Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Who will win between Johnny Depp and Amber Heard defamation case

681 replies

Egtermekaar · 25/05/2022 14:49

If you were jury in this case, how would you decide?

I think Johnny Depp will win because he had strong, reliable and consistent evidence of "his" case

I hope MN will allow debate about a matter of public interest.

OP posts:
Onthedunes · 28/05/2022 05:29

She's mounted a campaign of sheer malice against him and wrecked his reputation

Amber would have done this to Johnny regardless of whether she stayed with him or didn't. Narcissist have a habbit of destroying the person they are with, they have a need to win and also appear the victim, this is something universal about them.
I think Johnny knew that Amber was slowly destroying him whilst in the relationship but didn't fully understand why, his comment about her ambition was greater than her love for him was telling. I do think if they had stayed together Johnny would have retreated into himself more, drinking more, more substance abuse, not seeing his children as much to keep the peace. Her faux concern of his addictions were to place her in the light of the victim,when in reality she wouldn't have cared less if he'd od'd so long as his money was left to her.

She was angry, because he was wising up, she had not yet finished with him or used his benefits sufficiently, narcs do not liked to be discarded, they like to do the discarding, and she was not ready. So plan B, she did not get the settlement she wanted so she decided to ruin him and his reputation, the shame could have meant extracting more from him, it also had the added bonus of cashing in on her victimhood.

I am pleased he has had his day in court, Amber never banked on him doing this, she knew he was a very private person who really must have been mortified in having to lay bare all his private life to the world, his peers and his family.

She knew he felt shame, Amber does not feel shame, it is missing, along with empathy and love.

And for those who think Amber will come to harm after this trial if she loses, she will not be destroyed, she will already have many plan B's in the making, she thinks ahead, where others would hide in shame, she will not, narcissists do not understand shame.

For me this is not just about domestic abuse, it is about domestic abuse with a narcissist, Amber truly will not understand why this is monumently not going her way, she fully believes she has been abused, she doesn't understand fairness or truth, she can only see things from her point of view.

There is no reasoning with a narcissist, ever.

SpidersAreShitheads · 28/05/2022 03:02

TheEnemy123 · 27/05/2022 21:32

I see the same. Those on here calling him an abusive piece of shit and moaning about mysogyny, shame on you. You've shown yourselves incapable of critical thinking and subject to pre-dispositions regarding men always being the abuser and women always being the victim. When you're a man on the receiving end, people don't believe you. Or they think you're a weak waste of space. And you people siding with AH are perpetuating that. I expect better in 2022.

Completely this.

I don't know how much more evidence the man has to produce to show how horribly she abused him. If a woman had a history of substance abuse we wouldn't be suggesting that this was "proof" that she MUST therefore have been the abuser. Absolutely zero evidence of him touching her, and the evidence against her stacked up. She doctored the photos - proven in court by an independent expert - she submitted the same photo and claimed they were different incidents. Members of the police force testified that she was lying. According to her, everyone is lying and wrong except for her - and her fraudulent evidence.

If you support and believe AH, I can only think you've not actually seen the evidence presented, or you have a deep-seated issue with believing men can be victims.

He's odd, has substance addiction issues and you wouldn't want your daughter getting into a relationship with him - but he isn't an abuser. He is a victim. With all the evidence proving his case, we'd never treat a woman the way he's been treated and disbelieved. And I say all this as someone who's not even a Depp fan.

I'm not sure the whole jury will believe there's enough evidence to meet all the counts required for defamation. But I hope she never works again in Hollywood. She's mounted a campaign of sheer malice against him and wrecked his reputation.

DaisyQuakeJohnson · 28/05/2022 02:27

You are gaslighting in your posts here. The UK case and its verdict still stand. Its conclusions and evidence have been proved in a court of law. It's sweet that Depp supporters think their amateur understanding of a case in the US has any impact on UK justice. It doesn't.

They also clearly don't stand with victims of abuse. If they did, they would have followed the advice from DV charities and VAWG organisations that have explained how their narratives about DV are retraumatising victims.

And if, they decided to ignore the experts, and decided not only to continue to post in a damaging way but to deliberately come to a website that's known to support women who are living with or have fled abuse, then they are very obviously trying to create maximum hurt and trauma all under the pretext of 'defending' a wealthy man who doesn't even know they exist.

We know what patterns in DV look like. We know what gaslighting is. We know when posters are ignoring advice from experts in DV so they can pursue their own agenda. And we still know the result of the UK case.

DifficultBloodyWoman · 28/05/2022 02:12

And themself, not the self!

bloody autocorrect!

DifficultBloodyWoman · 28/05/2022 02:11

Sorry, that should have been a ?, not an !.

DifficultBloodyWoman · 28/05/2022 02:10

With regards to the London case, does anyone know if that could be revisited or appealed now that it has come to light that AH lied on the stand (about the divorce settlement donation and possibly other things)?

If a witness is known to have perjured the self, is that ground to retry the case!

TheEnemy123 · 28/05/2022 01:18

SunscreenCentral · 28/05/2022 00:07

You do realise, @DaisyQuakeJohnson , that Depp was not allowed to enter into evidence the information the US courts permitted, yes?

You seem to think that's an insignificant fact? Right-oh then

night all

Thank you! How many times are people defending AH going to reference the UK case when a good portion of what she said has now been proven to be a lie, and when there were various pieces of evidence not accepted? Some of the evidence that was submitted has now been credibly disputed or even debunked.

I'd go as far as to say any findings in the UK case are now essentially irrelevant.

It's staggering, how willing some people are to automatically believe women. I was painted as an abusive, narcissistic gaslighter. People believed this and often threatened physical violence against me. Meanwhile, I was letting this woman live in my house for free (after her "friends" basically turfed her out), letting her 18 year old autistic son live with us for free (who she never ever took out or spent any time with, despite me attempting to encourage her), taking her on holidays, all paid for by me, having to work from home while she stood in the background, drunk at 8am and making belittling comments while I was on work calls, separating me from my family and friends, starting arguments with me about female friends until I cut them off etc.

I've been there. I've been made out to be the abuser. I've been refused a restraining order despite months of harassment via email and social media after finally getting her out of my house, I've reported numerous incidents to the police and then found out via their online portal they've concluded their investigations without anyone informing me or her even being interviewed and no action being taken and I've had to take myself to therapy because of the defensive mess she turned me into which ruined the relationship that followed. All the while, I've never lifted a finger against a woman. I've never gaslighted a person. I've never abused anyone. But there are still people out there who think I have. It's horrendous, having to just accept that people think that way about you, despite everything you've been put through.

So yes, I am over the moon that a man has finally stood up and brought an abusive woman to account. I am reassured that people will believe the truth. I am encouraged that a falsely damaged reputation can be salvaged.

But that doesn't mean I want to see genuine female victims put off coming forward. It doesn't mean that I don't have an issue with the low rate of rape convictions. It doesn't make me a mysoginist. I stand by ALL victims of abuse, male or female. I'd encourage some of you to do the same.

DaisyQuakeJohnson · 28/05/2022 01:01

There was a point - when I read the posts that obviously have no understanding about abusive relationships - that I thought those posters were lucky to have been so sheltered. To have never had to think deeply about the patterns in VAWG.

But, now I think, it may be fine to have no understanding of the legal system in the UK. And it may be a blessing to have no close understanding of the dynamics of abuse. But, actually, there's no excuse for revelling in ignorance.

They're not sheltered or blessed - they're just devoid of empathy and are quite happy to retraumatise victims of DV whilst perpetuating that latest myth - that there is no-one as persecuted as a wealthy male who can pursue his grievances through courts across the world.

TheEnemy123 · 28/05/2022 00:46

mynamesnotMa · 27/05/2022 06:35

Midlifemusings he had the money arrogance and utter contempt for her that she had the strength to stand up to him and publicly shamed him. Ofcourse the article was about him.

Everything about this case is utterly abhorrent. Very upsetting for many who have had years of gaslighting by perpetrators like him.

Your posts are straight up offensive. Do you think assaulting someone then taunting them about it is "standing up" to someone? Good God. The mind boggles.

SunscreenCentral · 28/05/2022 00:07

You do realise, @DaisyQuakeJohnson , that Depp was not allowed to enter into evidence the information the US courts permitted, yes?

You seem to think that's an insignificant fact? Right-oh then

night all

SunscreenCentral · 28/05/2022 00:03

I started from the default "I believe her" and was disappointed to think JD was that sort of man - I've admired him as an actor and how he's always striven for a private life - but I believed her.

I have watched every minute of this trial.

At the end of it all, I do NOT believe her. I think she is a liar. I think she has many, many problems (as does JD, for sure) but I'm convinced based on the evidence and testimony I listened to that she lied and lied and lied. She's despicable.

Pollymollydolly · 28/05/2022 00:00

I think she’s lying. I don’t understand how anybody can have followed the trial and found her credible.

Both are clearly very damaged, troubled people.

i found the audio of her taunting him and laughing quite chilling.

lifecanbehardattimes · 27/05/2022 23:53

Regardless of who is right and wrong, she really comes across as an awful woman. She's done herself no favours!

DaisyQuakeJohnson · 27/05/2022 23:53

If this wasn't all so serious and sending such a bad message about abuse all over the world, it would be amusing how apparent Depp fans manage to post constantly about this case whilst missing the large magazine spreads Depp did about Heard before her op ed was published; and these super fans also apparently missed or completely misunderstood the findings of the London case.
No matter the outcome of the US case, the London findings still stand. Everyone still sees Depp for what he is. Now, we also get to see those who defend him for who they are too.

If the US case finds differently from the London one, all it will have proved is that justice in the US is for sale to famous men and that their court system is happy to be used as a further conduit for abuse. But we all know that about the US anyway.

AchatAVendre · 27/05/2022 23:28

TheEnemy123 · 27/05/2022 21:32

I see the same. Those on here calling him an abusive piece of shit and moaning about mysogyny, shame on you. You've shown yourselves incapable of critical thinking and subject to pre-dispositions regarding men always being the abuser and women always being the victim. When you're a man on the receiving end, people don't believe you. Or they think you're a weak waste of space. And you people siding with AH are perpetuating that. I expect better in 2022.

Actually, when you study evidence as a professional practical requirement of entry to the legal profession, you are taught how and why women tend to be less believed as witnesses than men, and made aware of the statistics given and studies that prove it (no, I am not going to dig them out free of charge to educate you).

But of course critical thinking is determined by not believing what someone on an internet site insists in the truth...

PurpleButterflyWings · 27/05/2022 23:13

TheEnemy123 · 27/05/2022 21:32

I see the same. Those on here calling him an abusive piece of shit and moaning about mysogyny, shame on you. You've shown yourselves incapable of critical thinking and subject to pre-dispositions regarding men always being the abuser and women always being the victim. When you're a man on the receiving end, people don't believe you. Or they think you're a weak waste of space. And you people siding with AH are perpetuating that. I expect better in 2022.

100% THIS! ^ 👏

TheEnemy123 · 27/05/2022 21:32

MyneighbourisTotoro · 25/05/2022 17:33

I see a woman who is abusive and likes to goad her partners into a fight, this was a toxic relationship and JD has always been vulnerable and has had difficulties with drink and drugs due to an abusive life growing up and AH also abused the same substances.
In my opinion if he ever did abuse her then it was in retaliation from her relentlessness, it doesn’t excuse the behaviour but she is clearly an awful person who repeatedly took advantage of him.
I say this as someone who has been abused and had to live with someone constantly pushing for fights and degrading me. It’s soul destroying, some people snap, others become a shell of their former self.

I see the same. Those on here calling him an abusive piece of shit and moaning about mysogyny, shame on you. You've shown yourselves incapable of critical thinking and subject to pre-dispositions regarding men always being the abuser and women always being the victim. When you're a man on the receiving end, people don't believe you. Or they think you're a weak waste of space. And you people siding with AH are perpetuating that. I expect better in 2022.

barms90 · 27/05/2022 21:26

Being a drunk doesn't make you abusive. I firmly believe it was the other way round.

How does he remember what he did?? SHe had to video him to remind him. If he is so out of it he passes out how does he even remember what he did.

Workwork21 · 27/05/2022 21:08

barms90 · 27/05/2022 21:07

I hope think she will win. She only has to prove that he hit her once which is obvs he did.
I don't get the hate for the woman. He abused her and she hit him back...so because she didn't passively take the beating she is an abuser. He is a drunk and a drug addict and seen as more credible?!?!?

Being a drunk doesn't make you abusive. I firmly believe it was the other way round.

barms90 · 27/05/2022 21:07

I hope think she will win. She only has to prove that he hit her once which is obvs he did.
I don't get the hate for the woman. He abused her and she hit him back...so because she didn't passively take the beating she is an abuser. He is a drunk and a drug addict and seen as more credible?!?!?

childofthecorn · 27/05/2022 19:15

Having watched the closing arguments, Johnny's teams was more compelling and credible than Amber's, without a shadow of a doubt

Aspiringmatriarch · 27/05/2022 16:41

DimplesToadfoot · 27/05/2022 11:45

Having seen the latest video , of Depp where depending on whether your team Depp or Team Heard he's either taunting Whitney or inviting Amber's lawyer for a fight, if he's brazen enough to do that in a court room then just what else is he capable of.

I don't think he was looking at Whitney (the angles are wrong) but he was 100% getting belligerent with Heard's lawyer. He looks like a man who is very comfortable with violence and aggression to me. Can't keep up the tortured soul act even with millions watching.

AchatAVendre · 27/05/2022 15:52

Justfiveminutes Well she didn't leave it at the op ed did she. For how long was he supposed to ignore her retelling of the narrative that painted herself as an abuse victim and him as the abuser? I certainly believed that narrative. But this has proven that she was far from a victim.

Where are these victim requirements to be found and does anyone else have to meet them, or just those sued by Johnny Depp?

PurpleButterflyWings · 27/05/2022 15:28

Kate Moss's testimony was a game changer. Amber Heard is toast now IMO.

Really want Johnny Depp to win. I think he will.

DaisyQuakeJohnson · 27/05/2022 15:23

Regardless of the outcome, the only winners from this are abusive men.

They've seen how easy it is to manipulate the public; to throw mud at abuse victims. They've highlighted the lack of understanding of DV in the public domain. And they've shown that social media platforms and forums do not care about the damaging effect of abuser-led discussions on victims as long as they can get clicks and sell advertising.