Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

American needs to fight against terror closer to home

314 replies

josil · 25/05/2022 00:25

And focus their energy on teenage boys who seem to be causing terror frequently by shooting us schools. Supermarkets etc etc.

What never ceases to amaze me is somehow these shooters manage to escape the stereotypes that others ethnic groups find it impossible to shake off.

RIP to those dead ok the latest massacre in the US.

The US needs to fight against terror and start with those close to home.

OP posts:
Noname1999 · 25/05/2022 12:59

Racism is not logical. There was a time when immigrants from Ireland, Italy and Eastern Europe were not considered white in the US. Some people still feel this way.

There are gun amnesty days in some states, trade your unlicensed gun for a bike/school supplies/etc.

The US government is not a parliamentary system. Minority interests have a massive hold on what legislation passes. The filibuster still exists.

The Supreme Court has also been happy to ignore precedent lately which means that common sense gun laws can be stuck down once a legal challenge is heard in the highest court.

It's a mess.

JosephdeMaistre · 25/05/2022 12:58

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 25/05/2022 12:56

If you think it's only "the twats in the NRA" you are very very wrong. Just have a think about it. If yours was a widely held view in the USA, things would have changed ages ago. The USA certainly believes it is special - look at history.

Ironically, a lot of American gun owners describe NRA members as ‘fuds’ and think the organisation is too willing to compromise on gun rights.

DdraigGoch · 25/05/2022 12:58

Lesserspottedmama · 25/05/2022 12:48

I don’t think it helps when people get all hysterical about guns. Where I live in rural U.K. quite a lot people around here have guns and shoot rabbits, pigeons, pheasants etc - for food of course, not sport. I’ve never held a gun in my life but I think it’s great they do that. It’s the lax laws and rules and culture in America that is not good. Plus all the things that are rapidly expanding the percentage of young people who are growing up completely unbalanced and damaged with nothing positive in their lives.

No one is getting "hysterical". No one is objecting to farmers owning shotguns, or banning rifles used for deerstalking. No, we're simply saying that there are no good reasons for military-grade weapons being so easily accessible by civilians.

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 25/05/2022 12:56

CapMarvel · 25/05/2022 12:44

It wouldn't.

It's been done in other places. The USA isn't special. Stop listening to the twats in the NRA.

If you think it's only "the twats in the NRA" you are very very wrong. Just have a think about it. If yours was a widely held view in the USA, things would have changed ages ago. The USA certainly believes it is special - look at history.

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 25/05/2022 12:52

All the people peddling "simple" actions like

Stop allowing everyone to own guns when they don't need to.
and
Have a big push to get guns out of the hands of people who don't need them.

Clearly have no idea of life and politics in the USA. Very large numbers of people in the USA seriously question to right of any government to tell them they don't "need" a gun. It's written into the constitution - but even if it wasn't, that's the prevalent view. Any attempt to come for their guns would be seen as precisely the form of tyranny that the constitution is supposed to prevent.

There is no point pretending that's not the case.

As other PPs have said - there would be very significant loss of life and civil unrest if these "simple" measures were enacted.

Pointing this out does not make someone a crazy gun-toting fool; of course we all wish it wasn't true, but it is one of many reasons I wouldn't wish to reside in the USA, and it's a fact.

grapewines · 25/05/2022 12:50

Gun ownership is deeply ingrained - frontier spirit and individual rights under the Bill of Rights. I get all that. America is different to Europe and Australia. I get that too.

What I can't fathom is that this happens over and over, and still people are like "it's my right and freedom!" They will fight for the right to kill each other, basically.

JosephdeMaistre · 25/05/2022 12:49

CapMarvel · 25/05/2022 12:44

It wouldn't.

It's been done in other places. The USA isn't special. Stop listening to the twats in the NRA.

You do realise every country is different.

look up the ‘boogaloo boys’

DdraigGoch · 25/05/2022 12:49

Florenz · 25/05/2022 11:39

"Yes it does. And that has been proven in every developing country that has banned guns.
It's worked. The USA is just to fucked up and backwards to do it."
What other country with mass gun ownership and a strong gun culture has banned guns? It simply wouldn't work in the US and would lead to civil war and the breakup of the country. Police officers just wouldn't be prepared to kill their neighbours and friends who had been law-abiders all their lives, now branded criminals because they own a gun.

You don't just ban guns. You introduce stricter licensing regimes and ban the sorts of guns that have no reasonable civilian function.

Lesserspottedmama · 25/05/2022 12:48

I don’t think it helps when people get all hysterical about guns. Where I live in rural U.K. quite a lot people around here have guns and shoot rabbits, pigeons, pheasants etc - for food of course, not sport. I’ve never held a gun in my life but I think it’s great they do that. It’s the lax laws and rules and culture in America that is not good. Plus all the things that are rapidly expanding the percentage of young people who are growing up completely unbalanced and damaged with nothing positive in their lives.

JosephdeMaistre · 25/05/2022 12:46

TigerLilyTail · 25/05/2022 12:43

Really!? I remember seeing a video of the gun amnesty in Australia and they collected something like half a million guns. Obviously, there are many times more in the US, but I don't think it's an impossible task at all.

Australia is culturally and historically very different to the US though.

Australia’s nationhood wasn’t born out of armed struggle against the British Empire.

CapMarvel · 25/05/2022 12:44

JosephdeMaistre · 25/05/2022 12:41

How would you deal with the insurrection this would inevitably cause?

It wouldn't.

It's been done in other places. The USA isn't special. Stop listening to the twats in the NRA.

TigerLilyTail · 25/05/2022 12:43

JosephdeMaistre · 25/05/2022 12:26

It’s not as “simple as that” countries with stringent gun control regimes already had low rates of personal gun ownership and no cultural or political attachment to guns. When hand guns were banned here in the U.K. owners just quietly surrendered them to the police.

If that was to happen in the states you Would be looking at months, if not years, of violent armed disorder and insurrection, and deadly no knock raids from the FBI and ATF.

Stop pretending every country is U.K.

Really!? I remember seeing a video of the gun amnesty in Australia and they collected something like half a million guns. Obviously, there are many times more in the US, but I don't think it's an impossible task at all.

JosephdeMaistre · 25/05/2022 12:41

How would you deal with the insurrection this would inevitably cause?

CapMarvel · 25/05/2022 12:40

JosephdeMaistre · 25/05/2022 12:26

It’s not as “simple as that” countries with stringent gun control regimes already had low rates of personal gun ownership and no cultural or political attachment to guns. When hand guns were banned here in the U.K. owners just quietly surrendered them to the police.

If that was to happen in the states you Would be looking at months, if not years, of violent armed disorder and insurrection, and deadly no knock raids from the FBI and ATF.

Stop pretending every country is U.K.

It is as simple as that.

Stop allowing everyone to own guns when they don't need to.

Have a big push to get guns out of the hands of people who don't need them.

Or just keep making excuses and carry on watching 7 year olds - fucking SEVEN YEAR OLDS - getting murdered for no reason.

Toughie.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 25/05/2022 12:34

When hand guns were banned here in the U.K. owners just quietly surrendered them to the police

The law abiding may have done, and even a few on the fringes of criminality, but I doubt that applied to the type we'd especially want to remove guns from

As ever it's one thing saying folk can't do something and quite another stopping them from doing it, and as the US learned with prohibition it can create an ever larger criminal class, who'll later diversify into other things

grapewines · 25/05/2022 12:34

Any politicians from either party, who have taken money from the gun lobby, should not be spouting anything about "thoughts and prayers" for dead children.

Imagine if Congress did something about this instead of insisting on having opinions about women's reproductive choices. Just imagine.

Flaxmeadow · 25/05/2022 12:28

Bidens speech last night

JosephdeMaistre · 25/05/2022 12:26

It’s not as “simple as that” countries with stringent gun control regimes already had low rates of personal gun ownership and no cultural or political attachment to guns. When hand guns were banned here in the U.K. owners just quietly surrendered them to the police.

If that was to happen in the states you Would be looking at months, if not years, of violent armed disorder and insurrection, and deadly no knock raids from the FBI and ATF.

Stop pretending every country is U.K.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 25/05/2022 12:26

Yesterday's event, Sandy Hook, Las Vegas etc etc are the price many are willing to pay for their precious 18th century Amendment

I'm afraid so; much as I love the US, IMO they get it very badly wrong on this

And yes, as things stand it would indeed be political suicide for a politician to insist on banning guns

Flaxmeadow · 25/05/2022 12:23

Reallyreallyborednow · 25/05/2022 12:13

Banning guns wouldn't result in there being no guns any more than banning alcohol resulted in there being no alcohol or banning drugs resulted in there being no drugs on the street. If anything, banning makes things worse as you go from there being some control to no control, you put the control into the hands of criminals who don't care about the law, they'll sell guns to kids just like they sell drugs to kids

so how come this has not been the case in every other country that has banned guns?

what makes the US so different? And as it stands there is no control in any places- in this case for example “gun control” = you must be over 18 to buy a gun. That’s it.

Because in states like California and Texas the electorate want guns, so any politician that tries change the law wouldn't be voted in again.

Biden, and others, I think aluded to this in his speech last night. That it is cowardice for politicians to not stand by their principles, even in the face of huge opposition. I'm not a great fan of Biden but his speech last night was one of his best

CapMarvel · 25/05/2022 12:21

Florenz · 25/05/2022 12:11

Banning guns wouldn't result in there being no guns any more than banning alcohol resulted in there being no alcohol or banning drugs resulted in there being no drugs on the street. If anything, banning makes things worse as you go from there being some control to no control, you put the control into the hands of criminals who don't care about the law, they'll sell guns to kids just like they sell drugs to kids.

I'm sorry, no.

This is a shit argument.

In the USA it's really easy to get guns. Lots of people get shot by private citizens with legal guns.

In countries where it's really hard to get guns, very few people get shot by private citizens.

This is not a co-incidence. Make it much harder to get guns = less people have them = less people get shot.

Fucking simple as that.

orwellwasright · 25/05/2022 12:20

Florenz · 25/05/2022 12:11

Banning guns wouldn't result in there being no guns any more than banning alcohol resulted in there being no alcohol or banning drugs resulted in there being no drugs on the street. If anything, banning makes things worse as you go from there being some control to no control, you put the control into the hands of criminals who don't care about the law, they'll sell guns to kids just like they sell drugs to kids.

They're not comparable.

There are millions of people who want alcohol and drugs so there's a market for criminals to exploit. There aren't millions of people desperate to shoot dead young children so there's not the same money to be made. Of course there is a criminal market for illegal guns but it's tiny and brings me on to my second point ..

Mass shootings are often opportunistic. There might be some planning involved but what is key is that these people were able to readily and easily access their gun and ammunition at a moment's notice. They could literally flip one morning and off they go. If they had to instead source an underground gun plus the money required (because they would be far more expensive) it would remove the opportunity for many.

AllPlayedOut · 25/05/2022 12:18

To call a Latino/a person white in America completely ignores the supreme injustice they suffer at every turn. Ignorant statement at best
Is there any topic, however horrible, that can't be derailed into a race row?

She's right though. There's some staggering ignorance on here about the prejudice that the Hispanic and Latino population in the U.S face, not to mention the ignorance about how many countries they originate from and their very diverse ancestry, sometimes including Indigenous peoples.

It's completely irrelevant what British posters would consider them to be.

Reallyreallyborednow · 25/05/2022 12:13

Banning guns wouldn't result in there being no guns any more than banning alcohol resulted in there being no alcohol or banning drugs resulted in there being no drugs on the street. If anything, banning makes things worse as you go from there being some control to no control, you put the control into the hands of criminals who don't care about the law, they'll sell guns to kids just like they sell drugs to kids

so how come this has not been the case in every other country that has banned guns?

what makes the US so different? And as it stands there is no control in any places- in this case for example “gun control” = you must be over 18 to buy a gun. That’s it.

Florenz · 25/05/2022 12:11

Banning guns wouldn't result in there being no guns any more than banning alcohol resulted in there being no alcohol or banning drugs resulted in there being no drugs on the street. If anything, banning makes things worse as you go from there being some control to no control, you put the control into the hands of criminals who don't care about the law, they'll sell guns to kids just like they sell drugs to kids.

Swipe left for the next trending thread