Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

WIBU to ask why people are so weird about cry it out?

408 replies

Worried675 · 24/05/2022 06:34

OK, I know already how this is going to go and what views about this are on Mumsnet, but my question I guess is why people are so against cry it out methods? Recent research showed no differences in babies' behaviour/happiness/attachment etc. between cry it out and other sleep training methods. I'm always surprised by how strongly people are against it, especially as anyone born in the 80s or before probably were trained that way.

Enlighten me! Is using cry it out unreasonable? Why/why not?

OP posts:
luxxlisbon · 24/05/2022 08:47

I didn’t even do cry it out as I can’t really deal with crying but if CIO taught a baby that no one will ever come or respond to their needs then they wouldn’t cry in the day either, which is obviously rubbish!

The reality is people have a stick up about things that are seen to benefit the parents over the baby when actually things that benefit the parents often actually benefit the baby too. A baby doesn’t benefit from a sleep deprived, emotional and soulless mother at the end of her tether all the time.

People hardline about sleep training imo haven’t experienced terrible sleep and having to get on with life.

Mumwantingtogetitright · 24/05/2022 08:45

Topgub · 24/05/2022 08:40

@Mumwantingtogetitright

I'm not sure how such a study would even work?

How could you pinpoint mental illness in a teen to being left to cio on a few occasions as a baby?

There's lots of research though

None of it shows any evidence of harm to the baby or to bond.

If the evidence was there we would have found it by now.

Oh, I agree, it would be very difficult to isolate that one factor. Not least because the kind of parents who are likely to use cry it out are also quite likely to parent differently in other ways, so it would be difficult to hone in on that factor alone. That's precisely why I don't share your optimistic view that, if there was an impact, we'd know about it by now. I just don't think the studies exist. In the meantime, I'm inclined to trust my instincts and the anecdotal evidence that is available to me.

Peoniesandcream · 24/05/2022 08:45

I think it's weird to try conceiving for god know how long, carry a baby for 9 months and then ignore it for long periods of time when it arrives. They seem to be similar, the kind that do this, long for a baby not having an understanding of what caring for one 24/7 entails then putting their own needs above the babies. Why bother having one? I was knackered when my son was little and I just got through it, napped with him, lots of coffee.

user1471481356 · 24/05/2022 08:44

Are you serious? How can you possibly think that leaving someone you supposedly love, who is helpless and vulnerable, all alone to cry hysterically for potentially hours, is anything but unreasonable!!!! You wouldn’t leave a friend or a partner in great distress

Newforumnewname · 24/05/2022 08:44

Some things feel wrong, and it doesn’t matter how much research you present me with showing one conclusion or the other. It felt totally wrong.

Except when it felt right, which was when I was absolutely at the end of my tether and exhausted and the baby was safer in the cot crying for twenty minutes whilst I gathered myself.

Basically, when it came to my babies, instinct was what I preferred to use. And instinct mostly told me to to pick them up and have them close to me.

user1471481356 · 24/05/2022 08:44

Are you serious? How can you possibly think that leaving someone you supposedly love, who is helpless and vulnerable, all alone to cry hysterically for potentially hours, is anything but unreasonable!!!! You wouldn’t leave a friend or a partner in great distress

SleeplessInEngland · 24/05/2022 08:43

"All the people saying ‘I did it and my child is fine’. How do you know your child wouldn’t have been great or amazing without CIO? You have no direct comparison of your child using CIO versus without"

Because sleep deprevation gets so bad that some parents don't have the luxury of 'wait and see' any longer.

Can we at least take it as read that no-one wants to do CIO unless they're desperate and nothing else has worked? You'd think parents who do it relished the prospect going by the tone of some on here.

BellePeppa · 24/05/2022 08:42

I relied on pure instinct when my children were babies, rather than what a book or ‘expert’ said and my instinct was to go to them when they cried. Not immediately but after about a minute (or maybe less if a minute seemed like too long a time). I knew nothing about babies, had never even held one before my own but I did most of my parenting by instinct and not a book or other people’s ways.

Mumwantingtogetitright · 24/05/2022 08:42

InChocolateWeTrust · 24/05/2022 08:31

Right, so only followed the kids until 18 months?

DaphneeBridgerton · 24/05/2022 08:41

I think there’s a difference between allowing a five month old baby to cry themselves to sleep and allowing a 14month old baby to fuss and cry on and off until they fall asleep once you know they are fed, clean and have tried all other methods like rocking, cuddling etc and nothing seems to be working. Personally I was very against any type of sleep training but I do what I described above with my 14mo (while checking in occasionally to comfort her) and it has worked for us both (including her as she sleeps very well now)

NearlyHeadlessNick · 24/05/2022 08:40

Because the sound of my children crying for a cuddle goes right through me 🤷🏼‍♀️ it causes me far more stress than going into their room and giving them a cuddle.
It's done no harm to my eldest who goes straight to sleep and sleeps through the night. I'm certain that my youngest will follow suit.

Each to their own.

Topgub · 24/05/2022 08:40

@Mumwantingtogetitright

I'm not sure how such a study would even work?

How could you pinpoint mental illness in a teen to being left to cio on a few occasions as a baby?

There's lots of research though

None of it shows any evidence of harm to the baby or to bond.

If the evidence was there we would have found it by now.

Mumwantingtogetitright · 24/05/2022 08:38

InChocolateWeTrust · 24/05/2022 08:24

I don't think sleep training is about getting babies to sleep through either.

It's more about sleep hygiene. Putting a baby to bed of an evening should not involve mum or dad spending 2 hours rocking/patting/sat by the bed singing or whatever (I genuinely know people who's entire evening is taken up by getting their baby or toddler to go to sleep).

The point is to "train" the child that bedtime is a quiet/stimulation free time and that delay tactics are pointless.

Yeah, there was a time when a great deal of my evening was taken up with getting my dd to sleep. It was pretty hard for a few years, but I consider it to have been well worth the effort. Ultimately, for me, it was about investing in the kind of relationship that I wanted to have with my dd.

It might be coincidence or it might not, but as a 17yo, she is one of the most confident and emotionally secure people that I've ever met and we have a much closer relationship than most of her peers have with their parents. Is that because we invested the time and energy in meeting her needs as a baby/ young child? Well, of course, we'll never know. Do I believe that the early investments in our relationship paid off? Yes, I do. Do I think that children who are left to cry will inevitably be less happy or confident as teens/adults? No, I don't. Would I want to risk feeling that early neglect of my child's needs had contributed to mental health issues or a lack of confidence further down the line? Personally, no I wouldn't.

Ahurricaneofjacarandas · 24/05/2022 08:37

I'm not sure CIO or especially sleep training is quite the demonic parenting that some make it out to be. However, like anything in parenting you have to take it in context with everything else that child is experiencing.

Will leaving a child to CIO every so often turn them into a serial killer? Probably not on its own. However everything else that a young baby instinctly craves and needs is also so much harder for parents to provide these days so the cumulation of things may well be unhelpful

I have never been able to leave my baby to CIO. I tried it for literally 5 minutes one night and couldn't stand the crying 🤣 I still lie in bed with her now at age 4 to go to sleep. You CAN still be firm in doing this though. I tell her it's sleeping time and then if she's trying to wind me up/be silly I ignore her.

I would implore every parent to read about attachment theory as it'll really make you reflect on how a baby's brain develops and what you're actually trying to acheive when managing your child's behaviour. A great book that's an easy (but harrowing) read is a book called 'the boy who was raised as a dog' It's a collection of short stories about children that a child psychiatrist has encountered and it really explains child development well

MummyGummy · 24/05/2022 08:35

All the people saying ‘I did it and my child is fine’. How do you know your child wouldn’t have been great or amazing without CIO?

You have no direct comparison of your child using CIO versus without. And I would argue that a parent willing to use CIO will also be less emotionally attached & responsive in many other aspects of the child’s life from baby to adult.

This compound effect will have an impact on emotional well being, resilience, attachment and cognitive and social development. You have no way of knowing what the unintended consequences could be, and I wasn’t willing or able to take that risk.

TheLadyofShalott1 · 24/05/2022 08:34

I will get too upset @Worried675 if I give enough thought to this to explain why letting babies "cry it out" is so horrendous for the babies (and their mums), and I know that there are enough women on Mumsnet who I can trust to explain it both much more succinctly than me, and much more articulately too. So all I will say, is that,

neither my babies born during the 80's, or me born during the 50's, were left to "cry it out".

AliasGrape · 24/05/2022 08:34

orwellwasright · 24/05/2022 08:13

But some people have different instincts. Are only your instincts valid?

I think if your ‘instinct’ is to leave your tiny baby screaming alone without even trying to comfort them then that probably does need questioning honestly.

Ending up there as a last resort because you’re sleep deprived and desperate I can kind of understand, but for it to be your ‘instinct’ is pretty off. (Not talking about controlled crying/ withdrawal type approaches which whilst they weren’t for us, can see that they worked for others, but full on just leave them to cry even if they are so distressed they make themselves sick, which I know at least one book recommends).

InChocolateWeTrust · 24/05/2022 08:31

Here's the recent research (or one reference I've seen).

www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2020/03/200310193305.htm#:~:text=Leaving%20an%20infant%20to%20'cry,at%2018%20months%20of%20age.

InChocolateWeTrust · 24/05/2022 08:29

I’d love to see this “new research” that is the polar opposite to every other scientific finding for years 🤨
Leaving a baby to cry themselves to sleep doesn’t teach them anything except that no one will come regardless. They don’t begin to “self soothe”, they just give up trying because they learn no one will respond to their needs.

If this is true why do they still cry in the day then? Surely they’d give up crying full stop if they truly learnt there was no benefit to it

This. I sleep trained mine. They still cried when poorly, when they needed feeds and nappy changes, when their duvets fell off and they got cold in the night, when they had bad dreams etc. They just no longer fussed if I didn't sit with them for 45 mins as they fell asleep. And (5m old at this point) instead of waking every 45 mins to comfort suck just long enough to go into the next sleep cycle, they woke for a feed when they were actually hungry, once or twice a night.

They did self soothe. One used to snuggle into an old blanket and rub the label as they nodded off. My sister's two sucked thumbs.

3WildOnes · 24/05/2022 08:26

orwellwasright · 24/05/2022 08:13

But some people have different instincts. Are only your instincts valid?

I would say both of your instincts are right. Each baby is different. If it feels wrong to leave your baby to cry then it probably is wrong for your baby/parent infant dyad. If it feel OK to you then it is probably OK for your baby/parent infant dyad. Some babies become really distressed when they can't see their parents , others might grumble and fuss a bit and then go to sleep.
I think think it is important to listen to our baby's cries and try and work out what they are attempting to communicate to us.

InChocolateWeTrust · 24/05/2022 08:24

I don't think sleep training is about getting babies to sleep through either.

It's more about sleep hygiene. Putting a baby to bed of an evening should not involve mum or dad spending 2 hours rocking/patting/sat by the bed singing or whatever (I genuinely know people who's entire evening is taken up by getting their baby or toddler to go to sleep).

The point is to "train" the child that bedtime is a quiet/stimulation free time and that delay tactics are pointless.

AliceW89 · 24/05/2022 08:21

Link your recent research please.

SleeplessInEngland · 24/05/2022 08:20

Onionpatch · 24/05/2022 08:17

But my main issue is how zealous people become about it and how they assume if you have a poor sleeper its because you just werent doing cry it out right.

I’ve never seen anyone say that. I have seen many people say sleep training doesn’t work at all, for anyone. Which, again, will be news to a lot of people who successfully tried it.

orwellwasright · 24/05/2022 08:20

What always interests me about these pointless squabbles is not the actual issue being argued about, it's the dogma and the illogical justifications people give.

MY BABY, MY RULES (but other people have different rules so are there ever objectively sensible rules? What about if someone wants to tattoo their baby? MY BABY, MY RULES)

IT'S INSTINCT (but everyone has different instincts so who's right?)

This is what baby rearing manuals play on. Regardless of what they're proposing they all propose theirs is the only way.

SleeplessInEngland · 24/05/2022 08:19

Matchingcollarandcuffs · 24/05/2022 08:12

If this is true why do they still cry in the day then? Surely they’d give up crying full stop if they truly learnt there was no benefit to it

Bingo. The presumption by some seems to be that CIO turns babies into emotionless drones. That’ll certainly be news to my son.