Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

WIBU to ask why people are so weird about cry it out?

408 replies

Worried675 · 24/05/2022 06:34

OK, I know already how this is going to go and what views about this are on Mumsnet, but my question I guess is why people are so against cry it out methods? Recent research showed no differences in babies' behaviour/happiness/attachment etc. between cry it out and other sleep training methods. I'm always surprised by how strongly people are against it, especially as anyone born in the 80s or before probably were trained that way.

Enlighten me! Is using cry it out unreasonable? Why/why not?

OP posts:
Topgub · 24/05/2022 22:21

@Bambi7

Side sleepers increase risk of entrapment

baby cry it out consistently will cause attachment issues and unnecessary stress for the baby.

Right. But that's neglect and not ST so is irrelevant to the thread.

Yet you keep saying st is neglect

Bambi7 · 24/05/2022 22:17

Topgub · 24/05/2022 22:13

@Bambi7

Youve made claims that are untrue.

There is no risk to st.

Yet you say you co slept which does carry risk

Wrong again 😆

I co sleep yes but I had one of those side cots that attaches to the bed. Co sleeping yes ✅ safe yes ✅

Let's agree to disagree. I stand by my opinion that letting a baby cry it out consistently will cause attachment issues and unnecessary stress for the baby.

If done a few times then it won't. It has to be a consistent pattern of behaviour to cause any harm.

Topgub · 24/05/2022 22:13

@Bambi7

Youve made claims that are untrue.

There is no risk to st.

Yet you say you co slept which does carry risk

LuckySantangelo35 · 24/05/2022 22:10

FrecklesMalone · 24/05/2022 21:59

Best thing I ever did. DS was awake every 20 minutes for about 4 weeks. Every. Fucking Twenty Minutes. I would try everyrhing, fed him, rocked him, dummy, co sleeping, nothing worked. I didn't sleep for more than 20 minutes in a row for 4 weeks. That is torture.
I was literally going insane and couldn't be a safe or gentle mother in the day. I quite possibly would have accidentally neglected him as I was so tired I couldn't even speak. DH worked nights so wasn't about.i spent a week weaning him off night feeds (as I was a dummy) and DH rocked him to sleep instead when on days. He continued to wake up.
One night I physically couldn't get up to him (in our room) he cried for about 20 mins as I kept waking up but falling back asleep then slept through for 4 hours. The next night I decided to leave him. He cried for about 15-minute then slept through third night 5 minutes. After that unless he was ill he never woke up. Fucking amazing. I recovered from hell.
Never judge anyone.

Could people honestly, genuinely think that leaving that baby in that situation was wrong??

Really?!?

Id love to hear how anyone could try and justify a viewpoint that what that woman did was wrong

Bambi7 · 24/05/2022 22:10

Topgub · 24/05/2022 22:05

@Bambi7

Yeah I think you just dont understand what ST is

So its maybe best you stop criticising parents for doing it

Its not neglectful or damaging or unsafe

Co sleeping on the other hand...

I will contribute to this discussion if I think it's necessary.

I do now understand ST and I will continue to give my opinion. I am giving my option to ST and not peoples individual experiences.

I have consistently said that if a parent is at the end of their tether then the risk of not ST outweighs the balance of having a breakdown and flying off the handle.

My DC was an appalling sleeper. He woke every 40 minutes. I didn't ST and that was my decision.

Dr Ferber has now revisited his ST advice and stipulates not to leave children crying. He did originally suggest they cry it out.

Topgub · 24/05/2022 22:05

@Bambi7

Yeah I think you just dont understand what ST is

So its maybe best you stop criticising parents for doing it

Its not neglectful or damaging or unsafe

Co sleeping on the other hand...

LuckySantangelo35 · 24/05/2022 22:04

Thehop · 24/05/2022 12:40

Because I consider it abuse.

@Thehop

Ah you don’t know the meaning of the word

FrecklesMalone · 24/05/2022 21:59

Best thing I ever did. DS was awake every 20 minutes for about 4 weeks. Every. Fucking Twenty Minutes. I would try everyrhing, fed him, rocked him, dummy, co sleeping, nothing worked. I didn't sleep for more than 20 minutes in a row for 4 weeks. That is torture.
I was literally going insane and couldn't be a safe or gentle mother in the day. I quite possibly would have accidentally neglected him as I was so tired I couldn't even speak. DH worked nights so wasn't about.i spent a week weaning him off night feeds (as I was a dummy) and DH rocked him to sleep instead when on days. He continued to wake up.
One night I physically couldn't get up to him (in our room) he cried for about 20 mins as I kept waking up but falling back asleep then slept through for 4 hours. The next night I decided to leave him. He cried for about 15-minute then slept through third night 5 minutes. After that unless he was ill he never woke up. Fucking amazing. I recovered from hell.
Never judge anyone.

Palease · 24/05/2022 21:55

Bambi7 · 24/05/2022 21:41

@Palease

You actually have no idea that it’s teaching them that. After 2 nights of the Ferber method my son slept through. I’d say it’s taught him to sleep. He’s not lying there wide awake not crying because he knows I won’t come. He goes to sleep in his cot, on his own without crying and sleeps through.

I'm not sure whether I believe that it just took two days. How long did you leave him crying for? I do believe you have got to get that balance and if you're at the end of your tether sleep deprived then maybe it is your better option. No judging here.

I think that sleep training is different for every person. From what I've learnt some may leave their child to cry it out for several hours and some may alway stay by their babies side soothing them by stroking their back so it's impossible to comment on every case.

What I do know if that babies who are left to cry consistently experience stress and their bodies and brains release adrenaline and cortisol which can be harmful to the brain. How about depression in adults. There are so many mental health issues now. Obviously I can't prove that it's all down to the cry it out method without giving you a longitudinal study which would be unheard of anyway.

To conclude what I'm saying I think there are better ways to get a baby to sleep. As I keep staying it a parent is at the end of her tether than it might feel like the only option.

So you think I’m lying that it only took 2 days? Why would I lie?

Sleep training does not mean continually leaving your baby to cry, like I said, after 2 nights my son was sleeping through and going to sleep without any rocking/shushing etc. Occasionally he’ll cry for a minute when I put him down for sleep or nap but that’s it. He knows how to go to sleep on his own.

Bambi7 · 24/05/2022 21:52

@Topgub

You've repeatedly said it will damage children/babies. But when its pointed out the difference between neglect and St you then say you never meant st in the first place

No I haven't. I have consistently stood by what I have said. I now know cry is out is basically sleep training so I stand by what I said - leaving a baby to cry it out is neglectful (actually first time I've used the word neglectful though).

I have wanted to add that if done once or twice it's ok. It has to be a pattern of behaviour. If you had read all the posts then you'd know I have said that already.

hitrewind · 24/05/2022 21:50

@LuckySantangelo35 an adult wouldn't be crying cos they're overtired though would they

You should try being a fly on the wall in my house – I cried just this morning because I was overtired! 😂I'm basically just a very tall baby

Topgub · 24/05/2022 21:49

Yes you have @Bambi7

You've repeatedly said it will damage children/babies. But when its pointed out the difference between neglect and St you then say you never meant st in the first place

Bambi7 · 24/05/2022 21:47

@Topgub

Why fo you keep calling posters who sleep training child abusers or saying thry are detrimentally affecting their child's development and then back tracking and saying you dont mean ST but actual neglect when you're called out on it being bullshit?

I don't really follow what you're saying. I haven't o called people who sleep train child abusers 🙂. I haven't back tracked once either 🙂.

workwoes123 · 24/05/2022 21:46

more anecdata…

sister and I both born in the 1970s. My mum didn’t leave me to CIO, first baby and she didn’t really need to. She did leave my sister to CIO - often and for too long (her own admission now). My sister has always been anxious, low self esteem, and been on anti anxiety meds for years now. My mum does think it’s partly down to her being left to cry as a baby and she really regrets it, she has often said that my sister needed more reassurance but the method of the time was CIO.

i Co slept with both my boys until they were 3 and 5. Knackering at the time but I am so glad now, love those memories of nighttime cuddles and being physically close to the people I love most.

Bambi7 · 24/05/2022 21:45

@LuckySantangelo35

An adult wouldn’t be crying cos they’re overtired though would they

You're missing the point. Whether an adult is crying because their over tired or not is irrelevant. You would support them regardless of why they're crying.

Also the baby might be crying for other reasons. How do you know that 💯 of the time it's because their tired. One poster said later after the cry it out method they found out the baby had been in pain.

Topgub · 24/05/2022 21:42

@Bambi7

Why fo you keep calling posters who sleep training child abusers or saying thry are detrimentally affecting their child's development and then back tracking and saying you dont mean ST but actual neglect when you're called out on it being bullshit?

Bambi7 · 24/05/2022 21:41

@Palease

You actually have no idea that it’s teaching them that. After 2 nights of the Ferber method my son slept through. I’d say it’s taught him to sleep. He’s not lying there wide awake not crying because he knows I won’t come. He goes to sleep in his cot, on his own without crying and sleeps through.

I'm not sure whether I believe that it just took two days. How long did you leave him crying for? I do believe you have got to get that balance and if you're at the end of your tether sleep deprived then maybe it is your better option. No judging here.

I think that sleep training is different for every person. From what I've learnt some may leave their child to cry it out for several hours and some may alway stay by their babies side soothing them by stroking their back so it's impossible to comment on every case.

What I do know if that babies who are left to cry consistently experience stress and their bodies and brains release adrenaline and cortisol which can be harmful to the brain. How about depression in adults. There are so many mental health issues now. Obviously I can't prove that it's all down to the cry it out method without giving you a longitudinal study which would be unheard of anyway.

To conclude what I'm saying I think there are better ways to get a baby to sleep. As I keep staying it a parent is at the end of her tether than it might feel like the only option.

LuckySantangelo35 · 24/05/2022 21:37

robinkombucha · 24/05/2022 21:02

If I saw an adult relative crying I would comfort them physically.

@robinkombucha

An adult wouldn’t be crying cos they’re overtired though would they

Flopisfatteningbingforchristmas · 24/05/2022 21:31

Worried675 · 24/05/2022 09:25

I think it might have been this. I can't remember now! Going through my Google history to try to find it!

The research only follows children up to 18 months so makes no comment on the long term impacts of cry it out.

Palease · 24/05/2022 21:28

Bambi7 · 24/05/2022 21:02

@Palease

How dare you tell me my baby is learning I can’t be depended on. Who do you think you are?

An educated one with a psychology background. Your original statement was insulting. I'm telling you that the cry it out method is teaching the child they can't depend on you to nurture them when they're crying. I stand by that statement.

You actually have no idea that it’s teaching them that. After 2 nights of the Ferber method my son slept through. I’d say it’s taught him to sleep. He’s not lying there wide awake not crying because he knows I won’t come. He goes to sleep in his cot, on his own without crying and sleeps through.

Why do you feel the need to be so judgmental to other mums who are doing the best for their children and their families?

Bambi7 · 24/05/2022 21:04

scoobydo99 · 24/05/2022 20:56

So those who say that not responding immediately is damaging, what about second or subsequent children. I never intentionally left my DC to cry, but with the younger one it did happen when my older (still very young) child needed me more. Example was when my younger DC was 2 weeks old my older DD threw up all over me, just when she started crying. It took me a while to change, clean myself up etc. so I didn't risk passing on any infection. It felt awful hearing a newborn crying hysterically, but I had no option. Most parents have situations like that particularly when the older children are still very young. In larger families this must be a fairly regular occurence. Are you saying that this damages younger children.

@scoobydo99 you have to read properly what the posts are saying. They're not saying if it's done intermittently (because you have other things going on such as taking care of their siblings). It's consistent letting them cry it out.

robinkombucha · 24/05/2022 21:02

If I saw an adult relative crying I would comfort them physically.

Bambi7 · 24/05/2022 21:02

@Palease

How dare you tell me my baby is learning I can’t be depended on. Who do you think you are?

An educated one with a psychology background. Your original statement was insulting. I'm telling you that the cry it out method is teaching the child they can't depend on you to nurture them when they're crying. I stand by that statement.

scoobydo99 · 24/05/2022 20:56

So those who say that not responding immediately is damaging, what about second or subsequent children. I never intentionally left my DC to cry, but with the younger one it did happen when my older (still very young) child needed me more. Example was when my younger DC was 2 weeks old my older DD threw up all over me, just when she started crying. It took me a while to change, clean myself up etc. so I didn't risk passing on any infection. It felt awful hearing a newborn crying hysterically, but I had no option. Most parents have situations like that particularly when the older children are still very young. In larger families this must be a fairly regular occurence. Are you saying that this damages younger children.

Palease · 24/05/2022 20:54

Bambi7 · 24/05/2022 20:48

@Palease

It is amazing but it feels shameful as people are so judgmental about it. IMO the baby is crying because it’s tired, not because it wants it’s Mum. The best way to care for the baby is help it learn how to go to sleep on its own. So those people saying they stop crying because they learn no one is coming are talking nonsense, they stop crying because they learn they can end their anguish at being tired by closing their eyes.

You're talking absolute nonsense! Richard Ferber is trained in physical health with no psychological training. Your baby is learning that you cannot be depended on - the most important developmental work your baby is doing is learning how to trust.

How dare you tell me my baby is learning I can’t be depended on. Who do you think you are?

Swipe left for the next trending thread