Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Who will win between Johnny Depp and Amber Heard defamation case

681 replies

Egtermekaar · 25/05/2022 14:49

If you were jury in this case, how would you decide?

I think Johnny Depp will win because he had strong, reliable and consistent evidence of "his" case

I hope MN will allow debate about a matter of public interest.

OP posts:
RosieRooster83 · 02/06/2022 22:06

@Aspiringmatriarch What ample evidence is there that Amber was assaulted? Meaning evidence that was in the trial.

minutesturntohours · 02/06/2022 22:05

Aspiringmatriarch · 02/06/2022 22:00

I can't make head or tail of this nonsense. Self-obsessed? Bizarre comment.

My point fairly obviously is that male victims do indeed exist. Go and support them if you care that much. Johnny Depp is a disgusting misogynist as evidenced extensively by his own words, so no I will not be supporting him. And there's ample evidence that Amber was assaulted. Ample. So stop straw manning over male vs female victims because you're the only ones making this an identity politics thing.

And also fairly obviously, I am referring to Amber being sued over her Op Ed. She wasn't sued over the testimony she then went on to give in court, was she? Crackers.

Thinking everything is about women, all the time. It isn't.

I do support male victims. Do you not?

Back to the self - obsessed point, I'm glad you know better than the judge.

She's a liar and she's finished, and I'm glad. Thankfully people like you are about 1 in 100, so I'm sure Johnny will cope.

Aspiringmatriarch · 02/06/2022 22:00

minutesturntohours · 02/06/2022 21:52

Kevin's is a criminal trial that hasn't started yet - I'm sure it will in time.

It's not an excuse to pass judgement of a woman. That's a really self obsessed point of view. The jury deliberated for 2 days, this went on for weeks, and you HONESTLY believe they cleared Johnny just for shits and giggles and because they don't like a woman?

Amber hardly "alluded". She repeatedly told lies about him, over and over and over, and again this morning not 12 hours since the trial she's done it again!

I can't make head or tail of this nonsense. Self-obsessed? Bizarre comment.

My point fairly obviously is that male victims do indeed exist. Go and support them if you care that much. Johnny Depp is a disgusting misogynist as evidenced extensively by his own words, so no I will not be supporting him. And there's ample evidence that Amber was assaulted. Ample. So stop straw manning over male vs female victims because you're the only ones making this an identity politics thing.

And also fairly obviously, I am referring to Amber being sued over her Op Ed. She wasn't sued over the testimony she then went on to give in court, was she? Crackers.

minutesturntohours · 02/06/2022 21:52

Aspiringmatriarch · 02/06/2022 21:50

And yet I haven't seen a word in support of Kevin Spacey's victims. So it's not about male victims. It's just an excuse to pass judgement on a woman and it could affect both men and women if they can be sued for even alluding to having been a victim.

Kevin's is a criminal trial that hasn't started yet - I'm sure it will in time.

It's not an excuse to pass judgement of a woman. That's a really self obsessed point of view. The jury deliberated for 2 days, this went on for weeks, and you HONESTLY believe they cleared Johnny just for shits and giggles and because they don't like a woman?

Amber hardly "alluded". She repeatedly told lies about him, over and over and over, and again this morning not 12 hours since the trial she's done it again!

Aspiringmatriarch · 02/06/2022 21:50

Justanotherlurker · 02/06/2022 21:44

Those suggesting it sends the 'wrong message' are basically saying men cannot be victims of assault, which is huge barrier to it being taken seriously.

Imagine the column inches if Amber had won and a lot of online comments where based on her apperance or saying she was 'vile' and 'creepy'

What has come to light on this situation is just a team sport situation but it's sex based, the idpol is obvious, it isn't about raising awarness, it's twitter hot takes ans standing by a team, unironically most people playing the team sport like to use the 'critical thinking' meme.

And yet I haven't seen a word in support of Kevin Spacey's victims. So it's not about male victims. It's just an excuse to pass judgement on a woman and it could affect both men and women if they can be sued for even alluding to having been a victim.

Justanotherlurker · 02/06/2022 21:44

Those suggesting it sends the 'wrong message' are basically saying men cannot be victims of assault, which is huge barrier to it being taken seriously.

Imagine the column inches if Amber had won and a lot of online comments where based on her apperance or saying she was 'vile' and 'creepy'

What has come to light on this situation is just a team sport situation but it's sex based, the idpol is obvious, it isn't about raising awarness, it's twitter hot takes ans standing by a team, unironically most people playing the team sport like to use the 'critical thinking' meme.

BigFatLiar · 02/06/2022 21:40

justfiveminutes · 02/06/2022 21:31

We can't forget that. AH supporters mention it every five minutes.

Don't forget that the reason OJ won his case was not because he was innocent but because the prosecution were caught out fixing evidence. If they'd simply stuck to rules they'd have got a conviction rather than ruin their case.

minutesturntohours · 02/06/2022 21:34

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

that is a disgusting post.

Fwiw, I agree with the Enemy 100 percent, as do the vast majority of people. I'm over the moon he won and Amber deserves everything she gets.

To tell a DV survivor you think she was happy someone was murdered is the most digusting thing I've read on here.

minutesturntohours · 02/06/2022 21:32

RosieRooster83 · 02/06/2022 21:07

Those that think JD was the abuser, what evidence is this based upon from the trial? Genuinely interested as to the reasoning behind it.

Three words. She's a woman.

justfiveminutes · 02/06/2022 21:31

Nothappyatwork · 02/06/2022 21:15

That’s not forget that this is the same justice system that found OJ not guilty 🙄

We can't forget that. AH supporters mention it every five minutes.

minutesturntohours · 02/06/2022 21:29

Nothappyatwork · 02/06/2022 21:15

That’s not forget that this is the same justice system that found OJ not guilty 🙄

Oh for goodness sake.
Johnny really can't win here, can he?

Now I assume if Amber had won you would be quite pleased with the justice system?

See, here's the thing. This isn't Johnny's fault. It isn't the media's. It isn't the judges. It isnt the people who support him, It isn't men's as a whole.

It's Amber's. Plain and simple. The fact she has a vagina does not magically free her from this fact.

Nothappyatwork · 02/06/2022 21:15

That’s not forget that this is the same justice system that found OJ not guilty 🙄

minutesturntohours · 02/06/2022 21:07

DaisyQuakeJohnson · 02/06/2022 10:01

This article is interesting. Republicans hated JD because he made a joke about Trump being assassinated but Reps and Trump have been falling over themselves to support him now because they hate women; they hate feminists and they hated Me Too.

The social media onslaught was about getting women to stfu and showing rich men in the US can shop around for their desired result.

AH was awarded damages too but even if every count had been found in her favour, posters wouldn't have been on here gloating. There was no gloating when the UK case upheld so many counts of abuse against him. Most women (and men with empathy tbh) don't celebrate abuse. Yet another sign that for the JD 'supporters'/bots/Republicans/MRAs/TRAs this was never about abuse. It was about certain factions consistently trying to get women to shut up and inadvertently showing how inadequate social media is at managing co-ordinated assaults. Women and many politicians have known both those things for a long time. This circus has just brought it to wider attention and given them more evidence for pushing ahead with social media reform.

Why Republicans Supported JD

Are you having a laugh? Of course they would have been gloating!

As for pretending that we must be MRAs if we dont blindly support a lying, disgraceful excuse for a human who uses abused women to ride on the coat tails of, that's ridiculous. Its not about "shutting her up", its about stopping her lying. And by the way, we arnt celebrating abuse. We are celebrating no abuse, because there wasn't any!

RosieRooster83 · 02/06/2022 21:07

Those that think JD was the abuser, what evidence is this based upon from the trial? Genuinely interested as to the reasoning behind it.

minutesturntohours · 02/06/2022 21:05

TalkingCat · 02/06/2022 13:11

That he did indeed abuse her so I didn't libel.

No, he didn't, so it is.

justfiveminutes · 02/06/2022 20:22

TalkingCat, I don't think I've posted on this thread but enjoyed reading the debate until yesterday when it got so nasty. I don't think it's right to insult posters who disagree with you - calling pp incels and misogynists, accusing them of celebrating when the OJ Simpson trial ended.

Unless you know JD or AH personally, you don't know any more about the case than everyone else. Some people have watched the trial, just like you, but reached a different conclusion, that's all. To you, he's an abuser who got away with it but to many she is the abuser who lied maliciously and has paid the price. I really think it's time to accept the verdict. Anyone who uses this case to disbelieve an abused victim probably wouldn't have believed them anyway.

Workwork21 · 02/06/2022 20:21

The evidence actually shows that JD was hiding in a bathroom whilst being goaded and pushed and pushed and pushed.

I can say when I was in the midst of it with my ex that goading would have been the last thing I did. It was always me hiding in the bathroom to keep safe. I resonate more as a victim with Johnny's actions, his actions were far more plausible to reality. That is why huge numbers of DV victims support him.

Workwork21 · 02/06/2022 20:18

TalkingCat · 02/06/2022 20:08

The minute a victim is violent or fights back the courts will no longer see her as a victim, there's been research on this and it's a huge contradiction in studies/mainstream view of abuse in general; this trial just proved it. This is a huge blow to DV survivors. But there are Meninists on this thread who are no doubt 'getting off' on this. 🙄

The evidence does not show that it was a case of fighting back.

For what it's worth, my ex tried to do me for fighting back and there were no issues with it being seen for what it was because the evidence supported the truth.

RosieRooster83 · 02/06/2022 20:10

TalkingCat · 02/06/2022 20:08

The minute a victim is violent or fights back the courts will no longer see her as a victim, there's been research on this and it's a huge contradiction in studies/mainstream view of abuse in general; this trial just proved it. This is a huge blow to DV survivors. But there are Meninists on this thread who are no doubt 'getting off' on this. 🙄

I don't think it is a blow for DV survivors at all. I think it is a positive thing for men who have been abused as so often they just do not get believed. Hopefully now they won't feel so ashamed to tell people what they have suffered.

TalkingCat · 02/06/2022 20:08

The minute a victim is violent or fights back the courts will no longer see her as a victim, there's been research on this and it's a huge contradiction in studies/mainstream view of abuse in general; this trial just proved it. This is a huge blow to DV survivors. But there are Meninists on this thread who are no doubt 'getting off' on this. 🙄

TalkingCat · 02/06/2022 20:05

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

TalkingCat · 02/06/2022 20:04

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Midlifemusings · 02/06/2022 19:48

Workwork21 · 02/06/2022 19:24

It would have been interesting if it could have done completely anonymised. Ie the juror didn't know who is person A or B. Voice distortion used for the testimonies etc. I suspect if you took out any way of knowing who was whom in it, the same outcome would have been reached.

I desperately wanted to believe AH. The actual evidence meant I could not.

I agree. I listened to some of the recordings where people reenacted them siwtching genders for the lines and I have no doubt if Depp had said and done the things that Heard did - the outcome would have found for Heard.

Interestingly Amber was the first one to bring social media into it - telling the jurors that social media was on Johnny's side and were being mean to her. She also clearly had been watching media and social media and even amended her own evidence when the TMZ photo was released with metadata showig itwas taken a year before the date she had just testified to.

Workwork21 · 02/06/2022 19:24

It would have been interesting if it could have done completely anonymised. Ie the juror didn't know who is person A or B. Voice distortion used for the testimonies etc. I suspect if you took out any way of knowing who was whom in it, the same outcome would have been reached.

I desperately wanted to believe AH. The actual evidence meant I could not.

Tontostitis · 02/06/2022 18:28

Indeed, but even taunting your victim on tape isn't enough for some people...
Agreed you have to be seriously prejudiced or wilfully ignorant to listen to those tapes and still side with AH. But my NY resolution was to not argue with idiots 😎