Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Should I pay for their vet treatments

212 replies

Crazycats1991 · 24/05/2022 19:50

I sold a ragdoll kitten last Monday at 14 weeks old from my litter of kittens 3 days later her eye has swollen and become infected the new owner has taken the kitten to the vet and it turns out she has herpes virus or Chlamydia virus from contact with another cat, she said he hasn't been near another cat but none of the other kittens in the litter are unwell and neither is mum and the other cat in my household. I have however offered to pay for half the vet fees.
AIBU to only offer half the vet fees and should pay the full amount
Or
AINBU and i don't need to pay any of the vet fees
No receipt or contract was given and the kitten was in good spirits and seemed healthy and she even sent me videos of her playing and jumping about in her new home
What should I do?

OP posts:
mcmooberry · 25/05/2022 14:46

Herpes and chlamydia haven't been confirmed yet I think everyone should calm down! I suspect the vet (rightly) commented that it could be a cause of conjunctivitis in a kitten.

GoFishandChips · 25/05/2022 14:41

And are children not allowed to be excited for their new kitten they are picking up after waiting 20 weeks for?

Excited yes, running around and screaming so much you forgot to give a recipt, no. Because decent owners to be would have warned them that their loudness might frighten the kitten, whether said kitten was frightened or not is irrelevant.

Hortensiateapot · 25/05/2022 14:41

Hafera · 24/05/2022 20:06

Yes you should pay imo. Reputable breeders usually sell with temporary insurance in place.
Infectious viruses at that age will almost definitely be acquired from mum with symptoms so soon after going to her new home, the stress of the journey could be enough for symptoms to start. Not all cats who carry these diseases display symptoms, typically some will display symptoms in times of stress. Mum must be a carrier, you probably shouldn't breed from her again.

This

Crazycats1991 · 25/05/2022 14:40

Ihatethenewlook · 25/05/2022 14:38

Are you serious? You’ve got your head so far up your arse you don’t even realise what a horrible breeder you’re coming across as on here. Some woman has honestly turned up at your house with 3 children completely out of control, one literally screaming so badly that your head was so battered you’d forgotten the paperwork, and you allowed these people to take home one of these poor kittens? What about this family/situation said to you ‘oh yes, what a perfect environment for a small kitten’? 😡

We'd had multiple video calls whilst once before the kitten had even been born and weekly afterwards and her house was often very quiet and the children were calm, would your children not be excited when picking their new cat up?

OP posts:
Ihatethenewlook · 25/05/2022 14:40

Crazycats1991 · 25/05/2022 14:37

I chose to only cover my costs hence why so cheap, if you believe there is money to be made in breeding then you are crazy the food the vet bills the damage to your house it is not worth it.
Are people with children not allowed a cat now? And are children not allowed to be excited for their new kitten they are picking up after waiting 20 weeks for? She told me about 3 times they're not usually like this and the kitten was playing happily around them.
If I had said I charge £1000 I'd have people telling me I use animals I say I charge £500 and I have people complaining I don't charge enough and I'm the problem you can not do right from wrong

If she can’t even get her children to behave normally at the actual breeders house, then why on earth do you think they behave more normally at home??

Crazycats1991 · 25/05/2022 14:39

Poppyseed14 · 25/05/2022 14:34

With no paperwork surely this ragdoll is just a very expensive moggy?

She does have paperwork?! She just didn't take the paper the I had written up stating how much she paid and the date.
She has all her paperwork including her parentage

OP posts:
Ihatethenewlook · 25/05/2022 14:38

Are you serious? You’ve got your head so far up your arse you don’t even realise what a horrible breeder you’re coming across as on here. Some woman has honestly turned up at your house with 3 children completely out of control, one literally screaming so badly that your head was so battered you’d forgotten the paperwork, and you allowed these people to take home one of these poor kittens? What about this family/situation said to you ‘oh yes, what a perfect environment for a small kitten’? 😡

Crazycats1991 · 25/05/2022 14:37

I chose to only cover my costs hence why so cheap, if you believe there is money to be made in breeding then you are crazy the food the vet bills the damage to your house it is not worth it.
Are people with children not allowed a cat now? And are children not allowed to be excited for their new kitten they are picking up after waiting 20 weeks for? She told me about 3 times they're not usually like this and the kitten was playing happily around them.
If I had said I charge £1000 I'd have people telling me I use animals I say I charge £500 and I have people complaining I don't charge enough and I'm the problem you can not do right from wrong

OP posts:
Poppyseed14 · 25/05/2022 14:34

With no paperwork surely this ragdoll is just a very expensive moggy?

Crazycats1991 · 25/05/2022 14:31

I understand some people want a little fury friend that costs £50. But others do not. I do a damn site more than most breeders do! I just do not and will not ever agree to spay a kitten before 6 months, kittens that people do wish to breed from I do not sell as ACTIVE and therefore cannot breed from them, and I only sell a kitten that is ACTIVE if they meet the breed standard therefore this enhances the breed itself.
British short hairs have an amazing temperament why should they not be alive because some cretin let their uneutred cat roam free and have unwanted babies when I have a waiting list for them?

OP posts:
GoFishandChips · 25/05/2022 14:28

This woman came to my house with 3 young children one of which was screaming and the other two running around

And you thought that was a good home for a kitten?! WTAF, is this a wind up?? Did the woman know anything about the breed she wants to profit from??

GoFishandChips · 25/05/2022 14:25

when my kittens are alot cheaper than going rate

This is a big part of why you are being criticized. Reputable breeders charge a lot of money because breeding healthy kittens is an expensive hobby and if done right there is very little profit in it (apart from the owners of studs) due to the huge amount of health screenings, pregnancy checks etc that should be done.

Also the fact that you don't charge a lot means you are selling to people who are looking for a "bargain" rather than investing in being reputable breeders or the amount of special care and diet a purebred needs.

girlmom21 · 25/05/2022 14:21

Not everybody who breeds is a bad breeder
This woman came to my house with 3 young children one of which was screaming and the other two running around which was why when I handed over the TICA paperwork I forgot to handover the receipt for the kitten.

Generally good breeders don't sell tiny animals to a woman with out of control children.

XelaM · 25/05/2022 14:21

OP I think you should take the kitten back, as the new owners don't sound good. Also, do they still intend to breed from a cat that has feline herpes?

Crazycats1991 · 25/05/2022 14:19

WiddlinDiddlin · 25/05/2022 02:53

So your queen hasn't been tested since being mated... so she could indeed be carrying something she's passed on to your other cats/kittens.

You should test for some things regularly 'I tested before her last mating' is not sufficient and you really ought to know that, as you ought to know the incubation period and that some conditions don't show physical symptoms yet an animal can still be a carrier infecting others.

Pay for the treatment. Get ALL your other cats and kittens tested and pay for their treatment too.

How would she have caught herpes virus if she went to a stud who was tested and does not have it and she is an indoor cat?

OP posts:
Crazycats1991 · 25/05/2022 14:15

I really don't understand how people can sit there telling me I'm a back yard breeder and breeding for money when my kittens are alot cheaper than going rate as I don't breed to just make money or "use an animals womb" as one person put it.
My cats have had all reccomend gene tests before being bred they have been in the last 16 months scanned for HCM they also have saliva tests sent to the lab, and they are health checked yearly and before and during pregnancy.
I attend shows and therefore my cats are vaccinated and upto date with boosters.
I DO HAVE breeders insurance and provide 14 days free insurance with petplan to the new owner but this insurance only covers injury in the first 14 days if they then chose to carry on themselves with this insurance it will then cover illness and that is normal of any insurance!
I breed ethically and with care and compassion. There may well be plenty of moggies in the RSPCA but what you will not find is any of my cats I have a breeders clause where if they chose not to want their cat anymore they are to come back to me! They are only allowed to breed with another registered cat that I agree to therefore to enhance the gene pool and the bloodline.
Not everybody who breeds is a bad breeder
This woman came to my house with 3 young children one of which was screaming and the other two running around which was why when I handed over the TICA paperwork I forgot to handover the receipt for the kitten.
I have offered to collect the kitten and treat her at my own house and bring her back when she is better the lady has declined this she is not unhappy with me offering half the vet bill as she said she took her to her mum's to meet her and her cats in the way home!
I just do not understand how a cat who came from somewhere where everyone is vaccinated and tested for these things regularly and a kitten that is also fully vaccinated now supposedly has feline herpes virus.

OP posts:
Itloggedmeoutagain · 25/05/2022 14:13

Don't think OP is coming back

Thatboymum · 25/05/2022 12:54

You should as a minimum offer to take your kitten back and ensure yourself that it receives appropriate Health treatment and refund the buyer. Can’t imagine the sadness as a family of being excited for weeks to Welcome a new fur baby into the family and immediately be plagued by vet bills and poor health making a happy time a sad time, it doesn’t portray you well as a breeder and word of mouth really is worth it’s weight in gold and I certainly would be speaking loudly if I was the new owner

InChocolateWeTrust · 25/05/2022 11:54

Astrak

Good for you but that's just not really what most families want from a pet.

The moggy kitten we were given for free has been the best pet ever. The whole family love her to bits, she is very attached to the children who give her tons of attention.

Astrak · 25/05/2022 11:27

I have an adult male cat (?12 years old) who was abandoned and mistreated on a sink estate. A large tabby moggy. He came to me via a friend who knew that I had to have my beloved companion cat (aged 22) pts due to acute onset kidney failure. Eighteen months on, he is reducing his over eating, aggressive behaviour and is sometimes coming to sit next to me. He goes out and comes back to call. He's beginning to accept a mini groom with a small rake brush. He's vaccinated and I've fully insured him.
I always have rescue animals and expect nothing from them for as long as they live.
With calm, kind and appropriate management, they have all done well and become valued and much loved companions.

InChocolateWeTrust · 25/05/2022 11:26

We were turned away from 6 rescues due to having 2 children under 5. Only one had any kittens at all despite it being kitten season, and they were kittens from a feral mother.

The others said none of their cats were suitable - several had cats with spraying issues, and most said the cats simply were suitable to go to a home with children. This was in the home counties.

Rescues round here are not bursting at the seams.

InChocolateWeTrust · 25/05/2022 11:23

Where I live there are never kittens in rescues except semi feral etc.

You don't need to buy kittens as people give accidental ones away free. We paid nothing for ours so I dont think the "seller" was in it for the cash.

Lady089 · 25/05/2022 11:17

InChocolateWeTrust · 25/05/2022 10:52

Just to say while I have tried to support rescues, DH and I decided recently that we wouldnt have another cat rather than go rescue again.

We and various family members have had lots of rescues over the last 20 years. We are finding: the only kittens they seem to get are the offspring of feral cats. Even when taken as 12 week kittens & worked with extensively, they become poorly socialised fearful cats which frankly speaking make crap family pets as they avoid most people and all children.

The older cats in rescues where we live are often similar. Relatively fearful, almost semi feral cats or one with chronic health conditions or other poor behaviours. Rescues often refuse to let people with young children have a pet.

By contrast, we also adopted a kitten, given away for free by a friend who's lovely family cat had an unplanned litter. We got her at 9 weeks, she is extremely social, loves our children and is happy to be stroked and fussed over by them and visitors, neighbouring children etc. Neighbour who bought a kitten from a breeder at similar age has had similar experience.

Rescue vs buying cats are different things. Rescues are driven by animal protection and welfare and whether unconsciously or not, don't really care if an animal will be a suitable pet for the family, as long as the animal's needs are met. It's not very sustainable as most people just want a friendly pet tbh.

That’s not a true reflection of rescues at all. I have three friends who have rescued cats from a well-known charity and all are super-friendly and great with their children and also I would rather offer a home to a rescued kitten/cat that may not be the ‘ideal’ pet than see it euthanised because it’s not the kitten/cat everyone wants.

Grumpyoldpersonwithcats · 25/05/2022 11:12

@InChocolateWeTrust
No idea which rescues you are going to but I have had the exact opposite experience to you.
Currently have four cats (two pairs aged 11 and 4). All came fron Battersea as kittens.
Excellently socialised by the rescue and have all grown up to be very friendly cats.

Rescues ...don't really care if an animal will be a suitable pet for the family, as long as the animal's needs are met.
wheras private sellers only care that the buyer has plenty of cash and diesn't give a fuck about the animal's welfare...

oakleaffy · 25/05/2022 10:54

Grumpyoldpersonwithcats · 25/05/2022 09:46

OP,
I won't continue the pile in, but ethically I think you should take the kitten back and refund or replace. If the buyer wants to keep her then you should pay for the full round of treatment.

Off topic but the below is the strangest cat related comment I've ever read. Just why?
That's not actually true. Some people don't want a rescue and would have no cat rather than a rescue

That is a bizarre statement.
Some people may want a specific breed of cat, but I imagine there are re- homing centres bfor specific breeds of cat, likely run by aficionados of that breed.
If one wants a kitten, there are reams of crossbreed kittens desperate for homes, and of course, adult cats too.

Swipe left for the next trending thread