Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

American needs to fight against terror closer to home

314 replies

josil · 25/05/2022 00:25

And focus their energy on teenage boys who seem to be causing terror frequently by shooting us schools. Supermarkets etc etc.

What never ceases to amaze me is somehow these shooters manage to escape the stereotypes that others ethnic groups find it impossible to shake off.

RIP to those dead ok the latest massacre in the US.

The US needs to fight against terror and start with those close to home.

OP posts:
Valeriekat · 26/05/2022 07:28

Mitt Romney has been the biggest recipient of NRA cash and it is quite a lot of it too $13,647,676. However the number of gun related deaths in Utah is among the lowest in the country. States with strict gun control laws do not have fewer shootings so it is not as simple as people in the UK seem to think.

Valeriekat · 26/05/2022 07:18

alphons · 25/05/2022 00:28

It amazes you. It disgusts and depresses me.

YANBU.

It’s homegrown terror, pure and simple. White supremacy, cultivated at home.

The attack at Uvalde was not white supremacy.
Bullied at school, poor, there is no pattern to these shootings other than maleness.

KobaniDaughters · 26/05/2022 03:08

GarlandsinGreece · 26/05/2022 00:37

I’m absolutely sick of it. Sick to the back teeth, nauseated, enraged…the list goes on.

I live in Connecticut. I’m proud of Sen. Chris Murphy for putting other politicians on the spot. As he said over and over: What are we doing?

I have adored the last twenty years of living in NYC and CT. The people have been amazing, the lifestyle, the arts, the culture, the outstanding opportunities. But by god, I don’t think I can stay here in this country and continue to raise my kids, because we are being held by the nuts by a bunch of disgusting old white Republican men.

I feel you. I too have loved a decade of Southern California living (and we are both lucky to live in liberal states) but this shooting coming 24th after my own child’s school went into lockdown is more than triggering.

We’re heading back to the U.K. in a month, this is definitely one of the reasons why

GarlandsinGreece · 26/05/2022 02:28

@SomersetONeil , thank you. I’m actually a British ex-pat, who for the first time in twenty years is about ready to throw in the towel and haul my American kids and husband to England.

I just read that another individual carrying an AK-47 was apprehended today outside a Texas high school. I would dearly love to stand outside the NRA conference in Texas Friday, and lob a few dozen eggs the way of Trump, Ted Cruz and all the other bigoted attendees.

samyeagar · 26/05/2022 02:18

DdraigGoch · 26/05/2022 01:37

They are far more likely to experience a classmate getting dunk at a party and dying in a car wreck with a few other classmates.

@samyeagar you are wrong there. In 2020 4,300 American children were killed by firearms. That's more than the 4,000 who were killed by cars and considerably more than the 2,000 or so who died of drug overdoses or the 2,000 who died of cancer.

Guns are now the biggest killer of American children.

I am going to split hairs here as this goes into two separate issues. Gun related injury and gun related crime.

In the context of this thread and what I was talking about gun crime and in particular mass school shootings. Those numbers you cited, while absolutely correct, include accidents and suicide, which make up a large majority of all gun related deaths.

Those are two different issues which require different approaches to solve.

SomersetONeil · 26/05/2022 01:41

GarlandsinGreece · 26/05/2022 00:37

I’m absolutely sick of it. Sick to the back teeth, nauseated, enraged…the list goes on.

I live in Connecticut. I’m proud of Sen. Chris Murphy for putting other politicians on the spot. As he said over and over: What are we doing?

I have adored the last twenty years of living in NYC and CT. The people have been amazing, the lifestyle, the arts, the culture, the outstanding opportunities. But by god, I don’t think I can stay here in this country and continue to raise my kids, because we are being held by the nuts by a bunch of disgusting old white Republican men.

I truly feel for Americans in your position.

My American friends and family feel exactly the same.

The infuriating impotence to do anything about it must be beyond frustrating.

And what’s worse is that there are young Republicans coming in behind to succeed the dinosaurs currently in office.

The only American I know who doesn’t think like this is an old pen-friend of my late DF’s. A South Carolinian who rabidly supports Trump, and yes, bought his grandkids guns for their first birthday.

DdraigGoch · 26/05/2022 01:37

They are far more likely to experience a classmate getting dunk at a party and dying in a car wreck with a few other classmates.

@samyeagar you are wrong there. In 2020 4,300 American children were killed by firearms. That's more than the 4,000 who were killed by cars and considerably more than the 2,000 or so who died of drug overdoses or the 2,000 who died of cancer.

Guns are now the biggest killer of American children.

GarlandsinGreece · 26/05/2022 00:37

I’m absolutely sick of it. Sick to the back teeth, nauseated, enraged…the list goes on.

I live in Connecticut. I’m proud of Sen. Chris Murphy for putting other politicians on the spot. As he said over and over: What are we doing?

I have adored the last twenty years of living in NYC and CT. The people have been amazing, the lifestyle, the arts, the culture, the outstanding opportunities. But by god, I don’t think I can stay here in this country and continue to raise my kids, because we are being held by the nuts by a bunch of disgusting old white Republican men.

samyeagar · 26/05/2022 00:26

This reply has been deleted

Withdrawn at poster's request.

It used to be like that, yes, but over the past 20 years, and especially the last decade, most major retailers, even dedicated sporting goods stores have stopped carrying firearms all together. It is too big of a legal liability for them.

pixie5121 · 25/05/2022 22:37

This reply has been withdrawn

Withdrawn at poster's request.

samyeagar · 25/05/2022 22:32

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 25/05/2022 22:17

A semi-automatic weapon is one in which it will fire one shot each time the trigger is pulled. The vast majority of all firearms across the world are semi-automatic. The AR-15, while commonly used and scary looking, is not a particularly powerful or accurate weapon. There is nothing particularly special about them as far as guns go. They just look intimidating and are cheap. A good hunting rifle is far more powerful, shoots further, and is more accurate.

The same is true of an AK-47 (except in can fire multiple rounds). Not accurate, not powerful, but reliable.

The AR-15 has the dubious "honour" of having been the weapon of choice for the majority of mass murders in US schools - you don't need accuracy or power to kill and maim large numbers of people if they are gathered in a place of worship or a school.

It's gotten that honour in large part because it looks intimidating, and has has been glorified as the centerpiece weapon in the whole gun debate. In short...it's what the cool kids use.

samyeagar · 25/05/2022 22:29

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 25/05/2022 22:08

It's mad that they are even at the supermarket, no matter what hoops you have to jump through to get one.

Seeing guns at the supermarket normalises them. They shouldn't fucking be normalised.

In fairness, I made that statement because upthread someone, a non American presumably, stated that you could. The closest that you can come to buying guns at the supermarket would be a few select rural Wal Marts that sell hunting equipment. So for anyone envisioning being able to go round to the local Tesco or Sainsbury's and having guns down the pickle row, yeah, it's not like that.

SomersetONeil · 25/05/2022 22:22

SomersetONeil · 25/05/2022 20:58

So a group of school children and their teachers don’t count?

@TruthHertz ?

You didn’t respond.

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 25/05/2022 22:17

A semi-automatic weapon is one in which it will fire one shot each time the trigger is pulled. The vast majority of all firearms across the world are semi-automatic. The AR-15, while commonly used and scary looking, is not a particularly powerful or accurate weapon. There is nothing particularly special about them as far as guns go. They just look intimidating and are cheap. A good hunting rifle is far more powerful, shoots further, and is more accurate.

The same is true of an AK-47 (except in can fire multiple rounds). Not accurate, not powerful, but reliable.

The AR-15 has the dubious "honour" of having been the weapon of choice for the majority of mass murders in US schools - you don't need accuracy or power to kill and maim large numbers of people if they are gathered in a place of worship or a school.

samyeagar · 25/05/2022 22:16

Puzzledandpissedoff · 25/05/2022 21:57

Nowhere in the USA can a person just walk into the local supermarket and legally purchase a gun ... federal level background checks are required

While true about the supermarkets, isn't this a bit selective?

AFAIK - and please correct me if I'm wrong - the background checks only apply to those purchasing from licensed gun sellers, and don't apply to many gun shows, internet sales, etc.
So someone who'd fail a background check can still buy a gun only too easily

Yeah, that is largely correct. The rules around temporary gun shows and internet sales are very grey, and need to be tightened up for sure. Though in some areas, all you need is $50 and the right street corner and you can get what ever you want. Those are the guns causing the most issues, and the ones that are the hardest to stop.

SomersetONeil · 25/05/2022 22:11

Nowhere in the USA can a person just walk into the local supermarket and legally purchase a gun ... federal level background checks are required

Nowhere in the world can a person walk into a local supermarket and expect to purchase a gun…..

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 25/05/2022 22:08

It's mad that they are even at the supermarket, no matter what hoops you have to jump through to get one.

Seeing guns at the supermarket normalises them. They shouldn't fucking be normalised.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 25/05/2022 21:57

Nowhere in the USA can a person just walk into the local supermarket and legally purchase a gun ... federal level background checks are required

While true about the supermarkets, isn't this a bit selective?

AFAIK - and please correct me if I'm wrong - the background checks only apply to those purchasing from licensed gun sellers, and don't apply to many gun shows, internet sales, etc.
So someone who'd fail a background check can still buy a gun only too easily

DdraigGoch · 25/05/2022 21:51

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 25/05/2022 19:05

I'm (mostly) not quarrelling with the logic - just the apparent ease with which you think the significantly fewer guns option could be achieved, that's all.

But what posters are proposing has been done before, and was successful at reducing this type of massacre:

A 2019 DiMaggio et al. study looked at mass shooting data for 1981 to 2017 and found that mass-shooting fatalities were 70% less likely to occur during the 1994 to 2004 federal ban period

samyeagar · 25/05/2022 21:31

Augend23 · 25/05/2022 20:55

So if licences and background checks already exist there shouldn't be an issue with extending them?

The current background checks are to check you aren't legally prohibited from owning a gun - i e. a restraining order or a felony conviction. My understanding is that they don't have to be completed when you buy a gun off another gun owner e.g. second hand sales. It seems to be like you could very reasonably introduce this for second hand sales.

Re licencing: this could reasonably be extended to locked cabinets with the amunition stored locked and separately without impacting on anyone's rights to bear arms. Sure it wouldn't solve gang based gun crime. And maybe you wouldn't get it implemented for everyone straight away but if you did those checks every time a gun changed hands for the next decade (i.e. if you buy a new gun then you have to apply these rules) then in 20 years it would be basically done. If that had started 20 years ago then it would be nearly done today.

I think it would also be very reasonable ASA starting point to allow no new purchases of guns with more than X chambered rounds (X tbc). A rifle is clearly more powerful but certainly in the UK rifles have a single shot and then you have to reload. Shotguns two shots.

None of those are banning guns or preventing people from bearing arms. The fact that fully automatic weapons are banned tells us that limits to this are possible and accepted. That is really a case of not letting perfect be the en enemy of good.

That is really a case of not letting perfect be the enemy of good.

I think this really gets to the heart of it for both sides, and why any sort of reasonable compromise has been so difficult because it is approached from an activist angle where compromise is seen as failure, and our politics catering strictly to our activists.

The suggestions above, which I do agree with, would have had minimal impact when it comes to the types of mass shootings as we saw yesterday, however, the issue with gun crime is far more than just these types of shootings. Those get the headlines but make up only a small portion for the overall death and injury toll. The reasonable steps above would have a significant overall positive impact for sure.

Another thing that is now making this even more complex is that 3d printing has gotten good enough and is easily accessible and affordable, the issue of ghost guns and gun modifications is becoming really serious. I mean, a person could walk into a Best Buy a buy the printer for under $1000, download plans for free, and print a dozen guns. Hell, in some places, you could just steal the printer right off the shelf knowing that you won't be prosecuted for shoplifting. And if printing guns isn't your thing, you could print expanded magazines that are otherwise fully illegal to buy anywhere.

samyeagar · 25/05/2022 21:09

Finally, If there are no guns, people can't shoot kids with them. If there are guns, people will shoot kids with them.

Is it really that simple? Well, yes. It really is that simple. Simple to the point of being meaningless. A drug addict? Make drugs illegal, and don't do drugs. In an abusive relationship? Make abuse illegal and leave.

But as they say, the devils in the details. While the high level platitude may be easy to see, the actual process for getting there is not nearly so straight forward.

Reallyreallyborednow · 25/05/2022 21:04

I've not said it will be easy. The principle is easy-> Less guns, less people getting shot. I'm aware the implementation of such a thing is not easy

the issue is it would appear there are americans who don't believe this.

who in fact believe more guns= fewer people getting shot.

there are seemingly genuine calls to arm teachers. Armed guards in schools. Hell I even saw one tweet suggesting that wach class should have an armed teacher and one well trained armed pupil. I’ve seen people state that 4 armed persons are the minimum needed to take a shooter down.

until the gun advocates can be convinced that gun control = fewer deaths nothing will change.

However the evidence is out there, the stats that guns kill people by accident more than in defence. But like I said earlier about Caleb Keeter’s about turn, it seems that most gun owners just believe they and their gun would make a difference. Even when the evidence says not- as in this case where 3 armed police were unable to stop one shooter entering a school and massacring kids.

SomersetONeil · 25/05/2022 20:58

TruthHertz · 25/05/2022 20:55

I'll agree when a lone teenage boy manages to blow up something of the magnitude of the twin towers or manages to take over another country/region.

So a group of school children and their teachers don’t count?

Augend23 · 25/05/2022 20:55

So if licences and background checks already exist there shouldn't be an issue with extending them?

The current background checks are to check you aren't legally prohibited from owning a gun - i e. a restraining order or a felony conviction. My understanding is that they don't have to be completed when you buy a gun off another gun owner e.g. second hand sales. It seems to be like you could very reasonably introduce this for second hand sales.

Re licencing: this could reasonably be extended to locked cabinets with the amunition stored locked and separately without impacting on anyone's rights to bear arms. Sure it wouldn't solve gang based gun crime. And maybe you wouldn't get it implemented for everyone straight away but if you did those checks every time a gun changed hands for the next decade (i.e. if you buy a new gun then you have to apply these rules) then in 20 years it would be basically done. If that had started 20 years ago then it would be nearly done today.

I think it would also be very reasonable ASA starting point to allow no new purchases of guns with more than X chambered rounds (X tbc). A rifle is clearly more powerful but certainly in the UK rifles have a single shot and then you have to reload. Shotguns two shots.

None of those are banning guns or preventing people from bearing arms. The fact that fully automatic weapons are banned tells us that limits to this are possible and accepted. That is really a case of not letting perfect be the en enemy of good.

TruthHertz · 25/05/2022 20:55

I'll agree when a lone teenage boy manages to blow up something of the magnitude of the twin towers or manages to take over another country/region.