Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this school mum is off?

132 replies

propernot · 25/05/2022 11:50

DS starts reception in Sept. Via a Facebook group I am on I was invited to join a whatsapp group for parents when children starting that school in September.
The mum 'X' who started the group already has 2 children at the school and her third is starting in reception. To my knowledge, she chose to start the group of her free will, presumably because she wanted to, and wasn't forced to do so.

The title of the group is 'school name intake 2022'. But its becoming really obvious that X actually only wanted this to be for school mums. When people said 'can I add my husband/partner' they were told 'not yet due to security reasons', and after a couple of weeks she finally relented and let dads join. X has a notes document which she updates and shares on a regality basis as new people join the group, which has the names of the children and their mum next to them. X says she is too busy to put the dads name on the document as well.

Dads are getting arsey now making passive aggressive comments about 'the March to parental equality' and some are raising that they are SAHD who do all the drop off and pick ups, so if there can only be one named parent on this group then it should be them...

AIBU to say that X is going around this wrong and feel sorry for the dads who are basically being sidelined? And to say that if X is finding the group too onerous to run she can stop?

OP posts:
saraclara · 25/05/2022 14:51

Personally I'd find it deeply unattractive if my husband expected me to pick up all the school admin simply because I'm a woman rather than challenging his right to have the same access to information I do.

Likewise.

Nahnanananahna · 25/05/2022 14:47

Johnnysgirl · 25/05/2022 14:06

What 51328gap said.

Frankly, if my dh was pouting that "his role as a parent had been minimised" because he wasn't included in some random biddy's WhatsApp group, I'd find it deeply, deeply, unattractive.
But that's just me.

Horses for courses. Personally I'd find it deeply unattractive if my husband expected me to pick up all the school admin simply because I'm a woman rather than challenging his right to have the same access to information I do.

XelaM · 25/05/2022 14:43

mistermagpie · 25/05/2022 13:54

Same. Our school WhatsApp groups are friendly and useful. Maybe we're all scatterbrained or the school is crap or whatever, but it's also a hell of a lot quicker to ask the WhatsApp group if it's non uniform day, than try to get hold of someone at the school. It was also really helpful during homeschooling when people were confused about some of the lessons and teachers were even harder to get in contact with.

These monsters at the school gates are something I only ever here about on here or see on tv.

Yep, totally my experience as well. I have never had an issue with another school parent and equally have never heard of any parent I know have an issue with any of the parents. We all chat politely if we ever meet at school gates/parties and then go home. No issues.

The WhatsApp group is just about reminders of what's happening in the school and like you said, any last minute questions by disorganised parents like me.

KettrickenSmiled · 25/05/2022 14:34

AIBU to say that X is going around this wrong and feel sorry for the dads who are basically being sidelined? And to say that if X is finding the group too onerous to run she can stop?

YABU.
This isn't even a storm in a teacup, it is so insignificant you will look batshit if you jump in with suggestions, corrections, or side-taking.

I would leave this group - who need the aggro & partisanship? -
& either start one of my own, ONLY adding people to it who seem like they won't act like prima donnas - OR get one of the dads to start one, & join that.

saraclara · 25/05/2022 14:30

But it's the small scale stuff that builds and facilitates the large scale stuff @5128gap

This WhatsApp group issue is entirely unnecessary. It's pointless, it's stupid and it's exclusionary.
Just as we wouldn't allow children to exclude others on the playground, we shouldn't be finding excuses for parents to exclude each other, based on their sex.

It's so simple, we really shouldn't be arguing about it.

My late husband was a hands on, fully involved parent, and had our kids been in this year group, I'd have absolutely fought for all parents to be part of the group if they chose. So I don't understand the people on this thread who think it's fine for the fathers to be second class parents.

Clarinet1 · 25/05/2022 14:28

It seems that you can’t have it both ways - one minute a woman is saying her DP doesn’t do enough for the children, the next a woman is saying someone’s DP can’t have the information (eg through WhatsApp) to know something needs doing!

5128gap · 25/05/2022 14:23

saraclara · 25/05/2022 14:11

I'm not being protective of men at all @5128gap But I am fiercely against discrimination and exclusion in any of its forms. Whether against women or men, against people of other nationalities or races, whether it affects the mentally or physically disabled, those of whatever sexual orientation.or any other group.

It's been the focus of my life's paid work, and now of my volunteer work in retirement.
This is just one entirely unnecessary example of the exclusion of a group. In this case it's fathers, and I'll stand up for them just as I've spent my life advocating for women, for the disabled, and for refugees.

Equity of rights and access is vastly important to me, and I resent only belong pulled up on it on MN when I have the efrrontery to point out when men being disadvantaged.

I too am passionate about equality. But all inequality is not equal.
I've noticed a number of threads recently that have either been overtly highlighting some form of unequal treatment of men, or have been used as a vehicle to push the message that men are disadvantaged. While I'm not saying men never experience some form of unequal treatment, whenever they do it seems to get a disproportionate amount of attention. The sort of exclusion spoken of here happens to women constantly in different spheres of life. Men are unlucky to experience it even on occasion. Yet before we know if we're at a point where the narrative is both women and men experience inequality' which takes no account of the fact that the respective scale and impact of it on each are chasms apart.

saraclara · 25/05/2022 14:11

I'm not being protective of men at all @5128gap But I am fiercely against discrimination and exclusion in any of its forms. Whether against women or men, against people of other nationalities or races, whether it affects the mentally or physically disabled, those of whatever sexual orientation.or any other group.

It's been the focus of my life's paid work, and now of my volunteer work in retirement.
This is just one entirely unnecessary example of the exclusion of a group. In this case it's fathers, and I'll stand up for them just as I've spent my life advocating for women, for the disabled, and for refugees.

Equity of rights and access is vastly important to me, and I resent only belong pulled up on it on MN when I have the efrrontery to point out when men being disadvantaged.

Johnnysgirl · 25/05/2022 14:06

What 51328gap said.

Frankly, if my dh was pouting that "his role as a parent had been minimised" because he wasn't included in some random biddy's WhatsApp group, I'd find it deeply, deeply, unattractive.
But that's just me.

5128gap · 25/05/2022 14:00

saraclara · 25/05/2022 13:30

Or maybe men should be equal involved parents because they are autonomous adults, rather than sitting around waiting for women to provide them with the tools

They're not "sitting around waiting for women to provide them with the tools". But a tool information library has been created which they are not allowed to access. That's discrimination, and as a pp said, it disadvantages women too, as it means they have to be responsible for passing the information on to the dad (who is actually the one being the kids ready in the morning)

You said 'if you want men to be equal parents you should..' which, assuming by 'you', you mean women, places the responsibility on women for men being equal parents.
Given that men have somehow managed to achieve far more than equality in every other sphere of life, I'm not sure why they can't do so in parenting if they wish. The truth is, until comparatively recently few of them had any desire to be involved in this sort of domestic detail, and with some exceptions, I'd be very surprised if the majority did now.
The whole thing is beyond trivial, would have no significant impact on their parenting ability, and is just being blown up to support the idea that men are disadvantaged too you know, and its not their fault they can't be equal parents with all these man hating women leaving them out all the time. It's just so weak.
And I don't hate men at all. I just find this unecessarily protective attitude to them and their rights a bit cloying and tiresome.

mistermagpie · 25/05/2022 13:54

XelaM · 25/05/2022 13:13

I have been on several school whatsapp groups for two schools and there has never been any drama. No one cares which parent joins on behalf of the child. I don't know why Mumsnetters have all this drama with school parents. All the ones I have ever met were normal and polite and drama-free.

Same. Our school WhatsApp groups are friendly and useful. Maybe we're all scatterbrained or the school is crap or whatever, but it's also a hell of a lot quicker to ask the WhatsApp group if it's non uniform day, than try to get hold of someone at the school. It was also really helpful during homeschooling when people were confused about some of the lessons and teachers were even harder to get in contact with.

These monsters at the school gates are something I only ever here about on here or see on tv.

TinyTear · 25/05/2022 13:49

Parker231 · 25/05/2022 12:39

What benefits are there in having these groups? The school will give you the information you need to know? We managed without any groups - some parents have too much time on their hands.

why wouldn’t this mother realise fathers equally parent their children?

There are actually some good benefits.
My y5 child is on the spectrum and would not want to stand out when not needed and the fear of being different is there - they like to know when there are costume days or pyjama days what the other kids are wearing and if somoene talked about costumes and so on, so asking me about the group reassures them that they won't be the only one in pyjamas

we have a good mix of mums and dads in our groups, dads being also class reps in the school and it;s not just for spellings and lost jumpers but we have a good support network for example taking kids to school when a parent was isolating

saraclara · 25/05/2022 13:45

Johnnysgirl · 25/05/2022 13:36

What information would the Dad who gets the kids ready in the morning need from a WhatsApp group that he can't get from any other source? How is he disadvantaged in the mornings by non access?
Not agreeing that he should be barred, there's no reason he shouldn't be allowed to join if he wants to, but claiming this is a "tool information library" without which his day is made correspondingly harder is a bit silly!

Well presumably the mothers on it get helpful information and reminders from it. So if its helpful to them, then it would also be helpful to a hands on dad.

If parent WhatsApp groups are not helpful, then why do they exist? If they are helpful, then they're helpful whether you're a mother or a father. And excluding one of those parties from having that help is discriminatory.

RebeccaCloud9 · 25/05/2022 13:42

Why on earth is she making it so complicated? Just add anyone who wants to be added. I find ours v useful, mainly for event day reminders and sharing info. I'm in 2, and neither have been bitchy or cliquey - they're just polite and useful.

BellePeppa · 25/05/2022 13:38

orwellwasright · 25/05/2022 11:59

School WhatsApp groups are bitchy, cliquey cesspits. Why anyone would want to be in one is beyond me.

I was part of one and everyone was lovely and there was a dad. I quite miss not knowing what’s going on there now mine are no longer there.

hangrylady · 25/05/2022 13:37

I'd have no part in any of this. First of all why would you need a whole year WhatsApp group? Secondly the mum who's set it up is clearly a do-gooder who thinks she's very important and I wouldn't be fuelling her ego and finally, grown men being upset they're not on the group and getting arsey. How embarrassing for everyone concerned.

Johnnysgirl · 25/05/2022 13:36

saraclara · 25/05/2022 13:30

Or maybe men should be equal involved parents because they are autonomous adults, rather than sitting around waiting for women to provide them with the tools

They're not "sitting around waiting for women to provide them with the tools". But a tool information library has been created which they are not allowed to access. That's discrimination, and as a pp said, it disadvantages women too, as it means they have to be responsible for passing the information on to the dad (who is actually the one being the kids ready in the morning)

What information would the Dad who gets the kids ready in the morning need from a WhatsApp group that he can't get from any other source? How is he disadvantaged in the mornings by non access?
Not agreeing that he should be barred, there's no reason he shouldn't be allowed to join if he wants to, but claiming this is a "tool information library" without which his day is made correspondingly harder is a bit silly!

fluffycereal · 25/05/2022 13:33

Such drama. I wouldn't have joined in the first place but I'm struggling to see how people who did are still part of it.

saraclara · 25/05/2022 13:30

Or maybe men should be equal involved parents because they are autonomous adults, rather than sitting around waiting for women to provide them with the tools

They're not "sitting around waiting for women to provide them with the tools". But a tool information library has been created which they are not allowed to access. That's discrimination, and as a pp said, it disadvantages women too, as it means they have to be responsible for passing the information on to the dad (who is actually the one being the kids ready in the morning)

Johnnysgirl · 25/05/2022 13:29

saraclara · 25/05/2022 13:26

It really is no wonder that mumsnet has such a terrible reputation for being a man hating site.

Nobody hates men, give over.

AllThatFancyPaintsAsFair · 25/05/2022 13:29

JudgeRindersMinder · 25/05/2022 13:22

Totally agree with this. All you generally have in common with people at the school gate is that you gave birth in the same year.
I’m so glad these groups weren’t a thing when my kids were at that stage.

What has that got to do with anything? Presumably when you started school the only thing you had in common with your classmates was that you were born in the same school year. Did that stop you somehow making friends with them?

Can you only make friends with people you have no common link with? That must make things incredibly hard, where did you find your friends?

ChairCareOh · 25/05/2022 13:28

This reply has been deleted

Withdrawn at the user's request

OnlyFoolsnMothers · 25/05/2022 13:28

To defend WhatsApp groups- ours is pretty quiet, literally only posts about own clothes days, the odd bday party and dates from the school are mentioned- messages are short and concise. I feel very lucky!

saraclara · 25/05/2022 13:26

It really is no wonder that mumsnet has such a terrible reputation for being a man hating site.

5128gap · 25/05/2022 13:25

saraclara · 25/05/2022 13:07

If they want to be in the group they should just point out why it's necessary they're included

They did. As did some of their wives. But the point is that they shouldn't have to!

People on here are simultaneously saying that men are useless and don't do enough, and that they shouldn't complain about not having the tools to be involved with the school that women have.
If you want fathers to be involved with their kids schooling and getting then ready for school in the morning, then you treat them as equal parents. Otherwise you're deliberately setting them up to fail.

Or maybe men should be equal involved parents because they are autonomous adults, rather than sitting around waiting for women to provide them with the tools? Do you think they go into work and sit there passively waiting for someone to facilitate them doing their jobs? Allow themselves to be missed off communications and kept out of the loop, or take action themselves to make sure they're in the know? Yet somehow they can't break through the wall of women preventing them from being involved fathers. Sorry, I don't buy it for a moment.
They should be in the group undoubtedly, but this sort of thing is not the reason their contribution is unequal.