Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

watching a town completely die

433 replies

BlessedByTheShitFairy · 25/05/2022 13:37

This is so sad really, the town where I grew up. I know many business folded during covid and many high street staples have been closing for years, but this is different.

It's a large town, over 400K population, had a bustling, varied and thriving centre for most it's history, has now lost, and many before covid:

Debs, Next, M&S, Topshop, H&M, Body Shop, its central post office, game shops, cafes, most youth related places such as skating, bowling, carts, ALL restaurants (no exaggeration), health food stores, 2 shopping centres, most pubs, it's huge market, several banks, nightclubs, a town centre co-op, Spar, book shops, many charity shops and all of it's high end hair salons. Even the Starbucks slid off and the main post office was reduced from around 10 staff to 1 and shoved into a tiny toilet sized cubicle on the periphery of the borough.

These have been survived and replaced by - pop up eyebrow/lashes salons, fast food joints, poundshops, phone-unlocking shops, cash converter type shops, Primark (it's only remaining clothes store), Iceland, and the rest if boarded up. Interestingly a ton of privately owned car parks have taken over the area and hardly anyone uses them. It is unrecognisable from even 7 years ago. It now only attracts crime, heavy drinking, and a much less diverse population.

I know many towns have experienced closures of big brands, and things are simply changing (the net, everything online, etc) but this is really extreme, especially in comparison to a few years ago, it was not particularly suffering a decline. I do know that the council slowly sold off everything over the years, and have sent 2 huge shopping centres to their doom by selling to overseas investors who never came and filled them, so they are like enormous empty spaces that attract crime.

I don't currently live there but my remaining family that do say they never go in to town anymore, and feel forced to buy everything from standalone supermarkets in other areas.
I live in a fairly average town that has seen changes but there are also attempts at rejuvenation. Things are still ok and thriving in the centre. I am also aware that many towns are coping ok, taking the rough with the smooth, even though these issues have increased across the uk over all.

What could have happened to this one? Why so desolate and different? It is like the council just gave up sold it off and turned away. It never used to suffer so much crime, and the sound of police and ambulances is constant around the area now. The town centre was it's pride and joy, had so much put into it (festivals, events), so I can't understand how it got so bad.
Even the people who you see there now are all strangely similar (dress the same, same behaviours) and the diversity has vanished. Curiously rents are still super high and I have no idea who is taking them, if at all.

I feel sad about it because I grew up there, and have so many good memories of my teens when it was thriving, packed and full of interesting places to go and shop. The pubs were visited from far and wide, and it had a great college, access to learning, and much more culture. Now it is lucky to hold on to a handful of football clubs and that's the only interest left. Where and why did everything just die? It was previously so bloody alive.

OP posts:
ParsleyRosemarySage · 25/05/2022 19:18

Derby has the same issue with Nottingham (and Sheffield, and even Birmingham).

It is those centralised chains pulling out now of the towns, where they ousted local businesses, and maximising their profits by retaining only the most attractive physical properties in areas with the very highest footfalls. Both pushed by the need to maximise not just profits but profit margins, for remote shareholders on the other side of the world, and Britain’s insanely unaffordable land prices. We need to re establish local businesses, but few have the resources either to supply the raw materials needed or those land prices and rates. Even the markets died.

ButtockUp · 25/05/2022 19:17

So many properties on the High Street are owned by absent landlords, absent property management companies , oligarchs ( by dint of investment portfolios.)

Properties on the High Street cost an absolute fortune.
No wonder business prefer the online business model.

Endless councils have put forward plans for a cafe culture combined with local/artisan/arty farty shops but the rents/lease are prohibitive.

Towns and cities are wanting to copy the European model of a thriving food market, independent coffee shops/ independent restaurants/craft and gift type shops as well as one off businesses but the property market in these places is unsustainable.

To many overly rich property portfolios are preventing the growth of towns and villages.

Badbadbunny · 25/05/2022 19:15

Would people moan if business rates were lowered though? Generally people want businesses to pay, but maybe not local ones so much?

The main problem with business rates is that a High Street store pays more (for exactly the same space) as an out of town retail park store or an online warehouse due to different multipliers being used for different types of premises, and High Street retail being the highest multiplier. That needs to change so that there is at least parity. An Amazon warehouse of exactly the same size as a High St store shouldn't be paying far less, in fact given online shopping trends, it should be paying more, i.e. time to reverse the multipliers!

MarshaBradyo · 25/05/2022 19:04

OldWivesTale · 25/05/2022 19:01

OK that's interesting. I thought councils set business rates. Oh well, one more reason to hate this fucking government then.

I noticed on recent local elections the Tory candidate was more pro local business than Labour

Not sure I agreed with it all - eg no ULEZ for business but it was the general direction

Would people moan if business rates were lowered though? Generally people want businesses to pay, but maybe not local ones so much?

OldWivesTale · 25/05/2022 19:01

Lincslady53 · 25/05/2022 18:45

Business rates are NOT set by local councils but by central government. The Valuation Office revalue all business premises every 5 years, based on the value you would have to pay to rent the premises. This is then multiplied by a figure, known as the multiplier to give the amount of business rates due. So, if the rateable value was £50,250 ( as our 800sq ft town centre shop was) and the multiplier is .45, then the rates payable are £50,250x .45, or £22,600 ish. If the rateable value is low, I think less than £15k then the business gets small business rates relief and will pay no business rates. The local council collects the rates on behalf of central gov. In the Northern city we had our shop in, the landlord was almost reasonable and didn't put our rent up at 2, 5 yearly rent reviews, but the business rates went up regardless of falling footfall.

OK that's interesting. I thought councils set business rates. Oh well, one more reason to hate this fucking government then.

OldWivesTale · 25/05/2022 18:59

Stoke on Trent is the same. It's always been a bit rough but it had a busy, vibrant city centre; now it's all closed down and even M and S have moved out of town. The council don't help when they charge a fortune for parking and high rates for small businesses. It's also difficult because you can get on a train and be in Manchester City centre in 40 mins - so that's what people tend to do. It's so sad. I'm guessing Wigan has the same problem being so near to Manchester.

JudgeJ · 25/05/2022 18:46

BlessedByTheShitFairy · 25/05/2022 15:47

Lots of replies here, had a surprise visitor so not had chance to read many, will get back asap.
I am also glad to hear im not alone in feeling sad about what happened to wigan. I dont think it was at all bad when I left, it just wasnt exciting enough for me at 18 Grin

You actually let a surprise visitor in?? Return your MNer badge PDQ!

Lincslady53 · 25/05/2022 18:45

ResentfulLemon · 25/05/2022 14:28

Locally our Labour council are a substantial part of the problem. The rates they set for businesses to operate are punitive, add in impossible infrastructure (can't easily drive in and park, but public transport is useless), plus ridiculous rents from commercial landlords and it's made for a perfect storm for places to literally shut up shop and become online entities only.

Fortunately we don't seem to be as badly affected as your hometown, but the decay is there to be seen and we seem to be at a tipping point on whether the area can ride this out or if the unsavoury element will make the place too risky for future investment (just for reference, the McDonalds in the centre has a bouncer for their entire opening hours - that's just nuts!)

Business rates are NOT set by local councils but by central government. The Valuation Office revalue all business premises every 5 years, based on the value you would have to pay to rent the premises. This is then multiplied by a figure, known as the multiplier to give the amount of business rates due. So, if the rateable value was £50,250 ( as our 800sq ft town centre shop was) and the multiplier is .45, then the rates payable are £50,250x .45, or £22,600 ish. If the rateable value is low, I think less than £15k then the business gets small business rates relief and will pay no business rates. The local council collects the rates on behalf of central gov. In the Northern city we had our shop in, the landlord was almost reasonable and didn't put our rent up at 2, 5 yearly rent reviews, but the business rates went up regardless of falling footfall.

Caszekey · 25/05/2022 18:44

This seems like mismanagement to me

I live in a town popn 285000 ranked in top 10% most deprived towns etc and it isn't that bad. We've lost a few chain restaurants and stores but there's at least six pubs in the wider town centre, 4 restaurants plus coffee shops (the big two) and cafes, Asda, Tesco, Entertainer, Argos, Smyths etc plus all the usual second hand shops, poundlands, vape stores. We've got a new bowling alley coming and even a Ninja Warrior UK thing as well as several soft play centres. Of course we lost the big Department stores and have empty beautiful buildings but it's busy

Libertaire · 25/05/2022 18:41

It’s definitely not just towns that are struggling. My nearest city is Leicester. The state of the city centre and the way it has declined over the last decade has to be seen to be believed. It used to be a thriving, diverse city with generally good relationships between various communities.

Now, it has become a total dump. Someone I know even used the phrase ‘third world shithole.’ A decade ago, Leicester had six department stores : John Lewis, House of Fraser, Fenwick, Debenhams, BHS & M&S. Now, only JL & M&S remain, and the latter is a tired store which is mainly used as a cut-through between two streets. Nail bars, chicken shops & other cash businesses used for laundering drug money have replaced normal shops. The main Highcross shopping mall is half empty. Entire streets, eg Belvoir St & Market st which used to be an upmarket shopping area, are now almost desolate. The market used to be excellent, it’s now a shadow of what it used to be.

The council responds to its dying city centre not by cleaning the place up dealing with all the druggies, beggars, scammers & religious/ anti-vax nutters but by making it ever more difficult, inconvenient & expensive to drive into town & park. Meanwhile, Fosse Park, a large retail park next to the M1 which is clean, safe & well run with free parking is expanding & thriving. I wonder why?

So-called ‘white flight’ has now become ‘middle-class Asian flight’ as families who can afford to move out to one of the affluent towns & villages in the county. Reports of stabbings have become an almost daily staple of the local rag. Many people I know simply refuse to go into Leicester at all because they just don’t feel safe.

HappyHappyHermit · 25/05/2022 18:41

@Iamthewombat My reasons make perfect sense.

Iputthetrampintrampoline · 25/05/2022 18:37

Ours is full of nothing but eastern european supermarkets,charity shops,takeaways,barbers and betting shops. It is so dire. I live a mile out and travel 10 miles to avoid going, It too has a large drug problem that is in the central precinct and beggars and gangs of men who will not move and make you walk off the path and in the road with a pram which is highy intimadating. I know its not politically correct and I know I will seem racist but it is how it is. Non of my friends and family go there it doesn;t feel safe at all. I have no idea whos to blame but thats the situation and I vote with my feet to not go there.

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 25/05/2022 18:33

I think to run an independent shop in London you must have to be quite wealthy to afford the rents.

Meanehike in skint northern places very few people can afford the rents or business rates.

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 25/05/2022 18:31

What's hard to face is the good times are over for the human population

That’s a bit bleak. I don’t think they are over for ever. It’s just a bad time.

Ferngreen · 25/05/2022 18:25

It's a shame we can't chivvy people to clean up town centres - ok you don't wade through piles of beer cans but you'd think powerhoses hadn't been invented. Green moss and algae, seagull droppings, dried vomit, fag ends. Anything concrete really dingy.
I had a week in Florida - I saw one fag end (lying on a drain) and not one speck of rubbish the whole week. Unbelievable.
But everything is the responsibility of 'the cooncil' not the public.

BlessedByTheShitFairy · 25/05/2022 18:25

CurbsideProphet · 25/05/2022 17:31

I'm sorry if this has already been said but there are restaurants left in Wigan and The Old Courts is being transformed by a community group, but definitely agree the town centre is devoid of any life. Hopefully the council plans for the new market / cinema etc are successful. We're only 30 mins away but never go.

The one's I was aware of a few years ago are gone. I am sure there are some round about. It has just completely altered for the worse.
The Old Courts is a dive, a lot of good intentions and hard work went into that over the past 15 years, it's a shame. It's been 'being transformed' for years. Nothing ever happens because there's no market left for any of it. God it's depressing :(

OP posts:
MarshaBradyo · 25/05/2022 18:16

When I go to towns I see what is described on this thread, it is depressing

But here (‘up and coming’ London or already reinvigorated) we have more independent shops and people using them and I wonder what the key differences are

EveningOverRooftops · 25/05/2022 18:15

Combination of things.

locally to me we have issues of -

reduced bus routes into town

high parking charges

huge rates costs for the private owner mall that naturally attracts the big names and that’s decimated the once thriving rest of the town where these shops once stood

High local business rates

BIDs (business improvement districts) that charge businesses on top of business rates. Oft private owned with big wage CEOs. Ours runs market days that draws income away from local shops into those out of town stall renters. It’s a big bone of contention here but you can’t opt out either.

limited range of options and ease/availability of online shopping. Eg this week I needed a sink plug, balls of yarn and something nice to eat I’d have to travel to 3 different shopping spots here as the DIY place has moved out of town, restaurants have moved to the ‘tourist hotspot’ 25 min walk away and the only yarn/craft place left is a hobbycraft on an industrial estate out of the town centre and they’re very limited yarn wise compared to a good yarn shop. To do it all it would be 6 different journeys just to get that then come home taking most of the day. Instead I shop online for most of it and save my time.

On my smaller high street the greengrocer shut due to competition from coop. The butcher went the same way.
yarn shop closed during the pandemic. The charity shops turned into a barbers and a fast food place. The pound shop type place now mostly sells vape juice.

ParsleyRosemarySage · 25/05/2022 18:13

No one seems to know how to plan at the bottom end of the economy now. It is all about large chains maximising profits which they can then suck out of local economies. They standardise offerings, which can be auctioned off to the highest paying large chain, rather than responding to local needs and markets. Local councils have little or no power to change anything: services have slowly been taken out of their control for decades, and they have been forced, by law, to contract work out to the lowest price with no regard for local impacts. There is no one to speak for local affairs in central government, no checks, no balances. A few celebrity mayors don’t really have the same voice as a mandated council with powers.

No one has ever had any interest in climate change: an economy governed by central government without a multiplicity of local powers was always going to be very vulnerable to takeover by centralised financial interests, and that’s exactly what happened. Decades ago. Centralised financial interests have no interest in people. It’s a far cry from lots of local companies manufacturing locally, supplying locally, employing local people and putting their wealth back in to the town in the form of parks and buildings.

Iamthewombat · 25/05/2022 18:11

Seeing people urinating everywhere is bleak. Lying on the floor in their own vomit

The drugs are very bad at the moment - had to call an ambulance a few times when out walking the dog recently. Just because people are passed out in front of Waitrose rather than a boarded up shop doesn't mean that issues are not there.

It s very naive to think that green towns do not have issues.

Towns die when locals give up on them. Locals are in despair about Harrogate at the moment - as are businesses.

Are all the locals and businesses ‘in despair’ about Harrogate? Have they all ‘given up on the town’? I doubt it. I was there two weeks ago (no, not on a hen do; we have friends living there). It looked fine to me. Thriving streets full of lovely shops, respectable-looking people and nice places to eat and drink. I didn’t see a single person urinating on the street or lying in a pool of vomit. You claim that it’s happening all the time (‘people urinating everywhere’), which is ridiculous. People probably do the same thing in Mayfair when the bars and clubs close.

I suspect that what you are really upset about, judging by your previous post, is housing in Harrogate becoming too expensive for your daughter and her friends to afford, hence the AirBnB ire. Not just at the AirBnB landlords but at the people staying in them.

Can you see that a proliferation of AirBnBs means that the town in which they are situated is a nice place that people want to visit? You don’t have to like it, any more than the residents of e.g. Reykjavik have to like the fact that many of their residential accommodation is now AirBnB. It doesn’t make the town ‘bleak’ though. You could start an alternative thread bemoaning the perceived drop in standards in Harrogate rather than hijacking the OP’s thread about towns with genuine problems, but I doubt that you’d get much sympathy!

BlessedByTheShitFairy · 25/05/2022 18:03

Something else that bothers me, and If anyone could explain or expand on it that would be great.

IF our town centre's are dying and shops moving out to retail parks, how does this affect pollution? Doesn't it make us more car dependent?

I hear that a lot of new estates are popping up with no shops, schools, et, so that most people are forced to drive everywhere, when this was at one time associated with living rurally.

It just seems that all government talk about climate change and pollution is simply lies. It seems more about how many contracts can be given to rich friends in the short term, with no foresight or care whatsoever.

OP posts:
Echosound · 25/05/2022 17:57

There are a load of empty units in the Trafford centre actually so this also affects larger shopping centres. All the ones we know about, gap, oasis, warehouse, topshop, Dorothy Perkins, burton, miss selfridge, Debenhams, monsoon all gone. And that’s just the clothes shops. Likely many more who have left. Some of the units have filled but not many. It’s so depressing but at the same time I buy clothes online all the time because there are no shops, or limited stuff in shop, but which came first, chicken or egg, it’s a vicious cycle

LinManuelMirandaIsAGenius · 25/05/2022 17:56

@TheJubileeLion it sounds like you’re talking about Whitehaven. I know it well, and agree…

ChiswickFlo · 25/05/2022 17:51

Derby is awful now.
The shopping centre has many empty units.
It costs me £5 in petrol to get there now and the same to park (£4.20 yesterday for 2 hours)
Debenhams, HofF, cath kidston, BHS, patisserie Valerie...all gone.
The out of centre cinema is gone, the main street basically has macdonalds and Costa and a waterstones. That's it.
My own main street where I live has no bank, no butchers, no grocers, no bakery...(had all of those 20 years ago..)
Plenty of hairdressers, estate agents, gift shops, curry houses and pubs!
We have 1 small co op.
I'm not sure the post office will last for another year ..
And all whilst 2 HUGE housing developments are being built 🤷‍♀️

ssd · 25/05/2022 17:48

Of course its happening all over Scotland too.