Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

watching a town completely die

433 replies

BlessedByTheShitFairy · 25/05/2022 13:37

This is so sad really, the town where I grew up. I know many business folded during covid and many high street staples have been closing for years, but this is different.

It's a large town, over 400K population, had a bustling, varied and thriving centre for most it's history, has now lost, and many before covid:

Debs, Next, M&S, Topshop, H&M, Body Shop, its central post office, game shops, cafes, most youth related places such as skating, bowling, carts, ALL restaurants (no exaggeration), health food stores, 2 shopping centres, most pubs, it's huge market, several banks, nightclubs, a town centre co-op, Spar, book shops, many charity shops and all of it's high end hair salons. Even the Starbucks slid off and the main post office was reduced from around 10 staff to 1 and shoved into a tiny toilet sized cubicle on the periphery of the borough.

These have been survived and replaced by - pop up eyebrow/lashes salons, fast food joints, poundshops, phone-unlocking shops, cash converter type shops, Primark (it's only remaining clothes store), Iceland, and the rest if boarded up. Interestingly a ton of privately owned car parks have taken over the area and hardly anyone uses them. It is unrecognisable from even 7 years ago. It now only attracts crime, heavy drinking, and a much less diverse population.

I know many towns have experienced closures of big brands, and things are simply changing (the net, everything online, etc) but this is really extreme, especially in comparison to a few years ago, it was not particularly suffering a decline. I do know that the council slowly sold off everything over the years, and have sent 2 huge shopping centres to their doom by selling to overseas investors who never came and filled them, so they are like enormous empty spaces that attract crime.

I don't currently live there but my remaining family that do say they never go in to town anymore, and feel forced to buy everything from standalone supermarkets in other areas.
I live in a fairly average town that has seen changes but there are also attempts at rejuvenation. Things are still ok and thriving in the centre. I am also aware that many towns are coping ok, taking the rough with the smooth, even though these issues have increased across the uk over all.

What could have happened to this one? Why so desolate and different? It is like the council just gave up sold it off and turned away. It never used to suffer so much crime, and the sound of police and ambulances is constant around the area now. The town centre was it's pride and joy, had so much put into it (festivals, events), so I can't understand how it got so bad.
Even the people who you see there now are all strangely similar (dress the same, same behaviours) and the diversity has vanished. Curiously rents are still super high and I have no idea who is taking them, if at all.

I feel sad about it because I grew up there, and have so many good memories of my teens when it was thriving, packed and full of interesting places to go and shop. The pubs were visited from far and wide, and it had a great college, access to learning, and much more culture. Now it is lucky to hold on to a handful of football clubs and that's the only interest left. Where and why did everything just die? It was previously so bloody alive.

OP posts:
ssd · 25/05/2022 17:47

I hate to read this. I haven't been to England for years but last time we were in Hexham and it was bustling and lovely. And ive always thought of Harrogate as very genteel and lovely to visit. Its awful how its going.

Doomgloom123 · 25/05/2022 17:47

And just to add many shops,such as BHS ,have closed down not because of them failing on the high street,
they have closed because some private investment group has taken over,sucked them dry,restructured debts and left them unable to service their liabilities such as pensions

Lolabalola · 25/05/2022 17:45

Our small local town is also in massive decline, but totally the councils fault.
They sold off the shopping centre area and existing land to a developer. The plan was for them to demolish the library and a in town supermarket and a theatre and cafe and rebuild a new shiny shopping centre with restaurants and a bowling alley, new library and theatre complex.
So they kicked out all the traders in the indoor market with just a few weeks notice, they had been really busy, butchers, barbers, sweet shops and a cafe that was always full and a central point for the elder town folk, put in an Argos instead. That closed down about four years ago so now that's all empty.
Demolished everything and have rebuilt....nothing. Area looks like a bomb site fenced off with heras panels. Library moved to a temporary site that has now become permanent. No theatre. Loads of shops moved out as once market was booted out and supermarket left, area became a desert. Now full of temporary shops or ridiculous pretend shops with stickers in the windows.
It's an absolute travesty. They are blaming Covid now obviously but this all started years before and anyone with half a brain could see they were never going to rebuild anything

DoubleCarbs4Life · 25/05/2022 17:43

Haven’t read the entire thread, but that sounds really sad, OP.

I live in a London suburb and our local high street has really changed over the last few years. It’s not decimated like you describe, but it’s wall to wall fast food outlets and cafes and lined with Uber Eats / Deliveroo etc bikes & motorbikes. It feels like the only way people can make money from the high street here is through food deliveries.

In my case, I think it is 100% to do with people shopping online. We’ve always had shit parking in London (well, for decades), so it’s not that.

Echosound · 25/05/2022 17:41

Whilst yes, rents are high etc I believe this is entirely down to us shopping online and in big retail parks. That’s the whole reason IMO. Imagine if Amazon or Asos didn’t exist, or the Trafford centre. Woolworths would likely still be on the high street. As would all manner of shops. This directly comes from online shopping.

Doomgloom123 · 25/05/2022 17:38

The sad thing is this is all over the world.ive moved back to the UK recently and was shocked at the difference between different cities. Some are zombie towns where as others are thriving. And this is not a case of north south divide. Its scattered across the country.

Were I lived before in America they had the exact same problem.

The demise of the high streets is a symptom of greater issues.

What's hard to face is the good times are over for the human population.

Those in their 60s and 70s have had the best of it. We are paying for it financially and environmentally.

City centres that are thriving are mixed use,ie a mix of shops,residential,leisure facilities and green space. The local area also has a large retired middle class population who have free time and money to go into town. These are the people with the most disposable incomes. They are also the people with the most free time to support civic societies and complain about anti social behaviour and volunteer for the community.

Covid accelerate what was going to happen anyway,and all governments have fucked things up,just in different ways.

The labour party introduced PFIs which have crippled organisations,and it's all about to get much worse as they are ending around now.

The conservative party have fucked us over allowing businesses to get away with tax dodge structures so we have not been able to invest this back into society.

I am thankful everyday that I live in a town centre that happens to be thriving. I feel so sorry for those who are not as things are only going to get worse.

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 25/05/2022 17:37

OP - I had a look on google maps/tripadvisor - there do seem to be restaurants listed in Wigan centre with recent reviews?

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 25/05/2022 17:36

Iamthewombat · 25/05/2022 15:12

I’m surprised that free parking is such a big deal for people. Is £5 for two and a half hours’ parking so very expensive really?

Ultimately, residents can’t have it both ways. You can’t have a charming and picturesque town centre that people want to spend time in (and Wigan, the subject of this thread, does have charming Victorian buildings) AND turn it into a massive free car park, with roads choked with traffic.

Somebody else complains that the nightlife in her local town has been killed off by the smoking ban. Great. Let’s reverse that then, shall we?

I was happy when they introduced parking charges in our nearest market town (this is a while ago) - the huge car park was always chock-full but after they started charging I could actually get a space. Some people do seem weird about paying to park their car though - my step Dad would drive for miles to find a free space to park, then walk miles rather than pay a couple of quid.

BelleTheBananas · 25/05/2022 17:36

OP, someone started a thread on here a few months ago about Wigan. She had similar complaints to you, but I think she was also upset at the lack of opportunities and ensuing lack of aspiration amongst residents.

From memory, it’s halfway between Liverpool and Manchester, both of which are a bigger draw than lots of North West towns. I assume what’s happened is that the more aspirational kids have left to go to uni/to a job in the city and left Wigan behind. My home city (near Wales) is similar.

StuckonanLNERtrain · 25/05/2022 17:35

Shortbread49 · 25/05/2022 17:32

Yes York it’s awful on a Saturday I avoid it although must admit didn’t realise Harrogate was the same . Don’t want my children encountering blow up dolls in the middle of a Saturday afternoon !

I used to go to York and be horrified when my children were little. I remember a woman stopping in front of my daughter in the street and weeing all over her feet (hers and my DDs)
Harrogate is now the same.

DressingPafe · 25/05/2022 17:35

I've been to Japan a couple of times and travelled round a bit. I thought about this a lot when I was there as their town/city centres are absolutely thriving. They have just as much access to online shopping as us so I wondered why this was.

Fact is, shopping there is a joy. You can get all manner of things, things you didn't know existed or didn't know you needed! So many lovely cafes to stop and have a coffee/lunch. Customer service is off the scale good. If I was there and wanted to buy someone a present I'd have so much choice. Here I resort to Amazon! I never now go shopping in this country for "pleasure".

Sadly I think it's too late to change things here. I don't see any answers.

Overthewine · 25/05/2022 17:35

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the poster's request.

lightisnotwhite · 25/05/2022 17:35

nearlyspringyay · 25/05/2022 14:15

Out of town retail and the internet. I work in this field and it's not just your town.

WFH has also killed many businesses. The rates situation hasn't helped.

A lot of towns are now looking at converting to resi with the help of levelling up funding but that hasn't been fairly awarded.

The traditional high street won't recover.

I don't get your point about male centric, that's supply and demand.

It’s not supply and demand. Plenty of queues in both banks and post office but they are closing anyway.
How can you have demand if there’s no supply?

Interesting point about it catering to male hobbies.We have lots of independent boutique shops for the well off SAHM/WFH mums. We have gyms but they are out of town and several are boot camp type places for women near parks and the rugby grounds. A few barbers but no muscle gyms or I cheap booze places etc although we obviously have men and poor men at that.

StuckonanLNERtrain · 25/05/2022 17:34

Iamthewombat · 25/05/2022 17:30

You described Harrogate as ‘bleak’. It is clearly not bleak. Why would you refuse to visit your local town, five minutes’ walk away, because you “can’t buy a towel or a suitcase”? Feels rather like cutting off your nose to spite your face. You can buy those things in Leeds if you can’t find them in Harrogate. Can a town only meet your standards if it sells everything you could possibly need? And if it fails to supply one thing, despite a range of lovely shops and cafes, is it ‘bleak’? Don’t be silly.

Seeing people urinating everywhere is bleak. Lying on the floor in their own vomit

The drugs are very bad at the moment - had to call an ambulance a few times when out walking the dog recently. Just because people are passed out in front of Waitrose rather than a boarded up shop doesn't mean that issues are not there.

It s very naive to think that green towns do not have issues.

Towns die when locals give up on them. Locals are in despair about Harrogate at the moment - as are businesses.

ParsleyRosemarySage · 25/05/2022 17:32

Faddy policy, not daddy!

Shortbread49 · 25/05/2022 17:32

Yes York it’s awful on a Saturday I avoid it although must admit didn’t realise Harrogate was the same . Don’t want my children encountering blow up dolls in the middle of a Saturday afternoon !

ParsleyRosemarySage · 25/05/2022 17:31

I’ll go back and read all the thread in a mo.

This has been happening all over the county for years, and yes it long pre dates Covid. High rates are a large part of it. People blame the Councils, which is correct sometimes: we all need to remember, and tell the world of need be, that those rises are mandated by central government.

I was working for a council in the early 00s when we were told - by a Labour government, thank you very much - that any and all income streams HAD to be maximised, simply because that was the daddy policy at the time; any who remember New Labour will remember that it was all about the worst combinations of private market ethics in the public sector, forcing public sector services to become money making institutions to any extent that they could. Even the libraries were told to maximise fines. These were deliberate policies chosen by central government and they made a mockery of everything the public sector was supposed to be and do.

Another reason for the death of the High Street is the rise of rents. We all know about the housing market and how unaffordable it is: few seem to recognise how badly that is also impacting on businesses, especially small and medium businesses. It has killed markets as well as shops.

Of course the internet is a third reason, but internet businesses are more successful precisely because they do not need to offset costs incurred.

This is an important topic, because it is killing our economy, and “the economy” is not just a phrase for statisticians and politicians to score points off. It’s how each and every one of us makes a living: it governs how we survive from day to day. Sorry this is long, it’s a topic that’s been annoying me for years because we are all being impoverished, dangerously so now, and that will result in increasing conflicts in times to come, just for a central politician’s fads and point scores. <and breathe> <and go back to read>

CurbsideProphet · 25/05/2022 17:31

I'm sorry if this has already been said but there are restaurants left in Wigan and The Old Courts is being transformed by a community group, but definitely agree the town centre is devoid of any life. Hopefully the council plans for the new market / cinema etc are successful. We're only 30 mins away but never go.

StuckonanLNERtrain · 25/05/2022 17:30

Iamthewombat · 25/05/2022 17:26

Airbnb kills communities.

I don’t think that Airbnb is the root of the problems experienced by Wigan, Bolton and other towns on the M62/M61/M66 corridors!

Different things kill different communities.

Iamthewombat · 25/05/2022 17:30

StuckonanLNERtrain · 25/05/2022 17:25

Says someone who doesnt live there and clearly doesnt know it well

What good is luxury bed shops and dress shop when you cant buy a towel? or a suitcase?

Towns die when there is no pull for locals. Harrogate has nothing that would make you go in at the moment.

But hey Oliver Bonas and another overpriced cake shop have just been approved.

You cant live on cake, art and beds!

You described Harrogate as ‘bleak’. It is clearly not bleak. Why would you refuse to visit your local town, five minutes’ walk away, because you “can’t buy a towel or a suitcase”? Feels rather like cutting off your nose to spite your face. You can buy those things in Leeds if you can’t find them in Harrogate. Can a town only meet your standards if it sells everything you could possibly need? And if it fails to supply one thing, despite a range of lovely shops and cafes, is it ‘bleak’? Don’t be silly.

StuckonanLNERtrain · 25/05/2022 17:29

My DDs friend is 26 and had a lowish paid service type job (most of Harrogate is service type jobs)

She rented a run down flat in town for £600 a month. Landlord out rent up to £800 last year. Now wants £1300 as that is what he will make on airbnb

Airbn and so that pisseed up hen dos ca come an urinate and vomit in the streets. You cant go into town after 4pm on Saturday without seeing the knickers of a Middle Aged woman around her ankles.

GonnaGetGoingReturns · 25/05/2022 17:26

Surely this applies to lots of town/city centres? I wonder why councils are just letting them all die off?

Iamthewombat · 25/05/2022 17:26

Airbnb kills communities.

I don’t think that Airbnb is the root of the problems experienced by Wigan, Bolton and other towns on the M62/M61/M66 corridors!

StuckonanLNERtrain · 25/05/2022 17:25

Iamthewombat · 25/05/2022 17:21

Come off it! Harrogate is as un-bleak as any town in Britain. Not many ‘bleak’ towns have a branch of Feather and Black, the most expensive cafe in Christendom (Bettys) and a Waitrose, do they?

(I don’t live in Harrogate but I know the town well).

Says someone who doesnt live there and clearly doesnt know it well

What good is luxury bed shops and dress shop when you cant buy a towel? or a suitcase?

Towns die when there is no pull for locals. Harrogate has nothing that would make you go in at the moment.

But hey Oliver Bonas and another overpriced cake shop have just been approved.

You cant live on cake, art and beds!

pixie5121 · 25/05/2022 17:23

This reply has been withdrawn

Withdrawn at poster's request.