Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

watching a town completely die

433 replies

BlessedByTheShitFairy · 25/05/2022 13:37

This is so sad really, the town where I grew up. I know many business folded during covid and many high street staples have been closing for years, but this is different.

It's a large town, over 400K population, had a bustling, varied and thriving centre for most it's history, has now lost, and many before covid:

Debs, Next, M&S, Topshop, H&M, Body Shop, its central post office, game shops, cafes, most youth related places such as skating, bowling, carts, ALL restaurants (no exaggeration), health food stores, 2 shopping centres, most pubs, it's huge market, several banks, nightclubs, a town centre co-op, Spar, book shops, many charity shops and all of it's high end hair salons. Even the Starbucks slid off and the main post office was reduced from around 10 staff to 1 and shoved into a tiny toilet sized cubicle on the periphery of the borough.

These have been survived and replaced by - pop up eyebrow/lashes salons, fast food joints, poundshops, phone-unlocking shops, cash converter type shops, Primark (it's only remaining clothes store), Iceland, and the rest if boarded up. Interestingly a ton of privately owned car parks have taken over the area and hardly anyone uses them. It is unrecognisable from even 7 years ago. It now only attracts crime, heavy drinking, and a much less diverse population.

I know many towns have experienced closures of big brands, and things are simply changing (the net, everything online, etc) but this is really extreme, especially in comparison to a few years ago, it was not particularly suffering a decline. I do know that the council slowly sold off everything over the years, and have sent 2 huge shopping centres to their doom by selling to overseas investors who never came and filled them, so they are like enormous empty spaces that attract crime.

I don't currently live there but my remaining family that do say they never go in to town anymore, and feel forced to buy everything from standalone supermarkets in other areas.
I live in a fairly average town that has seen changes but there are also attempts at rejuvenation. Things are still ok and thriving in the centre. I am also aware that many towns are coping ok, taking the rough with the smooth, even though these issues have increased across the uk over all.

What could have happened to this one? Why so desolate and different? It is like the council just gave up sold it off and turned away. It never used to suffer so much crime, and the sound of police and ambulances is constant around the area now. The town centre was it's pride and joy, had so much put into it (festivals, events), so I can't understand how it got so bad.
Even the people who you see there now are all strangely similar (dress the same, same behaviours) and the diversity has vanished. Curiously rents are still super high and I have no idea who is taking them, if at all.

I feel sad about it because I grew up there, and have so many good memories of my teens when it was thriving, packed and full of interesting places to go and shop. The pubs were visited from far and wide, and it had a great college, access to learning, and much more culture. Now it is lucky to hold on to a handful of football clubs and that's the only interest left. Where and why did everything just die? It was previously so bloody alive.

OP posts:
HappyHappyHermit · 25/05/2022 15:15

@Iamthewombat I think that's very expensive! Fortunately around here it is much cheaper than that. Actually it is not so much the paying but the faff of parking, getting dd out of car and then finding the right change or remembering my number plate, going back to the car and then the whole time having to check the clock to make sure I don't go over the time etc. I much prefer the ones where you take a ticket as you drive in and the just pay at the end for the time you are there.

tillytoodles1 · 25/05/2022 15:12

I used to live shopping in Liverpool City centre when I was younger, but we moved away and the nearest town is Chester.
Last time I went was four years ago, and the precinct that used to be really busy, was almost empty and a lot of the shops were empty too, it dead now that Debenhams has gone.
We have Broughton, Greyhound Park and Cheshire Oaks, all within easy reach by car.
There's restaurants and cinemas there, plus a large Tesco. But the main thing is free parking right outside where you want to go, no walking through town carrying heavy packages.

Iamthewombat · 25/05/2022 15:12

I’m surprised that free parking is such a big deal for people. Is £5 for two and a half hours’ parking so very expensive really?

Ultimately, residents can’t have it both ways. You can’t have a charming and picturesque town centre that people want to spend time in (and Wigan, the subject of this thread, does have charming Victorian buildings) AND turn it into a massive free car park, with roads choked with traffic.

Somebody else complains that the nightlife in her local town has been killed off by the smoking ban. Great. Let’s reverse that then, shall we?

rumred · 25/05/2022 15:11

I live in a large city and I've watched it die over the 30 odd years I've lived here. So it's not just online shopping.
Where I am, Yorkshire its been a number of problems - poverty, high infant mortality and disabilities, an unintegrated population, poor leadership, national services (eg royla mail, hmrc etc) being moved to a neighbouring more affluent area, poor national reputation, poor transport links, a thriving criminal sector (leading to money laundering and shops that are 'fronts' only).... That's off the top of my head.
It's seriously depressing and not getting any better. I muse about moving to somewhere thriving but it's beautiful here and the people generally are lovely.
Commiserations @BlessedByTheShitFairy

Limmers14 · 25/05/2022 15:11

That’s so tough to see OP. My hometown was similar for 5-10 years but is now flourishing. I put it down to active citizens who run creative and arty events. For example, a group set up a covered street market in an unused old car garage. This attracted people into town, they spent money and then street food popped up, more cafes and shops opened around it etc. I think it requires a community organiser and sadly, in my experience, not a lot of places in England have people that are willing to do those things.

I disagree with the parking = more footfall. We need to move away from this thinking as it just continues car use for short journeys which is contributing to climate change. Where I live now, the Lib Dem council have invested heavily in bike lanes and bike storage which has increased the numbers cycling a lot

JudgeJ · 25/05/2022 15:09

Lolliepoppie · 25/05/2022 14:05

Out of town shopping centres.

That’s it. You can park for free and close to the door. Huge buildings with economies of scale and lots of choice in 1 place.

Town centres just can’t compete, with the burden of high business rates, high rents, expensive and limited parking.

Where I live councils have reacted by…putting up parking charges in town centres 🙊.

I'm old enough to be surprised that people are surprised, I recall 30+ years ago when out of town retail parks were starting up discussing exactly this scenario, town centres were dying long before Covid, that's just made it worse. People complain about banks, libraries, post offices etc closing but looking at the footfall these places are very underused, so they close. Online shopping has added to this problem too, we don't even need to go to the post office to return stuff.

Dixiechickonhols · 25/05/2022 15:08

I’m an hour from Manchester or Trafford centre and like many if I’m going shopping or teen is you want plenty of shops so it makes sense to go somewhere with plenty of choice not a local town.
Small town near me seems to do ok as a market town with boutique style shops, cafes etc.
Parking is a major issue. I go to hairdresser in a nearby deprived town, there a while as I have colour. Parking is free but you display a disk. Wardens aggressively patrol I wouldn’t risk going over 2 hour limit. So instead of going into shops after I rush off - eg last time I drove to b & q as I can’t stop in Wilkinson to pick up what I needed as my time is up. Madness.

j712adrian · 25/05/2022 15:06

There is a 20-mile wide corridor going East from Preston to Leeds which was devastated in the 1980s by a combination of loss of jobs and dignity and out of town shopping centres. Sadly any progress during that time was funded by the EU and has been rubbed out by COVID - but the truth is that there never was any complete recovery during that period. The same could be said of North Wales (loss of tourism) and South Yorkshire/North Derbyshire and urban parts of Cumbria - closure of mines.

I can't believe that people would still believe that this was unusual in some way - it's been a fact of life for almost 50 years now. Whole swaithes of Britain are in permanent decline, and the up and coming kids from those areas move away as soon as they have the chance.

Allthegoodnamesarechosen · 25/05/2022 15:04

It is not just an English phenomenon. Over the decades we lived in France, we saw exactly the same thing happen. Our local town( which was also a tourist magnet) was the centre of the commune, so it had all the local and provincial offices. even that couldn’t save it. When we first went there you could buy literally anything except large machinery in the town. Shoe shops, clothes shops, wool shop, sewing machine shop and repair, wedding list shops, pharmacy, opticians, obviously bakers, butchers, bookshop…..Over time all the useful shops closed and were replaced with estate agents, the banks and insurance agents hung on but often with reduced nous and staff. The many small bars and restaurants have been replaced with much more expensive restaurants which cater for tourists and are closed October to Easter.

The same thing happened in the bigger town twenty miles away, they had more chain stores, even a small department store….all gone. Many of the People drive to the big supermarket to shop.

so it isn’t Brexit!

MindatWork · 25/05/2022 15:03

It's a shame OP - I live in a market town in South East and it's going the same way. Still lots of restaurants and a couple of live music venues, but the town used to have a thriving night-time economy that has all but died out (the change in licensing laws and the smoking ban saw to that, though).

I try and go into town to support local businesses but the last two trips to my local town centre have been a nightmare - no benches in the shopping centre (removed because of covid), £5 for 2.5 hours parking and so many empty units I spent 45 mins walking between the shops I needed to go to. Most of the clothes shops I visited barely had any stock (I was told they could order it in or I could order online at home) and 3 major stores have moved over to 100% self service tills so I was struggling to remove security tags while stopping my 3 year-old from running off...

It just wasn't a pleasant experience. Compare that to our local large retail park where you can park for free, visit multiple flagship stores with everything in stock (or you can check stock before you visit), grab a coffee and do a food shop all in one place.

We're also finding that we're able to get much of what we need from our local supermarkets; Morrisons, Tesco and Sainsburys near us are stocking more and more clothes/homeware/books/toys/plants, meaning that you don't always have to go into town if you need a birthday present or something for the house. Two Sainsburys stores near us also do click and collect Argos (often available same day or next day), so we use that a lot as well.

Our council are notoriously bad though, and have been for decades. There have been half hearted attempts at farmers markets throughout the years and they're laughable...

BobbinHood · 25/05/2022 15:02

nearlyspringyay · 25/05/2022 14:24

If it is Sunderland they have received c£20m in the first round of levelling up, they have chosen to spend over half on two relatively small housing developments, the rest is going on an education facility.

It’s not Sunderland.

That’s also not how the Levelling Up Fund money works - they had to bid for it for specific projects. Those are the projects they were awarded funding for. They weren’t just “given” £20m and allowed to choose what to do with it.

ShandaLear · 25/05/2022 15:01

icecreamcart · 25/05/2022 13:44

Things have got harder for shops. It hasn't impacted those at the council that are paid a wage regardless. They'll wake up next year and wonder 💔 really sad.

Council staff numbers have reduced by over a 1/3 since 2010 and many are barely hanging on thanks to the swinging cuts over the last 2 years. They’ve had to cut back on things like community safely, town centre management, refuse collection, adult and childrens services, etc. There is not a single department in the uk that isn’t stretched to its absolute limit. I’m

MercurialMonday · 25/05/2022 15:00

Redburnett · 25/05/2022 14:44

It's a vicious circle. Being retired and with time to do it, I quite often go round the shops in my North West 'city' (really just a town) looking for specific items, and cannot find them. So I resort to the internet. Then the next time I want that item I buy from the internet, and so on.

Yes - this is very true but also shopping is less an event it's around cinerma trips or tourist stuff for us and our wider family.

In our city center a lot of the look around places - things like tiger - have gone as has the cinerma - it was hard to find somewhere to eat that wanted to serve our group last few visits.

So next shopping trip we tried nearby town - more choice in shop cinemra is there and could easily grab food. It does cost us in transport but it was more of a day out.

Overthewine · 25/05/2022 14:58

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the poster's request.

Iamthewombat · 25/05/2022 14:58

The OP is correct about the population of the metropolitan borough, which as well as Wigan includes Hindley, Leigh etc.

I just looked online and there is a Wigan regeneration plan. Distilled down, it includes more housing development (especially affordable housing) near the centre to draw in younger people and families, plus splitting the town centre into linked ‘quarters’ (eg developing a heritage quarter near the pier, making it easy to get from there to other areas, relocating the market to a more central area).

I really hope it works. I grew up in greater Manchester and we’d often go to Wigan for shopping for a bit of a change (late 1980s) because it had a good range of chains and independents.

The other opportunity, I suppose, is as a commuter town for Manchester with enough local services to make it an appealing place to live for working people. The regeneration plan specifically refers to an ageing population. People in their 70s are probably not going to keep a town centre thriving. If they are anything like my value-seeking older relatives, anyway!

reggyreggymusic · 25/05/2022 14:58

You should see Northampton town centre...it's now an absolute shit hole

Badbadbunny · 25/05/2022 14:56

Unfortunately, it's classic evolution of "retail" over the past 70 years.

Go back to post war years and retail was dominated by huge numbers of small independent shops, on street corners, on small precincts, in villages, etc. Towns and cities would have multiple shopping areas, and then there'd be the High Street where you'd find the larger shops (still mostly independent) and a few chain stores.

In the 60s and 70s lots of towns and cities redeveloped their town centres to attract the new breed of "identikat" chain stores, which basically turned most High Streets into copies of eachother. This was triggered by "industry" moving out of town centres, i.e. warehouses, factories, print works, breweries, etc., not to mention low quality housing for workers in those "works". Go back to the 60s and 70s and town centres really weren't dominated by retail in the same way they were in the 80s and 90s so High Streets dominated by retail was very short lived!

By the later 70s and early 80s we started to get the big supermarkets taking over not only the grocery side of retail, but also muscling in on clothing and homeware.

As early as the 90s, the large chain stores started to close down their High Street stores and moved into the out of town retail parks.

In the last decade or so, we've seen a movement to online, but lots of High Streets were already dead before the rise of the internet due to huge supermarkets and out of town retail (with free parking) compared to the High Street where councils continued to drive up car parking charges, etc.

What's the next stage? Well actually, I think we'll see a partial return back to "in person" shopping. We're already seeing it as more and more convenience stores open up. I just don't think we'll ever see a return to dominance of High Street retail because it was actually a very short term thing. Probably more likely retail parks surviving along with larger "showroom" type of shops for homeware, furniture, etc - i.e. things that are hard to buy online if you can't physically see them.

Peonyperfect · 25/05/2022 14:56

Our North Yorkshire town has survived but with some closures - Debenhams, Jaeger, Monsoon, Jamie Oliver's Italian restaurant, the Slug and Lettuce, amongst others.

There is town centre parking and the town is usually quite busy, as its a tourist destination.

The problem of decaying town centres is a mixture of things.

Vast and increasing demand for online services, whether that's for goods or food.

Decreasing bus services.

Unrealistically high town city rents.

Closure of some post offices.

It's all very sad, but times have changed and city centres need to adapt.

nearlyspringyay · 25/05/2022 14:54

BlessedByTheShitFairy · 25/05/2022 14:35

You are correct. It was never a centre of high culture but I'm at a loss. It was so bloody active at one time. I hated it when young (wanted city life!) and got out after uni, but going back is upsetting. A lot of surrounding towns are similar.

I have this fear that these areas will end up devoid of anything but one large box store per town, with no infrastructure or way out for many. But then ive seen too many miserable sci-fi's..

Where did it all go? I swear to god the people there would love a functioning market, a food shop in the town centre (you cant even grab a carton of milk) and some decent places to eat and chat. Some of my family members used to go several times a week to get tea and scones at M&S. It's all been moved out to retail parks.

You've answered your own problem, it wasn't working when you lived there, you wanted to get out. Most of your generation probably felt the same, so now there is no one there to spend money, jobs have gone and it's the inevitable decline.

SecretVictoria · 25/05/2022 14:53

I knew it was Wigan. I had to move back here after redundancy a few years ago. There is nothing here now. It makes me so angry that there are pretty much zero opportunities for young people (or anyone) and that my 10yo DN will have significantly worse prospects than my friends DD (they live in an affluent village about 50 miles from London).

If I need to go shopping I go to the Trafford Centre, more shops, better choice, more options for food and free parking. There are no decent jobs here, there used to be, I know people who had them. If I had the money I’d move, I feel trapped here now.

Motherofcats007 · 25/05/2022 14:51

It’s not the councils fault, it’s market forces. Councils these days hardly have any landholding in town centres, there’s only so much grant they can give out (and then get accused of ‘giving brown envelopes to businesses) or business rates relief you can give out. Councils are on a stretched budget and there’s not a lot they can do really

People are online shopping these days so retail environment is difficult, banks are closing because they no longer get as many customers. As some previous posters mentioned, the out of town retail popular in the 90s is not helping the situation either.

RedHorsesAreDangerous · 25/05/2022 14:50

I'm guessing this is probably a non-Tory voting council. Central government has systematically starved such councils of cash over the last 12 years but many local people don't understand that and just blame the council for the cuts?

For a town of 370K people to not have ANY restaurants left is extraordinary, though, even after austerity, COVID-19, and the current supply issues. I got a shock when I went back to my old home town at the start of December as to how much had changed but there were still restaurants and chain stores open. Is this just in the city centre or the entire town?

Bramshott · 25/05/2022 14:49

It's sad. I guess we need to try to get beyond thinking of going "into town" meaning shopping, now that we can buy so much online, and go into towns for cultural activities, socialising, sports etc. And councils need to be way more flexible over business rates and parking charges, recognising that the whole landscape has changed. It's going to be a tough transition to be sure but maybe town centres will come out of it stronger and more vibrant in the long run??

TheHatinaCat · 25/05/2022 14:48

I can think of a town like this down South. Working class area but decent shopping centre with the favourites; M&S, Boots, Woolworths, Debenhams, Clarks, WH Smith, etc. We'd get the bus into town on a Saturday or in the holidays.

I stopped going there about twelve years ago as it had started to feel very different. Lots of the big shops had gone and there were big gangs of young men hanging around. The last two times I went I had a very uneasy feeling and kept checking my cross body bag. It's always been an ethnically diverse place but there had been a big influx of new people. No one seemed to be speaking English at all. It felt very odd. I dread to think what it is like now.

SweatyChamoisPad · 25/05/2022 14:48

It's happening to a lot of towns in Greater Manchester. I live between both Rochdale and Oldham and my God, they are shells of what they used to be.

With Rochdale, I think the local council is massively to blame - I know someone fairly high up there who says that he's never seen such infighting between councillors, and he's moved around between councils north and south a fair bit. Rochdale has a charter and has had a market for 1000 years, but I don't think it has any longer - just a couple of stalls in the Butts.
With Oldham - hmm, used to have a great market. Travelling to it doesn't help - it's impossible to drive around, and if you aren't on the metrolink line it's not the easiest to get to. I'm three miles away and I get two buses an hour to Oldham. it's not the easiest place to walk or cycle to either, due to the impassible ringroad. I've got on to get to Oldham before and been spat out almost in Tameside.
The tram could also be partially to blame for our local towns. People tout it as bringing people in to the outer boroughs of GM, but it just takes people away. Locals shop, work and socialise in Manchester mainly. Bury seems to have got it right - it's not perfect but it's decent enough if you don't want to go into Manchester. When I think how vibrant Oldham, Rochdale, Bury, Burnley, Ashton etc used to be, I can't understand how this has been allowed to happen.