Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Who will win between Johnny Depp and Amber Heard defamation case

681 replies

Egtermekaar · 25/05/2022 14:49

If you were jury in this case, how would you decide?

I think Johnny Depp will win because he had strong, reliable and consistent evidence of "his" case

I hope MN will allow debate about a matter of public interest.

OP posts:
TheEnemy123 · 02/06/2022 18:07

Tontostitis · 02/06/2022 18:05

Johnny Depp's legal team convinced a jury that the only liar and abuser was AH.
Tbf Amber's own recordings, words and actions played a big part in that.

Indeed, but even taunting your victim on tape isn't enough for some people...

Tontostitis · 02/06/2022 18:05

Johnny Depp's legal team convinced a jury that the only liar and abuser was AH.
Tbf Amber's own recordings, words and actions played a big part in that.

TheEnemy123 · 02/06/2022 18:01

Tillsforthrills · 02/06/2022 17:39

You seem to have some sort of axe to grind, therefore imbalanced.

No more than people refusing to accept men can be victims of abuse.

TheEnemy123 · 02/06/2022 17:57

TalkingCat · 02/06/2022 16:35

The only one trying to convince anyone of anything, is yourself. To say the 'only' liar and abuser is AH shows your deep ignorance and brainwashing. I truly feel sorry for you that you are this snowed by a celeb that you can't see Depp was proven to have lied and to have abused.

Well, clearly not as Johnny Depp's legal team convinced a jury that the only liar and abuser was AH. Clearly, your hatred of men blinds you so badly that this isn't enough for you. Clear, proven evidence, and AH perjuring herself by contradicting "evidence" she gave previously still aren't enough for you. It would be laughable if it wasn't so sad. I bet you campaign for equality don't you? Yet you can't extend that same courtesy to a male DV victim and throw soundbites and claims of celebrity brainwashing at anyone who disagrees with you.

The game is up. You and your ilk have been quashed. Accept it and move on. This verdict was a huge victory for DV survivors like myself, and you and your hatred can't take that away from us.

Tillsforthrills · 02/06/2022 17:39

TheEnemy123 · 02/06/2022 11:52

@DaisyQuakeJohnson give it up. You don't half talk some rubbish 😂 The man won. He won because he was innocent. It must be a tough pill to swallow for a misandrist such as yourself, but it's time to accept it and move on.

Amber Heard is a vile abuser. Fact.

You seem to have some sort of axe to grind, therefore imbalanced.

Tillsforthrills · 02/06/2022 17:38

AchatAVendre · 02/06/2022 13:36

I wish people would realise that the way American justice deals with these sort of cases is very, very different from the rest of the world.

First of all, it has an adversarial, not inquisatorial (judge-led) system (as does the UK), however only in the US do you get such plaintiff and defence led arguments with little judicial direction. That is why it turned into such a circus.

Then in addition, you have a civil jury. Juries are notoriously poor at sifting through evidence. When you study evidence as a law student, you learn that people and therefore jurors tend to hold all sorts of pre-conceptions, prejudices and personal views that affect their judgment. We know from studies that jurors are prejudiced to believe men and to disbelieve women and for that reason, in the UK at least, we tend to discourage their use where possible. Lawrence Fox has been refused a civil jury trial in the defamation case being brought against him presently.

Judges on the other hand are trained in adductive thinking (as are some of the police) where you develop many theories and then look for evidence and then examine that evidence to see which theory is best supported by it.

Non-lawyers tend to be prejudiced towards purposive thinking, which is where you have one outcome already decided in your mind as being the "best" and which you look for evidence to fit that outcome.

There is a reason that the US keeps producing these extremely powerful men who evade justice and these media circuses around trials - Epstein, Weinstein, OJ Simpson. There is a reason that the US can't decide whether allowing women to have bodily autonomy is a basic human right or not. In many ways, the US is quite backwards as to how it treats women (and poor people/minorities). I'm really shocked but not surprised by the whole thing. It is almost impossible in the US to bring a famous man to justice timeously. Albeit the former were criminal trials and this was a civil trial, but how many years did it take to bring Epstein and Weinstein to account?

Also not saying that the UK is perfect. I'm currently looking at the Malcolm Webster (wife killer) trial and the number of times people reported their concerns to the police after his first murder and how his father in the MET protected him is disgraceful.

Anyway, I don't think that Depp had to prove his case on the normal balance of probabilities at all. I think what was actually applied in this trial was a special standard of proof reserved for powerful Hollywood stars with a massive fan base and so what we actually got was "on the balance of public prejudice/public opinion/level of fame". Its a witch trial for modern times.

And please can anyone who disagrees with me not regale me with the plaintive "Did you read/watch/listen to the trial" question...Grin

Balanced and correct.

Ithoughtsummerwascoming · 02/06/2022 17:29

Excellent post a chat a vendre.

LetitiaLeghorn · 02/06/2022 17:11

@AchatAVendre
It would indeed be unreasonable to say that the jury only found for Depp because he was famous. Who said that?

Well, you did. With your mention special standards.

special standard of proof reserved for powerful Hollywood stars with a massive fan base

"Behaviour on the stand, eh?" Or who had the best acting abilities or played best to the audience? Anyway behaviour on the stand should not be relevant to evidence.

I'm puzzled by this. Of course Depp is going to bring his considerable acting skills to bear. How could he not? And Heard will bring hers and as she is forecasting that she's lost $100m in revenue, she must be excellent too. But what I find difficult to understand is that legal people genuinely believe that personality and presentation are notvteoevabt to anyone watching them. Of course it's not that it trumps evidence, but for many people it just helps to confirm belief. That's why lawyers make sure their defendant look respectable and respectful. Ideallly, should it matter? No. In reality does it matter? Yes. Truth is people,with charisma,and looks often get away with more than the rest of us.

trained legal minds can better overlook this than juries.

I'd agree they've had more experience but judges and stipendiary magistrates are open to making misjudgements based on demeanour and manner. Blimey, even lawyers who actually represent their clients and believe they know what's going on, get caught out.

An adversarial system with a civil jury in a defamation case is pushing the boundaries of justice.

That's a generalisation so I'm not going to comment. But here the uk judge made findings based on his belief that Heard was telling the truth. But we now know some of what she said was not the truth. So if you a person (being respectful 🙃) said that the jury gave him special consideration for his fame, maybe actually they'd looked at several bits of Heards testimony where she'd been shown to be dishonest, and so gave Depp the benefit of the doubt. Maybe if the UK judge had seen the things she'd lied over, he too would not have believed her and found in Depps favour. A person couldn't compare the uk and us trials because the facts were different. So I can't see you could base your claim of defamation jury trials as being unfair or pushing boundaries based on this case.

I hope one day you grow up and learn to communicate with people without being rude or insulting them just because you disagree with them.

😂 OK, then. I wasn't meaning to be rude but just pointing out that from this thread you have prejudices and beliefs that you carry with you like the rest of us. And like the rest of us, you try to keep them out of your professional life. But its imposdible to do that completely and when pushed into a corner of things being close or you're uncertain, your preconceptions will kick in.

TalkingCat · 02/06/2022 16:35

TheEnemy123 · 02/06/2022 16:29

😂 Who are you trying to convince? The only liar and abuser is AH. I feel sorry for you.

The only one trying to convince anyone of anything, is yourself. To say the 'only' liar and abuser is AH shows your deep ignorance and brainwashing. I truly feel sorry for you that you are this snowed by a celeb that you can't see Depp was proven to have lied and to have abused.

TheEnemy123 · 02/06/2022 16:29

TalkingCat · 02/06/2022 13:16

@TheEnemy123 You are the one talking rubbish. He wasn't found innocent. He is indeed an abuser and beater, so give it up.

😂 Who are you trying to convince? The only liar and abuser is AH. I feel sorry for you.

7eleven · 02/06/2022 15:17

AchatAVendre · 02/06/2022 13:36

I wish people would realise that the way American justice deals with these sort of cases is very, very different from the rest of the world.

First of all, it has an adversarial, not inquisatorial (judge-led) system (as does the UK), however only in the US do you get such plaintiff and defence led arguments with little judicial direction. That is why it turned into such a circus.

Then in addition, you have a civil jury. Juries are notoriously poor at sifting through evidence. When you study evidence as a law student, you learn that people and therefore jurors tend to hold all sorts of pre-conceptions, prejudices and personal views that affect their judgment. We know from studies that jurors are prejudiced to believe men and to disbelieve women and for that reason, in the UK at least, we tend to discourage their use where possible. Lawrence Fox has been refused a civil jury trial in the defamation case being brought against him presently.

Judges on the other hand are trained in adductive thinking (as are some of the police) where you develop many theories and then look for evidence and then examine that evidence to see which theory is best supported by it.

Non-lawyers tend to be prejudiced towards purposive thinking, which is where you have one outcome already decided in your mind as being the "best" and which you look for evidence to fit that outcome.

There is a reason that the US keeps producing these extremely powerful men who evade justice and these media circuses around trials - Epstein, Weinstein, OJ Simpson. There is a reason that the US can't decide whether allowing women to have bodily autonomy is a basic human right or not. In many ways, the US is quite backwards as to how it treats women (and poor people/minorities). I'm really shocked but not surprised by the whole thing. It is almost impossible in the US to bring a famous man to justice timeously. Albeit the former were criminal trials and this was a civil trial, but how many years did it take to bring Epstein and Weinstein to account?

Also not saying that the UK is perfect. I'm currently looking at the Malcolm Webster (wife killer) trial and the number of times people reported their concerns to the police after his first murder and how his father in the MET protected him is disgraceful.

Anyway, I don't think that Depp had to prove his case on the normal balance of probabilities at all. I think what was actually applied in this trial was a special standard of proof reserved for powerful Hollywood stars with a massive fan base and so what we actually got was "on the balance of public prejudice/public opinion/level of fame". Its a witch trial for modern times.

And please can anyone who disagrees with me not regale me with the plaintive "Did you read/watch/listen to the trial" question...Grin

Thank you for articulating my thoughts. I felt a discomfort I couldn’t put my finger on when I heard the verdict. I’m sure AH is a nightmare, I’m not defending her.

The fact that people outside the court were wearing pirate hats and a truck/ship parked outside made me think that some people think their hero ‘Swashbuckling Jack Sparrow’ was in jeopardy and somehow this was a cos play.

7eleven · 02/06/2022 15:09

*Bettany

7eleven · 02/06/2022 15:08

The text message exchange with Paul Bethany seems incongruous with the almost hero status JD has been ascribed.

AH has been found to have exaggerated and lied, but my ex has never sent his mate a message saying he wanted to burn me. I don’t think he’s the innocent victim he’s being portrayed to be.

TalkingCat · 02/06/2022 14:51

RosieRooster83 · 02/06/2022 14:20

I'm just catching up with the thread but while I do, can someone please explain what MRA and TRA stands for?

@RosieRooster83 Mens Rights Activists, and Trans Rights Activists.

AchatAVendre · 02/06/2022 14:38

LetitiaLeghorn So they would have a knowledgeable interpretation of what was going on, the legalities of how the court was being conducted, and how juries typically react to certain things. It seems unreasonable to me to say that the jury only found for Depp because he was famous, but ignore that Heards behaviour on the stand and her contradicted testimony and, honestly, lies, played no part.

It would indeed be unreasonable to say that the jury only found for Depp because he was famous. Who said that?

"Behaviour on the stand, eh?" Or who had the best acting abilities or played best to the audience? Anyway behaviour on the stand should not be relevant to evidence. Some witnesses are simply better at being witnesses than others, trained legal minds can better overlook this than juries. An adversarial system with a civil jury in a defamation case is pushing the boundaries of justice.

I don't know if you're in the legal profession but if you are, I hope you don't make judge. Because that would disprove that judges don't bring their own personal prejudices into court.

I hope one day you grow up and learn to communicate with people without being rude or insulting them just because you disagree with them.

LetitiaLeghorn · 02/06/2022 14:25

@AchatAVendre
"Anyway, I don't think that Depp had to prove his case on the normal balance of probabilities at all. I think what was actually applied in this trial was a special standard of proof reserved for powerful Hollywood stars with a massive fan base and so what we actually got was "on the balance of public prejudice/public opinion/level of fame". Its a witch trial for modern times.

"And please can anyone who disagrees with me not regale me with the plaintive "Did you read/watch/listen to the trial" question..."
................................

In my experiencea person's opinion on how well a judge or a jury performs, usually depends on how the result measures up to what they think it should have been. Most jury members do not take their responsibilities lightly and do their best. It's always easier for lawyers to know/feel they know better when they have access to so much more information.

I was interested watching US lawyers opinions online. I can't think of one that I watched that at the start thought that Depp would win. (A) because its so hard to win defamation; and (B) they relied on the UK judge making a reasonable finding. In fact they all thought Depp was mad to bring the case.

But as the trial progressed, their opinions shifted. Their comments moved more and more in Depps favour as the trial went on. These are lawyers working in the US system and have done criminal and civil law. They also called out good and bad lawyering on both sides. So they would have a knowledgeable interpretation of what was going on, the legalities of how the court was being conducted, and how juries typically react to certain things. It seems unreasonable to me to say that the jury only found for Depp because he was famous, but ignore that Heards behaviour on the stand and her contradicted testimony and, honestly, lies, played no part.

I don't know if you're in the legal profession but if you are, I hope you don't make judge. Because that would disprove that judges don't bring their own personal prejudices into court.

RosieRooster83 · 02/06/2022 14:20

I'm just catching up with the thread but while I do, can someone please explain what MRA and TRA stands for?

AchatAVendre · 02/06/2022 14:06

mynamesnotMa · 02/06/2022 13:57

AchatAVendre...very well explained.

Do you think she will appeal?

Her lawyer has apparently just announced her intention to appeal, one of the grounds being that she believes the jury has been influenced by social media and therefore the decision is biased.

I think its actually worth appealing the amount of damages.

Obviously theres no award of costs yet but you would assume neither side would have got costs because the Defender's side asked for the trial to be ended at an early stage (as is standard to try to avoid costs amongst other matters) and the judge's direction then was inconsistent with the jury outcome.

LetitiaLeghorn · 02/06/2022 14:03

Onthedunes · 02/06/2022 13:29

Amber was very generous pledging to donate all of her divorce settlement to ACLU.

Actually half her settlement to the ACLU. But bah. A measly $3.5m. I hearby pledge a billion dollars to the ACLU. Of course I might have a few difficulties in actually paying it but, at the end of the day, a pledge is the same as a donation so I'm sure they won't mind.
(I'm trying to get the bank to accept my pledge to pay a $3m mortgage on a lovely house near me. No luck so far but I'm sure once they see it's a perfectly acceptable arrangement, they'll change their mind. 🙏 🙂)

mynamesnotMa · 02/06/2022 13:57

AchatAVendre...very well explained.

Do you think she will appeal?

AchatAVendre · 02/06/2022 13:36

I wish people would realise that the way American justice deals with these sort of cases is very, very different from the rest of the world.

First of all, it has an adversarial, not inquisatorial (judge-led) system (as does the UK), however only in the US do you get such plaintiff and defence led arguments with little judicial direction. That is why it turned into such a circus.

Then in addition, you have a civil jury. Juries are notoriously poor at sifting through evidence. When you study evidence as a law student, you learn that people and therefore jurors tend to hold all sorts of pre-conceptions, prejudices and personal views that affect their judgment. We know from studies that jurors are prejudiced to believe men and to disbelieve women and for that reason, in the UK at least, we tend to discourage their use where possible. Lawrence Fox has been refused a civil jury trial in the defamation case being brought against him presently.

Judges on the other hand are trained in adductive thinking (as are some of the police) where you develop many theories and then look for evidence and then examine that evidence to see which theory is best supported by it.

Non-lawyers tend to be prejudiced towards purposive thinking, which is where you have one outcome already decided in your mind as being the "best" and which you look for evidence to fit that outcome.

There is a reason that the US keeps producing these extremely powerful men who evade justice and these media circuses around trials - Epstein, Weinstein, OJ Simpson. There is a reason that the US can't decide whether allowing women to have bodily autonomy is a basic human right or not. In many ways, the US is quite backwards as to how it treats women (and poor people/minorities). I'm really shocked but not surprised by the whole thing. It is almost impossible in the US to bring a famous man to justice timeously. Albeit the former were criminal trials and this was a civil trial, but how many years did it take to bring Epstein and Weinstein to account?

Also not saying that the UK is perfect. I'm currently looking at the Malcolm Webster (wife killer) trial and the number of times people reported their concerns to the police after his first murder and how his father in the MET protected him is disgraceful.

Anyway, I don't think that Depp had to prove his case on the normal balance of probabilities at all. I think what was actually applied in this trial was a special standard of proof reserved for powerful Hollywood stars with a massive fan base and so what we actually got was "on the balance of public prejudice/public opinion/level of fame". Its a witch trial for modern times.

And please can anyone who disagrees with me not regale me with the plaintive "Did you read/watch/listen to the trial" question...Grin

Onthedunes · 02/06/2022 13:29

Amber was very generous pledging to donate all of her divorce settlement to ACLU.

SaintJavelin · 02/06/2022 13:28

TalkingCat · 02/06/2022 13:16

@TheEnemy123 You are the one talking rubbish. He wasn't found innocent. He is indeed an abuser and beater, so give it up.

The UK trial was in civil court so no he isn't.

Onthedunes · 02/06/2022 13:22

This trial was no doubt political.

Many are signing the petition about the nuetrality of the uk judge, it shows a flow chart which they claim is evidence that the retired judge had conflicting interests.

TalkingCat · 02/06/2022 13:16

TheEnemy123 · 02/06/2022 11:52

@DaisyQuakeJohnson give it up. You don't half talk some rubbish 😂 The man won. He won because he was innocent. It must be a tough pill to swallow for a misandrist such as yourself, but it's time to accept it and move on.

Amber Heard is a vile abuser. Fact.

@TheEnemy123 You are the one talking rubbish. He wasn't found innocent. He is indeed an abuser and beater, so give it up.