Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

American needs to fight against terror closer to home

314 replies

josil · 25/05/2022 00:25

And focus their energy on teenage boys who seem to be causing terror frequently by shooting us schools. Supermarkets etc etc.

What never ceases to amaze me is somehow these shooters manage to escape the stereotypes that others ethnic groups find it impossible to shake off.

RIP to those dead ok the latest massacre in the US.

The US needs to fight against terror and start with those close to home.

OP posts:
orwellwasright · 25/05/2022 15:58

It's all part of the narrative isn't it?

'You think gun ownership is bad? Well, just try taking it away and then you'll know what bad really is'

What else can you expect from paranoid people who already believe guns make them safe even though it's demonstrably the opposite.

DdraigGoch · 25/05/2022 15:55

JosephdeMaistre · 25/05/2022 15:32

“So you don't have an answer then. Why am I not surprised.”

you don’t have any answer to the very real prospect of violent insurrection that your “simple” solutions could cause.

Don't be ridiculous. Banning the sale of automatic weapons, requiring licences and secure storage for the rest, and offering an amnesty is not going to incite people to throw tea into the sea.

CaveMum · 25/05/2022 15:55

Research has shown that these shootings are socially contagious - shooters want notoriety, they actively research previous shootings for “inspiration” or in an effort to “beat the body count”.

We should not name the perpetrators, they should be forgotten and the victims honoured instead.

I stumbled on a poem the other day called “Shame”. I don’t know who the author is (it’s at least 5 years old from what I can find), but it’s very appropriate:

Shame

I do not want to know his name.

Let it be silenced. Buried in shame.

Don't bother to name his neighbourhood.

He has no place, amongst the good.

Don't tell me where he went to school.

No child is born with a heart so cruel.

Don't talk about his faith, his race.

Such evil has no human face.

Don't air his rhetoric or ideas.

There's no value in what he thinks or feels.

Don't glorify details of his crimes.

Let them be lost, erased in time.

Don't play his video nor his voice.

Let's not pollute the air, by choice.

I do not want to know his name.

Let it be silenced Buried in shame.

RamblingEclectic · 25/05/2022 15:50

Part of me agrees, but I also think that it goes well beyond the weapons -- there is a lot of terror way beyond that, much weighed by the state, and that we'd need to look at more local regional issues. When looking at a map of mass gun shootings, it's interesting that the states with the highest gun ownership per capita - Montana and Wyoming - appear blank. Some of that is population differences, but I think there are also cultural components in how guns are viewed and also which guns are bought.

With gun laws, I think the US would be better going closer to the Swiss model of focusing more on ammunition, having centres which store them rather than on guns. I think there needs to be a shift to that more communal approach, though I don't really see how the US can get there from where it's at.

This suggests that guns are secondary to a primary cause. Mental health.
Or access to high-speed weapons happened. Or increase in media consumption and news. Or changes in diet. Or increases in education rates and laws requiring it. Or many other things.

Pathologizing violence doesn't actually solve anything and actually ignores a lot of the data around how copycat violence happens.

why are teenage boys wired in this way to keep doing this crap.

Wired? Seriously?

maybe American schools can do something simpler, look at school security.

UK school security makes sense when the mass shooting was done by an outsider.

The US ones are more commonly done by school students though, who have a right to be there and for whom current UK security wouldn't really do much - in fact it might make it worse if you have schools like my DDs where there are barriers to leaving as well which would leave those kids sitting ducks in an active shooter situation until someone can release the doors. It's also logistically more difficult with older high school students in the US where in many districts may be studying at 2-3 sites during the day, coming and going at different times which makes the UK practice of locking up the gates at particular times not work well.

Back when my sister and I were born in the 60's and 70's, our birth certificates state that we are of "white" race but of "Mexican" heritage.

Yeah, there has been an issue up to today of American Indigenous and Latino children among others being labeled White on the birth census in the US, even when they stopped putting it on birth certificates. It's a way they fuck with the numbers. Who gets counted as white changes a lot and has little to do with how the families view it.

I actually experienced this a bit in the UK with one of mine, I had a HCP who labeled my child as 'White, Other'. He couldn't be labeled as White British because I'm not, but she wouldn't use my ethnicity either and wouldn't allow me to correct it so by hospital records, my DS was labelled White Other even with no White Other heritage.

Which just goes to show how bonkers America is. The rest of the world sees people of Spanish heritage as white

No they don't. Not everyone who looks at the pictures going around of Salvador Romas is going to see ~Spanish Heritage~ or a White boy. For many of us, what we're seen as varies by viewer, even in the UK, and we are treated differently by how we're viewed. Also, not everywhere uses those European race markers as much as they got exported.

Really, I find your insistence that all Latino people are White very imperialistic and also a bit confusing, like you seem to have forgotten the people who lived there before the Spanish (many who were already colonized which is part of how the Spanish had it so easy, there were a lot of already pissed off people who were easy to divide). After independence, many groups embraced a mixed heritage that combines and yet is outside of those European racial markers.

Seriously, one drop of European blood does not a white person make and Latinos all have different views of our ethnicity and race depending on many factors: in the US, yeah, there is a significant portion who identify as White, but there is also a significant portion who don't and outside of the US, it gets way more complicated how we view ourselves because really, a lot of us have no idea how much mixing we have and many of us don't care.

American needs to fight against terror closer to home
knittingaddict · 25/05/2022 15:48

All this talk of "there will be a civil war" and "what about the inevitable insurrection" just makes the US look even more disfunctional and fucked up. It's not a good look.

What with their justice system, racism, misogyny, gun culture, ignoring the poor and disadvantaged, lack of care for the sick and mentally ill, banning abortion, Christian hypocrisy, inadequate education, etc, we might as well write them off now. They are not the leaders of the free world, that's for sure.

CapMarvel · 25/05/2022 15:41

JosephdeMaistre · 25/05/2022 15:32

“So you don't have an answer then. Why am I not surprised.”

you don’t have any answer to the very real prospect of violent insurrection that your “simple” solutions could cause.

I think this idea that if you gradually and thoughtfully restrict gun ownernship overtime is going to cause some kind of mass uprising is nonsense.

Yes, it will take time. Yes, it will annoy some people but you cannot think that keeping the status quo - or in some cases hellotexas making it easier to buy a gun - is the way forward.

Ferngreen · 25/05/2022 15:39

I don't think it's that easy. If everyone's got guns and you declare an armistice I don't think the bad guys will be the first to hand theirs in
And whilst the police are armed I doubt the bad guys would hand theirs in.
So you end up with police and bad guys armed and the rest not.
I would think they could attempt to ban repeat firing weapons though

CaveMum · 25/05/2022 15:35

People should look at Gun Violence Archive. They track and record every reported incident involving guns in the US. The stats on children are horrific - 140 children aged 0-11 killed so far in 2022 with a further 289 injured.

www.gunviolencearchive.org/

JosephdeMaistre · 25/05/2022 15:32

“So you don't have an answer then. Why am I not surprised.”

you don’t have any answer to the very real prospect of violent insurrection that your “simple” solutions could cause.

CaveMum · 25/05/2022 15:29

A key factor that is (deliberately, in my opinion) not talked about is that much of this violence is rooted in misogyny. I saw a thread on Twitter that said a study had been carried out by a California university that showed a common link between all mass shooters is hatred of women - 80% have a history of domestic violence, most kill a female relative/partner/ex-partner first, etc.

twitter.com/GeauxGabrielle/status/1529221838261338112?s=20&t=rm5LWDpzohDG6n6q_HWa-Q

CapMarvel · 25/05/2022 15:28

JosephdeMaistre · 25/05/2022 14:36

“So how are you going to stop this happening again. And again. And again.”

I’m not an American. I don’t have the power to influence policy in other countries.

So you don't have an answer then. Why am I not surprised.

It's really simple. You either try to make America safer by reducing the number of devices solely designed to kill other people, or you accept that many more innocent people will die. It's depressing how many people keep coming up with excuses - and that is all they are - as to why the former is not possible.

Ncwinc · 25/05/2022 15:21

’Owning a gun literally makes your children less safe.’

Yes. Children have been killed because they’ve found their parents guns and played with them. Children have accidentally killed siblings or friends while playing with guns. Teenagers have been killed by their parents who hear an ‘intruder’ downstairs and shoot only to realise it’s their own child.

Topgub · 25/05/2022 15:06

I was wondering that too @Cartoonmom

Most Americans are in favour of stricter gun control.

Those not and prepared to die for their guns are definitely not a majority

Topgub · 25/05/2022 14:54

@JosephdeMaistre

There was a camping against the ban of hand guns in the UK so its not true to say everyone just quietly went along with it.

I'm proud to say that most did and the dickheads were ignored.

My country took the right steps to protect its children on that occasion at least

orwellwasright · 25/05/2022 14:51

The stat that always gets me is that a child in a gun-owning household is more likely to die accidentally (usually by being shot by a sibling 😓) than that gun be used to legitimately defend the family.

Owning a gun literally makes your children less safe.

Cartoonmom · 25/05/2022 14:49

To control guns - why can't we just start simple and reenact the assault weapons ban that Congress passed in the 90s after Columbine? Am I the only American who remembers this??? The Republicans let the ban expire when W was president.

Also, why are we pretending that a majority of Americans are not in favor of stricter gun control? It's Republicans in the senate who are blocking legislation and they do not represent a majority of the voting population.

Ncwinc · 25/05/2022 14:48

How many school shootings have involved the murder/s using legally purchased weapons they either own themselves or have accessed through family members? These aren’t stolen guns. If you want to stop the shootings, stop selling guns.

If you sell guns people are going to use them to kill people. Hunting is very popular in many US states but people are not buying assault rifles or hand guns to go shoot ducks. It would be completely possible to limit the types of weapons sold.

The majority of the general public in the US want stricter gun control. The NRA has managed to control the law at every level through lobbying and it’s ability to swing the vote in key marginals by mobilising it’s supporters.

www.theguardian.com/us-news/2017/nov/17/nra-gun-lobby-gun-control-congress

Anonymous48 · 25/05/2022 14:48

MermaidEyes · 25/05/2022 14:43

They all seem to find some Irish heritage come March 17th too!

Any excuse for a knees up and a pint of Guinness!

Is there anything wrong with this?

We're all Mexican on May 5 too.

Anonymous48 · 25/05/2022 14:46

JudgeJ · 25/05/2022 14:38

Rather than continuing the pointless arguments about gun control, they won't do it because of powerful vested interests, maybe American schools can do something simpler, look at school security. No-one can enter my grandson's primary school without being identified after which the locked door is opened, the gates into the school are locked once school is in session. The HIgh School where I worked had only one of its many entrances available from the outside during school hours, when we were a polling station there was a police presence on the door being used. Surely that can't upset the gun toters?

I'm in the US. All the schools around me have very strict security. You have to scan your driving license and then wear a name tag to even get past the front desk. Most of them also have armed police officers on campus. I assume there was a similar set up in Texas, but unfortunately that system isn't infallible.

MermaidEyes · 25/05/2022 14:43

They all seem to find some Irish heritage come March 17th too!

Any excuse for a knees up and a pint of Guinness!

JudgeJ · 25/05/2022 14:41

MermaidEyes · 25/05/2022 14:30

This comment really made me laugh, but it's so true. An American colleague once said he thinks it stems from the fact America is such a 'new' country compared to a lot of the rest of the world, so they seem to feel this great need to figure out where they come from.

They all seem to find some Irish heritage come March 17th too!

JudgeJ · 25/05/2022 14:38

Rather than continuing the pointless arguments about gun control, they won't do it because of powerful vested interests, maybe American schools can do something simpler, look at school security. No-one can enter my grandson's primary school without being identified after which the locked door is opened, the gates into the school are locked once school is in session. The HIgh School where I worked had only one of its many entrances available from the outside during school hours, when we were a polling station there was a police presence on the door being used. Surely that can't upset the gun toters?

JosephdeMaistre · 25/05/2022 14:36

“So how are you going to stop this happening again. And again. And again.”

I’m not an American. I don’t have the power to influence policy in other countries.

Reallyreallyborednow · 25/05/2022 14:36

This comment really made me laugh, but it's so true. An American colleague once said he thinks it stems from the fact America is such a 'new' country compared to a lot of the rest of the world, so they seem to feel this great need to figure out where they come from

fucking hell that would be hilarious if it wasn’t so tragic.

complete whitewashing of Native American history.

we hate immigrants but all need to tell you about our immigrant ancestors.

oh and this country only started to exist once those immigrant ancestors arrived here.

Anonymous48 · 25/05/2022 14:33

Flaxmeadow · 25/05/2022 13:29

The constant racialisation of everything is a big problem in the USA. It's an obsession. It's often how Americans introduce themselves to the world.

Like "Hi there, I'm 1/4 Irish, 1/4 Scotch Irish , an 1/8 Polish and a 1/4 Cuban African and I have a Cherokee grt grt grt grt uncle". They say this as if their ethnic ancestry is the most interesting thing about them.

Anyone outside America just thinks 'oh so you're American then, born and raised in America'

I'm sorry, but that's laughable. Americans don't introduce themselves that way!

However, because of the melting pot nature of the US, a lot of Americans are very interested and proud of their heritage and culture, and there's nothing wrong with that.