Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

WIBU to ask why people are so weird about cry it out?

408 replies

Worried675 · 24/05/2022 06:34

OK, I know already how this is going to go and what views about this are on Mumsnet, but my question I guess is why people are so against cry it out methods? Recent research showed no differences in babies' behaviour/happiness/attachment etc. between cry it out and other sleep training methods. I'm always surprised by how strongly people are against it, especially as anyone born in the 80s or before probably were trained that way.

Enlighten me! Is using cry it out unreasonable? Why/why not?

OP posts:
Bambi7 · 24/05/2022 11:34

It's honestly basic psychology and teach at A level and first year at uni.

It is well known in psychology that consistently leaving a baby to cry results in attachment issues.

Do your own research people! You should know basic psychology of you are a parent!

SleeplessInEngland · 24/05/2022 11:33

"Yes - the example in the photo is extreme - from a Romanian orphanage"

Not this example again! It's the one that's always used and yes, it so extreme it's useless as evidence. Those children endured severe neglect, they were neglected in their waking hours, undernourished and ignored almost entirely.

lavenderfine · 24/05/2022 11:32

DD is almost 4 months old, from day 1 she's just laid down in her Moses basket or cot and fallen asleep when she's been tired, I have needed to help her fall asleep about 4 times she's been born, I've never had to think about crying it out.
DS however is 3.5 and still doesn't sleep through, still needs me or DH to sit with him while he falls asleep and still comes into our bed most nights. He's been an awful sleeper since day 1, I thought about letting him cry and I just couldn't do it, I like that DS is secure enough to come to me if he wakes. He knows I will meet his needs as I always have done, I don't think you get to clock out of being a parent.
Just to add though I have tried some gentle sleep training methods but just didn't bother sticking with them, I've no problem with gentle sleep training such as gradual retreat shush pat etc but I couldn't ever just leave my child to cry and ignore them, but I'd never leave my DH to cry and ignore him either.

SnackSizeRaisin · 24/05/2022 11:31

roarfeckingroarr · 24/05/2022 11:13

It's cruel, it's unnatural, it teaches babies that no one comes when they cry.

Once DS was around 14 months we used a variation of Ferber where he let him cry for 5, 7, 9, 11 min at a time. He never lasted 9 because he knew he was safe and loved and he was old enough to understand bed time.

Sleep training small babies is basically neglect

Eh? This makes no sense whatsoever

DogsAndGin · 24/05/2022 11:30

Because babies who are left unattended don’t develop certain parts of their brain.

Yes - the example in the photo is extreme - from a Romanian orphanage. I know several children who were left alone to the point of neglect here in the UK, who have the same underdeveloped brains. They suffer from attachment disorder as a result, and have extreme behavioural challenges and will never have the ability to feel empathy, love or safety like normal people do. They rely, instead, on their overdeveloped ‘fight or flight’ response - which you can see at the back of the brain.

Leaving a baby to cry for long periods is a bit too close to this type of neglect, even if it is temporary - who knows how quickly the damage can be done.

The children I am referring to were removed as tiny babies, but it was too late - life long physical damage to their brains had already been done. Love is critical to the development of a child, just like food and shelter.

WIBU to ask why people are so weird about cry it out?
Bambi7 · 24/05/2022 11:30

@Pyri

But the Ferber method (for example which is CC not CIO) usually only takes a few days to work for the baby to sleep through. So how is that “consistently not meeting the baby’s needs”? If you spend every other waking minute and hour meeting their needs for 9/10/11 months how does a few nights of leaving them to cry and going back a few minutes later damage them?

I am not referring to particular cry it out methods though am I? I am answering the poster. Also if you read my posts I said consistently not meeting a babies needs (and not one or two times).

SnackSizeRaisin · 24/05/2022 11:29

Bambi7 · 24/05/2022 11:03

Absolutely!

Research the different types of attachment issues.

Adults with avoidant attachment have usually had a childhood where their needs consistently haven't been met.

That means neglect as in social services removing the child. Not sleep training. Is restricting the number of sweets your child eats the same as starving them to death?

Somuchgoo · 24/05/2022 11:26

Stompythedinosaur · 24/05/2022 11:06

People hardline about sleep training imo haven’t experienced terrible sleep and having to get on with life

This is not true. Both my dc were awful sleepers, and the first 18 months of their lives were a dark and difficult time because of the sleep deprivation. Neither reliably slept through until 3.

What I now know (but didn't know then) is that this was related to a physical issue and they were in pain.

I am very proud that they were never left to cry in pain alone and uncomforted. It was hard, but I feel we made the right decision but continuing to comfort them, no matter how tired we were.

We had similar. My absolutely awful sleeper, who I cuddled and breastfed baby to sleep innumerable times a night turned out to have a brain tumour which was causing her headaches.

I'm very glad I comforted rather than sleep trained, even though it was hard. The idea that I could have left her cry herself to sleep when in pain makes me shudder now.

Pyri · 24/05/2022 11:25

Bambi7 · 24/05/2022 11:16

And actually it doesn't need to be abuse to result in attachment issues. If you're consistently not meeting your child's needs (ie the cry it out method) then yes that will result in some attachment issues. They're learning that their basic needs won't be met by their primary caregiver.

But the Ferber method (for example which is CC not CIO) usually only takes a few days to work for the baby to sleep through. So how is that “consistently not meeting the baby’s needs”? If you spend every other waking minute and hour meeting their needs for 9/10/11 months how does a few nights of leaving them to cry and going back a few minutes later damage them?

Bambi7 · 24/05/2022 11:23

@Cornettoninja

It was the other way around in my experience, sharing a bed was never something I had a preference for (or indeed had much irl support for). Sleep training didn’t work for us but cosleeping did and came about after many failures to get dd to sleep alone.

This was my experience too.

SleeplessInEngland · 24/05/2022 11:22

^sorry, meant to say you tried sleep training first

SleeplessInEngland · 24/05/2022 11:22

Cornettoninja · 24/05/2022 11:19

It was the other way around in my experience, sharing a bed was never something I had a preference for (or indeed had much irl support for). Sleep training didn’t work for us but cosleeping did and came about after many failures to get dd to sleep alone.

And that's great - but as you say you did try co-sleeping first. My post was for the people who would never dream of it, for the aformentioned reasons.

Bambi7 · 24/05/2022 11:21

Topgub · 24/05/2022 11:17

@Bambi7

That makes no sense.

Well I don't know how else to explain it to you Smile

I'm a therapist.

You don't have to agree with me or understand what I'm saying (I'm not here to do your homework).

Please do you your own research but use the appropriate research databases and tools x

Cornettoninja · 24/05/2022 11:19

SleeplessInEngland · 24/05/2022 11:14

My benchmark for a good/bad sleeper is whether they can co-sleep. If they can do that sufficiently enough for mother and baby to get enough hours then that mother's opinion on whether sleep training is cruel/unecessary doesn't hold much weight to me. Co-sleeping is a really nice option to have if it works for you.

I only mention it as there have been quite a few posters berating CIO and then casually adding that they coslept instead. Yeah, you did that because you could.

It was the other way around in my experience, sharing a bed was never something I had a preference for (or indeed had much irl support for). Sleep training didn’t work for us but cosleeping did and came about after many failures to get dd to sleep alone.

Topgub · 24/05/2022 11:18

@Bambi7

Except thats not true.

There's no evidence cio (in the context of a st method in a non abusive home) leads to attachment issues

SleeplessInEngland · 24/05/2022 11:17

Research attachment issues.

Why don't you give me the abridged version. You brought it up, after all.

Topgub · 24/05/2022 11:17

@Bambi7

That makes no sense.

Bambi7 · 24/05/2022 11:16

Topgub · 24/05/2022 11:09

@Bambi7

Adults with avoidant attachment have usually had a childhood where their needs consistently haven't been met.

needs consistently haven't been met being the important bit of that sentence. There has to be consistent, sustained, abuse and neglect.

Not a few nights of st where all other needs are met.

Sleep is a need too.

And actually it doesn't need to be abuse to result in attachment issues. If you're consistently not meeting your child's needs (ie the cry it out method) then yes that will result in some attachment issues. They're learning that their basic needs won't be met by their primary caregiver.

Bambi7 · 24/05/2022 11:14

Topgub · 24/05/2022 11:09

@Bambi7

Adults with avoidant attachment have usually had a childhood where their needs consistently haven't been met.

needs consistently haven't been met being the important bit of that sentence. There has to be consistent, sustained, abuse and neglect.

Not a few nights of st where all other needs are met.

Sleep is a need too.

But I'm not saying that letting your child cry it out once or twice is going to result in attachment issues.

I'm answering the posters question about the cry it out method.

SleeplessInEngland · 24/05/2022 11:14

My benchmark for a good/bad sleeper is whether they can co-sleep. If they can do that sufficiently enough for mother and baby to get enough hours then that mother's opinion on whether sleep training is cruel/unecessary doesn't hold much weight to me. Co-sleeping is a really nice option to have if it works for you.

I only mention it as there have been quite a few posters berating CIO and then casually adding that they coslept instead. Yeah, you did that because you could.

roarfeckingroarr · 24/05/2022 11:13

It's cruel, it's unnatural, it teaches babies that no one comes when they cry.

Once DS was around 14 months we used a variation of Ferber where he let him cry for 5, 7, 9, 11 min at a time. He never lasted 9 because he knew he was safe and loved and he was old enough to understand bed time.

Sleep training small babies is basically neglect

WhatNoRaisins · 24/05/2022 11:12

There needs to be some nuance to this topic.

I had bad sleepers who I didn't sleep train but as a result my mental health nosedived, I would spend a lot of time in a state of flight or fight due to sleep deprivation and regularly lose my rag during the day. I'm not convinced this is necessarily the better option for everyone.

Topgub · 24/05/2022 11:09

@Bambi7

Adults with avoidant attachment have usually had a childhood where their needs consistently haven't been met.

needs consistently haven't been met being the important bit of that sentence. There has to be consistent, sustained, abuse and neglect.

Not a few nights of st where all other needs are met.

Sleep is a need too.

Bambi7 · 24/05/2022 11:09

SleeplessInEngland · 24/05/2022 11:05

This was one time. Be careful if you decide to do because when you find out how detrimental it is to them you won't forgive yourself either.

How did you discover it was detrimental? What did you discover that researchers didn't?

Research attachment issues.

John Bowlby was the founder of the attachment theory.

Stompythedinosaur · 24/05/2022 11:06

People hardline about sleep training imo haven’t experienced terrible sleep and having to get on with life

This is not true. Both my dc were awful sleepers, and the first 18 months of their lives were a dark and difficult time because of the sleep deprivation. Neither reliably slept through until 3.

What I now know (but didn't know then) is that this was related to a physical issue and they were in pain.

I am very proud that they were never left to cry in pain alone and uncomforted. It was hard, but I feel we made the right decision but continuing to comfort them, no matter how tired we were.