Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to offer cash to other passengers for their seats on flight

414 replies

Blewitagain · 24/05/2022 22:26

I am going on holiday and have discovered I haven't pre booked seats on our flights. I'm traveling with two children. This was an oversight. I can get two seats which would leave eldest sat alone.

Would it be weird to take cash to compensate anyone willing to move seat? No one might be willing to move but I'm hoping.

I once travelled last minute in an emergency and no one was willing to move seats.

OP posts:
notacooldad · 25/05/2022 14:44

To be honest I wouldn't change my seat last minute. I know it's a small risk but my name would be allocated to that seat and in the event of an accident it helps trace who some people are very quickly if they're in the correct seat

If it was that important the canine staff woulnr allow anyone to change seats once they've said " boarding complete"
Go on any Ryan flight from from Liverpool where there's a hen party or stag do going to Benidorm and it's a wonder anyone sits on their original allocated seat! 🤣🤣

Regularsizedrudy · 25/05/2022 14:41

I’m not reading 13 pages so sorry if this has been said but are you sure the airline staff will take kindly to you wandering around flapping cash at people?

Thebeastofsleep · 25/05/2022 14:38

rainbowmilk · 25/05/2022 14:23

@Thebeastofsleep I'm not convinced the idea is workable - what would happen if there weren't enough free seats for every group wanting to travel and there weren't enough single passengers to accommodate this? (I'm thinking in particular of charter flights to Florida in summer - very few single people on those flights). They'd have to sit apart. Only difference is they'd be arguing with people who hadn't paid to reserve their seats, but who'd booked early enough to benefit from there being free seats available together - and I still don't think many people would move, in that scenario. That's kind of emphasised by this thread, really.

And no, I don't particularly want to sit next to a stranger's young child but I'd expect their parent to do the necessary to avoid that happening by ensuring that parent and child were sitting together (where possible - clearly the OP is in a different scenario). If parent is "happy" for a stranger to be ignoring their child and having no responsibility whatsoever to them, then that's on them, but I'd feel sorry for the child in that scenario having such a person as a caregiver.

Personally I think in a Florida holiday type scenario seats should just be preallocated like in the old days! Find out your seat when you arrive at the airport. Stops random single seats being left.

SofiaSoFar · 25/05/2022 14:33

Blossomtoes · 25/05/2022 12:23

I actually think that would be a far better way to do it. Why are people “entitled fuckers” to expect airlines to provide something free of charge when there’s no actual cost? It must piss people like you off no end to hear that this “entitled fucker” has never paid to select a seat, yet always gets a pair of seats together - usually seat and window. You’re paying for that and I’m not.

The "at no cost" bit is a red herring. They need to get a level of revenue to make flights profitable or, as things currently are, make the least loss they can.

If they need to average £110 per ticket to do that, and some people are happy with a random seat at £100 and others prefer a selected seat at £120 then that works for everyone. If no one ever paid, they'd have to increase the base ticket cost.

It doesn't piss me off in the slightest by the way, much to your disappointment I'm sure.

I can't remember the last time I flew in economy so seat selection charges isn't something I come across very often at all.

I doubt anyone here is half as indignant at your entitled attitude as you'd like to think.

Poppyseed14 · 25/05/2022 14:25

OP have you managed to speak to the airline yet?

rainbowmilk · 25/05/2022 14:23

@Thebeastofsleep I'm not convinced the idea is workable - what would happen if there weren't enough free seats for every group wanting to travel and there weren't enough single passengers to accommodate this? (I'm thinking in particular of charter flights to Florida in summer - very few single people on those flights). They'd have to sit apart. Only difference is they'd be arguing with people who hadn't paid to reserve their seats, but who'd booked early enough to benefit from there being free seats available together - and I still don't think many people would move, in that scenario. That's kind of emphasised by this thread, really.

And no, I don't particularly want to sit next to a stranger's young child but I'd expect their parent to do the necessary to avoid that happening by ensuring that parent and child were sitting together (where possible - clearly the OP is in a different scenario). If parent is "happy" for a stranger to be ignoring their child and having no responsibility whatsoever to them, then that's on them, but I'd feel sorry for the child in that scenario having such a person as a caregiver.

PacificWalrus · 25/05/2022 14:13

If someone offered me cash to change seats, to be honest I would feel quite awkward and embarrassed about the whole situation. If I didn't mind changing then I would - and would refuse cash. If I did mind changing, I would feel put on the spot.

I can't think of a way of offering this cash without it being massively cringe.

I mean what do you say - 'excuse me would you mind changing seats so my family can sit together'

'Sure' - great, no embarrassing/vulgar offers of cash needed.

' No I am sorry, I deliberately chose this aisle/window/whatever seat and prefer not to move. 'OK how about if I offer cash'. Just NO - so cringeworthy.

You can hardly announce this offer in the aisle as the logistics are too confusing whilst everyone is trying to get on, sitting down etc..

maddy68 · 25/05/2022 14:08

My husband has anxiety when he flies. He books the right seat for him. He definitely would not nice and nor should he. If you want seats together you need to book them I would feel uncomfortable vwirh someone asking me to move

CorpseReviver · 25/05/2022 13:59

Morph22010 · 25/05/2022 13:54

In the event of an emergency like the plane crashing people won’t all be seated nicely in seats, they prob won’t even be in one piece and will have zero chance of identifying everyone from seat records

This is completely untrue. You're obviously not a fan of Admiral Cloudberg's 'plane crash series'. They have frequently identified people based on their seats after crashes.

www.popularmechanics.com/flight/a1918/4219452/

time.com/3934663/safest-seat-airplane/

www.reddit.com/r/MorbidReality/comments/1e2qlo/a_seat_map_showing_fatalities_and_injuries_on/

Morph22010 · 25/05/2022 13:54

ifonly4 · 25/05/2022 10:30

To be honest I wouldn't change my seat last minute. I know it's a small risk but my name would be allocated to that seat and in the event of an accident it helps trace who some people are very quickly if they're in the correct seat.

In the event of an emergency like the plane crashing people won’t all be seated nicely in seats, they prob won’t even be in one piece and will have zero chance of identifying everyone from seat records

LookingGlassMilk · 25/05/2022 13:43

No one said that being a considerate person is compulsory, or that anyone has a 'right' to anything just because they have children.

People obviously have the right to focus on themselves and their own wants/needs. It's just not how I was raised. I don't only offer seats on buses and trains to disabled and elderly people, I also offer my seat to pregnant women and people with young children. It's completely irrelevant that they chose to have the children.

As I go about my life I always try to be considerate of others, irrespective of whether they have 'the right'. Low paid waiters and waitresses don't have a 'right' to a tip, but I always tip them anyway because I remember what it was like to be a low paid waitress.

And before anyone mentions anything about female socialisation, I learned this from watching my Dad, who is a complete gentleman.

If I am flying with my family I will always pay to stay together, but most of the flights I take these days are on my own. I usually opt for an aisle seat, but it really wouldn't be much skin off my nose to swap seats for a nervous 12 year old, even to a rubbish middle one.

The arseholery I referred to is from posters on this thread and the general attitude towards a nervous 12 year old.

I'd also like to add that flying frequently as an unaccompanied minor does not necessarily translate into being a good flyer when you get older. I flew on my own from the age of 10, and by 16 was taking a return shorthaul flight every weekend. I still hate flying.

Blewitagain · 25/05/2022 13:43

LoveHeartsFan · 25/05/2022 12:59

So who would you approach then, OP? The little old lady with a nice face? Who might struggle out of her seat? The middle-aged woman because she’s probably a Mum? The solo girl because she probably hasn’t reserved her seat?

Or the solo lad who might be tanked? The businessman giving off ‘don’t disturb me’ vibes?

A lot of this is predicated on social conditioning, and women being ‘nice’. That middle-aged woman might be working or have an unseen disability and so might the young girl.

Yes I was planning on targeting passengers based on vulnerability. Or I was going to ask those in neighbouring seats?!

OP posts:
Thebeastofsleep · 25/05/2022 13:40

I mean "you" more generally.

Thebeastofsleep · 25/05/2022 13:38

rainbowmilk · 25/05/2022 13:22

You are suggesting that parents should be able to choose their desired seating (next to one another) for free. Yes, they might not get 3A and 3B, but they will get an A and a B without paying for it. By contrast, a couple without children would not be able to do that without paying. I don't think that's right.

I prefer the way it is now: if you want a certain seat (be that in terms of where it is on the plane, or who it's next to) you pay for it. If you don't, you save money.

And lets say, I am happy to be seated away from my kids (aged 3&6) would you be happy to seated next to them? I wouldn't be happy seated next to other peoples kids.

And you can say "oh I'd just ignore them" and I would, but I also wouldn't want them touching me, or playing loudly on their tablets/ with their toys or spilling food on me. But if the fasten seatbelt sigh is on, this isn't something the parents could manage.

And there are times, like in the OP where it isn't possible to pay for seats together, like if the OP had only just booked. Using the system I described above, single passengers who have not paid to select their seat would automatically be moved, no disturbance to those who had paid.

Thebeastofsleep · 25/05/2022 13:30

rainbowmilk · 25/05/2022 13:22

You are suggesting that parents should be able to choose their desired seating (next to one another) for free. Yes, they might not get 3A and 3B, but they will get an A and a B without paying for it. By contrast, a couple without children would not be able to do that without paying. I don't think that's right.

I prefer the way it is now: if you want a certain seat (be that in terms of where it is on the plane, or who it's next to) you pay for it. If you don't, you save money.

No. I am suggesting that a group who books together (adults or children, just any group) are automatically allocated seats together. So, me, my mum and my sister (all adults) are allocated row 26, seats d,e&f (e.g the 3 middle seats of a large aircraft). if we want to sit at the front, at the back, have a window seat or any seat other than those allocated we should have to pay. but to pay simply to sit together, is wrong.

There should be no differentiation between groups that have kids and groups that don't.

IcaMorgan · 25/05/2022 13:23

For those asking about disabled and carers paying to book seats I know on EasyJet if you book special assistance they automatically put you together for free (inc choosing which seats as I always get given the first two rows when I book), Ryanair gave me my seat free but charged my companion (carer) priority boarding to sit next to me (they also put in me last row and wouldn’t help me get on or off the plane).

rainbowmilk · 25/05/2022 13:22

Thebeastofsleep · 25/05/2022 11:38

It is an unreasonable expectation.

But I also think it is unreasonable expectation that a passenger can be sat by a child whose adult is not easily accessible, and that is what airlines allow.

I am not suggesting that people traveling with children should be able to freely choose their seats either, I'm saying that airlines should sit them together as a matter of course, and allow them to pay to choose which seats they sit in if they do not like the preselected seats, much like a single traveler does.

You are suggesting that parents should be able to choose their desired seating (next to one another) for free. Yes, they might not get 3A and 3B, but they will get an A and a B without paying for it. By contrast, a couple without children would not be able to do that without paying. I don't think that's right.

I prefer the way it is now: if you want a certain seat (be that in terms of where it is on the plane, or who it's next to) you pay for it. If you don't, you save money.

rainbowmilk · 25/05/2022 13:13

5128gap · 25/05/2022 11:04

I think its really unfair to call people arseholes because they might not want to be inconvenienced or out of pocket to facilitate someone else's parenting. Its not a pleasant position to put someone in, because effectively they're made to feel that the flight experience of a child they've never met is down to them rather than the parent's oversight.
Most people are actually happy to do their bit to support parents, but its not the default that every adult in the world has to put the needs of parents above their own.
Parenting is not the same as having a disability, it's a choice that carries responsibilities and the understanding should be that that's on you as the parent to meet them. Help and special concessions from strangers a bonus, but not a right.

This is the comment of the thread for me. Couldn't agree more.

Blossomtoes · 25/05/2022 13:12

The solo lad would be the best bet. If he was tanked he wouldn’t give shit where he sat.

LoveHeartsFan · 25/05/2022 12:59

So who would you approach then, OP? The little old lady with a nice face? Who might struggle out of her seat? The middle-aged woman because she’s probably a Mum? The solo girl because she probably hasn’t reserved her seat?

Or the solo lad who might be tanked? The businessman giving off ‘don’t disturb me’ vibes?

A lot of this is predicated on social conditioning, and women being ‘nice’. That middle-aged woman might be working or have an unseen disability and so might the young girl.

Aubriella · 25/05/2022 12:50

Blossomtoes · 25/05/2022 12:45

Saying that airlines shouldn't charge families to sit together specifically is entitled

If you really think that you don’t understand the meaning of entitled. When our kids were little budget airlines had a policy of boarding families first. You’d have exploded with indignation I expect.

Airlines already have a policy to cater for little kids, including at boarding time. No one is questioning that. There’s no need for you to contemplate anyone exploding with indignation.

Blossomtoes · 25/05/2022 12:45

Saying that airlines shouldn't charge families to sit together specifically is entitled

If you really think that you don’t understand the meaning of entitled. When our kids were little budget airlines had a policy of boarding families first. You’d have exploded with indignation I expect.

grapewines · 25/05/2022 12:43

but I think it is much more likely that a single passenger sitting in a row of three will not have paid for that particular seat.

More likely perhaps but I wouldn't assume. I pay to get a window seat when I fly.

Aubriella · 25/05/2022 12:31

I actually think that would be a far better way to do it. Why are people “entitled fuckers” to expect airlines to provide something free of charge when there’s no actual cost? It must piss people like you off no end to hear that this “entitled fucker” has never paid to select a seat, yet always gets a pair of seats together - usually seat and window. You’re paying for that and I’m not.

Saying that airlines should everyone to choose their seats free of charge is not entitled.

Saying that airlines shouldn't charge families to sit together specifically is entitled.

Blossomtoes · 25/05/2022 12:24

Middle and window.

Swipe left for the next trending thread