Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

WIBU to ask why people are so weird about cry it out?

408 replies

Worried675 · 24/05/2022 06:34

OK, I know already how this is going to go and what views about this are on Mumsnet, but my question I guess is why people are so against cry it out methods? Recent research showed no differences in babies' behaviour/happiness/attachment etc. between cry it out and other sleep training methods. I'm always surprised by how strongly people are against it, especially as anyone born in the 80s or before probably were trained that way.

Enlighten me! Is using cry it out unreasonable? Why/why not?

OP posts:
Bambi7 · 24/05/2022 20:51

@LuckySantangelo35

Parents (well mothers cos let’s face it, it’s alway mothers) have needs too and sleep is one of them. No need to feel sad or guilty about it at all!

Absolutely. If we need to leave them for a little bit because we are at the end of our tether wIth sleep deprivation then that's ok, we're only human. We're taking about consistent cry it out / sleep training.

Bambi7 · 24/05/2022 20:48

@Palease

It is amazing but it feels shameful as people are so judgmental about it. IMO the baby is crying because it’s tired, not because it wants it’s Mum. The best way to care for the baby is help it learn how to go to sleep on its own. So those people saying they stop crying because they learn no one is coming are talking nonsense, they stop crying because they learn they can end their anguish at being tired by closing their eyes.

You're talking absolute nonsense! Richard Ferber is trained in physical health with no psychological training. Your baby is learning that you cannot be depended on - the most important developmental work your baby is doing is learning how to trust.

LuckySantangelo35 · 24/05/2022 20:44

Going against the grain here, but if you are on your knees with exhaustion I see absolutely nothing wrong with letting a baby cry for a little bit - sometimes they will just have a cry before drifting off or when settling themselves back to sleep, etc

A baby who is loved and cared for, not hungry and not wet/dirty will be absolutely fine to cry for a short time - they will not be emotionally traumatised and scarred. Baby will come to no harm and is in no danger. They are safe and warm.

Parents (well mothers cos let’s face it, it’s alway mothers) have needs too and sleep is one of them. No need to feel sad or guilty about it at all!

Palease · 24/05/2022 20:28

KingofLoss · 24/05/2022 20:18

That’s awesome! It’s such a valuable thing to help them get better sleep.

We also used Ferber two years ago, at 6m. He’s slept through every night since (barring a night feed for the first few months). He’s 2.5yr now and loves his bedtime. Goes to sleep within literally seconds at 630pm and sleeps until I get him up for the day at 7am. Best decision I’ve ever made. I’m so, so thankful. It’s like magic.

It is amazing but it feels shameful as people are so judgmental about it. IMO the baby is crying because it’s tired, not because it wants it’s Mum. The best way to care for the baby is help it learn how to go to sleep on its own. So those people saying they stop crying because they learn no one is coming are talking nonsense, they stop crying because they learn they can end their anguish at being tired by closing their eyes.

pucelleauxblanchesmains · 24/05/2022 20:23

"I wouldn't leave my husband or mother crying alone, why would I do that to a baby just so I can watch TV or sleep undisturbed? Don't have a baby then." I'm sure that's really helpful for mothers experiencing post natal mental illness aggravated by poor sleep, or afraid of getting into car accidents or hurting the baby accidentally. They clearly aren't just cut out for motherhood (??)

KingofLoss · 24/05/2022 20:18

Palease · 24/05/2022 20:15

We did sleep training with my DS, the Ferber method when he was 8 months old. He was waking in the night and crying because he was tired. I couldn’t get him back to sleep as he wasn’t crying for a bottle so I was at a loss as to how to help him get back to sleep. After 2 nights he was sleeping through.

He’s 12 months now. I put him to bed an hour ago, gave him his teddy which he took and then went to sleep without even a grumble. He’s a great sleeper now. Goes down for naps without crying. I feel I’ve helped him learn how to sleep well.

That’s awesome! It’s such a valuable thing to help them get better sleep.

We also used Ferber two years ago, at 6m. He’s slept through every night since (barring a night feed for the first few months). He’s 2.5yr now and loves his bedtime. Goes to sleep within literally seconds at 630pm and sleeps until I get him up for the day at 7am. Best decision I’ve ever made. I’m so, so thankful. It’s like magic.

Palease · 24/05/2022 20:15

We did sleep training with my DS, the Ferber method when he was 8 months old. He was waking in the night and crying because he was tired. I couldn’t get him back to sleep as he wasn’t crying for a bottle so I was at a loss as to how to help him get back to sleep. After 2 nights he was sleeping through.

He’s 12 months now. I put him to bed an hour ago, gave him his teddy which he took and then went to sleep without even a grumble. He’s a great sleeper now. Goes down for naps without crying. I feel I’ve helped him learn how to sleep well.

PatientlyWaiting21 · 24/05/2022 17:07

LeeMucklowesCurtains · 24/05/2022 12:56

I have only known one person who said they did cry it out and it meant they put their baby in their room at 8pm and then didn’t open the door for anything until 6am. Baby was on another floor so they said they wouldn’t hear much anyway.

That was unspeakably cruel and dangerous in my opinion, but I am sure they are in the minority and most people wouldn’t dream of doing that, they would listen and check and that couple were just an extreme example.

That is horrendous!!

SnackSizeRaisin · 24/05/2022 15:24

scoobydo99 · 24/05/2022 14:44

@Ahurricaneofjacarandas - is there actually any evidence for any of those things though? And while maybe fewer (middle class) parents worked they were often less "present". Have seen plenty of theories (many plausible) but not real evidence. What I suppose I'm trying to say is that despite our more child-focussed lives now we are somehow still failing to support our children's mental health.

Social media has been shown to cause problems for mental health of teenagers.

Lack of responsibility, risk taking and independence from a young age is also shown to cause mental health issues.

So child centred parenting actually causes more problems in some ways - now children no longer play outside with friends with all the risks and benefits involved. They are more likely to be home "safe" behind a screen.

Bambi7 · 24/05/2022 15:19

RidingMyBike · 24/05/2022 15:06

@Bambi7 in that case no encouragement to try stuff for themselves, they have no experience of their mum going away and coming back, as they've never been away from her, so not had a chance to build up that confidence. The kid was never ever put down as a baby so there was never any opportunity to experience things on their own - initially for mine this was a few minutes as a small baby, including a bit of grizzling before she went to sleep. And that's just carried on as this kid got bigger.

Most people don't take AP to those extremes, like most people don't, I suspect, go to the full extreme of CIO. Most people's reality is being able to respond immediately to their kid the vast majority of the time, and a few days of a bit of crying isn't going to do any harm.

Ok but that's got nothing to do with the co-sleeping / sleep training.

You can co-sleep and still have an independent child.

RidingMyBike · 24/05/2022 15:06

@Bambi7 in that case no encouragement to try stuff for themselves, they have no experience of their mum going away and coming back, as they've never been away from her, so not had a chance to build up that confidence. The kid was never ever put down as a baby so there was never any opportunity to experience things on their own - initially for mine this was a few minutes as a small baby, including a bit of grizzling before she went to sleep. And that's just carried on as this kid got bigger.

Most people don't take AP to those extremes, like most people don't, I suspect, go to the full extreme of CIO. Most people's reality is being able to respond immediately to their kid the vast majority of the time, and a few days of a bit of crying isn't going to do any harm.

3WildOnes · 24/05/2022 14:56

ShirleyPhallus · 24/05/2022 13:21

If the methods involves consistency letting your child cry it out then I don't agree with it.

<bangs head against wall>

No method of sleep training consistently let’s your child cry it out. Once you do it, if you do it, it takes a few days and that’s that. There is no method of sleep training that consistently leaves your child to cry.

It often takes longer than a few days. From what I remember of extinction studies 90% of babies are sleeping through within two weeks of training commencing.

Bambi7 · 24/05/2022 14:53

@scoobydo99

What I suppose I'm trying to say is that despite our more child-focussed lives now we are somehow still failing to support our children's mental health.

Agree with this. I blame some of it on the 'time out' approach. I'm not going to explore this now as that is for another thread!

Everything I do for my DC is for their MH and a lot of the parenting books are not for me!

scoobydo99 · 24/05/2022 14:44

@Ahurricaneofjacarandas - is there actually any evidence for any of those things though? And while maybe fewer (middle class) parents worked they were often less "present". Have seen plenty of theories (many plausible) but not real evidence. What I suppose I'm trying to say is that despite our more child-focussed lives now we are somehow still failing to support our children's mental health.

Bambi7 · 24/05/2022 14:40

RidingMyBike · 24/05/2022 14:31

The most anxious child I know, a 10yo very much lacking in self-confidence has never experienced sleep-training, has been extremely attachment parented, always been responded to instantly, always co-slept.

But there is a reason for the child being anxious isn't there. They have been exposed to something within their environment to cause this.

Just because you co sleep doesn't mean you're child won't suffer from being anxious in the future - something else could have caused this.

RidingMyBike · 24/05/2022 14:31

The most anxious child I know, a 10yo very much lacking in self-confidence has never experienced sleep-training, has been extremely attachment parented, always been responded to instantly, always co-slept.

Ahurricaneofjacarandas · 24/05/2022 14:30

scoobydo99 · 24/05/2022 14:04

It's not something I would ever have done with my DCs for many reasons, but I was born in the 1960s where it was certainly the norm (and my mum certainly did it). It is interesting that there has been a massive increase in anxiety in children and young people (some evidence this is "real" rather than related to increased diagnosis), yet these cohorts would rarely have been exposed to CIO like earlier generations were. I think bandying it around as a cause of long term anxiety with no real proof is probably not helpful (although am obviously not suggesting CIO reduces the risk of anxiety!).

There are many reasons that mood disorders and personality disorders are more common ow than in the 60's

  1. We talk about these things and label them more readily

  2. There's lots more factors of modern life which mean a baby is less likely to get the bonding and crucial interaction it needs. It's much more common for both parents to work. There's more access to screentime etc. We're often more separated from secondary caregivers eg grandparents.

  3. We're generally a lot less willing to allow our kids to take risk than we were generations ago. Kids don't go off for hours on end and climb railway lines etc. This might not seem important but actually it's massive ITO kids developing a sense of self and the feeling of wellbeing that comes with it

  4. kids are exposed more and more to unhelpful and antisocial play such as computers and tablets. This is fine in small bursts but many of the 6-12 YOs I know who IMO should absolutely be playing together are so fixated on screentime that they don't know how to play or they see it as 'uncool' to play with their peers.

  5. we were all generally more active in the 60s. This has a massive impact on wellbeing

These and lots of other factors mean it's impossible to use how are parents were put to sleep vs how we put our own kids to sleep as any kind of meaningful comparison

scoobydo99 · 24/05/2022 14:04

It's not something I would ever have done with my DCs for many reasons, but I was born in the 1960s where it was certainly the norm (and my mum certainly did it). It is interesting that there has been a massive increase in anxiety in children and young people (some evidence this is "real" rather than related to increased diagnosis), yet these cohorts would rarely have been exposed to CIO like earlier generations were. I think bandying it around as a cause of long term anxiety with no real proof is probably not helpful (although am obviously not suggesting CIO reduces the risk of anxiety!).

Bambi7 · 24/05/2022 13:37

@Fridafever

No method of sleep training consistently let’s your child cry it out. Once you do it, if you do it, it takes a few days and that’s that. There is no method of sleep training that consistently leaves your child to cry.

Why is it called cry it out then?! I think the OP knew what she was doing when she put that in the title. A bit misleading if you're not letting them cry or out don't you think?

ShirleyPhallus · 24/05/2022 13:35

Bambi7 · 24/05/2022 13:27

@ShirleyPhallus

No method of sleep training consistently let’s your child cry it out. Once you do it, if you do it, it takes a few days and that’s that. There is no method of sleep training that consistently leaves your child to

Bang your head all you like 😂

I will still state from OPs description of cry it out (she doesn't state the process of CIO) that I don't agree with letting children cry it out.

You have to understand @ShirleyPhallus that people who use this approach might consistently leave their child to cry. My exs friends wife did this and I remember describing it to as leaving him to cry and it was heartbreaking but now he doesn't cry for her during the night. Hmm wonder why.

If you don’t understand what the process of any sleep training method is then why come on to a thread with your “expert” opinion and argue against it? If someone has put something for discussion it isn’t up to them to educate posters so they can give a random opinion. I would never wander on to threads about alcoholism or something and then give my opinion, all the while misunderstanding what is actually being discussed!

Fridafever · 24/05/2022 13:27

ShirleyPhallus · 24/05/2022 13:21

If the methods involves consistency letting your child cry it out then I don't agree with it.

<bangs head against wall>

No method of sleep training consistently let’s your child cry it out. Once you do it, if you do it, it takes a few days and that’s that. There is no method of sleep training that consistently leaves your child to cry.

So would this:

I was pressured into it by friends with my ds and it was awful to ignore hours of crying, being sick, shaking etc but eventually it worked.

count as sleep training or not?

Bambi7 · 24/05/2022 13:27

@ShirleyPhallus

No method of sleep training consistently let’s your child cry it out. Once you do it, if you do it, it takes a few days and that’s that. There is no method of sleep training that consistently leaves your child to

Bang your head all you like 😂

I will still state from OPs description of cry it out (she doesn't state the process of CIO) that I don't agree with letting children cry it out.

You have to understand @ShirleyPhallus that people who use this approach might consistently leave their child to cry. My exs friends wife did this and I remember describing it to as leaving him to cry and it was heartbreaking but now he doesn't cry for her during the night. Hmm wonder why.

Bambi7 · 24/05/2022 13:23

On reflection OP it would have been better to put a type of sleep training and briefly describe it so then people can then critically appraise that particular approach.

ShirleyPhallus · 24/05/2022 13:21

Bambi7 · 24/05/2022 13:18

@ShirleyPhallus

They are. It’s in the Op that she was referred to CIO and sleep training methods. You’ve said all along that you were referring to CIO outside of sleep training, and now when asked about sleep training babe concluded that CC is fine.

I haven't said once that letting a baby cry it out consistently is ok whether that's sleep training or not.

I stand by what I originally said that I don't agree with letting a baby cry it out. Now there may be several different sleep training methods - which one are we referring to?! If the methods involves consistency letting your child cry it out then I don't agree with it.

I have consistently said that leaving them to cry a few times (so we can emotionally regulate as being a parent is hard) then that's ok too.

If the methods involves consistency letting your child cry it out then I don't agree with it.

<bangs head against wall>

No method of sleep training consistently let’s your child cry it out. Once you do it, if you do it, it takes a few days and that’s that. There is no method of sleep training that consistently leaves your child to cry.

Bambi7 · 24/05/2022 13:18

@ShirleyPhallus

They are. It’s in the Op that she was referred to CIO and sleep training methods. You’ve said all along that you were referring to CIO outside of sleep training, and now when asked about sleep training babe concluded that CC is fine.

I haven't said once that letting a baby cry it out consistently is ok whether that's sleep training or not.

I stand by what I originally said that I don't agree with letting a baby cry it out. Now there may be several different sleep training methods - which one are we referring to?! If the methods involves consistency letting your child cry it out then I don't agree with it.

I have consistently said that leaving them to cry a few times (so we can emotionally regulate as being a parent is hard) then that's ok too.

Swipe left for the next trending thread