Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to offer cash to other passengers for their seats on flight

414 replies

Blewitagain · 24/05/2022 22:26

I am going on holiday and have discovered I haven't pre booked seats on our flights. I'm traveling with two children. This was an oversight. I can get two seats which would leave eldest sat alone.

Would it be weird to take cash to compensate anyone willing to move seat? No one might be willing to move but I'm hoping.

I once travelled last minute in an emergency and no one was willing to move seats.

OP posts:
tigerlilly22 · 26/05/2022 18:26

I'm travelling with my kids who are 'young' teenagers and I have paid one hundred pounds to make sure we can sit together (so I can keep an eye on them and make sure they behave) I was given the option when I booked our holiday. Now, I don't agree with the charge but I did want all of us to sit together, so I 'paid up' .
There is no way I would give my seats up and split us up so 'others' who haven't paid can sit together. Apologies if that sounds harsh but it's the truth.

Insanelysilver · 26/05/2022 18:26

You Couid put the two kids together.
If I were the passenger, sat in the seat next to your two kids aged 3 and 4 , I’d give you money to let me sit somewhere else. Even on the wing outside the plane lol 😂

1000N · 26/05/2022 18:12

1000N · 26/05/2022 18:11

YANBU, is a fair deal but not sure if the company will allow it, it us scary to think of it but the name-seat allocation is very important because in case of a accident this lust is what guides a rescue…

List not lust *

1000N · 26/05/2022 18:11

YANBU, is a fair deal but not sure if the company will allow it, it us scary to think of it but the name-seat allocation is very important because in case of a accident this lust is what guides a rescue…

5128gap · 26/05/2022 12:53

Blewitagain · 26/05/2022 09:31

It's really not that loaded! Either it suits you to move or it doesn't. If it doesn't for some reason, no need to feel bad. I would never question why and would be very polite/friendly and apologise for asking. Like most reasonable people. Maybe you need to get more comfortable with saying no, it's doesn't have to be antagonistic. If you don't move just because you resent being asked, I wonder if that uncomfortable feeling is your conscience!

We aren't responsible for others but we generally do have an impact on each others lives which is surely ok? If I was asking about an elderly nervous grandmother because I hadn't managed to get seats together would the responses be the same?

If I am in a queue for a public toilet I would let a child or elderly/frail woman go in front of me....or indeed anyone who asked because I would assume their need was great. I wouldn't think fuck that, I'm standing my ground, I've queued fair and square etc. It's just about being considerate of others. It's generally a nicer way to live! And one day if you slip up and find yourself in need then you might be thankful others are willing to put themselves out a little.

That was quite a lecture sorry! But some responses are bonkers. With lots of reasonable replies too, thank you.

Actually you're quite wrong. My conscience wouldn't trouble me in the slightest, because I would swap with you as I wouldn't want your child suffering from your oversight.
I'd be perfectly comfortable saying no to YOU, but a nervous 12 year old sitting alone? Not so much.
I would however resent you, because you had made your oversight my problem.
But no doubt that makes me 'bonkers' like everyone else who isn't giving you a round of applause for your idea.

declutteringmymind · 26/05/2022 10:39

I'd try and offer my 12 year old some money for sitting in his own!

garlictwist · 26/05/2022 10:33

Gensola · 24/05/2022 22:48

I wouldn’t move unless it was to an equivalent seat - I always pay extra for an aisle seat so wouldn’t move to middle or window. I think 12 is old enough to sit on his own for a flight, too.

Ha, I always pay for window. The thought of being put in the aisle makes me feel quite stressed.

rainbowmilk · 26/05/2022 10:27

@Blewitagain That's not a comparable example, though. In that scenario most people would let the vulnerable person go ahead, because you're both getting to use the same facility, the only issue is a small delay. What you're asking is for a person who has paid for a particular thing (a specific seat) to give it to you, on the basis that that's being considerate and nice. You're not exceptional in giving up your place in a queue - most people do that. A better example would be giving up a meal you'd paid for in a restaurant to a hungry person at the next table who only brought enough money for a drink. I'm guessing you don't regularly do things like that cos #bekind?

ExMex · 26/05/2022 10:23

Op, my dad always prebooks as he's got a number of problems with one leg and his back so needs a particular seat. He wouldn't be able to move. I wouldn't mind moving if I hadn't paid money. If I had I'd probably feel guilt tripped into moving and not be happy about it.

I think actually offering money is a great idea as you are showing that you are not taking it for granted that people will do You a favour just because you've got children and that you don't expect anyone to pay for a service that they aren't receiving.

I'd offer the amount it costs to prebook a seat or maybe more than that.

And be kind when people say no. Hopefully you'll find someone to swap with you.

Do call the airlines though and ask if you can still prebook seats or what their policies are. And prepare you 12 year old that they possibly have to sit on their own. Maybe they'll enjoy it. Give them a book and snacks and tell them you'll check on them or that they can come see you as soon as you can.

Tldr yes do offer to pay the prebooking cost if someone agrees to swap.

pixie5121 · 26/05/2022 10:19

This reply has been withdrawn

Withdrawn at poster's request.

Regularsizedrudy · 26/05/2022 10:08

If you think wandering around a plane with your wallet out and sad faces kids in tow isn’t loaded you are deluded. You know beggars with dogs get more money?

Blewitagain · 26/05/2022 09:51

Also as some have suggested, they have decided they will have the two seats together and I can sit by myself. They were quite pleased at the idea! So all good Grin

OP posts:
Blewitagain · 26/05/2022 09:31

It's really not that loaded! Either it suits you to move or it doesn't. If it doesn't for some reason, no need to feel bad. I would never question why and would be very polite/friendly and apologise for asking. Like most reasonable people. Maybe you need to get more comfortable with saying no, it's doesn't have to be antagonistic. If you don't move just because you resent being asked, I wonder if that uncomfortable feeling is your conscience!

We aren't responsible for others but we generally do have an impact on each others lives which is surely ok? If I was asking about an elderly nervous grandmother because I hadn't managed to get seats together would the responses be the same?

If I am in a queue for a public toilet I would let a child or elderly/frail woman go in front of me....or indeed anyone who asked because I would assume their need was great. I wouldn't think fuck that, I'm standing my ground, I've queued fair and square etc. It's just about being considerate of others. It's generally a nicer way to live! And one day if you slip up and find yourself in need then you might be thankful others are willing to put themselves out a little.

That was quite a lecture sorry! But some responses are bonkers. With lots of reasonable replies too, thank you.

OP posts:
5128gap · 26/05/2022 08:22

dumdumduuuummmmm · 26/05/2022 07:32

@pixie5121 we aren't talking about entitled rude behaviour with hugging and puffing though. We are talking about asking people something and then graciously moving in if the answer is no. If that make other rolls uncomfortable then that's in them. Christ alive are we living in a world where we don't have normal human interactions because people can't cope?

It doesn't matter how you're asked. The fact is a woman with 3 children is asking you to move for the benefit of her child. That's extremely loaded. Many adults would feel uncomfortable in refusing a request if that impacted a child. As I said before the request basically means the child's comfort on the flight hangs on your decision. That's an unfair position in which to place someone.

notimagain · 26/05/2022 07:48

if I were in your position, I’d discreetly ask the cabin crew to ask the passengers, then nobody need feel awkward.

Please don't, not if there's cash involved.

We know the airline involved here has a system in place for it to make money out of seat allocation.

If the cabin crew get involved in an off the books cash transaction for a seat move and the company find out I suspect they'll be out of the doors PDQ.

dumdumduuuummmmm · 26/05/2022 07:36

CentrifugalBumblePuppy · 26/05/2022 06:58

I was flying internationally with my son from the age of 10 to & from jobs (he was an actor). On the very occasional flight where we had to be separated (around the age of 12 on a full flight, some jobs were booked with only a few days notice & flights were booked by production companies, not us), he had his script, books, schoolwork, PSP etc., he’d just get on with it.

I’d wander over mid flight; usually he’d be chatting to his neighbour or watching a film. He loved the independence.

At no point did I want to wangle cash around to sit next to him. He was at secondary school (and got himself there & back every day with a 2 mile walk or cycle), was obviously working (under licence) & probably enjoyed it more without me flapping around him. He was 12!

Would you feel the same if it was your 12 year old daughter and they were placed like an island in a sea of drunken boorish blokes?

ArabianLeopard · 26/05/2022 07:35

Reminds me of an experience years ago on a cross country overnight coach. Seating was first come first served. I had a window seat and vacant seat next to me. A couple of minutes before departure a young couple got on. There we no seats left together. The girl started loudly moaning about how she can't possibly sit on her own etc etc. It went on. Sitting alone I agreed to move to an aisle seat next to someone else. Not ideal.

We stop at the services and are told 20 minutes then bus would leave. Couple get off and leave most of their things on their seats including their coats. 20 mins passes and they don't get back on. The bus drives off. All their stuff still sitting in their seats.

I make eye contact and exchange shrugging gestures with fellow passengers. No one tells the driver.

I often wonder how she reacted when she got back to the empty parking space on a cold winter night in the north with no coat and the bus gone.

dumdumduuuummmmm · 26/05/2022 07:32

@pixie5121 we aren't talking about entitled rude behaviour with hugging and puffing though. We are talking about asking people something and then graciously moving in if the answer is no. If that make other rolls uncomfortable then that's in them. Christ alive are we living in a world where we don't have normal human interactions because people can't cope?

rookiemere · 26/05/2022 07:30

DS would have happily sat on his own at 12 , but that wasn't the question posed.
Some DCs mature at different times to others, plus they want to sit together as a family, that's why she paid for it originally.

liveforsummer · 26/05/2022 07:27

Sswhinesthebest · 26/05/2022 07:23

My uni ds is now as independent as they come but at age 12, or even 14, there is no way he would have had the confidence to sit on his own. Those posters who blithely say, my child did it so yours should, clearly lack a bit of empathy!

The majority will be getting themselves to school every day and doing similarly independent things in their daily lives at that age that's why people are assuming. Maybe the odd dc won't be comfortable but most would. (Assuming no ASN)

Sswhinesthebest · 26/05/2022 07:23

My uni ds is now as independent as they come but at age 12, or even 14, there is no way he would have had the confidence to sit on his own. Those posters who blithely say, my child did it so yours should, clearly lack a bit of empathy!

CentrifugalBumblePuppy · 26/05/2022 06:58

I was flying internationally with my son from the age of 10 to & from jobs (he was an actor). On the very occasional flight where we had to be separated (around the age of 12 on a full flight, some jobs were booked with only a few days notice & flights were booked by production companies, not us), he had his script, books, schoolwork, PSP etc., he’d just get on with it.

I’d wander over mid flight; usually he’d be chatting to his neighbour or watching a film. He loved the independence.

At no point did I want to wangle cash around to sit next to him. He was at secondary school (and got himself there & back every day with a 2 mile walk or cycle), was obviously working (under licence) & probably enjoyed it more without me flapping around him. He was 12!

Neu · 26/05/2022 06:51

Why don't you or your husband have the single seat and one of you have both children?

BadLad · 26/05/2022 06:38

BalloonsAndWhistles · 26/05/2022 05:10

That is hilarious! Would you be providing proof of your donation to Save the Children @BadLad 😂 Virtue signalling at its finest. I bet you’re one of those who feels ‘blessed’ to buy a homeless guy a coffee and then do a TikTok video about it.

Even though I didn't use the quote function, I'm surprised that you didn't understand from the use of bold in my post and indeed the actual words I wrote, that I was quoting someone else.

Fozzleyplum · 26/05/2022 06:34

I was the poster who mentioned the donation. Those who accuse me of virtue signaling have completely missed the point. The idea is not to virtue signal, but to shut down the tutting and accusations of selfishness that so many on thread and other similar ones have reported when they are not willing to give up their paid for reserved seats.

The cheeky person who would accuse you of not being "nice" can have the seat, if they are prepared to be " nice" - to a charity. And everyone who would be the audience for any performance of comments and tutting,, gets to hear that too.

And why would I not give the money to charity? I'm too old to do a sponsored skydive, so this would be the next best thing!