Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Who will win between Johnny Depp and Amber Heard defamation case

681 replies

Egtermekaar · 25/05/2022 14:49

If you were jury in this case, how would you decide?

I think Johnny Depp will win because he had strong, reliable and consistent evidence of "his" case

I hope MN will allow debate about a matter of public interest.

OP posts:
Midlifemusings · 31/05/2022 15:42

It is a good question - what do the Jussie Smollets and Amber Heards of the celeb world do after they lose public support? People that have always acted and now can't and have name and face recognition issues related to legal woes and lying - what career is next?

Change your name and be a voice actor?

Leopolds · 31/05/2022 10:25

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

starlingdarling · 31/05/2022 09:09

I think she will win her case and his will lose his. In the court of public opinion he's easily won. This trial may have cost millions but his career was worth more and there's a good chance he can get it back on track now. She's unlikely to ever work in Hollywood again and after the stories that have come out she can't sell herself as a spokeswoman for abuse survivors either.

I do worry for her, she's clearly damaged and desperate. I don't know how she's going to get her life back on track after this. With her existing mental health issues I worry she will be bullied to death. As awful as their relationship was, she doesn't deserve that.

LetitiaLeghorn · 30/05/2022 21:59

@JenniferAlisonPhilipaSue I also read about the house insurance story. This litigation has been going on for three years and has cost over $6m. Would house insurance cover that? It sounded from the report that her lawyers told her to claim and pay them that way. So not that the house insurance had hired them. Which is puzzling.

  1. If the house insurance is paying, why couldn't she afford better witnesses?
  2. She said the trial had cost her $6m. But then she's fond of semantics where money is concerned.
  3. If she's not paying herself, why couldn't she carry on donating her settlement?

However, if the house insurance hired her lawyers, it would explain why she saddled herself with that lot.

LetitiaLeghorn · 30/05/2022 21:49

@JenniferAlisonPhilipaSue She was caught tweeting and texting from the front row of the courtroom which is not allowed. So the judge banned her from the courthouse for the rest of the trial.

She had tried to interfere with the proceedings over one of Depps witnesses and Depps team objected. Responding to this, the judge banned her for texting and texting.

JenniferAlisonPhilipaSue · 30/05/2022 21:32

I've tried to watch as much as the trial as I can when not workinng but I'm not sure what happened with Eve Barlow, Amber's alleged GF. I can see that she was caught faking evidence, using her phone, and was thrown out of courst as a result.
Did all this happen in front of the jury? Does the jury know that she faked evidence?
Also if Amber is, as alleged, using house insurance to pay lawyers, does that mean her lawyers were chosen for her and not chosen by her?

Changedagain876 · 30/05/2022 21:07

Who is Ah current partner @ChoccyJules ?

minutesturntohours · 30/05/2022 20:36

ChoccyJules · 30/05/2022 20:27

AH‘s current partner has posted JD‘s planned whereabouts for the next two evenings on Twitter and someone has already said they will be there with a banner. Good job he has security as that could go all kinds of wrong…

Imagine Johnny did that to Amber.

ChoccyJules · 30/05/2022 20:27

AH‘s current partner has posted JD‘s planned whereabouts for the next two evenings on Twitter and someone has already said they will be there with a banner. Good job he has security as that could go all kinds of wrong…

spaceman1 · 30/05/2022 18:06

JD has won the court of public opinion (as played out on YouTube TikTok and Reels). AH has been widely ridiculed by the public and her career is finished regardless of the outcome of the trial. Perhaps this is what JD wanted as his career was already over. Karma is a xxxxx.

ArabianLeopard · 30/05/2022 15:36

My gut feeling is that JD will win, mainly because it is a Jury trial. He has come across as far more likeable and credible I think. I think with Juries this comes into it where as a Judge only decision is going to be based solely on the law which he may struggle with.

My feeling is that he was probably incredibly difficult to live with at times - due to his drug taking and alcohol abuse but that he is not an abuser.

I think there were probably a lot of very toxic arguments, with things thrown, rooms trashed and quite extreme verbal abuse on both sides.

I believe that she has been violent towards him. The Orient Express black eye seemed credible to me.

Neither will 'win' in terms of their reputation and future careers though in my view. Unless he can be rehabilitated by a friendly director and an amazing role.

Leopolds · 30/05/2022 14:53

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

ICanSmellSummerComing · 30/05/2022 14:47

Hamad a what did he say?

Leopolds · 30/05/2022 14:47

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

ICanSmellSummerComing · 30/05/2022 14:46

What I didn't like was how much he ingratiated himself with her family either, spending loads of money on them...sounds like grooming to me.
After some years of marriage, yes why not
..but straight aways??

ICanSmellSummerComing · 30/05/2022 14:44

This isn't.simply recreational drug use though, JD is a major addict whose daughter is driven to panic attacks by the fear of his antics and and a 5 hour call to VP with VP talking about how his drinking is impacting his relationship with his dd.

He's putting his addictions first and this is what's so sad. It sounds like he has massively damaged the relationship with his dd over it and now lost amber whom I believe he was madly In love wiry with and still is.

Let's say JD actually got deep counseling over his past,and truly kicked his addictions. I feel he would be apologising to Amber in a few years.

This is all About his mum and his addictions. His power and money have made this get onto the world's stages...but this is an illustration of how powerful addiction is and how destructive for those around the addict.

spaceman1 · 30/05/2022 13:46

I think AH will win, but it will be a pyrrhic victory as is so often the case with this type of litigation.

asleeponthetable · 30/05/2022 11:36

as someone who has been in abusive relationships - she was the abuser. She has shown herself in recordings to not be a victim and his retaliation is that of a victim. I believe the bruises are fake. I also believe she faked and staged photos.

she's abused and beaten others in the past, she's an emotional toxic person. They have BOTH had massive drug problems, not just him.

Is he perfect? No. Abusive relationships can bring the worst in the victim too, because of the emotional turmoil they are going through.

it has set back DV but she shouldn't get away with playing the victim having absolutely obliterated his life. She's destroyed him long after they've been apart and nobody should have that power.

i don't think he'll get his career back though, it will always hang over him.

ricestardust · 30/05/2022 11:04

If I was on the jury, I'd vote for JD. His evidence has been consistent and reliable, and his witnesses have been very credible. AH's evidence has been poor quality and contradictory. Moreover, AH's anecdotes have been egregiously OTT. Anyone who has ever suffered a bruise, let alone is a real DA/DV survivor, knows that AH's evidence is not credible.

AchatAVendre · 30/05/2022 10:15

BigFatLiar · 30/05/2022 08:30

Juries are weird you can't tell what they'll do. Many will have made up their minds very early on and see the attorney's presentations only in terms of what they've already decided.

For an interesting comparison of the way the US and the UK treats defamation cases, the actor Lawrence Fox has just been refused a jury trial in a defamation case being brought against him for remarks he made on social media.

BigFatLiar · 30/05/2022 08:30

Juries are weird you can't tell what they'll do. Many will have made up their minds very early on and see the attorney's presentations only in terms of what they've already decided.

minutesturntohours · 29/05/2022 19:59

Midlifemusings · 29/05/2022 19:38

It is a wait and see. The second instruction to the jury is to examine the credibility of everyone involved.

Thanks for this. It's all so bloody complicated!

Midlifemusings · 29/05/2022 19:38

minutesturntohours · 29/05/2022 19:32

I'd go Johnny every day of the week, but because of the technicalities I think Amber will take it. She's still finished though. As she should be.

It is a wait and see. The second instruction to the jury is to examine the credibility of everyone involved.

minutesturntohours · 29/05/2022 19:32

I'd go Johnny every day of the week, but because of the technicalities I think Amber will take it. She's still finished though. As she should be.

justfiveminutes · 29/05/2022 16:14

Yes, of course, worded badly.