Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Leaving baby in buggy when going for swim

108 replies

Popsicle72 · 24/05/2022 08:29

I’m on a forum for outdoor swimmers and spotted this argument a few days ago. A mum was looking for advice about dryrobe to use. She mentioned she leaves her baby in buggy when she goes for a swim. Lots of people gave dryrobe recommendations and then someone pointed out how irresponsible it is to consider going off for swim and leaving baby in buggy. Such an argument/debate followed. I am in agreement that’s it’s very irresponsible but just wondered what others think? Sometimes I think I worry too much about child safety

OP posts:
donquixotedelamancha · 24/05/2022 09:38

I would be very very surprised if the police prosecuted for neglect in any of these circumstances.

Police don't even prosecute for neglect when a family court judge rules neglect is so severe that children should be placed for adoption.

This. I think some people are a bit deluded about how hard it is to prove neglect.

Making a risk judgement that some/many would disagree with isn't even close.

ComDummings · 24/05/2022 09:37

Wild swimming alone and leaving a child on the side unattended is beyond stupid.
Mum could drown, child could get tangled up in the buggy straps while mum is swimming, someone could take the buggy, the buggy could roll into the water, child could choke etc etc.

TabithaTittlemouse · 24/05/2022 09:32

Depends on the age of the baby, how quickly mum can get out, the area…. A hundred things!

This debate comes up often where I live because of the beaches and rivers. I don’t think there’s one set answer.

Whenever I swim I tell someone where I am going, just in case. Some places are safer than others.

BogRollBOGOF · 24/05/2022 09:26

When my two were little they had back to back swimming lessons. Initially baby was in his car seat, then the play pen during DS1's lessons, and DS1 sat poolside during DS2's lessons, he was 2 and old enough to play with his toys and understand that he and baby took turns to swim (turns out he has ASD which was why he was pretty patient and complient). Critically there was a teacher/ lifeguard next to him and in a shallow teaching pool, I was never far away.

I "wild swim" solo. My children are much older now and can swim, but I still wouldn't mix the two. I wouldn't leave a baby in a pram as to be in deep enough water to be shoulder deep, and have gentle enough access in and out, you're not that close. It's not long before babies can wriggle out of straps and if they are young enough that's pretty bloody young to be left with minimal supervision.

Swimming in cold water is not free from the chance of unpredictable risk even if experienced with excellent local knowledge and it's a bad idea in case of a random incident involving mother or baby.

If there is someone consistently with baby aware that they are monitoring them, that's a different situation.

anniz91 · 24/05/2022 09:25

How can people say it's safe? Are you telling me you know every single person that passes the "buggy" with the child in know the persons full history/ background?

Just the other day I saw a white van pull up asking a boy of 10 to come with him for a ride. The boy refused and ran home. I'm pretty sure leaving a defenceless baby in the buggy is even worse...

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 24/05/2022 09:21

There are plenty of acceptable and much safer alternatives.

Buddy up with another parent and take turns
Use a pool with a creche
Book a babysitter/have a grandparent or the other parent mind the baby
Swim after/before work and have baby in childcare longer
Reduce hobby amount if none of the above are possible, accepting that we have to change sometimes when kids come along.

ElenaSt · 24/05/2022 09:19

I think there should be at least two responsible people there so one can swim and one can stay with baby/child if it's wild swimming.

Notanotherwindow · 24/05/2022 09:18

Also how old is this baby? Mine could undo her own straps by 14 months.

Googlecanthelpme · 24/05/2022 09:16

Wild swimming alone and leaving baby in the buggy unattended - hell no!

what the actual fuck?

99% of the time it’s going to be absolutely fine isn’t it. It’s very very unlikely that anyone is going to come along and take or hurt baby. Like super unlikely.
But it’s not impossible. Because it happens, babies are snatched, kids are taken.

On the basis that I do not even want to take a 1% chance that something could happen to my child then no I absolutely would not and could not ever do this.

Some people are ok taking that small chance aren’t they.

Perhaps those people do not listen to true crime podcasts and do not understand that all it takes is to be in the wrong place and the wrong time.

WorkEvent · 24/05/2022 09:15

A lot of context missing. If you are properly swimming then I really don’t think it’s possible to pay enough attention, or that you’d be close enough to baby to be of any use of something happened. A quick dunk and a bit of head up breaststroke and it’s probably be fine. Also Is it a swim in a pond/river on private land, or a busy beach? Loads of other stuff to consider too.

BungleandGeorge · 24/05/2022 09:11

Lazypuppy · 24/05/2022 09:00

That type of swimming yes irresponsible. In a pool where you can always see the pushchair and child is asleep i don't see the problem. No different to leaving them in the car at petrol stations.

I think important things are being able to see them, and get to them relatively quickly once they have woken up

Well it is really as the baby would be in a locked car for a very short time unattended whilst paying for petrol. It’s an essential activity and there’s a risk involved in taking them out across the forecourt. Not really the same as leaving them on the side because you fancy a swim.

shes leaving her child unattended to pursue a leisure activity. And a risky one at that.

SaggyBlinders · 24/05/2022 09:08

Assuming that you mean this post?

Sounds like she is wild swimming rather than just outdoor swimming. I can't see any negative comments on the forum, but personally I think it's a pretty stupid. Something could happen to her, cold water shock, get her feet tangled in weeds, get cramp, fast currents, struggle to get out etc, and then what happens to the baby?

Odd that I can't see any negative comments on the post though, must have all been deleted.

Leaving baby in buggy when going for swim
Snoken · 24/05/2022 09:06

I wouldn't necessarily have a problem with it if she was swimming with other people, and not because I think the baby is in any great danger of kidnappers but because something can happen to the mother out there in the water. Then the baby is on its own for god knows how long.

Lazypuppy · 24/05/2022 09:00

That type of swimming yes irresponsible. In a pool where you can always see the pushchair and child is asleep i don't see the problem. No different to leaving them in the car at petrol stations.

I think important things are being able to see them, and get to them relatively quickly once they have woken up

Beamur · 24/05/2022 08:57

If it's remote and she's alone, that's very risky. What if she got cramp or cold water shock? She could drown and then what would happen? That's more likely I would have thought than child abduction.

Popsicle72 · 24/05/2022 08:55

Sorry I should have added it is remote swimming, she said she swims alone. The other poster said it was neglectful and there was uproar. It just shocked me at how many people were trying to say it was acceptable to go for a swim and leave the baby in buggy.

OP posts:
CousCousSalad · 24/05/2022 08:54

Tiani4 · 24/05/2022 08:41

Leaving a baby unattended in a buggy whilst you go for a swim even if child is in sight (they won't always be) is it-responsible and if anything happened to baby or someone spotted this, police would be called and consider child neglect. This happens also of someone reports a baby being left in car whilst parents goes into petrol station shop. Even though many parents do that and say they children are in sight at all times.

U.K. laws are vague enough that people don't realise how easily police can prosecute for child neglect

Leaving a baby unattended whilst going for a swim is a very unusual and potentially very unsafe decision. No one needs an outdoor swim that much they can't arrange childcare for it.

I would be very very surprised if the police prosecuted for neglect in any of these circumstances.

Police don't even prosecute for neglect when a family court judge rules neglect is so severe that children should be placed for adoption.

Qwill · 24/05/2022 08:53

What if she goes with friends who take it in turns to look after the babies? What if it’s a specific mum and baby swim session and there is supervision. There aren’t really enough details here.

DingleyDel · 24/05/2022 08:53

If you are just swimming up and down within a pool sized area whilst you baby is in sight I don’t see a problem. I used to leave baby dc in their car seat on the side of the pool occasionally whilst I had a quick dip either before or after taking them.

Needmorelego · 24/05/2022 08:52

Sorry...just re read and saw it's outdoor swimming. If that's 'wild swimming' then no definitely not a good idea. If it's a public Lido then maybe...?

Needmorelego · 24/05/2022 08:51

I remember my local swimming pool as a child had a built in play pen to put babies in at the side of the pool so presumably parents could swim without them.

FreedomDrops · 24/05/2022 08:48

Anything could happen.

SaggyBlinders · 24/05/2022 08:48

I wonder where she goes outdoor swimming. I go to a place which would definitely not allow this.

Leaving a baby/child in a thing with wheels near water is the dumbest thing I've heard for a while.

Unless she literally swims up and down in tiny little lengths right next to where the buggy is parked (which is doubtful), then she would struggle to keep an eye on her baby or get back in time if anything did happen: buggy somehow went in water, someone ran off with baby etc.

InChocolateWeTrust · 24/05/2022 08:43

police would be called and consider child neglect. This happens also of someone reports a baby being left in car whilst parents goes into petrol station shop

I'm willing to bet the number of successful prosecutions for child neglect on account of a baby left in a car whilst parents go into petrol station shop, with the car in eyesight, is zero.

Tiani4 · 24/05/2022 08:42

I'd expect there to be an adult on shore supervising generally whilst babies or children are left on the side

If this parent is doing solo swim or group not leaving anyone supervising then it is not a decision children services nor police would be happy with if they were called

Swipe left for the next trending thread