Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to offer cash to other passengers for their seats on flight

414 replies

Blewitagain · 24/05/2022 22:26

I am going on holiday and have discovered I haven't pre booked seats on our flights. I'm traveling with two children. This was an oversight. I can get two seats which would leave eldest sat alone.

Would it be weird to take cash to compensate anyone willing to move seat? No one might be willing to move but I'm hoping.

I once travelled last minute in an emergency and no one was willing to move seats.

OP posts:
notimagain · 25/05/2022 11:07

@Thebeastofsleep

There will be several single passengers who don't pay to choose their seat (like me) who can be moved around the cabin to accommodate the automatic grouping of seats and that wouldn't show as occupied in the paid-seat selection section. This isn't an idea - this is a functioning, working program in use by some airlines.

Sounds reasonable, if I'm travelling solo, not in a rush etc I'll happily take my chances.

The issue for me is the perception some seem to have that solo passengers can and perhaps should always be prepared to give up seat they have chosen to facilitate a group being together...IMHO that's an unreasonable expectation.

5128gap · 25/05/2022 11:04

LookingGlassMilk · 25/05/2022 10:36

YANBU, I would swap seats in those circumstances and I wouldn't take any money off you. In fact, if I was sitting alone beside a mother and a young child, and I noticed that she had another child or teenager sitting apart, I would offer to swap. The same way I would offer a seat on a bus or a train to someone who was more in need, except on the plane I still end up with a seat.

I don't know what is wrong with people on mumsnet. While there have been some valid reasons mentioned for not swapping, such as being neurodiverse and needing a particular seat, most people just seem to be trying to competitively out arsehole each other.

I think its really unfair to call people arseholes because they might not want to be inconvenienced or out of pocket to facilitate someone else's parenting. Its not a pleasant position to put someone in, because effectively they're made to feel that the flight experience of a child they've never met is down to them rather than the parent's oversight.
Most people are actually happy to do their bit to support parents, but its not the default that every adult in the world has to put the needs of parents above their own.
Parenting is not the same as having a disability, it's a choice that carries responsibilities and the understanding should be that that's on you as the parent to meet them. Help and special concessions from strangers a bonus, but not a right.

countrygirl99 · 25/05/2022 10:57

Discovereads · 25/05/2022 10:21

No the specific item of choosing a seat was never part of the price you paid until it was introduced as a separate charge. Airlines used to have a policy of passenger Tetris where they would automatically try to keep group bookings seated together. Now they have a policy of deliberately splitting up all bookings as much as possible specifically so they can then charge extra for seat selection. This disportionately affects young families and disabled who can least afford the extra charges.

Airline tickets have been steadily getting cheaper since the 1960s due to competition, the advent of online price comparison sites, increased fuel efficiency in the newer aircraft, and so on. So the fact you paid a higher price in 1996 is just part of the general trend and not evidence of how their pricing structure was back then.

Actually it's a good point that you couldn't pick your seat back in the day. I remember a long haul flight late 90s where DH was one end of the plane with DS1 and I was at the other end with DS2. Much better to be able to pay to pick your seat if it's important to you or not if you aren't bothered. But you should acknowledge that it's largely the low cost carriers that drove the competition that reduced prices with innovative practices.

Thebeastofsleep · 25/05/2022 10:56

notimagain · 25/05/2022 10:50

I don't know what is wrong with people on mumsnet. While there have been some valid reasons mentioned for not swapping, such as being neurodiverse and needing a particular seat, most people just seem to be trying to competitively out arsehole each other.

...More a case that some people who invest time on-line and money on getting a seat that meets their specification (and there doesn't need to be a medical reason behind the choice) are getting a bit hacked off when some seemingly expect they should shift, gratis.....

Like others I've moved seats to help out on occasions but even I might end up a bit arseholey if I was travelling on a flight where for whatever reason I'd paid for an aisle seat up front and was being pressurised to move towards the back of the aircraft to make life more convenient for another passenger.

There are ways round this though. An automatically allocated seat, next to the others in your booking. Some people can then pay to choose a specific seat to their liking. There will be several single passengers who don't pay to choose their seat (like me) who can be moved around the cabin to accommodate the automatic grouping of seats and that wouldn't show as occupied in the paid-seat selection section. This isn't an idea - this is a functioning, working program in use by some airlines.

I can almost get over with cheap airlines, but when the more 'luxury' airlines (virgin, I'm looking at you) and supposed all inclusive package deals (first choice) I think it is simply criminal.

Wafflesnsniffles · 25/05/2022 10:52

How long is the flight? At 12 yes sure your eldest might want to sit with you but if the flight is only an hour or so I dont really see the problem.

notimagain · 25/05/2022 10:50

I don't know what is wrong with people on mumsnet. While there have been some valid reasons mentioned for not swapping, such as being neurodiverse and needing a particular seat, most people just seem to be trying to competitively out arsehole each other.

...More a case that some people who invest time on-line and money on getting a seat that meets their specification (and there doesn't need to be a medical reason behind the choice) are getting a bit hacked off when some seemingly expect they should shift, gratis.....

Like others I've moved seats to help out on occasions but even I might end up a bit arseholey if I was travelling on a flight where for whatever reason I'd paid for an aisle seat up front and was being pressurised to move towards the back of the aircraft to make life more convenient for another passenger.

Rosehugger · 25/05/2022 10:48

"With" is defined as per CAA guidelines and can include across aisle, or in row in front or behind. It doesn't necessarily mean "next to". The only way to guarantee next to is to pay for it

Probably fine for most people. Other than those sitting next to a baby - but then that's the airline's problem. They have made it their problem.

Thebeastofsleep · 25/05/2022 10:46

I understand it is a money making exercise for the airline, however I do not understand what benefit is for the airline to have young children away from their parents. Seems a gamble to me that the parent will pay to sit with them. I wouldn't want to sit next to an unaccompanied child, even if traveling with my own children (so where I couldn't offer to move). What if the child is abused? Surely the airline has a responsibility?

PeekAtYou · 25/05/2022 10:46

Just asked my teen and he'd move for cash and so would I. The cash offered needs to be at least the charge for allocated seating

rainbowmilk · 25/05/2022 10:43

Rosehugger · 25/05/2022 10:40

If you are on your own with them and they are under twelve they will both be sat next to you anyway. Children under 12 have to be seated with at least one parent or guardian. The only reason to book and pay for seats is if you are a larger family group and all want to sit together.

I don't know what the rules are for children aged 12 and over who have a disability and need to be sat next to a parent. You really shouldn't have to pay extra for a measure resulting from a disability. Ryanair were hauled over the coals for something similar.

"With" is defined as per CAA guidelines and can include across aisle, or in row in front or behind. It doesn't necessarily mean "next to". The only way to guarantee next to is to pay for it.

notacooldad · 25/05/2022 10:42

MrsJorahMormont
Feel free 🤷‍♀️
Interesting engagement if my post!🤣🤣
Is it a case of shutting me down having the last word over me or do you prefer the old way of flying where it was more expensive but you paid for things you didnt need or care about?

TheOriginalClownfish · 25/05/2022 10:40

I'd move because it doesn't bother me where I sit, DP probably would as well, and only one of us needs to sit with DS. I'd do it for free but if you offered me a glass of wine as a thank you I'd be chuffed.

If you are polite when asking, and gracious to anyone who refuses due to their own personal reasons then no harm done really.

myusernamewastakenbyme · 25/05/2022 10:40

I flew Ryanair last week and sat apart from my partner...I quite enjoyed the chat i had with the stranger sat next to me.
On another note...who in their right mind pays for priority boarding...what an utter waste of money.

Rosehugger · 25/05/2022 10:40

If you are on your own with them and they are under twelve they will both be sat next to you anyway. Children under 12 have to be seated with at least one parent or guardian. The only reason to book and pay for seats is if you are a larger family group and all want to sit together.

I don't know what the rules are for children aged 12 and over who have a disability and need to be sat next to a parent. You really shouldn't have to pay extra for a measure resulting from a disability. Ryanair were hauled over the coals for something similar.

LookingGlassMilk · 25/05/2022 10:36

YANBU, I would swap seats in those circumstances and I wouldn't take any money off you. In fact, if I was sitting alone beside a mother and a young child, and I noticed that she had another child or teenager sitting apart, I would offer to swap. The same way I would offer a seat on a bus or a train to someone who was more in need, except on the plane I still end up with a seat.

I don't know what is wrong with people on mumsnet. While there have been some valid reasons mentioned for not swapping, such as being neurodiverse and needing a particular seat, most people just seem to be trying to competitively out arsehole each other.

TheHumanSatsuma · 25/05/2022 10:34

TheHumanSatsuma · 25/05/2022 10:33

Exactlyy

Ignore this, replied to wrong thread!

TheHumanSatsuma · 25/05/2022 10:33

Exactlyy

MrsSkylerWhite · 25/05/2022 10:33

orangeisthenewpuce
Anyone who takes the money to move is a tight arsed skinflint imo“

don’t be silly. They’ve paid extra for their seats. You’d effectively give up to £50 to a stranger who wanted your seats?

ifonly4 · 25/05/2022 10:30

To be honest I wouldn't change my seat last minute. I know it's a small risk but my name would be allocated to that seat and in the event of an accident it helps trace who some people are very quickly if they're in the correct seat.

notimagain · 25/05/2022 10:26

XelaM · 25/05/2022 10:24

Yes, we have a small dog. A dog up to 8Kg is allowed to travel in the cabin. We have taken our previous fog on flights a few times. Dog can sit with my daughter and I am happy to sit on my own 🤣🍹

FWIW Dogs in cabin allowed or not depends on the airline/national rules...

XelaM · 25/05/2022 10:24

dog*

MrsJorahMormont · 25/05/2022 10:24

notacooldad · 25/05/2022 10:21

Tbh my contempt for budget airlines has put me off flying full stop. We booked flights recently and from here on we're doing packages or nothing. There is nothing budget about budget airlines any more and they've made flying utterly joyless
I disagree with this post.
Flying is relatively cheap , if you have flexibility. I like paying for what I need.
So far this year I have paid £34 for a return flight to Malaga and £28 return to Prague. I have just booked for Spain again for £16 return.
There's no rxtra flight costs. I dont care where I sit, I don't want to pay for cases as I always travel cabin bag only unless I'm away for more than 2 weeks.
I have paid for seats twice in the last 15 years.Both times it was because I was with a nervous passenger so I was happy to pay an extra 10 quid each way to make them feel comfortable.

Feel free 🤷‍♀️

XelaM · 25/05/2022 10:24

CloudPop · 25/05/2022 09:59

The dog ?

Yes, we have a small dog. A dog up to 8Kg is allowed to travel in the cabin. We have taken our previous fog on flights a few times. Dog can sit with my daughter and I am happy to sit on my own 🤣🍹

Discovereads · 25/05/2022 10:21

countrygirl99 · 25/05/2022 10:10

Actually it was included in the price so you paid whether you wanted it or not. I was sorting through some stuff yesterday and came across some details I had kept from a trip to Berlin in 1996. I was shocked how much we paid for flights as I could easily get a cheaper flight now and at the time they were bargain tickets.

No the specific item of choosing a seat was never part of the price you paid until it was introduced as a separate charge. Airlines used to have a policy of passenger Tetris where they would automatically try to keep group bookings seated together. Now they have a policy of deliberately splitting up all bookings as much as possible specifically so they can then charge extra for seat selection. This disportionately affects young families and disabled who can least afford the extra charges.

Airline tickets have been steadily getting cheaper since the 1960s due to competition, the advent of online price comparison sites, increased fuel efficiency in the newer aircraft, and so on. So the fact you paid a higher price in 1996 is just part of the general trend and not evidence of how their pricing structure was back then.

notacooldad · 25/05/2022 10:21

Tbh my contempt for budget airlines has put me off flying full stop. We booked flights recently and from here on we're doing packages or nothing. There is nothing budget about budget airlines any more and they've made flying utterly joyless
I disagree with this post.
Flying is relatively cheap , if you have flexibility. I like paying for what I need.
So far this year I have paid £34 for a return flight to Malaga and £28 return to Prague. I have just booked for Spain again for £16 return.
There's no rxtra flight costs. I dont care where I sit, I don't want to pay for cases as I always travel cabin bag only unless I'm away for more than 2 weeks.
I have paid for seats twice in the last 15 years.Both times it was because I was with a nervous passenger so I was happy to pay an extra 10 quid each way to make them feel comfortable.

Swipe left for the next trending thread