Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is this rude?

216 replies

Ritascornershop · 24/05/2022 10:12

My family is staying with me. They eat meat at every meal, I’m vegetarian. I said it’s fine that they cook meat (though the smell really bothers me but I act like it’s fine). Last night I made dinner for us with veggie “meat”. My son-in-law, who is a wonderful person, ate everything but the protein. And then went out and ordered a meat pizza.

He just doesn’t like the taste of fake meat (whereas I don’t eat meat for ethical reasons). I was taught to eat what’s in front of you. My mum was a terrible cook but I had to eat her food 3 times a day for 18 years. I’m a pretty good cook, I’ve taught cooking, took cooking classes for years, I have a real interest in it. Should he have eaten the whole curry?

I’m glad my daughter married him, just wondering if thinking on this has changed. I ate a lot of my mother-in-law’s good that I found pretty weird (crisps crumbled on top of spag bog was one) as I didn’t want to offend.

OP posts:
Ritascornershop · 24/05/2022 12:53

Eeksteek, that’s completely different as his is a taste preference whereas mine is an ethical one. I liked the taste of meat decades ago when I stopped eating it (I’ve since lost the taste for it).

They had been cooking for themselves and I wanted to give them a night off and share a meal.

OP posts:
Ritascornershop · 24/05/2022 12:50

I think some people are getting a bit tangled up on the specifics of the protein. I didn’t want to lie about it, but if I’d said I cooked chicken curry and he dislikes chicken but loves beef, pork, lamb, and fake meat, then some of the anti-fake meat sentiment wouldn’t weigh in.

I guess to me every meal I eat does not have to be amazing. I often have muesli in the morning (I don’t bother to make my own anymore but do add seeds and fruit) as while I don’t love it, it is healthy and easy and quick and helps me stay a healthy weight (as my toasty preference was making me gain weight). So I even have myself eat stuff I don’t love and somehow I survive the experience.

OP posts:
coffeecupsandfairylights · 24/05/2022 12:46

Ritascornershop · 24/05/2022 11:53

I wish I could edit the original post as I know people
can’t always read the whole thread, but I did NOT make the food knowing he disliked it. That would be bizarre. I thought he’d get on more with fake meat (they’re soft “meat”balls that soak up the sauce so taste like whatever the sauce is) than chickpeas or dahl.

No, but the point is you just assumed and didn't check, which is pretty damn rude IMO.

Hugasauras · 24/05/2022 12:44

I think most people have (thankfully) moved on from the old tradition of having to eat everything on your plate, including stuff you really don't like. That really isn't something to look back on fondly!

Eeksteek · 24/05/2022 12:44

What would you have done if he served you meat? What should any adult do? Politely decline and cater for themselves, I’d have thought. You tried (and that’s thoughtful) but he didn’t like it. It’s not you he doesn’t like. Maybe more discussions in advance about meals to help with waste etc.

maxelly · 24/05/2022 12:44

I do think the people that are saying it's the ordering of the pizza that was rude not the leaving of the tofu, are right - getting a takeaway does draw attention to the situation and a pizza is a whole meal in itself which kind of implies OP had provided nothing at all for him which isn't right, he'd eaten the other elements just not the protein part, so he shouldn't have needed a whole extra meal to not starve, he wouldn't have wasted away before the morning on a piece of toast or a yoghurt or sandwich or something and given he was staying in the house as a family member he could def have fetched that discreetly later in the evening without drawing attention to it (totally different if it was a dinner party situation when it absolutely would have been weird for a guest to go to the host's kitchen and start helping themselves to extra food, but then he could have just got himself something on the way home in that scenario).

I think today's etiquette on unwanted meals in other people's homes has shifted a bit since my youth, in the past I do think 'force it down' was more expected (I gave myself food poisoning once by forcing down undercooked pork to avoid giving offence, that def was going too far Grin) - now I think it's more normal to eat it if it's something you simply don't prefer/not to your taste, but if you truly dislike it or are allergic or whatever to push it around a bit, make polite noises about it being lovely but you're just not very hungry right now if asked about it and then quietly get yourself something else if still hungry later on, if at all possible without your host noticing as it's still rude to imply their food/cooking wasn't nice even if it was obviously horrible (which it sounds like yours wasn't) - it's the last part he's failed on IMO!

AdmiralsPie · 24/05/2022 12:43

I don't force my kids to eat everything on the plate like I was taught to do. Leaving a particular veg quietly on the side of the plate is ok in my book.

However it was very rude of him to order the pizza. It would be been better to nip out for some evening snacks to share.

Ruraljurer · 24/05/2022 12:41

I always tell my kids to listen to their body, and don’t force themselves to eat anything they don’t want to. But they do need to be polite about it.

Ruraljurer · 24/05/2022 12:39

Not at all rude. If I were in his position I would have said something like, ‘ I’m so sorry, you’re a wonderful cook but I just am not into X so if it’s ok I will leave it, thank you for the lovely dinner’.

SpeedofaSloth · 24/05/2022 12:29

Nothing would make me eat fake meat TBH, I am not one for eating things out of politeness either really and I don't expect my kids to if it is something they really don't like.
Not sure I would have ordered a pizza though, I might have eaten your fruit bowl instead possibly.

AhNowTed · 24/05/2022 12:28

I'm probably a similar age to OP as I was also brought up to eat everything on the plate.

That included fat and gristle which made me gag.

Todays equivalent is tofu.

So, no I wouldn't expect him to eat it, and I don't force feed my children stuff they genuinely cannot stomach.

Ritascornershop · 24/05/2022 12:24

@Noglassjustthebottleandastraw 🙄

OP posts:
Passportloser · 24/05/2022 12:23

No way would I eat fake meat. I don’t like what it’s made of I shouldn’t have to eat it because someone chooses to be vegetarian

Notanotherwindow · 24/05/2022 12:22

I wouldn't have been able to eat it either tbh. Fake meat tastes vile and I'm not that keen on most veg either. The taste makes me gag.

I'd probably have picked at what I could stomach then claimed a headache and gone to McDonald's if hungry. Wouldn't have ordered a pizza to your house though, that is really rude. He should have just made an excuse and left early.

Noglassjustthebottleandastraw · 24/05/2022 12:19

OP I am glad you found this out now before they have children (sorry assuming they don't have children yet) as the whole eat what's in front of you and forcing an individual person to eat something that they don't like is abusive controlling behaviour. It is perfectly normal for people not to like certain foods and it's perfectly normal for them not to eat it. People and children are allowed autonomy over there own bodies and life.

Your responses to this thread actually make me feel like you are oblivious to this and that's really scary.

coconuthead · 24/05/2022 12:19

Maybe a bit rude to order a pizza or cook meat in a vegetarians home. But to me, as a host, you should check what your cooking is going to be ok for your guests

Pickabearanybear · 24/05/2022 12:16

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

ReadyToMoveIt · 24/05/2022 12:16

And if he’s there for a long visit, far better that he feels comfortable enough to sort himself out with food if he needs to.

Alcibiade · 24/05/2022 12:14

YABU to have the attitude that your SIL should eat what is put in front of him. He is not a child.

He would have been rude if he made snide, sarcastic comments about the fake meat. Assuming he was polite in saying that he did not like it, I do not see what you are upset about. It's not as though he was implying that your cooking was bad. He just does not like fake meat, so he got himself something with a bit of meat in it.

ReadyToMoveIt · 24/05/2022 12:14

CulturePigeon · 24/05/2022 12:11

YANBU. I'm a veggie but my husband isn't and we manage because he's a sensible meat-eater and realises that he won't die if he doesn't eat meat twice a day. Human's don't need to eat meat every day from a nutritional point of view. Yes, he prefers meat but he knows it's better for everyone (including the fact that we can share a meal!) to go meatless a few days a week.

It's surely just conditioning that meat and 2 veg = a proper meal?

Even as a veggie, I would argue that people really just need to cut down on meat consumption and be prepared to pay a lot more for it (an animal's life is sold way too cheaply at the moment) and then welfare etc for these poor creatures could be improved. Older relatives remember when a chicken was a treat - in the way a joint of beef is now - and perhaps it still should be!

I think you’ve misunderstood the issue.
The SIL didn’t have an issue with the meal being vegetarian. He just didn’t like the fake meat in the curry, so he left it. I don’t like it either, so would have done the same. I am unwilling to force down food that I really dislike.
Obviously as he then didn’t have enough to eat, he ordered himself a pizza so that he wasn’t hungry.
He wasn’t expecting meat to be served, he just didn’t like the tofu based alternative.

Bonjovispjs · 24/05/2022 12:14

I don't blame him, sounds disgusting🙁I'd have wanted a pizza too!

CulturePigeon · 24/05/2022 12:11

YANBU. I'm a veggie but my husband isn't and we manage because he's a sensible meat-eater and realises that he won't die if he doesn't eat meat twice a day. Human's don't need to eat meat every day from a nutritional point of view. Yes, he prefers meat but he knows it's better for everyone (including the fact that we can share a meal!) to go meatless a few days a week.

It's surely just conditioning that meat and 2 veg = a proper meal?

Even as a veggie, I would argue that people really just need to cut down on meat consumption and be prepared to pay a lot more for it (an animal's life is sold way too cheaply at the moment) and then welfare etc for these poor creatures could be improved. Older relatives remember when a chicken was a treat - in the way a joint of beef is now - and perhaps it still should be!

maddy68 · 24/05/2022 12:10

No he isn't rude. You haven't provided food he will eat. So he provided his own

ReadyToMoveIt · 24/05/2022 12:08

And if he’d have eaten it, you’d have assumed he liked, and cooked it again. Far better to be honest.

ReadyToMoveIt · 24/05/2022 12:07

I’d be mortified if I found out someone had forced down food they don’t like just so that they didn’t offend me.

Swipe left for the next trending thread