we split up maliciously paying PR firms to destroy my reputation in public."

I must have missed that evidence in the courtroom.

AdamRyan · 27/05/2022 09:39

Its clear that Depp is using the law of defamation to harass, humiliate and basically stalk Amber Heard. He could have chosen to make his own series of public statements rather than the courts, denying the allegations and he has enough of a fan base that people would have believed him, but he has chosen action that repeatedly rehashes the same issues of their relationship, over and over again, in the most expensive way possible.

Exactly. To me he's basically gone "I'm going down and I'm taking you with me"

He could have come out after the op ed and said something like "I'm aware of some of the issues amber had in her life prior to meeting me, and commend her for using her voice for victims of abuse"

And it would have been a total non-story
But no, he has to escalate and get all this aired in court

AchatAVendre · 27/05/2022 09:34

AdamRyan · 27/05/2022 09:19

If someone abused me, for years, in private and then spent the time after we split up maliciously paying PR firms to destroy my reputation in public, then dragged me to court saying I was lying, I would want to tell my side in the most public way possible and I don't think I'd care very much about the impact on that person.

Do we really want the situation where women are terrified into talking about their past relationships by powerful rich men to become the norm?

Depp isn't the only famous star to have been involved in a libel trial. Craig Maclachlan in Australia just last week dropped his defamation action against multiple woman who had accused him of sexual assault. Theres been a few cases in Britain where men have used the law of defamation to silence women for speaking out against abuse or even rape claims - there was a British case a few years back where the ex girlfriend killed herself in the face of various claims being made against her by her ex, backed by his wealthy family.

The law of defamation is a bit of a farce. Its often vanity-based legal action and ironically often does more to damage the claimant's reputation than the claimed defamatory statements themselves. Because we have an Anglo-American legal system in the UK (well in England at least) we have these awful trials which are not judge-led but claimant and defence led, descending into these lengthy mud slinging battles at great expense. Lawrence Fox is facing a bill of £150,000 just for asking and failing to be granted a civil jury trial as part of his defence for a defamation case being brought against him.

But if your ex is wealthy and was abusive, do you really want to live your life in silence lest you make a statement that might be slandarous or libellous in any way? Its clear that Depp is using the law of defamation to harass, humiliate and basically stalk Amber Heard. He could have chosen to make his own series of public statements rather than the courts, denying the allegations and he has enough of a fan base that people would have believed him, but he has chosen action that repeatedly rehashes the same issues of their relationship, over and over again, in the most expensive way possible.

DoIDareSayAnything · 27/05/2022 09:31

Who will win? The Lawyers. 😁

AdamRyan · 27/05/2022 09:23

mynamesnotMa · 27/05/2022 06:35

Midlifemusings he had the money arrogance and utter contempt for her that she had the strength to stand up to him and publicly shamed him. Ofcourse the article was about him.

Everything about this case is utterly abhorrent. Very upsetting for many who have had years of gaslighting by perpetrators like him.

Exactly.
For some reason posters can say "she's just like my mum/grandma/ex with BOD, she's an abuser" and they get told that's correct and women abusing men is a huge problem
Say "he's just like my abusive narcissist stonewalling gaslighty ex" and you get called a man hater with an agenda

Its misogyny and also distorting reality

AdamRyan · 27/05/2022 09:19

justfiveminutes · 27/05/2022 06:00

If someone told malicious lies about me in public, repeatedly, over years, not caring about their impact on me and my family, I would want to tell my side in the most public way possible and I don't think I'd care very much about the impact on that person.

If someone abused me, for years, in private and then spent the time after we split up maliciously paying PR firms to destroy my reputation in public, then dragged me to court saying I was lying, I would want to tell my side in the most public way possible and I don't think I'd care very much about the impact on that person.

tabulahrasa · 27/05/2022 07:40

I’m going to point out again that they did choose where to file the suit - they went with where the paper is printed, not the headquarters or where the owner is based, both of those were options.

Whydothat · 27/05/2022 07:22

I have never been a JD fan and he has proven himself to be a vile abhorrent man with serious issues however, my ex has borderline and the recordings of Amber terrified me. The only difference between them was he would physically hurt himself then say I did it. I'm pleased JD found a way to get his side played to the world. I don't think it matters if he wins, he's won anyway.

starlingdarling · 27/05/2022 06:50

She wasn’t listened to at all, all the pro Johnny depp social media campaigns started as soon as it was reported on and he had plenty of support from public figures too.

I believed her. I saw her as a meek young woman who was abused by a megastar and too scared to speak out for fear of being blacklisted in Hollywood. I assumed she finally felt safe because of the MeToo movement and a huge shift in support of women speaking out about the abuse in Hollywood. After the English trial she didn't seem quite so helpless but I still thought the relationship was toxic because of him. Since this trial my opinion has changed. @MyneighbourisTotoro put it more eloquently than I could below. She's going to be blacklisted but not because she's a victim.

I see a woman who is abusive and likes to goad her partners into a fight, this was a toxic relationship and JD has always been vulnerable and has had difficulties with drink and drugs due to an abusive life growing up and AH also abused the same substances.
In my opinion if he ever did abuse her then it was in retaliation from her relentlessness, it doesn’t excuse the behaviour but she is clearly an awful person who repeatedly took advantage of him.

Midlifemusings · 27/05/2022 06:46

Maverick101 · 27/05/2022 06:41

The only winners are the lawyers.

The amount of money spent has to be astronomical. People get to choose how they spend their money and I guess Johnny felt that having a voice was worth tens of millions. I was reading some of the court documents and there are so many more motions and write ups and back and forth between lawyers and judges behind the scene that we never even see in the lead up to the trial. One small detail can have dozens of documents associated with it.

Maverick101 · 27/05/2022 06:41

The only winners are the lawyers.

mynamesnotMa · 27/05/2022 06:35

Midlifemusings he had the money arrogance and utter contempt for her that she had the strength to stand up to him and publicly shamed him. Ofcourse the article was about him.

Everything about this case is utterly abhorrent. Very upsetting for many who have had years of gaslighting by perpetrators like him.

Midlifemusings · 27/05/2022 06:27

QuebecBagnet · 27/05/2022 06:21

has he got to prove he wasn’t abusive or has he got to prove he didn’t hit her?

I think they’re both totally toxic and that he could smash the place up and shout (which is abusive). But also that she was abusive to him - and physically as well, she admits it on a tape.

she has been caught out lying at least once on the stand. Which makes me not believe anything she says. Do they not have perjury laws in America?

but I also think he might lose the case as he can’t prove the article was about him.

but I agree he’s “won” no matter what the jury decides. Everyone has heard his side and they have seen how she can be.

He’s repeatedly taking her to court, including purposefully picking a state that neither of them have anything to do with just so he could get all that footage of “his side” out

just wanted to mention this - I believe neither got to choose where the case was heard? It’s to do with the location of the HQ of the newspaper which published her article.

HIs defamation suit was based on three sentences in the OpEd - the title about Amber being a victim of sexual violence, a sentence that said she was a public figure representing domestic violence, and a sentence about insitutions had protected him the abuse but she had faced culture's wrath. Hers was based on three phrases - abuse hoax, fake and fraud.

We will have to wait for specific jury instructions to really understand the law in Virginia and what the jury is tasked to do but I believe the plantiff in each case has to prove the claims the defendents made were false and done with malicious intent.

TheGetaway · 27/05/2022 06:24

This case, along with the Rooney/Vardy one have sickened me and I’ve refused to follow either. Neither should have come to court.

There are no winners

QuebecBagnet · 27/05/2022 06:21

has he got to prove he wasn’t abusive or has he got to prove he didn’t hit her?

I think they’re both totally toxic and that he could smash the place up and shout (which is abusive). But also that she was abusive to him - and physically as well, she admits it on a tape.

she has been caught out lying at least once on the stand. Which makes me not believe anything she says. Do they not have perjury laws in America?

but I also think he might lose the case as he can’t prove the article was about him.

but I agree he’s “won” no matter what the jury decides. Everyone has heard his side and they have seen how she can be.

He’s repeatedly taking her to court, including purposefully picking a state that neither of them have anything to do with just so he could get all that footage of “his side” out

just wanted to mention this - I believe neither got to choose where the case was heard? It’s to do with the location of the HQ of the newspaper which published her article.

Midlifemusings · 27/05/2022 06:20

There are many victims who wish they could expose their abuser. Especially when that abuser has manipulated and charmed others.

Amber didn't think he would ever have a venue to tell his story but he did. He had the money and the perseverance to make it happen. I have seen so many survivors talk about how empowering this trial has been for them to see a victim be able to expose their abuser for who they really are. Many for whom the dynamic in the recordings is all too real and who wish everyone knew what their abuser was really like behind closed doors. They don't have the money or position to do that but having an example of similar experiences in the public sphere validates their own experiences.

mynamesnotMa · 27/05/2022 06:08

justfiveminutes you sure about that how exactly? You are choosing to believe him why? How do you know these are lies because he said so 🤔 My points still stand.

mynamesnotMa · 27/05/2022 06:04

Furthermore he knows how to manipulate her and what buttons to press. She looks like a woman on the edge whilst he portrays the victim smirking. Watch their body language.
I would be interested to know how many of you have had any experience of working with or supporting those who been abused or lived through trauma.
I see this as sad a case as OJ Simpson. He had the best lawyers and ultimately got away with murder.
Look at the body language he's enjoying her discomfort knows she's weaker than him and he's using his public support to twist the knife.

justfiveminutes · 27/05/2022 06:00

mynamesnotMa · 27/05/2022 05:39

I find the whole thing sickening to watch.
He has been allowed to abuse her through the courts. He knows exactly what he's doing. He's a very powerful popular actor and this is all part of his abuse.

If someone told malicious lies about me in public, repeatedly, over years, not caring about their impact on me and my family, I would want to tell my side in the most public way possible and I don't think I'd care very much about the impact on that person.

mynamesnotMa · 27/05/2022 05:39

I find the whole thing sickening to watch.
He has been allowed to abuse her through the courts. He knows exactly what he's doing. He's a very powerful popular actor and this is all part of his abuse.

Swipe left for the next trending thread