Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How to handle this situation? BBQ & drinking

184 replies

ohwhattodo96 · 24/05/2022 20:12

So we are planning to have a BBQ next week for QJ.

My mum can’t handle her drink, she’s not an alcoholic, but when she does get a couple of drinks in her she starts picking fights (verbal obviously) and being argumentative with people, my younger sister (in her 20’s) in particular she can be quite horrible to.

Obviously it wouldn’t be fair to deny everyone else there alcohol because of her (or would it?!) but how do I tell a fully grown adult she’s only allowed one drink?!

The BBQ is at my house, and the rest of the family who live with her will be invited so it’s not like I can just leave her out, but I don’t want her to ruin it or make my sisters day miserable by being nasty to her because she’s had a couple of glasses of wino!

how do I handle this sensitively? If I bring up her behaviour and the real reason why, she will get defensive and rain down hell on me

OP posts:
newbiename · 25/05/2022 11:00

I wouldn't invite her and I'd tell her why.

5foot5 · 25/05/2022 10:57

Having read all of your posts it seems as though the alcohol problem is only one of many issues. Your Mum sounds like a really awful person drunk or sober frankly.

Definitely have your BBQ without her and avoid her as much as possible. I do feel very sorry for your poor sister. I hope you or the wider family can find some way of helping her get out of this difficult situation.

ohwhattodo96 · 25/05/2022 10:53

Thank you everyone, I will talk to my sister about it all when I next see her (which should be later on this week) and I will speak to the rest of the family about it later on today and see what their opinions are about it and post an update

OP posts:
FarmGirl78 · 25/05/2022 10:35

@ohwhattodo96 in your second post you said she "doesn't do those things apparently".

Maybe record her the next time she's drunk and on one. And once things have all quietened down and you've gone to visit or you're having a coffee or a natter, show her the video. She might not realise how bad she gets and it might shock her into changing.

StageRage · 25/05/2022 09:43

Sorry OP, missed some of your posts because of the constant fucking page refreshing and jumping about that MN does these days.

StageRage · 25/05/2022 09:40

Sainsburys have some Prosecco on offer atm , £5 a bottle. It isn’t advertised as low alcohol but it is much lower than Prosecco usually is. I think it will be the saving of many a jubilee BBQ, tbh, because so many people will buy it because if the price without realising.

Does your sister live in the same house as your Mum?

I would say ‘Mum, really looking forward to the BBQ, but I Ned to be honest. You are very different when you have been drinking, not like our usual lovely Mum. Last time my neighbours complained about your shouting and swearing, and it is very upsetting when you shout at sister. Please come and have a good time without one too many. If you hulk out, I’m going to put you in a taxi home, no messing’.

If she kicks off at that, “LOL, Mum, you’re taking yourself out of being invited at all! Seriously. Come and be nice? Or make other plans?”.

But I would get your sister, DH and other relatives on your side and agree to calmly back you up if she turns nasty.

It isn’t you creating ‘drama’, or being confrontational. Why is it ok for the rest of the family to endure her being wildly insulting and aggressive, but you all worry about being ‘insensitive’.

Watch some if the real life police programmes. The police deal with all manner of insulting drunks ready for a fight, being straightforward and non confrontational. Channel them!

Onlyhuman123 · 25/05/2022 09:12

I've just caught up with all your posts OP and I am so sorry for you and your sister. What an awful, horrible situation to find yourself in. Your poor sister having to live with it and the unfairness of the brother too. Your mum is a total bully and sounds like a really nasty person. I do hope you can get your sister out of the place at some point and then you have to go NC for your own and sisters health. Flowers

Onlyhuman123 · 25/05/2022 09:04

ohwhattodo96 · 24/05/2022 20:16

I also live in a fairly new neighbourhood so this will be my first time hosting here, and previous times she’s sat in the garden swearing at my sister loudly and shouting and my old neighbours had to knock the next day to let me know they had heard everything… it’s bloody embarrassing and I don’t want to set that tone with this neighbourhood too… but she thinks there’s nothing wrong with that and she doesn’t do those things apparently

surreptitiously film/record her whenever she kicks off and play it back to her when she's sober. She won't be able to argue with evidence.

How embarrassing for you with your old neighbours. <cringe>

HJ40 · 25/05/2022 08:59

Your poor, poor sister. Is there other relative she could even stay on the sofa with until she finds somewhere else? How much does she pay your mum each month.

Please stop pandering to your mum's behaviour.

Andante57 · 25/05/2022 08:25

You shouldn't even try to manage her drinking OP. Banning alcohol, watering drinks, extracting promises, none of it works and just means your entire focus will be on trying to control her. Its very stressful

This. You can’t stop an alcoholic drinking.

EmeraldShamrock1 · 25/05/2022 07:44

I would give her a sterne warning if she starts I'd physically remove her and she wouldn't be invited again.

I understand it's risky she'll most likely kick off anyway.

At least it gives you the opportunity to bar her forevermore.

I would have physically removed her in your last home once she started.

5128gap · 25/05/2022 07:37

You shouldn't even try to manage her drinking OP. Banning alcohol, watering drinks, extracting promises, none of it works and just means your entire focus will be on trying to control her. Its very stressful.
Her drinking is just part of a huge problem with her behaviour. You say it will all come to a head at some point, and really, it needs to. While you're trying to keep the peace, you're all just papering over the cracks and not addressing the mistreatment of your sister.
Personally I'd let events at the BBQ take their course. Defend your sister and remove your mother if her behaviour is unacceptable. It will no doubt lead to the confrontation you're dreading, but it really needs to happen as you can't go on like this.

MachineBee · 25/05/2022 07:20

Your sister needs to keep her savings and promotions quiet. Could she use your address for correspondence so there’s no chance of your DM finding out? And if she’s let slip her online banking details to her mum she needs to change the PINs and passwords immediately.

It really is time for you and your sister to stop handing power and information to a woman who uses it to abuse you.

Aquamarine1029 · 24/05/2022 23:20

ohwhattodo96 · 24/05/2022 23:05

To be honest I think it will all come to a big blow out. I’m not usually a fiery and confrontational person, but she’s pushed everyone to pretty much their limits now so it might be a case of not caring what she says to me and just letting her have it (some home truths!)

It takes two people to have a big blow out. Don't engage with her like this.

RampantIvy · 24/05/2022 23:20

what my mum does is whenever my sister has some savings built up or when she got a promotion at work, she pretty much doubled her rent/keep

Why does your sister tell her she has been promoted or got some money? She needs to keep quiet about her her finances.

Can't your sister stay at your grandparents?

JaceLancs · 24/05/2022 23:17

Would she drink something like Sangria?
I’ve not found any no alcohol wines that taste great but are ok if mixed
nosecco makes a good white version and mcguigan Merlot good for red - by the time you’ve added fruit, lemonade and orange juice it’s hard to tell
If you think others might enjoy then try mixing 1 bottle of alcohol free with 1 bottle of normal wine plus all the other bits and she might not even notice

Honeyroar · 24/05/2022 23:10

Your poor sister. Can’t she live at a grandparent’s or something until she can save up. I can’t believe your whole family sits back and watches her get abused. And still pussy doors around your mother inviting her to parties and never pulling her up on her behaviour. It’s ridiculous. Tell her she’s not invited because she ruins it for everyone else and can’t behave. Then ignore her tantrums. But you all need to help your poor sister.

ohwhattodo96 · 24/05/2022 23:05

To be honest I think it will all come to a big blow out. I’m not usually a fiery and confrontational person, but she’s pushed everyone to pretty much their limits now so it might be a case of not caring what she says to me and just letting her have it (some home truths!)

OP posts:
ChickenBurgers · 24/05/2022 23:05

To add, I wouldn’t make her drinks weak. She’ll probably taste the difference, but even if she doesn’t if she thinks drinking x amount she may behave drunk anyway and still cause drama. I’d say soft drinks or nothing.

ChickenBurgers · 24/05/2022 23:02

Idk I don’t think you can do this without avoiding confrontation and her kicking off in some form, you could beat around the bush and go softly softly, but ultimately no matter how you word it it sounds like it’ll go down like a lead balloon. so I think you should just go all out and say it how it is.

“hey mum, when you’ve had a few too many you become quite spiteful. You’re more than welcome to come to the BBQ if you stick to the soft drinks, but if you’re not prepared to do that then you will have to sit this one out”.

ohwhattodo96 · 24/05/2022 23:02

@Herejustforthisone it really is very sad for her, because she gets no love, affection or even kindness from my mother she seeks this in the form of other relationships… basically a lot of people have shit on her but because she is so desperate for someone to just love her, she just keeps going back and back to these unhealthy bonds she forms with no good people

OP posts:
Blarting · 24/05/2022 23:01

Your sister is being abused, who has her back?

Herejustforthisone · 24/05/2022 22:59

Your poor, poor sister. Your mother is a witch. A cruel witch.

tkwal · 24/05/2022 22:56

I would volunteer to waitress for your Mum. Make sure she has lots of food and ensure her drinks are on the weak side or topped up with water. If you can speak to your sister and explain your concerns you could encourage her not to engage when your Mum starts on her. Otherwise , try to realise that people won't judge you by your Mum's behaviour and that she is responsible for whatever opinions people hold of her. At worst, if things go as you fear you will need to have a very Frank, and awkward discussion with her

ThreeLittleDots · 24/05/2022 22:54

anytime she does try and work something out my mum emotionally blackmails her, and my sister is a really sensitive person so she finds this really difficult

This is why counselling or therapy would be a good investment. Not because your sister is weak, but because she's being abused.