Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Are GPS generally this uninformed about fertility issues? Read for a laugh!

89 replies

blueberry23 · 24/05/2022 19:47

Just been advised by a GP that the fact I'm breastfeeding has absolutely nothing to do with my cycle being short and the fact I keep having chemical pregnancies (7/8 day luteal phase).

In fact she didn't even know what a luteal phase was Grin and when I said I was having chemical pregnancies she said 'meaning?' And had no idea what it it was.

And she said 'why are you feeding a 15 month old child that child should be weaned from the breast' honestly I just gave up at that point

She followed up by saying - if you want to get pregnant have sex during ovulation' - ohhhh sure I didn't think of that. Must be where we are going wrong!

Are GPs generally this uninformed about fertility issues? I'm mind blown. First contact I've made after 6 months of TTC and two chem pregnancies. I've asked her to send me for a blood test and told her what I need to be tested for GrinGrin

Ridiculous!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
PlanBea · 25/05/2022 17:18

Quite often when a GP asks you to explain something (luteal phase, chemical pregnancy etc) is to understand what you think it means. Often people come in and say something but mean something else - the best way to check you both mean the same thing is to ask you to explain what you mean

takemetomars · 25/05/2022 16:46

LesLavandes · 24/05/2022 20:45

I am finding GPs very lethargic and uninterested these days.

Not surprising really is it? Massively overworked, seeing patients who do nothing but complain and who have unreasonable expectations, expected to make hundreds of complex decisions on an almost daily basis

BarrowInFurnessRailwayStation · 25/05/2022 16:41

I find GPs are uninformed about most things tbh. It's best to go in with very low expectations and assume they can just about manage to know where a particular body part is located. The rest is down to Google.

Chichz · 25/05/2022 16:22

@pbdr Sorry, the above comment was meant to quote your response ^^ 😊

Chichz · 25/05/2022 16:19

If only everyone could comment with such respect, helpfulness and eloquence! 😁

blueberry23 · 25/05/2022 12:15

Just to say, it wasn't an NHS doctor. It was a private GP appointment booked through my works private healthcare scheme

OP posts:
FarmGirl78 · 25/05/2022 10:06

I think that your GP has come across as out of touch will a few of the things they've said, but I think that you're also expecting too much of a GP on the whole.

In essence GENERAL Practioners know a small amount about everything. They aren't specialists. It would help so many peoples expectations if they walked into a GPs surgery thinking of the GP as someone who'll say "Look, too big a job for me, but hey, I know this guy....". The might not know themselves if you need expert advice on something specialised, but they can refer you into someone who does know.

They don't have a textbook knowledge of the reference ranges of every single blood test (there's just too many!)so if they will likely have to look this information up elsewhere. I'm female, I'm a medical professional and while I know luteal phase is something to do with hormones/pregnancy/menstrual cycle I couldn't tell you off the top of my head.

Of course they'll check whether you're having sex at the right time of the month before they refer you on. Bear in mind that your GP will also be dealing with those women who genuinely don't know when the best time to have sex when TTC is. There's some seriously uneducated, ill-informed people out there!! You're obviously up to speed on your situation and health needs, and so it's likely that right now you are much more well read on this specialist area than your GP is.

Your GP night well have been kicking themselves when you left the room for coming over as such a moron. And she wouldn't initially be aware of the extent of your knowledge. I'd just say be aware they might only know the bare bones of what's obviously a specialism, and be ready to ask for referal onwards if you've already exhausted all the basics.

pbdr · 25/05/2022 10:05

I'm a GP, and while I wouldn't claim to know in detail the effects of partial (as opposed to exclusive) breastfeeding of an older infant would be expected to have on the length of the luteal phase, I certainly know what a luteal phase is, as should any GP. "Chemical pregnancy" is a term I have only come across in informal contexts (mumsnet etc.), it was not a term ever used during my medical training/ in the medical literature that we learned from. We would usually refer to that as an early miscarriage, so that might be where that confusion is coming from. The evidence regarding whether breastfeeding during pregnancy can cause miscarriage is controversial and mixed. I have seen evidence that exclusive breastfeeding significantly increases miscarriage risk, but there does not seem to be the same evidence of any effect of partial breastfeeding, so it is hard to say definitively whether your chemicals are a result of breastfeeding or just bad luck.
Poor of her to say your 15 month old "should be weaned from the breast" already when the WHO/NHS guidelines advise 2 years. Weaning is of course an option which might (or might not) help you get pregnant, but that is your call to make. There's no "should" about it.

Crystalvas · 25/05/2022 09:53

Traveller3367 · 25/05/2022 06:17

Love the GP bashing here!
Do you guys think the GP might have slightly more important conditions to remember than a fertilised egg that didn't stick?
Honestly as long as my GP can treat me for the barrage of other conditions that might kill me (you know actual serious conditions like sepsis, cancer, aneurysms, heart attacks), then I'm happy to accept a lack of knowledge about infertility and the many colloquial terms that people use to describe a late period!
The GPs job is to refer to specialists who treat infertility.
But yes, typical MN users think their Google searches are the equivalent of a medical degree 😂
Look forward to the days when my taxes are not used to entertain such nonsense.

Quiet right 🤣

Minimalme · 25/05/2022 08:30

I have a child with a medical disability and another with a neurological disability.

I moved house three years ago and since then my GPs seem to believe that it's my fault that my kids get substandard care from them.

They are so dismissively pompous and fuck up my eldest son's dosage changes all the time.

They are rude to me over the phone when I ask if they can correct the dose on ds repeat prescription to what the paed consultant has asked for (via the letter they haven't read).

We are moving house again soon and I will be delighted to move our GP surgery.

I actually don't mind the lack of knowledge or mistakes, it is the patronising pomposity which is the deal breaker for me.

Traveller3367 · 25/05/2022 07:51

@CHiSOCG
This!! It's no wonder we are haemorrhaging nurses and doctors if this is the kind of entitled, arrogant patients they have to see on a daily basis

Silvercatowner · 25/05/2022 07:34

Ilovechinese · 25/05/2022 03:49

You don't need to wean your baby to get pregnant. I got pregnant with my twins whilst breastfeeding my toddler

Just because you did, doesn't mean other women will. BF is well known to inhibit pregnancy.

CHiSOCG · 25/05/2022 07:30

To be honest you sound like a condescending know it all, I’m sure you’ve done 5 years of med school and the appropriate subsequent training. Just listen to yourself!

GPs are exactly that, Genera Practitioners and she’s right. Give up breastfeeding and frankly perhaps start having some respect for people.

user1477391263 · 25/05/2022 07:29

She shouldn't make comments about how your child should be weaned from the breast. However, I would wonder whether continuing to BF could be making these conceptions less sticky. It might be worth considering stopping in the near future if you have age-related reasons for needing the conception to happen fairly soon? There is a high chance that actually getting pregnant will either make your milk dry up or make BFing mentally and physically uncomfortable, so you may have to give up when you get PG anyway.

CoreyTaylorsbiggestfan · 25/05/2022 07:25

Also OP on your other thread it said you had been ttc for 4 months

howtomoveforwards · 25/05/2022 07:25

A GP is a generalist at the end of the day, having to make decisions about whether an issue warrants a referral to a specialist, whether it’s something they can treat themselves or whether it’s a wait and see situation. They are the first port of call for the majority of people about their health issues. By far the majority of the time they get it right. They can’t know everything in the same depth as a specialist. I think you are expecting too much.

CoreyTaylorsbiggestfan · 25/05/2022 07:22

It sounds like she was asking what your understanding of luteal phase and chemical pregnancy.
Health professionals do this is people come in with all sorts of jargon and they mean something different.
Are you over 35? They do tell you that after 6 months ttc if your over 35 to see your GP.
I know that breastfeeding can cause low progesterone which can cause a short luteal phase. A lot of women can't conceive when breast feeding.
The GP was probably thinking a long the lines of this... that your saying your struggling to conceive but still breastfeeding which can cause low progesterone so the solution is to stop breastfeeding to conceive.
Doesn't sound like she delivered that well.

OakAshBeech · 25/05/2022 07:20

Traveller3367 · 25/05/2022 06:53

@Comtesse
You may wish to reread my post as that is NOT what I said. I said I'm happy to accept a lack of knowledge in a field with no urgency. A GP doing so reading and calling me back about a fertility issue isn't going to be as detrimental as a GP delaying my care to learn about cancer symptoms etc. Honestly raise your game!

But where did the OP say that her GP was planning to do her research/reading and call her back??

Comtesse · 25/05/2022 07:16

GP didn’t offer to look anything up - said the baby should be weaned, shot from the hip about some basic biology and got it wrong. All sounds a bit substandard to me. If they can’t get this right, can we be sure they are safe on the critical illnesses either? Not sure what that has got to do with raising MY game but you know… have a nice day I guess😀

custardbear · 25/05/2022 07:13

Tania64 · 24/05/2022 19:51

If she told you to stop breastfeeding you should make a complaint.

That's not what the GP said though - it was in response to fertility - BF can Interfere with fertility. If you want to get pregnant and can't, stopping BF where it's no longer a necessity is something some people may not know can help get pregnant

Giraffesandbottoms · 25/05/2022 07:09

She didn’t tell her to stop breastfeeding in order to get pregnant though she asked her why she’s still feeding a 15 month old as if she shouldn’t be

this. Totally ignorant and I would complain about it.

some people are totally fine to conceive whilst pregnant (I did), and some aren’t. I would give it a bit longer before giving up.

Traveller3367 · 25/05/2022 06:53

@Comtesse
You may wish to reread my post as that is NOT what I said. I said I'm happy to accept a lack of knowledge in a field with no urgency. A GP doing so reading and calling me back about a fertility issue isn't going to be as detrimental as a GP delaying my care to learn about cancer symptoms etc. Honestly raise your game!

Comtesse · 25/05/2022 06:39

Oh so GPs only do life saving things do they @Traveller3367 ? Perfectly legit to talk about conception, breast feeding etc with a medical practitioner and also expect a modicum of knowledge.

Kangaruby · 25/05/2022 06:31

I'm not sure what your complaint is, if I was a busy GP, think I would be a bit bemused by a healthy woman who has only being trying to get pregnant for a few months while continuing to breastfeed wanting to talk it through. I'm not a huge fan of GP's but I think your expectations are a bit unrealistic

Traveller3367 · 25/05/2022 06:17

Love the GP bashing here!
Do you guys think the GP might have slightly more important conditions to remember than a fertilised egg that didn't stick?
Honestly as long as my GP can treat me for the barrage of other conditions that might kill me (you know actual serious conditions like sepsis, cancer, aneurysms, heart attacks), then I'm happy to accept a lack of knowledge about infertility and the many colloquial terms that people use to describe a late period!
The GPs job is to refer to specialists who treat infertility.
But yes, typical MN users think their Google searches are the equivalent of a medical degree 😂
Look forward to the days when my taxes are not used to entertain such nonsense.