Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Who will win between Johnny Depp and Amber Heard defamation case

681 replies

Egtermekaar · 25/05/2022 14:49

If you were jury in this case, how would you decide?

I think Johnny Depp will win because he had strong, reliable and consistent evidence of "his" case

I hope MN will allow debate about a matter of public interest.

OP posts:
AdamRyan · 28/05/2022 11:56

at most get perjury charges for the doctored photos
There's no proof she doctored the photos. The forensic expert said he found the originals in the submission and they hadn't been edited

Tillsforthrills · 28/05/2022 11:53

What do all of those defending Johnny make of his texts about burning her and then raping her dead burned body to make sure she’s really dead?

That says an awful awful lot about him.

I can imagine what the reaction would have been if she texted that about him!!!

TheAverageUser · 28/05/2022 11:52

AdamRyan · 28/05/2022 11:42

The trouble is there's no solid evidence. The jury need to find that the evidence points to him hitting her and being shit to someone when you're arguing just doesn't mean you hit them.

This is the whole issue with domestic and sexual violence. Its always 2 contradictory versions, there's often little evidence due to the shame felt by the victim (man or woman). I don't think the adversarial approach works in this case as it relies on someone being "a liar" when reality is more complex than that.

I think in this case the photos/witnesses are good corroboration that she was abused. I also think what she said in the op ed was true (because I don't read it as aimed at anyone, I read it as her life experience) and so it can't be defamatory. The burden of proof is on Johnny's team to prove it was defamatory and I don't think they have done that.

However that's just my perspective and I'm not on the jury.

I think you're probably right in legal terms, I don't think either party has proved their case.

There's a question around wether its true for her to represent herself as the face of domestic violence and I take huge exception to that piece. She has a charge for DV already and unquestionably hit Depp.

I think both cases should be gotten rid of and Amber Heard at the very least should go quiet but at most get perjury charges for the doctored photos. She's made a mockery of the court and victims of DV by exaggerating or making up claims in my view.

Interesting to be on the jury or maybe they're sick of it!

Midlifemusings · 28/05/2022 11:50

mynamesnotMa · 28/05/2022 11:43

She had to sit in the room so she fought back and why should he be allowed to ruin her life. I see a very distressed uncomfortable woman. Whilst he snigger and jokes. It's a farce.

That is a very biased assessment. If you watch the trial, at various times both of them laugh, joke, smile, roll their eyes, shake their heads etc. Amber tends to give a wider range of facial expressions. There are many occasions where neither looks uncomfortable and other occasions where each of them looks uncomfortable. I have seen little difference when it comes to their facial expressions while sitting listening to testimony.

Watch Amber duing Johnny's rebuttal testimony - none of that is a distrssed uncomfortable woman.

HalfShrunkMoreToGo · 28/05/2022 11:49

Regardless of the outcome they have both lost. They've shown themselves up to both be drug addled, violent, self-obsessed idiots who shouldn't be around decent people.

Midlifemusings · 28/05/2022 11:46

I am not sure why he argues that people are wrong to infer the OpEd is about Johnny. He is refuting evidence from his own client who testified in rebuttal that it was about Johnny. These two were also under NDAs so the first amendment argument doesn't apply.

mynamesnotMa · 28/05/2022 11:43

She had to sit in the room so she fought back and why should he be allowed to ruin her life. I see a very distressed uncomfortable woman. Whilst he snigger and jokes. It's a farce.

AdamRyan · 28/05/2022 11:42

The trouble is there's no solid evidence. The jury need to find that the evidence points to him hitting her and being shit to someone when you're arguing just doesn't mean you hit them.

This is the whole issue with domestic and sexual violence. Its always 2 contradictory versions, there's often little evidence due to the shame felt by the victim (man or woman). I don't think the adversarial approach works in this case as it relies on someone being "a liar" when reality is more complex than that.

I think in this case the photos/witnesses are good corroboration that she was abused. I also think what she said in the op ed was true (because I don't read it as aimed at anyone, I read it as her life experience) and so it can't be defamatory. The burden of proof is on Johnny's team to prove it was defamatory and I don't think they have done that.

However that's just my perspective and I'm not on the jury.

mynamesnotMa · 28/05/2022 11:41

They will have to find in her favour. She had every legal right to write what she did. There is no proof that it ruined him and if it did good. He is vile. How awful that people are so blind to how people Like him operate. This is the very reason why victims don't speak out.

EmeraldShamrock1 · 28/05/2022 11:33

But, I’m clearly watching a different trial to everyone else as I see a vile man, with a history of violence, drug and alcohol problems - who writes messages in his own blood FFS, it’s not exactly a stretch to believe he hit her.
I agree.
AH is a vile woman with a similar history.
They should have never been together or aired all their crazy shit in public.

TheAverageUser · 28/05/2022 11:28

AdamRyan · 28/05/2022 11:11

Watch Rottenborns summing up. He used what Johnny had said, and photos. Not what Amber said.

The trouble is there's no solid evidence. The jury need to find that the evidence points to him hitting her and being shit to someone when you're arguing just doesn't mean you hit them.

It's easy to rail against Amber because we have clear evidence she hit him.

AdamRyan · 28/05/2022 11:11

Agrudge · 28/05/2022 09:27

Unfortunately a lot of mn users have determined who is in the wrong based on what's between their legs .

I still haven't seen any proof he has hit her

Watch Rottenborns summing up. He used what Johnny had said, and photos. Not what Amber said.

Scoobydoo7474 · 28/05/2022 11:11

As a survivor of an abusive, it has been a joke watching this, no way would I have sat in same room with my abuser, yet alone near him & look at him! Her body language says it all & his 2, she is the abuser, not him, I’m team Johnny all the way & women like her should be punished! Knowing the justice system, she will probably win but people will still hate her & love him, no matter what!

Doggyfish · 28/05/2022 10:46

'I see the same. Those on here calling him an abusive piece of shit and moaning about mysogyny, shame on you. You've shown yourselves incapable of critical thinking and subject to pre-dispositions regarding men always being the abuser and women always being the victim. When you're a man on the receiving end, people don't believe you. Or they think you're a weak waste of space. And you people siding with AH are perpetuating that. I expect better in 2022.'

Oh look, a man has come along to lecture us all on how shameful we are for believing the woman. The woman who has been proven to have been abused by her partner in a court of law. Sorry for annoying you by 'moaning about misogyny' it must be terribly inconvenient for you and all the other poor men who just want to get on with gaslighting us that it is men who are more frequently victims of DV and not women.

Lucycantdance · 28/05/2022 10:36

I’ve watched most of the trial from the start and was of the initial view that of course she was telling the truth. Being a feminist. Totally changed my view now. I have found her behaviour chilling. It’s very sad that he struggled with addiction and she just took photos of him out of his mind. She’s a complete liar. Terrible business and so damaging for genuine survivors.

Thelnebriati · 28/05/2022 09:36

And many others understand the dynamics of DA, and the effect this show trial has on the wider community.

You are so pleased to get your chance of a Two Minutes Hate. Well done, all of you.

Agrudge · 28/05/2022 09:27

Unfortunately a lot of mn users have determined who is in the wrong based on what's between their legs .

I still haven't seen any proof he has hit her

Andouillette · 28/05/2022 09:23

BobbinHood · 25/05/2022 19:00

That still leaves 8 incidents even if those 2 were dismissed. And his team were denied leave to appeal. His behaviour in even bringing this case at all backs up that he’s an abuser.

I don't think you quite understand how leave to appeal a civil case works in the UK. Appeals can only be granted if there has been an 'error in law' by the judge. No such error occurred therefore the appeal was denied. It is not predicated on the 'worthiness' or otherwise of JDs case. That being said Ms. Heard did perjure herself and risks being charged with that if she comes back to the UK. It is also possible the the Sun will go after her as she has caused them to lie to the court as well.
The whole thing is very sad. Two people who should never have been together, leading to huge unhappiness. Her biggest problem is that she actually has no real, provable evidence and should never have written that stupid piece about domestic violence. She then compounded that idiocy by claiming it wasn't about JD...and then admitted in court yesterday that it was. More perjury.

justfiveminutes · 28/05/2022 09:07

As her team said in closing 'if you think they were both abusive to each other, she wins.'

But given what we have seen and heard of her behaviour, in this relationship and others, I find it incredible that she painted herself as a downtrodden victim and never expected to be challenged. I suppose she thought he wouldn't want his own failings exposed.

My opinion has completely changed after watching this trial. AH has just provided more ammunition for abusive men.

AdamRyan · 28/05/2022 08:48

Listen to Rottenborns closing and then say Depp wasn't abusive. It's disgusting that people explain away what Depp himself said and did.

Willyoujustbequiet · 28/05/2022 08:06

As a dv and sa survivor I believe her.

I don't particularly like her but he's clearly been abusive according to the last judgement and am astounded at the vitriol and misogyny spouted against her.

FantaLover · 28/05/2022 08:06

I can't believe there are still people on here who believe her. It's mind boggling to me having watched the trial.
As for the UK trial - what a joke.

TheAverageUser · 28/05/2022 07:01

I think she defamed him in the op Ed but my knowledge of US law isn't good enough to know if his team have proved it? Certainly it was written about him and she intended malice. The question is wether the jury believe on the weight of evidence that it's more likely than not that he hit her at least once. Personally I don't think the evidence is there to show he did.

The counterclaim it's hard to prove she staged the scene although logic seems to show she did, I doubt he'set his burden of proof there. Although I seriously doubt he cares about monetary compensation from her either.

Dismiss both claims?

mynamesnotMa · 28/05/2022 06:56

DaisyQuakeJohnson spot on. This thread is full of his flying monkeys.

Turn the sound down look at her body language then look at his.

He is enjoying torturing her. Enjoying acting the victim.

Onthedunes · 28/05/2022 06:11

The post nup was the trigger for the narcissistic rage.

I do believe she was grinding him down daily, eroding his confidence and belittling him', you can tell in Johnny's voice he sounded worthless, she was convincing him of that and that had been going on for some time.

What would be the ultimate outcome for a narc or phychopath in a situation like this, torment an alcoholic and drug user to death, reap the rewards and then soak up the sympathy for having to put up with said alcoholic.

Yes, some people are that evil.

Some people on here are questioning his motives but really what would he have achieved by crushing her, I believed he loved her but became scared of what she was capable of, her lack of empathy.

He had a lucky escape.

I hope he finds someone to regain his trust in humanity again.