Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Who will win between Johnny Depp and Amber Heard defamation case

681 replies

Egtermekaar · 25/05/2022 14:49

If you were jury in this case, how would you decide?

I think Johnny Depp will win because he had strong, reliable and consistent evidence of "his" case

I hope MN will allow debate about a matter of public interest.

OP posts:
TalkingCat · 02/06/2022 13:11

minutesturntohours · 02/06/2022 01:58

@TalkingCat

and your point is?

That he did indeed abuse her so I didn't libel.

LetitiaLeghorn · 02/06/2022 12:48

I posted a quote from The Guardian about the outcome of the UK case.

At the start of Depps suing NGN and Heard, Depps side decided to court and give information to Internet news and YouTubers. Heard's side decided to go to the main stream media.
During the UK trial, I wasn't really that interested and I only heard the news reports on TV and of course that is just a reporters summary of what they think is important. That's why I assumed the uk outcome to be fair.
But because the US trial was televised and I could see myself what was happening, when I read reports in The Independent or The Guardian, I could see they didn't tally with what I'd observed. On top of that there were many articles written in favour of Heard based on feminists issues. I have no problem with opinion pieces although there were never any from Depps perspective. But the fact that the new reports were slanted or toned down made me wonder how accurate newspaper reports are generally and specifically to this case whether this was part of Heards publicity campaign.

DaisyQuakeJohnson · 02/06/2022 12:29

You seem to be confusing me with another poster. I'm not pushing any narrative.

I posted a quote from The Guardian about the outcome of the UK case. An article from the US about what they had observed about the alliances springing up between MRAs, Republicans and JD 'supporters' and a comment from an international media lawyer on why the UK and US cases were different.

All referenced. All factual.

TheEnemy123 · 02/06/2022 12:24

DaisyQuakeJohnson · 02/06/2022 12:03

You're showing you misunderstood this case and also the meaning of 'fact'. Now whether that's because you didn't follow it, based your impression on social media, think you know better than professionals in the field or are being deliberately disingenuous, I don't know. I also don't care.

Those who tried to push disinformation (and continue to do so) are making it clear who they are and what they care about (whilst showing a shocking lack of understanding of DV; VAWG and both the US and UK cases). No amount of smiley faces hides that.

There's nothing for me to 'give up'. Despite certain factions wanting to pretend this outcome negates the UK case - it doesn't. Despite them wanting to pretend it was a completely different judgement than a defamation case - it wasn't. And despite them wanting to pretend they care about abuse victims - they obviously don't.

Those of us that do- will still be here working on VAWG; challenging the DAVRO and supporting posters on MN that need it.

No, you're showing that you've not paid attention to the UK case, the evidence that wasn't allowed to be submitted and the FACT that AH has perjured herself during the US trial and contradicted things she stated as fact in the UK case.

You can say whatever you wish about it, but you can't dispute the things I've just written as they're now documented forever, for the world to see.

I get you have an issue with male violence. Every reasonable human being should have. But this case doesn't represent that. If it's triggered you because of past experience then I'm sorry, as a fellow survivor of an abusive relationship I truly do sympathise. But please, separate yourself from this and stop trying to push the "JD is an abuser" narrative. It's literally been blown to pieces.

DaisyQuakeJohnson · 02/06/2022 12:03

You're showing you misunderstood this case and also the meaning of 'fact'. Now whether that's because you didn't follow it, based your impression on social media, think you know better than professionals in the field or are being deliberately disingenuous, I don't know. I also don't care.

Those who tried to push disinformation (and continue to do so) are making it clear who they are and what they care about (whilst showing a shocking lack of understanding of DV; VAWG and both the US and UK cases). No amount of smiley faces hides that.

There's nothing for me to 'give up'. Despite certain factions wanting to pretend this outcome negates the UK case - it doesn't. Despite them wanting to pretend it was a completely different judgement than a defamation case - it wasn't. And despite them wanting to pretend they care about abuse victims - they obviously don't.

Those of us that do- will still be here working on VAWG; challenging the DAVRO and supporting posters on MN that need it.

TheEnemy123 · 02/06/2022 11:52

@DaisyQuakeJohnson give it up. You don't half talk some rubbish 😂 The man won. He won because he was innocent. It must be a tough pill to swallow for a misandrist such as yourself, but it's time to accept it and move on.

Amber Heard is a vile abuser. Fact.

LetitiaLeghorn · 02/06/2022 11:01

There was no gloating when the UK case upheld so many counts of abuse against him.

There's a big difference between the two cases, though. In the UK trial people had to accept the judges finding was made professionally and in good faith. But the US trial was televised so people could see the demeanour of witnesses and assess evidence themselves. People could judge her overacting performance and make their own decision on pledge vs donate. It gave opportunity for Morgan Night to see evidence given and deny it. We could see Amber Heard slap her hands over her mouth as she said TMZ has been alerted. The televisation gave people the possibility to see all of the trial first hand and make their own decision.

It might be if the uk judge knew that Heard had lied over some things, that might have changed his impression of her and his belief in everything she said. And the result may have been different. We don't know.

Germolenequeen · 02/06/2022 10:53

**Birdie746 · Yesterday 23:42

Germolenequeen

Goodbye offensive post 👋🏻👋🏻

Hope so I reported it too

If something truthful is offensive to you then maybe that’s telling you something**

It tells me a lot about you and I won't engage further

DaisyQuakeJohnson · 02/06/2022 10:15

And for posters still spreading disinformation about the UK case (where - to quote The Guardian - 'Of the 14 alleged assaults heard in open court – all of which have been denied by Depp – he [the judge] found that 12 of them were proved on the balance of probability. 12 out of 14 were proven - and that judgement still stands).

This explainer from a lawyer may help posters struggling to understand why the findings were different -
'Mark Stephens, an international media lawyer familiar with both cases, said Depp’s legal team in the United States ran a strategy known as DARVO — an acronym for deny, attack, and reverse victim and offender — in which Depp became the victim and Heard the abuser.

“We find that DARVO works very well with juries but almost never works with judges, who are trained to look at evidence,” Stephens said.'

DARVO is a recognised technique used by MRAs; TRAs; misogynists and abusers. It's a lot of 'sound and fury' that they hope distracts people from facts and evidence. It's gaslighting on steroids.

DaisyQuakeJohnson · 02/06/2022 10:01

This article is interesting. Republicans hated JD because he made a joke about Trump being assassinated but Reps and Trump have been falling over themselves to support him now because they hate women; they hate feminists and they hated Me Too.

The social media onslaught was about getting women to stfu and showing rich men in the US can shop around for their desired result.

AH was awarded damages too but even if every count had been found in her favour, posters wouldn't have been on here gloating. There was no gloating when the UK case upheld so many counts of abuse against him. Most women (and men with empathy tbh) don't celebrate abuse. Yet another sign that for the JD 'supporters'/bots/Republicans/MRAs/TRAs this was never about abuse. It was about certain factions consistently trying to get women to shut up and inadvertently showing how inadequate social media is at managing co-ordinated assaults. Women and many politicians have known both those things for a long time. This circus has just brought it to wider attention and given them more evidence for pushing ahead with social media reform.

Why Republicans Supported JD

Ithoughtsummerwascoming · 02/06/2022 08:13

I thought both her parents were drugs addicts?

Whatever issue's she had I think it's clear being with Johnny would have made them.100 times worse.
To be honest unless he said to her pretty early on in their relationship, I'm a junkie.

I am addicted to many substances and my team enables me.

I do sober up when I can but this is what you will be dealing with...

He sold her false goods didn't he.

I assume he wasn't honest about the extent of his addictions at all instead he was throwing money at her and her friends and family to "woo" her.
Once she was deep in ,the "pattern" emerged.

However I think she's foolish for marrying him.
Because by that point she had been the victim of abusive behaviour.

BigFatLiar · 02/06/2022 08:00

This is another OJ Simpson.

Hardly an OJ case, He won his criminal case because the police and prosecution totally messed up.

LetitiaLeghorn · 02/06/2022 03:46

@TalkingCatThis is another OJ Simpson. Justice only favours the rich in the US. That's why Heard won in the UK.

Heard didn't win anything. The UK Court case was Depp vs News Group Newspapers, which is a lot richer than Johnny Depp. So maybe justice favours the rich in the UK as well?

EveryFlightBeginsWithAFall · 02/06/2022 02:01

So 1 all for rich , drug taking abusive people who should stay away from each other and get on with their lives now then

Let's hope that's the end of it all

Andouillette · 02/06/2022 02:00

TalkingCat · 02/06/2022 01:39

@minutesturntohours He won a defamation case, that doesn't denounce the fact he lost a case in the UK that proved he abused Amber.

You really need to learn a little bit about civil law in the UK. You have said numerous times that he was 'found guilty' in the UK. There is no such thing as a guilty verdict in a case like that, a single judge found on the balance of probability (as low as 51%) that the Sun did not libel him. This verdict was reached at least in part because AH committed perjury. JD was refused an appeal because the judge did not err in law which is NOT proof that the judge was right.

minutesturntohours · 02/06/2022 01:58

@TalkingCat

and your point is?

TalkingCat · 02/06/2022 01:39

minutesturntohours · 02/06/2022 00:47

Hes won, so please stop with the libel

@minutesturntohours He won a defamation case, that doesn't denounce the fact he lost a case in the UK that proved he abused Amber.

minutesturntohours · 02/06/2022 00:47

TalkingCat · 01/06/2022 22:51

And this, is how men like Depp get away with abusing women. People fall for their public nice guy act.

Hes won, so please stop with the libel

EveryFlightBeginsWithAFall · 02/06/2022 00:11

Ithoughtsummerwascoming · 02/06/2022 00:00

Come on and he doesn't?
His dream was to become a good dad and he owns endless houses and a bloody Island but there he is,face down drugged out of his mind.

Giving his dd panic attacks??

Being carried out of places smashed?

Yeah he does too, doesn't take away from the fact she has some serious issues though and he's not parenting a young child on his own if you want to start bringing up children.

One who she has from buying another women's womb. Although that doesn't seem to matter to the usual people on mn who hate that

Curlykimbo · 02/06/2022 00:05

JK Rowling believed Johnny Depp when the mob were baying for his blood. JK, who has made herself public enemy number 1 for defending women on Twitter.

Ithoughtsummerwascoming · 02/06/2022 00:00

Come on and he doesn't?
His dream was to become a good dad and he owns endless houses and a bloody Island but there he is,face down drugged out of his mind.

Giving his dd panic attacks??

Being carried out of places smashed?

EveryFlightBeginsWithAFall · 01/06/2022 23:56

She's always said the OP Ed wasn't about him, then on the stand says it was

She's a very damaged individual, a dangerous one who needs help imo

EveryFlightBeginsWithAFall · 01/06/2022 23:51

Ithoughtsummerwascoming · 01/06/2022 23:40

What's this ACLU?

American civil liberties union

DysonSphere · 01/06/2022 23:49

BasicDad · 01/06/2022 23:37

Don't agree. Heard lost by a galactic mile.

One will find their way back to well paid employment in Hollywood. The other will become the next Lynsey Lohan. She's got a head start with her TMZ network.

Agree, she lost on every count, the most killing part for me was that the jury found her to have purposefully and maliciously gone after him in the WP op-ed or something like that the term malicious was used.

Warner Brother executives who employed her also had to appear and testify in court (to cover their backsides).

I doubt she'll work with them again.

Birdie746 · 01/06/2022 23:45

Amazing how loads on here know more than the jury but somehow aren't sure who the aclu are 🥴