Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

American needs to fight against terror closer to home

314 replies

josil · 25/05/2022 00:25

And focus their energy on teenage boys who seem to be causing terror frequently by shooting us schools. Supermarkets etc etc.

What never ceases to amaze me is somehow these shooters manage to escape the stereotypes that others ethnic groups find it impossible to shake off.

RIP to those dead ok the latest massacre in the US.

The US needs to fight against terror and start with those close to home.

OP posts:
knitnerd90 · 27/05/2022 03:41

The thing is that the guns in Chicago don't come from Chicago; they come from neighboring states with stricter gun laws. This is why it's so hard and there needs to be federal action, but then you get caught in who can regulate what. I live outside DC, which has strict laws (except the ones the Supreme Court struck down) but it's not at all difficult to go to other states to get them, I think VA is more lax.

CheerfulYank · 27/05/2022 02:59

DrippyLongstocking · 27/05/2022 02:39

Could I ask why you lay blame on both parties? I’m only old enough to remember Clinton onwards. Clinton did manage to pass some gun control legislation. Obama tried but was blocked by (mostly) Republicans and any attempts by Biden will also inevitably be sunk by mostly Republicans.

It feels like 90% of Democrat politicians want gun control legislation, but only a handful of Republicans, and the Democrats rarely have the Senate margin needed to do it themselves.

Because gun control is all the Left consider. I think it would be lovely but it also isn’t going to happen. The laws we do have are already abused in many ways and some places with tighter gun control (Chicago) have some of the worst gun crime.

We need to focus on actual solutions that can be passed right NOW instead of pointing fingers. Yes I DO lay most of the blame on the Right, for their refusal to act and the insane gun culture many of them revel in, but the Left pooh-poohing any measure like bulletproof doors and the like is also not helping.

That monster bought those guns legally. Clearly that system is fucked. But the reality is, he bought them legally. Bulletproof doors would have saved those babies.

DrippyLongstocking · 27/05/2022 02:39

CheerfulYank · 27/05/2022 01:44

I’m American, have lived my whole life here. I’m just sick and tired and angry. My kindergartner had a music program today and I’m not one for dramatics but my breath caught seeing them all lying on the floor pretending to be sleeping bunnies for the song. I couldn’t help picturing an entire class lying on the floor, still like that, but not pretending.

I’m sick of EVERYONE. Mostly the Republicans and those lining their pockets with NRA money but honestly I’m tired of both sides right now. Fucking DO SOMETHING.

Both sides are using the blood of these children for their own agenda and it won’t work, it will never work, we’re just going to point fingers and fight and meanwhile it will happen again and again.

We need practical shit until our culture can shift from the insanity we’ve descended into. We need to sign Extreme Risk Protection Orders into law, we need to ban the production and importation of high capacity magazines, we need community and school teaching on identifying risk factors and effective reporting of them. And we need bulletproof doors etc. Most on the left mock the idea of them and say they don’t want to send their kids to school like that and I don’t either, but here we fucking are.

Do the job you were elected to do and FIGURE IT OUT.

Could I ask why you lay blame on both parties? I’m only old enough to remember Clinton onwards. Clinton did manage to pass some gun control legislation. Obama tried but was blocked by (mostly) Republicans and any attempts by Biden will also inevitably be sunk by mostly Republicans.

It feels like 90% of Democrat politicians want gun control legislation, but only a handful of Republicans, and the Democrats rarely have the Senate margin needed to do it themselves.

CheerfulYank · 27/05/2022 01:44

I’m American, have lived my whole life here. I’m just sick and tired and angry. My kindergartner had a music program today and I’m not one for dramatics but my breath caught seeing them all lying on the floor pretending to be sleeping bunnies for the song. I couldn’t help picturing an entire class lying on the floor, still like that, but not pretending.

I’m sick of EVERYONE. Mostly the Republicans and those lining their pockets with NRA money but honestly I’m tired of both sides right now. Fucking DO SOMETHING.

Both sides are using the blood of these children for their own agenda and it won’t work, it will never work, we’re just going to point fingers and fight and meanwhile it will happen again and again.

We need practical shit until our culture can shift from the insanity we’ve descended into. We need to sign Extreme Risk Protection Orders into law, we need to ban the production and importation of high capacity magazines, we need community and school teaching on identifying risk factors and effective reporting of them. And we need bulletproof doors etc. Most on the left mock the idea of them and say they don’t want to send their kids to school like that and I don’t either, but here we fucking are.

Do the job you were elected to do and FIGURE IT OUT.

Lunar27 · 26/05/2022 23:07

@samyeagar

I'll have to take your word for it as I've only spent time working in AL. I guess working with professionals, buying illegal firearms would never be on the radar but get your point that a killer wouldn't think twice about going down an easier route.

Naturally it's an interesting topic for an Englishman working in the US and colleagues were more than happy to discuss the culture and where they fit in with it. You're probably right as even the most anti gun person didn't talk about schools but accidents, suicide etc. Although one incident at the time involved a toddler killing his mother after finding a small handgun in her purse and firing it.

It must depend on where you are but my American friends are horrified with this side of US culture and hate guns.

DrippyLongstocking · 26/05/2022 19:22

TruthHertz · 26/05/2022 19:13

Do the 3000 people who died in 9/11 not count? Or the Ariana Grande concert victims? Or all the American citizens who've been beheaded on video?

To fight terrorism at home you also need to tackle the root which may not be so close.

It isn’t relevant to this particular mass shooting, but the FBI and Department of Homeland Security have both determined that the greatest terrorist threat to the US is domestic terrorism by white supremacists.

www.politico.com/news/2020/09/04/white-supremacists-terror-threat-dhs-409236

TruthHertz · 26/05/2022 19:13

SomersetONeil · 25/05/2022 20:58

So a group of school children and their teachers don’t count?

Do the 3000 people who died in 9/11 not count? Or the Ariana Grande concert victims? Or all the American citizens who've been beheaded on video?

To fight terrorism at home you also need to tackle the root which may not be so close.

lolaflores · 26/05/2022 15:13

Mexican is also inclusive of indigenous people prior to colonisation. Latinos are considered unwelcome illegal immigrants by white American society. Take fof example the term, wet back.
Latino culture is distinct from white Anglo American culture.
Mexican spanish differs from European Spanish as does Spanish I South America.
I lived in Texas for 4 years and I had found active shooter drills at my daughters school a sobering event. But it was not a guarantee of survival. Imagine the panic?
Imagine hoping drills will help kids cor eyed in a room being riddled with military grade bullets from an automatic machine gun?
It's not really a deterent os it

samyeagar · 26/05/2022 15:02

Lunar27 · 26/05/2022 08:27

Not quite true, although I accept that AL might be considered rural to you!

I've worked in AL and my family and I found it fascinating that you could walk into a regular Walmart and see a range of rifles/guns/ammo clearly on show.

Not that you'd shop in Walmart, when much more serious gear can be bought from a Bass Pro store but I managed to find firearms in Dicks too, which is a UK equivalent of Sports Direct!

Regarding what you said earlier about perspectives, my colleagues all said that they either known someone personally who'd been shot or knew people who'd had direct experience with gun crime. None of them knew anyone would hadn't been affected by guns.

I take your point, but it still remains that the vast majority of Wal Marts across the United States do not sell firearms at all, and less than half of Dicks stores sell guns any more. Unfortunately in many places it would be faster, easier and cheaper to buy a gun illegally.

I am an ex pat who grew up in the midlands and moved to downstate Illinois in the late 80's. Live in a city of about 100,000 people. With it being relatively rural, most everyone I have known the entire time has owned firearms. No personal experience with gun crime, and the only person I know is my brother in law who was carjacked at gunpoint in St. Louis. So personal experience and perspective is fascinating.

Aside from the fringes on both sides, most Americans want legal firearms with sensible restriction. This sentiment is really shown in how the entire debate is approached. Gun related accidents and suicides far out number murders and shootings, yet the debate and outrage really only flares like this when there is a mass incident like this.

With suicides, the focus is on mental health and how the person could have been helped and the gun is not even talked about.

With accidents, it is just generally accepted that accidents happen...that is unless it is a child. When it is a child, the discussion goes to responsible storage, keeping the gun out of the hands of a kid, and should the gun owner be prosecuted...not all that different than any other negligent act.

It really is a different cultural mindset than anywhere else, and unless one actually lives in it, they are going to struggle to understand it at all.

OneTC · 26/05/2022 10:36

Flaxmeadow · 26/05/2022 09:39

America, where you can have a fun day out with your children at a Bullets and Burgers theme park and the kids get to try out an Uzi. What could possibly go wrong?
en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shooting_of_Charles_Vacca

jfc 😑

JosephdeMaistre · 26/05/2022 10:24

Flaxmeadow · 26/05/2022 09:39

America, where you can have a fun day out with your children at a Bullets and Burgers theme park and the kids get to try out an Uzi. What could possibly go wrong?
en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shooting_of_Charles_Vacca

That looks like good clean fun tbh

CaveMum · 26/05/2022 10:22

Forgot to post the blurb for those podcasts:

“Laura and Jim interview Professors Jillian Petersen and James Densley, co-founders and co-presidents of The Violence Project, a nonprofit, non-partisan research center best known for its mass shooter database, funded by the National Institute of Justice.
Together they have written a book called 'The Violence Project: how to stop a mass shooting epidemic.' They have interviewed perpetrators and victims and their families with the aim of preventing future mass shootings. Building on their coverage and analysis of Columbine and other mass shootings, Laura and Jim discuss their findings including making the links across violent offending behaviour, the red flags, the pathway to murder and early identification, intervention and prevention opportunities.”

The hosts, Laura and Jim, are ex-Scotland Yard and ex-FBI respectively so fully understand the background to these incidents as well as being expert criminal profilers.

CaveMum · 26/05/2022 10:20

@KittenKong you may have read the same Twitter thread that I linked to earlier in this thread that stated that research has shown that 80% of mass shooters have a history of domestic violence, and yes many of them do kill a female relative/partner/ex-partner before carrying out the mass shooting.

There are a lot of factors to take into account, and gun control absolutely should be a part of it, but there are also a lot of common issues in the background of each of these perpetrators that can be used to identify those who are are at risk of committing these awful crimes.

I'll link again to a two-part podcast that is absolutely worth listening to on this topic:

How To Stop a Mass Shooting Epidemic pt 1: podcasts.apple.com/gb/podcast/how-to-stop-a-mass-shooting-epidemic-part-1/id1081244497?i=1000537711586

Pt 2 - podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/how-to-stop-a-mass-shooting-epidemic-part-2/id1081244497?i=1000538477326

Flaxmeadow · 26/05/2022 09:39

America, where you can have a fun day out with your children at a Bullets and Burgers theme park and the kids get to try out an Uzi. What could possibly go wrong?
en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shooting_of_Charles_Vacca

Flaxmeadow · 26/05/2022 09:27

Bellevu · 26/05/2022 08:49

Compare the USA rates of school shootings v countries where terrorists and jihadists storm schools and kidnap children.

Woah! That number is shocking

AuxArmesCitoyens · 26/05/2022 09:13

FWIW there have been a number of female mass shooters and loads of male ethnic minority ones of all ages. But it's true the overwhelming majority are male.

Bellevu · 26/05/2022 08:49

Compare the USA rates of school shootings v countries where terrorists and jihadists storm schools and kidnap children.

American needs to fight against terror closer to home
Florenz · 26/05/2022 08:43

"How many school shootings have there been in Great Britain in the 26 years since Dunblane?
ZERO!
Because John Major and Tony Blair took strong action to vastly restrict the private ownership of guns as a result of the tragedy. I'd call that a success."
It was a success but there was never anything like the same level of gun ownership or gun culture in the UK than there is in the US. Banning guns in the US would not have the same effect that Banning guns did over here. Because it is a very different country.

Lunar27 · 26/05/2022 08:34

I should add that the guns in Walmart weren't in a special area but in the same vicinity as kids toys/clothing/bicycles/outdoor equipment etc. It really wasn't any different to my local Tesco except for a section with rifles in a glass cabinet.

It was sweet that they even had kids rifles in there for little Chuck's birthday!

Lunar27 · 26/05/2022 08:27

samyeagar · 25/05/2022 22:29

In fairness, I made that statement because upthread someone, a non American presumably, stated that you could. The closest that you can come to buying guns at the supermarket would be a few select rural Wal Marts that sell hunting equipment. So for anyone envisioning being able to go round to the local Tesco or Sainsbury's and having guns down the pickle row, yeah, it's not like that.

Not quite true, although I accept that AL might be considered rural to you!

I've worked in AL and my family and I found it fascinating that you could walk into a regular Walmart and see a range of rifles/guns/ammo clearly on show.

Not that you'd shop in Walmart, when much more serious gear can be bought from a Bass Pro store but I managed to find firearms in Dicks too, which is a UK equivalent of Sports Direct!

Regarding what you said earlier about perspectives, my colleagues all said that they either known someone personally who'd been shot or knew people who'd had direct experience with gun crime. None of them knew anyone would hadn't been affected by guns.

JesusMaryAndJosephAndTheWeeDon · 26/05/2022 08:20

BritWifeInUSA · 25/05/2022 01:00

He’s Hispanic. But I’m not sure what point you are making about race.

What do you think the solution is? Make all guns illegal? That’ll keep them off the streets, wing it? I mean, it worked for heroin and cocaine, right?

You are missing the point when it comes to gun ownership. Stopping responsible law-abiding gun owners from having guns will not stop this sort of thing from happening.

How many school shootings have there been in Great Britain in the 26 years since Dunblane?

ZERO!

Because John Major and Tony Blair took strong action to vastly restrict the private ownership of guns as a result of the tragedy. I'd call that a success.

knitnerd90 · 26/05/2022 08:00

oh my I hate this argument, but it's worth pointing out that the USA is a federal country. It's much harder to do because you need all 50 state legislatures to tighten up their laws. Meanwhile the Supreme Court keeps striking down gun laws. "Well we did it after dunblane" doesn't hold true.

The GOP could get its head out of its arse and agree to some reforms but this will never be like the UK or Australia.

Also, to answer something on the first two pages, Hispanic/Latino ethnicity is separate from race (though often popularly regarded as a race). You can be Latino and of any race. Many Mexican-Americans are mixed-race (part Indigenous, this is even more true for Central Americans who may not even speak Spanish) and will check that off on the race section of the census. It's actually quite a complicated question as some people are regarded as white in their home countries but not in the US. I know people who refer to themselves as "white Latino" also. You can see how this can get ridiculous with someone like Anya Taylor-Joy (to pick an extreme example). But many Mexicans are really not white by anyone's definition; they are mestizos.

Florenz · 26/05/2022 07:55

The only female school shooter I can think of is the girl that "I don't like Mondays" is about, and that song is over 40 years old.

orwellwasright · 26/05/2022 07:53

I suspect toxic masculinity is playing a part. So expect more of these types of shootings as the online MRA/incel/extreme misogyny culture gets ever more powerful.

KittenKong · 26/05/2022 07:43

I was reading somewhere (on here maybe?) that in so many of these cases the man (for they are almost always men - can’t think of a female shooter) first attacks a female (often partner or mum/grandmother), and often there is domestic violence.

I remember when there seemed to be a spate of university campus shootings - was there always attacks in schools, or is this a more recent escalation in these things?