Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

WIBU to ask why people are so weird about cry it out?

408 replies

Worried675 · 24/05/2022 06:34

OK, I know already how this is going to go and what views about this are on Mumsnet, but my question I guess is why people are so against cry it out methods? Recent research showed no differences in babies' behaviour/happiness/attachment etc. between cry it out and other sleep training methods. I'm always surprised by how strongly people are against it, especially as anyone born in the 80s or before probably were trained that way.

Enlighten me! Is using cry it out unreasonable? Why/why not?

OP posts:
Hercisback · 24/05/2022 07:38

Controlled crying literally saved my life and probably that of my child's. He'd be worse off without a mother than a bit of crying.

I'd never CIO though.

IncompleteSenten · 24/05/2022 07:30

Do you mean cry it out or do you mean controlled crying?

Cry it out is wrong.

Never going to your baby no matter how long they cry until they just stop bothering to cry is hugely neglectful. Leaving them crying now and again is unavoidable but never responding to their cries, night after night after night, is neglect.

Controlled crying, although not something I ever considered personally, is completely different to just ignoring them every single night until they just stop what is a natural and important infant communication.

catbirddogchild · 24/05/2022 07:28

warwick.ac.uk/newsandevents/pressreleases/leaving_your_baby/

This research?

YouSoundLovely · 24/05/2022 07:27

'will be nice when people stop expecting to give birth to a child who sleeps from 7 until 7.'

Absolutely this.

Those saying it's harmful to suggest a baby left to cry will develop a disturbed attachment (they might, and they might not - no way of knowing in advance for each individual child, so why take the risk?), what about the opposite narrative, the one that suggests if a baby isn't sleep 'trained' they'll never learn to sleep? The 'rod for your own back' crap? I bed-shared/co-slept (bedside cot arrangement basically) safely with all three of mine, and bf them at night until they stopped night feeding (well over age 2 for two of them), and they learned to drop off - with a parent in the room, at first - just fine, and two of them never came into our bed at night (except when ill) beyond the age of three or so (while one still kept coming until about 9. Individual temperaments, again).

Yes, there were moments of exhaustion. But I was not going to be made to feel I was doing it all wrong/setting myself up for some kind of eternal slavery because I did what felt right to me. IMO a lot of these narratives come from an idea that somehow you have to get the better of children/come out on top/be in control. Authoritarian at heart.

SnackSizeRaisin · 24/05/2022 07:27

Oysterbabe · 24/05/2022 06:53

When I hear a crying baby, doesn't even have to be my own, I cannot tune it out, it's just a pneumatic drill in my brain. The need to scoop them up and comfort them is insanely strong. Ignoring that just seems like madness.

This is why people don't like it. The reality is that you only contemplate it when you are pretty desperate. And if the choice is 3 nights of some extra crying or ongoing problems lasting years leading to depression, relationship breakdown...

Ringmaster27 · 24/05/2022 07:26

I’d love to see this “new research” that is the polar opposite to every other scientific finding for years 🤨
Leaving a baby to cry themselves to sleep doesn’t teach them anything except that no one will come regardless. They don’t begin to “self soothe”, they just give up trying because they learn no one will respond to their needs.

Skinnermarink · 24/05/2022 07:23

Bit the OP seems to be (I’m interested if they are actually going to come back to explain further) CIO. Not controlled crying. Leaving your baby to cry itself to sleep. Most parents know the difference between leaving your baby a few minutes see if they really need anything or assume they don’t just leave them to sob themselves into oblivion.

MissChanandlerBong80 · 24/05/2022 07:22

It’s not something I could do. That said, I think the studies showing that it’s bad for babies were flawed - they were based on children in Romanian orphanages who were neglected in every way, rather than on babies who were otherwise fed and safe and loved.

That made me wonder - there have been several situations where I’ve not been able to respond to my baby’s crying immediately and have had to leave him for a while. For example, when I’m driving or my toddler has fallen over and needs me more urgently than the baby. It makes me feel ill to leave him crying for any amount of time but sometimes you don’t have a choice, particularly with second or subsequent babies. From a baby’s POV there’s no difference between leaving them to cry out of choice and leaving them to cry because you have no choice. So if crying causes brain damage then my second baby is likely to be more brain damaged than my first because he’s been left to cry more often than my first ever was, just because he’s my second.

isthenewsuff · 24/05/2022 07:22

JustJoinedRightNow · 24/05/2022 06:38

Yes it is unreasonable to use cry it out methods. I’m in my 40s and like you say, was most likely left to cry and I suffer from anxiety.
Someone will come along soon to link the actual research showing the links to crying it out and the stress levels in a baby’s hormones, there is a direct link to mental health issues such as anxiety. No, I don’t have a source, hoping someone has it at the ready for discussions such as this.

Same. Suffered from anxiety and insomnia since I was a small child.

My mum tells me I was a terrible sleeper and used to scream and scream. I honestly have vivid memories from about the age of 3-4 of being terrified of sleeping and lying in the dark scared to move.

I've wondered if cry it out left an impact on me this way, or if I'd have been like this anyway.

110APiccadilly · 24/05/2022 07:21

I don't mean, incidentally, that I would have routinely left DD crying for five or ten minutes. But it probably would have been helpful to know that if I did it occasionally it wasn't going to hurt her.

milveycrohn · 24/05/2022 07:20

My DC were born in the 80s, and I was certainly not taught to let them cry out, and would never do so.
In relation to sleep 'training', babies (like adults), stir, change position and then sleep again, so I would generally leave a maybe just a few minutes only but then go, especially if breast feeding a young baby. (The difference then is that my young DC were in a separate room, with a baby monitor, though now babies are usually with the mother for the first 6 months).
I once asked my mother about the then theory of feeding babies every four hours only - rather than on demand (ie those DC born in the 50s etc), and she told me that she generally ignored that advice, as there was no way one can ignore a crying baby.

ChagSameachDoreen · 24/05/2022 07:19

Would you leave an adult crying inconsolably in a room to teach them a lesson?

Presumably not. That would be abusive.

110APiccadilly · 24/05/2022 07:19

The "just co-sleep" advice winds me up something awful. But that's because I couldn't do it safely (DD did not meet the criteria, having a low birth weight). In retrospect, I wish someone had told me sooner that it was ok if she cried in her Moses basket for five or even ten minutes! My mum (who did in fact co-sleep, but completely understood that this wasn't an option for us) pointed this out to me in the end - but discussions like this one meant it took me a while to believe her.

I have no beef with co-sleeping, or with sleep training. But I do think there are people (mostly on the co-sleeping and no sleep training side) who are so absolutely convinced that theirs is the only way that they cannot imagine that their advice might not work for everyone. Babies are different, and parents are different. It's not one size fits all. Do what you need to do, safely.

Skinnermarink · 24/05/2022 07:19

SameToo · 24/05/2022 07:10

Why are we training babies? That in itself is odd. Then to train your baby to think that when they cry, no one will come? Bonkers.

will be nice when people stop expecting to give birth to a child who sleeps from 7 until 7.

I know I don’t sleep through the night without waking most nights so why would I expect a child to do it? Yes it’s tiring, if you don’t want to get up with a child, don’t have one. That’s what confuses me the most.

Bloody NCT have a lot to answer for this! Seems to be ‘the goal’ to be the first one to get your baby sleeping through, pop them down at 7, greet them again at 7 the next day. It’s an absolutely bullshit ideal. When the women in my group say their (out babies are 8 months) have slept 7-7 since 8 weeks I think two things

  1. you lying cow
  2. do they ‘sleep through’ or do you just not go to them? Because it’s not the same thing. At all.
ShirleyPhallus · 24/05/2022 07:18

I think there’s actually something pretty harmful to the parent (usually the mother) with the excessively emotional narrative that if you let a baby to cry it will have terrible attachment issues and will grow up to be a broken child and parent. Most parents are pretty responsible and the point at which they let their baby cry; they’ve usually exhausted all other options and are absolutely broken by the lack of sleep. You read threads on here when mothers say they’ve nearly crashed their car / had severe PND caused by lack of sleep. You also read threads where the mother is actually angry, tired and upset with the baby and the advise is to pop the baby in the cot where they’re safe and walk away for a few minutes. It doesn’t do the baby any harm to cry, that’s what they do!

letting a baby cry for a few minutes at a time to encourage them to self settle, to the point where they are sleeping through the night within a few days is really beneficial to the child who is actually getting a proper sleep, as well as to the parents. That’s a good thing and actually results in far less crying overall than a few nights of concentrated crying.

A few minutes of crying at a time won’t undo a bond of months or years that the parent has with the child.

Do posters who are against CC think the baby never ever cries again?!

Classicblunder · 24/05/2022 07:16

RandomQuest · 24/05/2022 07:07

Does anyone actually do proper CIO these days? Personally I’ve never come across anyone that has. CC, where you pop in ever few minutes to reassure yes, but never actual CIO. I was born in the late 80s and I’m not sure anyone even did it then tbh, my mum said she did the disappearing chair thing with us as recommended by the HV.

My BIL and SIL in the US were advised to do so by their pediatrician in the last 5 years

www.thenewbasics.com/en/book-excerpt/sleep/

Classicblunder · 24/05/2022 07:13

Giraffesandbottoms · 24/05/2022 07:10

@Classicblunder

some car journeys are unavoidable though. Mine have always hated the buggy so I take a sling if they cry; but there is no sensible alternative on the school run than the car, or to our paediatrician who is quite far away. Unfortunately sometimes you need to take the car - if you have several children you can’t just sit at home indefinitely/avoid all car journeys!

Of course but we did avoid journeys of longer than 2 hours for UK holidays as that was doable if we did it at nap time and I have been told that that was precious/ridiculous.

It also has played a role in us not buying a car (we are in London) for now and only renting one occasionally

SameToo · 24/05/2022 07:10

Why are we training babies? That in itself is odd. Then to train your baby to think that when they cry, no one will come? Bonkers.

will be nice when people stop expecting to give birth to a child who sleeps from 7 until 7.

I know I don’t sleep through the night without waking most nights so why would I expect a child to do it? Yes it’s tiring, if you don’t want to get up with a child, don’t have one. That’s what confuses me the most.

Giraffesandbottoms · 24/05/2022 07:10

@Classicblunder

some car journeys are unavoidable though. Mine have always hated the buggy so I take a sling if they cry; but there is no sensible alternative on the school run than the car, or to our paediatrician who is quite far away. Unfortunately sometimes you need to take the car - if you have several children you can’t just sit at home indefinitely/avoid all car journeys!

Jellychat · 24/05/2022 07:10

There is something to be said for the point where your baby is inconsolable, won’t co-sleep (and is mobile enough to be unsafe and awake in your bed) and isn’t actually getting the sleep they need to develop healthily.

if it was the choice between rocking baby to sleep then gently putting them down in their cot and ‘cry it out’ then I would choose the former. Sometimes, ‘cry it out’ is the absolute last resort, and if you are informed, prepared and manage it correctly (naps, lighting, bedtime routine), then it works and it works quickly.

Giraffesandbottoms · 24/05/2022 07:08

How awful i feel (like ripping my skin off!) when my baby is crying and I can’t pick them up to console them (eg in a car) shows me that leaving my baby to cry on purpose would never be an option for me. The fact that most people have a problem with letting their baby cry indicates it’s pretty unnatural/wrong to do it.

RandomQuest · 24/05/2022 07:07

Does anyone actually do proper CIO these days? Personally I’ve never come across anyone that has. CC, where you pop in ever few minutes to reassure yes, but never actual CIO. I was born in the late 80s and I’m not sure anyone even did it then tbh, my mum said she did the disappearing chair thing with us as recommended by the HV.

Classicblunder · 24/05/2022 07:05

InChocolateWeTrust · 24/05/2022 07:00

I find it odd when people a) can't tell the difference between a baby fussing and screaming b)can't recognise that babies don't always want what's good for them.sometimes they are fussing because they are tired, but find mum or dad quite stimulating, there's a fine line between responding to their cries and not allowing them to be free of stimulation so they can fall asleep.

The point about cio is not all babies are the same. Some babies will grumble a bit put in the cot because they don't want to sleep, they've got fomo, they are tired. You leave them to "cio" because they actually need sources of stimulation removed, and they fuss for about 3 mins before nodding off.

Some babies aren't ready to fall asleep without assistance, and will scream when left. The point being to recognise a cry of need vs the grumble of a tired baby.

Yes! I think it's where the "just cosleep" advice also misses the mark with many. Some babies obviously respond to that really well but my first especially just found it over stimulating. I did do Ferber with him and he has slept through ever since (now 5)

One of the things I find funny is that I have been mocked on here for not doing long car journeys with mine as babies/toddlers because they cried so much in the car - but the received wisdom seems to be that that's an ok type of crying whereas something that helps everyone sleep is evil.

Flopisfatteningbingforchristmas · 24/05/2022 07:05

what research OP? We know that stress hormones have a negative effect on babies so there is research which suggests cry it out will have negative effect. Obviously leaving a baby to cry is abhorrent and therefore unethical so I imagine you will struggle to find any peer reviewed research but if you do do find any let me know.