Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

American needs to fight against terror closer to home

314 replies

josil · 25/05/2022 00:25

And focus their energy on teenage boys who seem to be causing terror frequently by shooting us schools. Supermarkets etc etc.

What never ceases to amaze me is somehow these shooters manage to escape the stereotypes that others ethnic groups find it impossible to shake off.

RIP to those dead ok the latest massacre in the US.

The US needs to fight against terror and start with those close to home.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Cartoonmom · 28/05/2022 13:32

@DdraigGoch - I agree that federal legislation is the best way forward because our state borders are very porous. But even with guns traveling from less restrictive states to stricter ones, the data shows that gun deaths are lower per capita in states with stricter gun control laws.

So if you look at gun deaths for every 100,000 people - the rate of gun related deaths in Illinois is far lower than the rate of gun related deaths in Mississippi. You can check out the link I posted above if you are interested.

Cartoonmom · 28/05/2022 00:15

@Valeriekat - is your Utah data re gun deaths in total or per capita/adjusted for population differences? If you check out this link Utah does not fair well at all re gun deaths when adjusted for population. everytownresearch.org/rankings/

knitnerd90 · 27/05/2022 23:03

Defunding the police has happened in news headlines, not in reality. So it's not a factor.

DdraigGoch · 27/05/2022 21:33

Valeriekat · 26/05/2022 07:28

Mitt Romney has been the biggest recipient of NRA cash and it is quite a lot of it too $13,647,676. However the number of gun related deaths in Utah is among the lowest in the country. States with strict gun control laws do not have fewer shootings so it is not as simple as people in the UK seem to think.

The reason that states with stricter gun laws are no safer than those without is simply that it's very straightforward to just drive over the border and buy one there. That's why action needs to be at a Federal level.

DdraigGoch · 27/05/2022 21:30

samyeagar · 26/05/2022 02:18

I am going to split hairs here as this goes into two separate issues. Gun related injury and gun related crime.

In the context of this thread and what I was talking about gun crime and in particular mass school shootings. Those numbers you cited, while absolutely correct, include accidents and suicide, which make up a large majority of all gun related deaths.

Those are two different issues which require different approaches to solve.

Not really that different, the solution is still to make it more difficult to access firearms, particularly the most dangerous ones.

samyeagar · 27/05/2022 17:45

CheerfulYank · 27/05/2022 17:25

Ted Cruz is a complete asshat and I cannot stand him, but I think what he is suggesting is implementing doors that you can get out of easily but not into.

No small part of what we are seeing and struggling with, is with the extreme polarity, and not just in politics, but a polarized population in general is that any ideas at all are being solely judged on the person who says them, so if my guy says 'it', no matter what 'it', it is the only way, but if the other guy says 'it', no matter what 'it' is, it must be wrong, and we must do the exact opposite.

CheerfulYank · 27/05/2022 17:25

AuxArmesCitoyens · 27/05/2022 11:39

Ted Cruz suggests only having one way in or out of schools. That does not sound like good fire safety planning to me.

Ted Cruz is a complete asshat and I cannot stand him, but I think what he is suggesting is implementing doors that you can get out of easily but not into.

AuxArmesCitoyens · 27/05/2022 11:39

Ted Cruz suggests only having one way in or out of schools. That does not sound like good fire safety planning to me.

AuxArmesCitoyens · 27/05/2022 11:37

@BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz the suggestions I am seeing on Twitter by gun nuts involve actually physically locking kids into classrooms, not just buzzing people in at the front gate.

CaveMum · 27/05/2022 10:00

I’ve just read that the husband of Irma Garcia, one of the teachers killed in the attack, has died from a reported heart attack. They have 4 children aged 12-23.

My heart breaks, again, for this community.

Trainbear · 27/05/2022 08:33

knitnerd90 · 27/05/2022 08:05

It's just bloody awful. I like living in the USA actually and my area is so different from what many Brits imagine the USA to be like. It's just so frustrating as a majority of Americans do want to tighten the laws and ... the politicians just won't. Meanwhile the police seem to have done a terrible job so how can we expect more security theatre to improve a thing?

(Also I should have said "laxer" not "stricter"! Oops.)

Are there more or fewer gun crimes/ any crimes in areas where the police have been defunded?

knitnerd90 · 27/05/2022 08:05

CheerfulYank · 27/05/2022 03:44

Yes.

How are you? Everyone I know here is shellshocked and numb right now. It’s…I don’t even know what to say or do anymore.

It's just bloody awful. I like living in the USA actually and my area is so different from what many Brits imagine the USA to be like. It's just so frustrating as a majority of Americans do want to tighten the laws and ... the politicians just won't. Meanwhile the police seem to have done a terrible job so how can we expect more security theatre to improve a thing?

(Also I should have said "laxer" not "stricter"! Oops.)

CaveMum · 27/05/2022 07:59

Totally agree that the time for strict gun control has long passed in the US - Sandy Hook showed that. Modifications can be made to laws but the idea that everyone will just hand their guns back as as unrealistic as expecting everyone to be given their own gun for personal protection.

A key thing that has to be addressed is what “makes” a young male (because let’s face it, the majority of them are) carry out such an act. There are always signs, no one jumps from regular guy to mass murderer in one easy step in the same way that men who rape and murder usually have a history of “minor” sex offences like indecent exposure.

I’m not saying it is all about mental health but there are always patterns of behaviour in these cases so why isn’t money being spent to try and look at how to help and support disenfranchised young men and prevent more of these atrocities?

I am in no way trying to excuse the actions of these men and boys by saying “poor them, they just need more hugs”, but I refuse to believe that some kind of intervention earlier in their lives wouldn’t have had the potential to stop things escalating so far.

Dashdotdotdash · 27/05/2022 07:48

I am going to split hairs here as this goes into two separate issues. Gun related injury and gun related crime.

In the context of this thread and what I was talking about gun crime and in particular mass school shootings. Those numbers you cited, while absolutely correct, include accidents and suicide, which make up a large majority of all gun related deaths.

Those are two different issues which require different approaches to solve.

But they aren't really different issues, are they? Mass shootings happen because of easy access to guns. Fatal ccidents involving guns happen for the same reason. And I suspect that at least some of those suicides wouldn't happen if the means of killing yourself didn't come so easily to hand.

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 27/05/2022 07:13

AuxArmesCitoyens · 27/05/2022 07:11

If you lock down schools so they are hard to get into, eventually kids will die in a fire because they can't get out easily either.

Uk schools are well fenced off to intruders. When was the last time you heard of one being on fire or another emergency which left the children trapped?

AuxArmesCitoyens · 27/05/2022 07:11

If you lock down schools so they are hard to get into, eventually kids will die in a fire because they can't get out easily either.

DrippyLongstocking · 27/05/2022 05:27

CheerfulYank · 27/05/2022 05:08

So then we’ll die. Because that won’t happen. Even if it went through, many gun owners won’t give up theirs willingly. The police won’t go take them. The army may, but it would lead to Civil War. I mean that literally.

If it’s truly the case that any meaningful restrictions on gun ownership are impossible, then a higher incidence of mass shootings is part of the reality of being American.

Maybe big societal changes like universal access to mental healthcare would reduce it a little, but ultimately country with massive gun ownership and loose restrictions thereon will inevitably have a high incidence of mass shootings.

If the negatives outweigh the positives of living there, and you are able to, you emigrate.

CheerfulYank · 27/05/2022 05:08

DrippyLongstocking · 27/05/2022 04:45

It’s that or gun control.

So then we’ll die. Because that won’t happen. Even if it went through, many gun owners won’t give up theirs willingly. The police won’t go take them. The army may, but it would lead to Civil War. I mean that literally.

DrippyLongstocking · 27/05/2022 04:45

It’s that or gun control.

CheerfulYank · 27/05/2022 04:31

DrippyLongstocking · 27/05/2022 04:20

It would likely cost billions and billions to implement (I see one company has managed to get the cost-per-door down to $2,500, so times that by the amount of schools in the country, then the number of doors per school) and there’s no real evidence to suggest it’d be effective. That’s only the doors, of course, which would likely be a small fraction of the overall costs of fully securing a school.

Lock them down completely (yards and school
gates included) and I’m sure you’ll see a rise in shootings at movie theatres, soft play areas, youth centres and alike. Already school shootings only account for 11% of mass shootings in public places.

Either you heavily secure and militarize most/all public spaces, or introduce gun control, or carry on as is.

Just to add that I’m not saying that it’s not worth spending billions to protect children, but even if the country found that political will to do so, it just doesn’t sound like a realistic solution to me.

Yup, we’ll just die.

DrippyLongstocking · 27/05/2022 04:20

CheerfulYank · 27/05/2022 04:07

And adaption takes time. Yes they will adapt. Sick fucks always find a way. But it would save some kids in the meantime. Banning guns would take much much longer and cause untold disaster in the meantime.

It would likely cost billions and billions to implement (I see one company has managed to get the cost-per-door down to $2,500, so times that by the amount of schools in the country, then the number of doors per school) and there’s no real evidence to suggest it’d be effective. That’s only the doors, of course, which would likely be a small fraction of the overall costs of fully securing a school.

Lock them down completely (yards and school
gates included) and I’m sure you’ll see a rise in shootings at movie theatres, soft play areas, youth centres and alike. Already school shootings only account for 11% of mass shootings in public places.

Either you heavily secure and militarize most/all public spaces, or introduce gun control, or carry on as is.

Just to add that I’m not saying that it’s not worth spending billions to protect children, but even if the country found that political will to do so, it just doesn’t sound like a realistic solution to me.

CheerfulYank · 27/05/2022 04:07

And adaption takes time. Yes they will adapt. Sick fucks always find a way. But it would save some kids in the meantime. Banning guns would take much much longer and cause untold disaster in the meantime.

CheerfulYank · 27/05/2022 04:06

DrippyLongstocking · 27/05/2022 03:46

But surely all that would happen if all schools had bullet proof doors and windows and lock down the external doors, all that will happen is that shooters will adapt their tactics (shootings in the playground or at the school gates, for example)?

Possibly. Probably. But moving targets are quite hard to hit. The worst cases are those like the most recent atrocity, where some unhinged monster with a gun can barricade themselves in a room and murder everyone in it in minutes.

DrippyLongstocking · 27/05/2022 03:46

CheerfulYank · 27/05/2022 02:59

Because gun control is all the Left consider. I think it would be lovely but it also isn’t going to happen. The laws we do have are already abused in many ways and some places with tighter gun control (Chicago) have some of the worst gun crime.

We need to focus on actual solutions that can be passed right NOW instead of pointing fingers. Yes I DO lay most of the blame on the Right, for their refusal to act and the insane gun culture many of them revel in, but the Left pooh-poohing any measure like bulletproof doors and the like is also not helping.

That monster bought those guns legally. Clearly that system is fucked. But the reality is, he bought them legally. Bulletproof doors would have saved those babies.

But surely all that would happen if all schools had bullet proof doors and windows and lock down the external doors, all that will happen is that shooters will adapt their tactics (shootings in the playground or at the school gates, for example)?

CheerfulYank · 27/05/2022 03:44

knitnerd90 · 27/05/2022 03:41

The thing is that the guns in Chicago don't come from Chicago; they come from neighboring states with stricter gun laws. This is why it's so hard and there needs to be federal action, but then you get caught in who can regulate what. I live outside DC, which has strict laws (except the ones the Supreme Court struck down) but it's not at all difficult to go to other states to get them, I think VA is more lax.

Yes.

How are you? Everyone I know here is shellshocked and numb right now. It’s…I don’t even know what to say or do anymore.

Swipe left for the next trending thread