Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

American needs to fight against terror closer to home

314 replies

josil · 25/05/2022 00:25

And focus their energy on teenage boys who seem to be causing terror frequently by shooting us schools. Supermarkets etc etc.

What never ceases to amaze me is somehow these shooters manage to escape the stereotypes that others ethnic groups find it impossible to shake off.

RIP to those dead ok the latest massacre in the US.

The US needs to fight against terror and start with those close to home.

OP posts:
DdraigGoch · 25/05/2022 10:57

Trainbear · 25/05/2022 07:37

Americans have had the right to bear arms since 1776.
School shootings such as this did not start until the 1960s.
This suggests that guns are secondary to a primary cause. Mental health.

Calling for gun control (and doing nothing) is easier than tackling a huge mental health issue.

You've overlooked that the type of guns available has changed. How many ordinary citizens prior to the 1960s could get hold of an automatic weapon? Difficult to have a mass shooting using a Civil War musket.

Agrudge · 25/05/2022 10:52

Stopping responsible law-abiding gun owners from having guns will not stop this sort of thing from happening

Agreed.

They should bring into law gun safes. So kids/teenagers cant get hold the parents guns.

Acheyknees · 25/05/2022 10:38

I just can't understand why the USA allows 18 year olds to buy these powerful automatic rifles (not sure of the correct term). I understand there is a belief in the 'right' to have a gun, but surely not these huge powerful guns for 18 year olds. I frequently hear of peoples need to 'protect' themselves, so they buy a gun. The US must be awash with guns, from what I understand, citizens will never accept a ban. So why not control the access to powerful automatic rifles, an 18 year old does not need one of those!

DenholmElliot1 · 25/05/2022 10:36

It's a generational thing. When the current generation of 20 and 30 somethings gain political power they will vote for a ban on privately owned weapons. The baby boomers (who seem to think it's ok for these children to be slaughtered and that its a price worth paying so that they can have guns) will start to die off soon, and the voting result will change. It's just a matter of time but obviously they will have to tolerate this sort of thing until then.

orwellwasright · 25/05/2022 10:31

@BritWifeInUSA

You are missing the point when it comes to gun ownership. Stopping responsible law-abiding gun owners from having guns will not stop this sort of thing from happening

Would you still be opposed to tighter regulation if your children will killed by a school shooter?

Or would you say the murderer's right to bear arms was more important than your children's lives?

Genuine question, not rhetorical.

RedHelenB · 25/05/2022 10:23

Trainbear · 25/05/2022 07:37

Americans have had the right to bear arms since 1776.
School shootings such as this did not start until the 1960s.
This suggests that guns are secondary to a primary cause. Mental health.

Calling for gun control (and doing nothing) is easier than tackling a huge mental health issue.

How about something radical like doing both?

RedHelenB · 25/05/2022 10:20

BritWifeInUSA · 25/05/2022 01:00

He’s Hispanic. But I’m not sure what point you are making about race.

What do you think the solution is? Make all guns illegal? That’ll keep them off the streets, wing it? I mean, it worked for heroin and cocaine, right?

You are missing the point when it comes to gun ownership. Stopping responsible law-abiding gun owners from having guns will not stop this sort of thing from happening.

It did here. It did in New Zealand. There is no need to keep firearms apart from a very very small minority ( like farmers having a shotgun)

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 25/05/2022 10:18

Even if handguns and ordinary rifles were still freely available, why on earth they don’t ban automatic rifles I will never understand. Who on earth outside the military - or the police - ever needs one?

As has been pointed out, the constitutional right to bear arms was enshrined in law long before such weapons of mass murder were available.

ChristineCagney11 · 25/05/2022 10:12

iklboo · 25/05/2022 09:27

You are missing the point when it comes to gun ownership. Stopping responsible law-abiding gun owners from having guns will not stop this sort of thing from happening

Someone drank the Kool Aid.

Thankyou @iklboo
Bit of light relief

MoiraQueen · 25/05/2022 10:10

Completely agree with this. As a teenager I dreamed of living in the US. Now I wouldn't live there for any amount of money. The rest of the world is slowly waking up to the reality of the 'American Dream'. Britain is a shitshow, but I'd still rather be here.

I love the US (or parts of it!) I'm frequently on here defending it and I hate the anti American slant on MN, there are a lot of bloody lovely Americans and a lot of their country is breathtakingly stunning. But I'm not sure I could live there and like you it used to be my dream.

Bakedpotatoesfortea · 25/05/2022 10:05

Americans can keep their right to bare arms. But those arms don't have to be the kind of arms used in these shootings. Let them all have a 1777 pistol not a 2022 rifle and see the effect that has on mortality rates. Problem solved, no more school shootings. Because the shooter will get maybe one or two shoots at best.

We don't have a gun ban in the UK we have stricter laws on gun control, which is not the same thing. There are many people with a gun license. But these are harder to get, involve stringent checks and the types of weapon are restricted. America could absolutely improve gun controls in the same way over time and see a massive reduction in these kinds of incidents. Would it eradicate Them overnight? No. But it would improve the number and severity of incidents pretty damn quickly.

When your kid keeps drawing on the wall, you don't hand them crayons more easily, do you? No. You take the crayons. You hide the crayons. You only give them crayons when they have some paper to draw on. You make the crayons harder to get. You give them alternatives, why don't they play dolls or do jigsaws? They might still get hold of a crayon and draw on the wall, but there will be less crayon overall.

These teenagers are reaching out in desperation for something to help them, and instead of finding connection, community, therapy, mediation, love, a mentor, a parent, a friend, a priest, they are finding that a gun is in easier reach. But what if it was harder to get to a gun? What if it was so difficult to get one that by the time they did they had had a chance to make a different choice. They had a chance to fix some of their feelings and problems and never got to that gun at all?

The easiest intervention is to create distance. It is so much easier for a kid to not draw on the wall if they don't have any crayons. So much easier not to eat all the cookies if you don't buy any cookies. So much easier to not shoot up a school if you can't easily come by a gun.

The problem of disenfranchised young men, incels, racists etc. Is not unique to America, but the shootings are. And that can only be because of the availability of guns, and not just any guns but the kind that are largely restricted elsewhere in the world.

MermaidEyes · 25/05/2022 09:46

SomersetONeil · 25/05/2022 04:57

Honestly, America is a back water now.

It really is.

A Wild West mentality, where people can shoot ip swathes of people. And women’s rights’ eroding.

It is not an example, or a leader, and in any way aspirational.

It is quite the opposite.

Completely agree with this. As a teenager I dreamed of living in the US. Now I wouldn't live there for any amount of money. The rest of the world is slowly waking up to the reality of the 'American Dream'. Britain is a shitshow, but I'd still rather be here.

JosephdeMaistre · 25/05/2022 09:43

Stringent gun control works in other countries because personal fire arm ownership is low in the first place.

America has the highest rate of personal fire arm ownership in the world and they won’t give up their guns.

'1776 will commence again if you try to take our firearms' -Alex Jones.

TigerLilyTail · 25/05/2022 09:37

I always felt that if change didn’t happen after Sandy Hook, then it would never happen, but I do hope that maybe with newer generations, minds will change.

I find it hard to imagine the police will be against a change in the law. How many police officers are killed by guns every year?

pixie5121 · 25/05/2022 09:35

This reply has been withdrawn

Withdrawn at poster's request.

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 25/05/2022 09:31

Trainbear · 25/05/2022 07:37

Americans have had the right to bear arms since 1776.
School shootings such as this did not start until the 1960s.
This suggests that guns are secondary to a primary cause. Mental health.

Calling for gun control (and doing nothing) is easier than tackling a huge mental health issue.

That's more to do with the fact that;

  1. Mass education for all wasn't really a thing until after ww2, less than 10% of 15-18 years were attending high school in 1920 rising to 75% by 1940 but then there was the war.

  2. Automatic or semi-automatic guns that allow people to commit mass shootings didn't exist until the turn of the 20th century and weren't easily available to the general public from the get go. Interestingly, the AR-15 so often used in these butcherings went on sale to the American public in 1960, exactly when you claim mass school shootings started.

Mental health may well be an underlying factor but I would argue not a primary cause, unless you subscribe to the thought that people who are racist, homophobic, misogynistic, or full of hate are just mentally unwell. Guns, and semi automatic guns in particular, are without doubt the primary driver for mass shootings.

No guns = no shootings. Tight gun control = less shooting (which is the best America can hope for).

knittingaddict · 25/05/2022 09:30

SomersetONeil · 25/05/2022 04:57

Honestly, America is a back water now.

It really is.

A Wild West mentality, where people can shoot ip swathes of people. And women’s rights’ eroding.

It is not an example, or a leader, and in any way aspirational.

It is quite the opposite.

All of this is so true.

Any credibility the US had is gone now. I'm embarrassed for them.

iklboo · 25/05/2022 09:27

You are missing the point when it comes to gun ownership. Stopping responsible law-abiding gun owners from having guns will not stop this sort of thing from happening

Someone drank the Kool Aid.

CharSiu · 25/05/2022 09:24

There are white supremacist massacres but the other type of mass killing is carried out by young men who are part of or heavily influenced by the INCEL online subculture. This young man was not white, his life will be studied and it may transpire he was influenced by this culture. If you are unaware of this growing subculture have a quick read of this it’s a BBC news link so safe www.bbc.co.uk/news/blogs-trending-44053828

There have always been outsiders in life, men and women who struggle to fit in. Now people can congregate online. There have been many threads on here over the years with people admitting to being lonely and without friends, it’s a common recurring theme. Now imagine loneliness but with impressionable misogynistic young men who have grown up in an online world, it’s a world they can slip in to all too easily. It obviously does not mean they are all destined to become killers. but it’s an incredibly dangerous world.

ahhhhhhhhhhhhh · 25/05/2022 09:23

ineedsun · 25/05/2022 08:23

This needs repeating ad infinitum.

How do gun lobbyists square this in their own heads?

THIS!

Its not just the mass school shootings it’s also the accidental shootings when little Lucy finds Daddy’s gun in the cupboard and thinks it’s a toy and shoots her baby brother…

I also used to think the USA was so amazing and progressive! In reality it just appears it’s potentially pretty damn dangerous unless you’re a white straight rich man…

On my list of ‘would NEVER live here’ alongside a few others where women and their unborn babies are actively punished for unwanted pregnancies and just going to school can be fatal.

Mally100 · 25/05/2022 09:14

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 25/05/2022 08:42

How are schools so accessible? I can't speak for all UK primary schools but every single one I've beeb past/people I know attend; have high fencing, locked gates all day etc. It would be almost impossible for anyone to access the grounds without scaling these fences, but by that point they'd be spotted and the police called.

How is it possible to get into Elementary/Middle/High Schools in the US - why wouldnt they fence them all?

I've also wondered this. With these types of incidents, they have always walked in and went to a class or teaching area. How does nobody stop them before that ? In our schools, you can't get pass the gate without a member of staff vetting you. School gate is locked and entry into the building- you need to be buzzed in.

AnneElliott · 25/05/2022 09:09

Absolutely tragic for those poor children and their families. And I can't see America ever changing their rules - they didn't after Sandy Hook so what on earth will make them change then now?

Completely bonkers to let normal people own semi automatic weapons. There is just no lawful need to own such a thing.

MoiraQueen · 25/05/2022 08:57

You are missing the point when it comes to gun ownership. Stopping responsible law-abiding gun owners from having guns will not stop this sort of thing from happening

The thing is you don't need to ban all guns, the UK hasn't. Certain types of gun are banned and you have to adhere to rules and regulations, mainly safety related when owning a gun. Why do so many Americans act as if it is an all or nothing solution, are the militant people the ones who know they won't be granted guns if legislation is tightened?

pixie5121 · 25/05/2022 08:53

This reply has been withdrawn

Withdrawn at poster's request.

Theluggage15 · 25/05/2022 08:47

Same for me @Toddlerteaplease If it had happened in Germany, Spain, Australia or wherever I would have been horrified but I saw the news and just thought oh another one.

Swipe left for the next trending thread