Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

WIBU to ask why people are so weird about cry it out?

408 replies

Worried675 · 24/05/2022 06:34

OK, I know already how this is going to go and what views about this are on Mumsnet, but my question I guess is why people are so against cry it out methods? Recent research showed no differences in babies' behaviour/happiness/attachment etc. between cry it out and other sleep training methods. I'm always surprised by how strongly people are against it, especially as anyone born in the 80s or before probably were trained that way.

Enlighten me! Is using cry it out unreasonable? Why/why not?

OP posts:
ElenaSt · 24/05/2022 09:15

I never had situation where I had to leave a baby crying. Why would I, unless I was laying on the floor with a broken leg unable to get to them.

SleeplessInEngland · 24/05/2022 09:14

"Those saying it's harmful to suggest a baby left to cry will develop a disturbed attachment (they might, and they might not - no way of knowing in advance for each individual child, so why take the risk?), what about the opposite narrative, the one that suggests if a baby isn't sleep 'trained' they'll never learn to sleep?"

In the torture of sleep deprevation you don't know how long that'll last though. A year? Two? Five? There are no shortage of threads in the sleep section who've had to endure that long, or longer.

Very easy to be judgemental when you're on the other side, not staring at that seemingly endless abyss. At what point does it become irresponsible to not try chainging anything even though your sleep deprivation is making you a worse parent in the day? Not to mention their sleep deprevation and what damage that could be doing.

Worried675 · 24/05/2022 09:14

I don't not understand the reluctance. I'm just interested by the strength of people's reactions. I've not used the method myself, but I don't feel that strongly against it, especially the controlled crying one. I'd probably try it if I thought I needed to try something and other things weren't working. I guess what I mean is that I understand people saying, oh that's not for me, but I find it a bit surprising the level of reaction, for example, against a parent who says they've tried it.

This article is a balanced look at research pros and cons. The recent research I'll have to look for as I came across it somewhere in the news but didn't bookmark it. It was this week or last week, I think.

www.bbc.com/future/article/20220322-how-sleep-training-affects-babies

OP posts:
TabithaTittlemouse · 24/05/2022 09:13

I think a lot of it depends on the age of the baby.

By crying they are communicating that they need something. Ignoring the crying is to me ignoring your baby’s needs.

Mumwantingtogetitright · 24/05/2022 09:13

SnackSizeRaisin · 24/05/2022 09:06

I don't think you realise how bad some babies are. If it was a case of quick feed every few hours and back to sleep then there would be little need for sleep training. My first baby was like that and never even considered it. I had a similar attitude to you probably. The second one, despite cosleeping in my arms and breastfeeding on demand, plus having tried everything, woke screaming every 20-90 minutes for the first 6 months. I hated to do it but I did, and after 3 nights of controlled crying, with probably less crying in total than a normal night, my baby could sleep all night with only a couple of wakes.

It really isn't that people don't realise how bad it can get. Waking for a feed and then going back to sleep for a few hours would have been a dream! Mine woke hourly for most of the first year. She went through phases when she wouldn't sleep for longer than half an hour at at time. I was back at work and it was bloody torture. However, I wasn't prepared to go down the route of leaving her to cry, no matter how bad it got. Fair enough if that's what felt right to you, but it just wasn't the way I wanted to parent my child. We ended up co-sleeping, and though it didn't completely resolve the sleep issues, it enabled me to get through that period.

ShirleyPhallus · 24/05/2022 09:11

stuntbubbles · 24/05/2022 09:01

Echoing that this is untrue. DD woke hourly until 18 months and I never sleep trained and never would. My BFF had a kid who wouldn’t sleep til midnight, then did two 3-hour bursts then that was it, she was done. She sleep trained but not CIO or controlled crying, it was all hippie woo sleep consultant feelings stuff. It’s possible to take a hard line against cry-based sleep training and also be on your knees with exhaustion.

Not very efficient sleep training was the hippy woo stuff then ey

Peoniesandcream · 24/05/2022 09:09

@SleeplessInEngland As I said in my post, I was knackered, who are you to try and measure how tired/ desperate? It wasn't luck actually it was, napping with him, Co sleeping, meeting his needs.

SnackSizeRaisin · 24/05/2022 09:06

YouSoundLovely · 24/05/2022 07:27

'will be nice when people stop expecting to give birth to a child who sleeps from 7 until 7.'

Absolutely this.

Those saying it's harmful to suggest a baby left to cry will develop a disturbed attachment (they might, and they might not - no way of knowing in advance for each individual child, so why take the risk?), what about the opposite narrative, the one that suggests if a baby isn't sleep 'trained' they'll never learn to sleep? The 'rod for your own back' crap? I bed-shared/co-slept (bedside cot arrangement basically) safely with all three of mine, and bf them at night until they stopped night feeding (well over age 2 for two of them), and they learned to drop off - with a parent in the room, at first - just fine, and two of them never came into our bed at night (except when ill) beyond the age of three or so (while one still kept coming until about 9. Individual temperaments, again).

Yes, there were moments of exhaustion. But I was not going to be made to feel I was doing it all wrong/setting myself up for some kind of eternal slavery because I did what felt right to me. IMO a lot of these narratives come from an idea that somehow you have to get the better of children/come out on top/be in control. Authoritarian at heart.

I don't think you realise how bad some babies are. If it was a case of quick feed every few hours and back to sleep then there would be little need for sleep training. My first baby was like that and never even considered it. I had a similar attitude to you probably. The second one, despite cosleeping in my arms and breastfeeding on demand, plus having tried everything, woke screaming every 20-90 minutes for the first 6 months. I hated to do it but I did, and after 3 nights of controlled crying, with probably less crying in total than a normal night, my baby could sleep all night with only a couple of wakes.

BurnDownTheDiscoHangTheDJ · 24/05/2022 09:04

I actually do remember being left to cry it out. Was probably about one and in lots of ways my parents were very hippy-dippy so it wasn’t their style, but by their own admission they tried it to try and get me off the breast at night when I was around 14 months. They’re not incredibly detailed memories, but I distinctly remember standing at the bars of my cot and shouting/crying and no one coming. It felt like it went on for eons and I was really frightened. I’ve never told my mum this because she would be horrified, as I say not heir usual style at all, but the memory stays with me and makes me very anxious to think about. Didn’t want to make my own baby feel that way.

KangFang · 24/05/2022 09:04

Tin hat, OP.

RandomQuest · 24/05/2022 09:02

Classicblunder · 24/05/2022 07:16

My BIL and SIL in the US were advised to do so by their pediatrician in the last 5 years

www.thenewbasics.com/en/book-excerpt/sleep/

Your link doesn’t work but I lived in the US so am very aware of that particular particular paediatrician, presuming it’s Michel Cohen, because it’s that notorious (think worse than Gina Ford on here). Granted I didn’t live in NY where he’s based but I still don’t know anyone that did CIO and my paediatrician did not recommend that book at all. Amongst our circle there was lots of controlled crying at 4 months in preparation for end of parental leave but never, ever CIO. Thankfully I had good sleepers and a European contract with longer leave so it didn’t come to that for us!

stuntbubbles · 24/05/2022 09:01

Mumwantingtogetitright · 24/05/2022 08:54

People hardline about sleep training imo haven’t experienced terrible sleep and having to get on with life.

Not true.

Echoing that this is untrue. DD woke hourly until 18 months and I never sleep trained and never would. My BFF had a kid who wouldn’t sleep til midnight, then did two 3-hour bursts then that was it, she was done. She sleep trained but not CIO or controlled crying, it was all hippie woo sleep consultant feelings stuff. It’s possible to take a hard line against cry-based sleep training and also be on your knees with exhaustion.

Babyboomtastic · 24/05/2022 09:00

People hardline about sleep training imo haven’t experienced terrible sleep and having to get on with life.

I had 2 non sleepers under 2, with my youngest a bottle refuser we often woke 10+ times a night, and I returned to work (part time) at 6w.

I'm very against adjust training as I believe it's cruel and neglectful.

But aye, we couldn't possibly know what it's like 🙄

Mumwantingtogetitright · 24/05/2022 08:58

Topgub · 24/05/2022 08:53

@Mumwantingtogetitright

So you do deny the research?

What 'kind of parents' are the kind to cio?

I don't deny the research, I just don't think it exists in so far as I haven't seen anything that looks beyond those early years.

As for the kind of parent who does CIO... I simply mean the kind of parent who is capable of emotionally distancing themselves from their child to that extent and who believes that it's OK to do that.

Topgub · 24/05/2022 08:57

@3WildOnes

Do you have any links to that research? I couldn't find any but it was just a quick Google

I'm confident in the research I could find.

People should be more concerned with actual abuse and neglect rather than trying to make themselves feel superior over a non issue

racquel86 · 24/05/2022 08:55

My baby is coming up 7 months and has been a good sleeper since 10 weeks. She is still in my room in the next to me cot.
I haven't purposely thought 'I'll lea e her to cry it out' BUT she does get herself in a tizzy when tired and does seem to cry herself to sleep - if I pick her up and try to rock her she fights to stay awake cos she has my attention. I know myself even at 36 I get over emotional simply cos I'm tired. I'm not completely against it at all, but I do think we have to make sure it is a 'tired' cry and not something else

Mumwantingtogetitright · 24/05/2022 08:54

People hardline about sleep training imo haven’t experienced terrible sleep and having to get on with life.

Not true.

Topgub · 24/05/2022 08:53

@Mumwantingtogetitright

So you do deny the research?

What 'kind of parents' are the kind to cio?

3WildOnes · 24/05/2022 08:52

Topgub · 24/05/2022 08:40

@Mumwantingtogetitright

I'm not sure how such a study would even work?

How could you pinpoint mental illness in a teen to being left to cio on a few occasions as a baby?

There's lots of research though

None of it shows any evidence of harm to the baby or to bond.

If the evidence was there we would have found it by now.

There are on-going studies that will look at exactly this. They will work in exactly the same way that all of the other studies into sleep training have, with one group of infants who were sleep trained using extinction and the other control group who were not sleep trained with extinction. They will to to make sure that both groups are a similar as possible in every other way. They will then look to see if rates of anxiety, depression or addiction are significantly higher in one group or the other.

avocadotofu · 24/05/2022 08:52

I'm the opposite of you, I cannot believe that anyone would do that to a baby. It feels awful and unnatural to leave a baby to cry. I was really shocked when I became a parent that people still do this. I think there have to be attachment issues if one thinks it's okay to do this. My mother absolutely never left me or any of my siblings to cry ourselves to sleep neither did my maternal grandmother so even in the past it was possible to go against parenting fads.

Topgub · 24/05/2022 08:52

Oh dear.

The idea that you can only love/be close to/have a bond with/ instill emotional intelligence in children if you dont ST is hilarious.

Kids are for life, not just for babies.

But yeah. All parents who st are cruel, neglectful and dont love their kids

🤣

Inciwinci · 24/05/2022 08:51

8yo DS just asked if there’s an architecture or design club he can go to? Any ideas? We are south west Fife nearest to Edinburgh.. TIA.

SleeplessInEngland · 24/05/2022 08:49

Peoniesandcream · 24/05/2022 08:45

I think it's weird to try conceiving for god know how long, carry a baby for 9 months and then ignore it for long periods of time when it arrives. They seem to be similar, the kind that do this, long for a baby not having an understanding of what caring for one 24/7 entails then putting their own needs above the babies. Why bother having one? I was knackered when my son was little and I just got through it, napped with him, lots of coffee.

Then count yourself lucky you were never desperate enough to have to try it.

SleeplessInEngland · 24/05/2022 08:48

"It might be coincidence or it might not, but as a 17yo, she is one of the most confident and emotionally secure people that I've ever met"

My aunt did CIO on my cousin and said cousin is now in a great job, with a loving family and seems as well adjusted as anyone I know.

This kind of anecdotal evidence serves no purpose, and is part of the reason these discussions become so heated: it's all emotive speculation.

loislovesstewie · 24/05/2022 08:47

I didn't do cry it out, but controlled crying. I didn't do it when they were very tiny, and I only left them for a short while before returning, patting them and then leaving. With both of mine, it took only one go at controlled crying before they slept through the night. The oldest had always slept poorly, the youngest had a blip when I returned to work.