Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Nursery guilt

37 replies

pumpalump · 25/05/2022 10:21

Can someone help me deal with this please.. I'm sure there will be someone who'll have something helpful to say..

I have a one month old and a two and a half year old.

My two and a half year old started nursery at the beginning of the year and had a hard time settling. Eventually he was OK. Then had a few weeks off and now is struggling again at drop off.

I feel so incredibly guilty for sending him to nursery. But on days he's home, I find it so difficult to look after both children. I feel like I am failing him and sending him away. He's also been sick ( like they all are ) so many times, so I actually feel like I am sending him away and being careless about the fact he will probably get sick. Almost like I am being negligent.

Every day is the same. Just when I sit down to have a small rest while the baby is sleeping, I feel so guilty about my boy at nursery. I just can't shake the feeling I'm not doing a good job with him and neglecting him because I need to look after the baby.

I just can't shake the guilt towards my first born. Did anyone else feel this way ? Does it get better ?

I try to play with him etc while baby sleeps as much as possible etc. The nursery staff say he's really happy after a few minutes, but it breaks my heart every day. And generally my heart breaks every time he wants my attention and I can't give it to him the way I used to.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Mysisterlivesinbicester · 26/05/2022 09:57

OP, one thing to bear in mind is that millions of SAHMs have managed more than one baby/toddler at a time for God knows how long. Nursery is a relatively new thing. My choice was either have them at home, or send them to nursery, as there wasn't another adult there during the day and my family are hundreds of miles away. Nursery was never an option. But it honestly is easier to have them both at home all the time. You might need to lower your expectations in some respects - I prioritised getting us all out of the house, even if just to walk to the shops at toddler pace and back - over cleaning or cooking. Obviously I fed everyone, but the house was a bombsite for many, many years. I wasn't doing much very active at four weeks, but I did manage to get to playgroups, which are a very good place to sit and fail to drink more than one sip of tea whilst feeding your baby and talking to other parents (it was mostly mums, but with the occasional dad back in the day). Obviously our situation is a bit different in that you have worked as well and will presumably want to return to work - and you've had the really shitty end of the stick, having babies/small children during lockdown. I am not sure how I would have coped with lockdown at that stage. Not very well, I think.

pumpalump · 26/05/2022 01:45

MissyB1 · 25/05/2022 22:53

Five days a week? And he’s struggling? I’m not surprised, sounds like it’s too much for him. I’m sure you could cope with him at home for a couple of days.

Well he was going 5 days a week, before the baby came along. Since the baby has come, he's not actually been 5 days a week yet. He's only been back two weeks and both weeks, I only sent him 3 days maximum for now.

But 5 days was/ is his usual. Not that he did many full weeks, as he was always sick for some of the week and at home anyway. So no, he's not been going 5 days since the baby, but is still struggling anyway.

OP posts:
Stompythedinosaur · 25/05/2022 23:05

One of the secrets of maternity leave is that it is hugely much easier for two parents to care for four dc and it is for two seperate parents to care for two each. Get along to a toddler group with both dc to make friends if you can.

Nursery is a perfectly caring environment for your dc, but I admit I'm surprised he is going fulltime. Is there more of a balance you can strike?

It is easier to manage two dc if you have a good sling for the baby.

MissyB1 · 25/05/2022 22:53

Five days a week? And he’s struggling? I’m not surprised, sounds like it’s too much for him. I’m sure you could cope with him at home for a couple of days.

HappyMeal564 · 25/05/2022 21:56

I say this nicely, if you feel that guilty just dont send him if you're home, or pick him up early or whatever suits. The more you're with them both the easier is is to juggle them. You'll get there eventually!

pumpalump · 25/05/2022 21:54

QueenoftheNimbleFlyingCat · 25/05/2022 21:49

OP, this is classic second child guilt. I had it with my DC1 when my younger DC was born, she was only 18 months so it felt really awful but I desperately needed the break. Your son will be fine, the guilt will ease and you need to rest too.

I think it's hit me so hard !

I'm the second born and never had to deal with a younger sibling. But my brother really struggled. It's still a thing to this day. He's not over it. Maybe that's why the guilt is even worse for me. I've felt guilt for having taken my brother's shine my whole life. My parents did not manage it well..

In any case, I am really really really trying to manage it well. But the tantrums and clinginess have definitely got worse since number 2 has come along... which makes me feel so terrible.

OP posts:
QueenoftheNimbleFlyingCat · 25/05/2022 21:49

OP, this is classic second child guilt. I had it with my DC1 when my younger DC was born, she was only 18 months so it felt really awful but I desperately needed the break. Your son will be fine, the guilt will ease and you need to rest too.

MissChanandlerBong80 · 25/05/2022 21:47

Your baby is only four weeks- it’s hardly surprising you’re exhausted! I wouldn’t have contemplated looking after them both solo at that stage - I was still healing from giving birth for a start.

Give it another couple of months - perhaps to the end of the ‘fourth trimester’ then re-evaluate and consider dropping his hours. I found it so much easier with two from when my youngest was about three months.

Mally100 · 25/05/2022 21:43

What makes you feel guilty op? I don't think you should, he's 2 so at a good age to start socializing with other children and he is probably having alot of fun as well. I put my ds into nursery at 18m, 5 days a week for 5 hours a day - and a sahm! I didn't feel guilty. There was only so much I could do with ds, and he Was a very highly attached baby. I did it for my sanity. He would be there from 7.30-12.30 and we still had the entire day to ourselves, but those 5 hours really helped me cope. Your ds will be absolutely fine. Our nursery didn't allow pt / fewer days a week as it was so unsettling for the kids. Your ds is still settling in after having a few breaks. Give it some time, he will be ok.

pumpalump · 25/05/2022 21:42

Mysisterlivesinbicester · 25/05/2022 21:23

OP, if nursery is your decision, you have to try to ditch the guilt and view it as a positive thing.

Your DS presumably doesn't need to go to nursery if you're at home with a very small baby. You could have him at home - but you have chosen not to. For that reason alone, you need to chuck your guilt in the fuck-it bucket. You can't send a child to nursery when he doesn't need to be there, and then feel guilty. Either you think it's a positive thing for him (which is, I hope, the case if you're sending him), or you don't (in which case, don't send him).

Are you sending him to nursery partly because you find it difficult looking after them both at home? If so, I can tell you that - bizarrely - the more you do it, the easier it is. If you are at home with small children all the time, you soon find ways to cope with them. I think it's far harder when you're not with them all day, every day. It's a long time since my children were little, but I took them to toddler groups, playgroup, the library, park, soft play, local shops etc, etc when they were that age. The thing that made a big difference to me was being around other adults for part of the day - there was always someone at playgroup whose children were being even more revolting than mine. You can make great friendships that way.

Yeah so I started sending him because I was working. I had a nanny from when I went back to work ( when he was 8 months ) and then sent him to nursery when he was 2. So I've kept it the same.

Are you sending him to nursery partly because you find it difficult looking after them both at home? If so, I can tell you that - bizarrely - the more you do it, the easier it is. If you are at home with small children all the time, you soon find ways to cope with them. I think it's far harder when you're not with them all day, every day. It's a long time since my children were little, but I took them to toddler groups, playgroup, the library, park, soft play, local shops etc, etc when they were that age. The thing that made a big difference to me was being around other adults for part of the day - there was always someone at playgroup whose children were being even more revolting than mine. You can make great friendships that way.

This resonates with me. Newborn is only 4 weeks old. So I've only had a few days alone with both of them and found it extremely difficult. All those things you mention, library, groups etc, I can't imagine having the energy to do those at the moment. I can barely get myself out of the house for the nursery run. But yes, I bet if and when I find that energy, it would change things so much. Having adult company whilst being with children makes it so much easier. I'm just finding it so hard to get out. I had the same problem with my first born, but then the pandemic hit, so I didn't get the choice to even go out. I just find everything so tiring at the moment.

In an ideal world, I would probably send him to nursery 3 days ( he's going 5 days at the moment - I haven't changed his hours yet, but he's only been back 2 weeks, since I had the baby ). He was at home for a good month with us, off nursery, but I had my mum staying with me, so it was completely different.

He seems so happy once there ! But lately I just don't feel like I have much quality time with him. I either need to feed the baby or Tidy and cook etc. everything is tiring right now.

OP posts:
MissChanandlerBong80 · 25/05/2022 21:38

I get it. I felt terrible guilt about sending my eldest to nursery when my youngest was born and I was on mat leave. It’s one thing sending them because you have to in order to work but it’s another sending them when you feel you don’t ‘need’ to.

But then my SIL, who was a SAHM, had a second baby and her oldest didn’t go to nursery (there was no space at any of their local nurseries). And the effect on her oldest was really sad to see - he went from having a really attentive mum who was down on the floor playing with him for hours and hours a day to having a mum who was spending hours feeding a newborn and couldn’t play with him in the way he was used to. He become withdrawn, clingy, anxious and miserable. And absolutely hated his new baby sister.

I realised then that I’d done my eldest a favour by keeping him in nursery even though I felt so guilty about it at the time.

SlightlyGeordieJohn · 25/05/2022 21:37

Our eldest started nursery at three months old, our youngest at six months. Both have had weepy moments when going, but it’s been brilliant for both of them, and I’d not do anything different if we did it over again.

SnackSizeRaisin · 25/05/2022 21:36

I think the guilt is normal. But everyone I know kept their 2 year old in nursery 2 days a week when they were off on maternity with the second child.

You do what you need to cope, and it's hard with two little ones at home especially when you're breastfeeding all day long . I do think that as someone said, it's easier to manage two when you do it every day. I always find the day after a nursery day the hardest.

Mine didn't mind nursery but if she had disliked it I might have taken her out. Many people will say their child loves nursery but I don't believe any 2 years olds actually prefer nursery to spending time with mum. I do think it starts to become beneficial for them at around 2.5, they start to have their own friends etc. I would try not to let him miss any sessions unless ill, keep the routine going.

Don't worry about illness, unless you are going to stay home all the time they will pick things up at soft play and toddler groups anyway.

Charmanderzard · 25/05/2022 21:34

**feeling pushed out not being pushed out!

Charmanderzard · 25/05/2022 21:34

I don't blame you for sending him. I did the same in your shoes. Purely from the perspective of having been there and done that, I don't think the start of the year was a good time to start him TBH. It was close enough with you being pregnant and the new baby for him to connect the two things. Resulting in him being pushed out.

Our eldest had been at the childminder since six months old so I kept in there full time for about six weeks after youngest was born. Then he went for one day a week. We get funding from 2YO here so he then went for mornings in the September. So I did it myself. But in a setting he was already familiar with.

I had a two year age gap and I actually agree with the other poster, it is actually easier with them both at home. Get Paw Patrol on demand and snuggle up with eldest on the sofa while you feed the youngest. Get youngest napping in their room and go and play with the eldest. Most of my attention went on the eldest when i was on my second mat leave and poor youngest was just kind of plonked in the carry cot or bouncer to watch. You can't give both of them your undivided attention anymore and it's better that your eldest learns this quickly.

butterflyrabbit · 25/05/2022 21:30

I felt the same OP, and my firstborn also got ill all the time for the first year or so - BUT she's hardly been ill at all since - she's halfway through primary school - so I reckon it bullet-proofed her immune system!

2.5 is a good age to start. DC1 started age 1 and I never quite shook the guilt until she was about 3 (she made loads of friends and would go in quite happily). DC2 started at 2.5 and she is different - enjoys it while she's there but doesn't ever want to go.

Qwill · 25/05/2022 21:26

Maybe try and reframe your thinking? You got to spend precious time with your first as a newborn - just the two of you. Now, you get to do that with your second whilst your first has great fun playing, making friends, doing lots of activities that you may not realistically be able to do with a newborn in tow. They they can get to come home to a better rested mum and sibling. Mum guilt is awful, and I think we’ve all felt it. Don’t put so much pressure on yourself, you’ve done a brilliant job so far.

Mysisterlivesinbicester · 25/05/2022 21:23

OP, if nursery is your decision, you have to try to ditch the guilt and view it as a positive thing.

Your DS presumably doesn't need to go to nursery if you're at home with a very small baby. You could have him at home - but you have chosen not to. For that reason alone, you need to chuck your guilt in the fuck-it bucket. You can't send a child to nursery when he doesn't need to be there, and then feel guilty. Either you think it's a positive thing for him (which is, I hope, the case if you're sending him), or you don't (in which case, don't send him).

Are you sending him to nursery partly because you find it difficult looking after them both at home? If so, I can tell you that - bizarrely - the more you do it, the easier it is. If you are at home with small children all the time, you soon find ways to cope with them. I think it's far harder when you're not with them all day, every day. It's a long time since my children were little, but I took them to toddler groups, playgroup, the library, park, soft play, local shops etc, etc when they were that age. The thing that made a big difference to me was being around other adults for part of the day - there was always someone at playgroup whose children were being even more revolting than mine. You can make great friendships that way.

Darbs76 · 25/05/2022 21:17

we all feel it. I had so many mornings dropping off crying children and it didn’t feel nice. I didn’t have much choice as I had work but agree that it’s good developmentally for him and either way he will catch most of these bugs eventually

lalaley · 25/05/2022 21:14

Oh OP I really understand you Flowers It is very hard at this stage. My advice would be to be very kind to yourself and patient with all of you. Your little baby was only born one month ago- these things just take a little time to adjust. I PROMISE you in a few months' time it will all feel much happier and lighter. I remember feeling this way but I really shouldn't have, as it's so great for the older ones to start to have a bit of a life of their own and their little friends at nursery. I think for me I felt a bit like you do because the mum instinct is so strong after giving birth, it made it feel more as though I was meant to be with my eldest too 24/7. But that's not the case- it's actually great for him to gain that bit of independence at this age and to play with others at nursery. Him being briefly upset at drop off just shows he has a healthy and strong attachment to you xxx

MissyB1 · 25/05/2022 21:10

How many days (and hours per day) is he there?
Eg 3 half days - great, probably a positive thing for him.
All day every day - not great.

Somethingsnappy · 25/05/2022 21:09

The guilt is the hormones speaking OP! They will settle down soon, I promise. I felt guilty just having another baby each time (I have 4 kids), like I was betraying the youngest that they weren't 'my baby' anymore! It honestly felt like a betrayal, like I was being unfaithful. The guilt was almost unbearable. But the hormones, and the guilt settle down. If your son weren't at nursery, you'd be feeling guilty about something else. It'll be OK x

waterrat · 25/05/2022 21:07

Your tired brain is guiltily you out. Enjoy the quieter days with the baby knowing your toddler is having fun.

waterrat · 25/05/2022 21:06

Oh op..I really understand thr guilt. When mu youngest was born I kept my son ..then 2 years old...with his childminder 2 or 3 days a week. I remember bawling my eyes out with guilt...partly because I was also quite bored when just with the baby so I felt I could have had him too

But honestly honestly he was better off ! It's really fantastic for a lively toddler to be with nursery staff who have slept! Surrounded by children and playing all day.

You would not be giving optimal care if you had him all week long.

Tbh I just felt better once I went back to work part time and they were both in childcare!

Give yourself a few kind words instead of a hard time. Having a baby and toddler was the most insanely exhausted time of my life.

Bunnycat101 · 25/05/2022 21:02

In all honesty it’s rubbish for toddlers being stuck with a newborn- nursery will be much more fun. Don’t feel guilty - you’re not neglecting him- you’re allowing him to socialise with his peers and give your baby some of the 1:1 time the eldest got.