Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel undervalued and under paid

60 replies

serc · 23/05/2022 21:23

I've worked in care homes for many years, my current hourly rate is £9.50 per hour.

My son is 18 and is about to leave school he has got a job in a factory assembling parts. To bridge the gap between school and uni. It's his first job so has no experience. His starting rate is £11.25!

AIBU to feel seriously undervalued and under paid?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
JaceLancs · 24/05/2022 23:58

I would seriously consider being a self employed home carer
where I live the local authority charge those who need care at £18 an hour
I have a friend who does dementia care charging £16 an hour with a waiting list for relatives who need respite
DB and I pay DD £15 an hour to help our DM with personal care, shopping and cleaning

glitterwobbles · 24/05/2022 23:48

You are doing a skilled and highly important job. It makes me want to cry thinking about the wages of carers.
The country needs carers and needs not to take advantage of their kindness and commitment.
This comes from my heart as a daughter whose Mum had carers who made her last months meaningful.
I am also a nurse who would not be without my amazing carer colleagues.

OversBo · 24/05/2022 23:14

Good call @NellWilsonsWhiteHair I don’t know a lot about the sector so that’s useful to know.

THisbackwithavengeance · 24/05/2022 15:43

Topgub · 23/05/2022 22:06

Yanbu.

We're facing (are actually in already tbh) a crisis in care both private and NHS.

We have an elderly population that we don't have the staff to care for.

We have a general public who think they deserve gold standard care but who also don't want to (or cant) pay for it and who begrudge nhs staff a 10% discount on their shopping never mind an actual appropriate wage

I don't think the general public begrudge decent wages to carers, nurses etc. a poster earlier said that a care home resident is charged £1200 per week for a room which is pretty standard from what I can see. That money is going somewhere as it's not going on staff wages or improved services.

But I hear you OP. Im a civil servant in a skilled and difficult profession and would probably earn more these days working in Lidl. I stay only for the pension (5 years and counting...).

NellWilsonsWhiteHair · 24/05/2022 14:28

OversBo · 23/05/2022 21:55

Carers (and nursery workers) deserve better pay, but a majority of customers can’t afford more than they already pay. There needs to be something to break the deadlock. Probably the state needs to intervene with subsidies. My child’s nursery is already a charity, no shareholders are making a profit, costs are are low as they can make them, and they are fighting to turn over enough to stay open.

I would say state (well, LA) direct provision of these services, rather than subsidy. I understand much more about early years than about care homes, but staff in LA early years settings (nursery schools, children's centres etc) have much better pay and other working conditions than in private settings, at least in London, and from a 'customer' perspective typically provide higher quality education/childcare too. Subsidising non-profit organisations could work (I can think of a couple of excellent charity-run nurseries) but certainly the state subsidising private sector nurseries feels like the same sort of propping up profits that housing benefit and WTC have enabled, without offering the same upsides.

As a general point re: the OP, it is awful that such important jobs are paid so badly. Good carers are worth their weight in gold and do a difficult job not all of us could manage. You deserve much more.

Sugarplumfairy65 · 24/05/2022 14:22

DaisyStPatience · 23/05/2022 22:59

Well, it is unskilled labour, notwithstanding the fact that it's an undesirable role for most people.

It isn't unskilled labour

serc · 24/05/2022 14:18

CooooCoooo · 24/05/2022 12:34

So leave and do the same job as your son then? Alternatively, take action - join a union and go on strike.

You could go self employed and become a private carer? Going self employed was the best thing I ever did. I spent 4 years teaching myself a pretty easy skill anyone can learn. I get paid £80-£100 per hour meaning I only have to work two 10 hour days per month to pay my bills. I don't have a single GCSE to my name or any other formal qualifications. I'm always encouraging my friends and family to go self employed and start their own businesses - there really is nothing stopping anyone from doing the same as me.

What job do you do?

OP posts:
butimjayigetaway · 24/05/2022 14:16

serc · 23/05/2022 21:59

Why do you think Carers get paid so poorly? I don't understand the reason. We have to undertake training, there's a huge amount of responsibility and we work extremely hard and we actually still care and go above and beyond for the people in our care. I actually see it as a privilege at times to care for people when they are so vulnerable. Respecting their wishes and keeping their dignity. Not everyone gets to do that for their loved ones, some people have nobody and we are there for them, we don't discriminate. But it feels like carers are seen as the lowest workers.

Where I work residents rooms start at £1200 a week! I know the cost of living has gone up etc but they hardly live expensive lifestyles.

Because a significant portion of the population need to be forced into debt to keep our money system functioning.

butimjayigetaway · 24/05/2022 14:12

Care is one of the lowest paid jobs, and the most needed. It's disgusting that they are paid so low. You are being underpaid, you can hardly even survive on such a wage.

I did this work and wanted to continue but just couldn't commit to a life on such a wage.

Runorsleep · 24/05/2022 12:54

I agree with a pp , look into working for yourself for private clients

Runorsleep · 24/05/2022 12:52

I see childcare and care jobs advertised constantly. What would /will honestly happen if they just can’t get people to work in these jobs which should be highly valued in society? In Ireland here people who work in preschool don’t get paid all summer , no proper sickness or maternity pay? Just why? Why can’t they be salaried like other jobs ?! What happens in other countries.

kolomo · 24/05/2022 12:35

Your pay isn't determined by the social value of your work, but by the market value. To get paid more you have to increase your bargaining power. If you are paid minimum wage, your individual bargaining power is zero. So if they could pay you less they would, but the government uses its bargaining power to put a minimum floor on that number.

To get paid more you need to increase your bargaining power by organising with other care workers collectively bargaining for pay increases. You have no power alone.

CooooCoooo · 24/05/2022 12:34

So leave and do the same job as your son then? Alternatively, take action - join a union and go on strike.

You could go self employed and become a private carer? Going self employed was the best thing I ever did. I spent 4 years teaching myself a pretty easy skill anyone can learn. I get paid £80-£100 per hour meaning I only have to work two 10 hour days per month to pay my bills. I don't have a single GCSE to my name or any other formal qualifications. I'm always encouraging my friends and family to go self employed and start their own businesses - there really is nothing stopping anyone from doing the same as me.

TabithaTittlemouse · 24/05/2022 12:27

It is disgusting but won’t change because someone is always willing to do it.
You absolutely do deserve much much more.

Sceptre86 · 24/05/2022 12:18

Yabu because wages just aren't based on how much a person doing that role deserves. In community pharmacy assistants will be earning minimum wage or a pound above that, it doesn't take into account all the extra learning they are expected to do to gain qualifications in their own time, it doesn't reflect the level of responsibility that goes with their jobs. This is why staff morale is low and people leave.

You do deserve higher wages and carers shouldn't be expected to just run on altruism and it being a vocation, that doesn't pay the bills. You should be adequately compensated for the very tough job that you do.

Thebeastofsleep · 24/05/2022 11:50

mackthepony · 23/05/2022 23:52

Could you go go into private caring? In a private home?

They don't pay more. In fact some pay less.

ProclivityForPyrotechnics · 24/05/2022 02:20

@Bubblesandsqueak1 isn't that disgusting though?

ProclivityForPyrotechnics · 24/05/2022 02:19

It's disgusting that care assistants are paid so badly.

I work in a specialist icu for infectious diseases so our icu care assistants are so needed and really needed. They get us really needed equipment when our patients are crashing; they help us do personal care, 3 of my amazing health care assistants braid hair better than I do, so as a team we wash a patient (and I mean really wash a patient, wash the blood out of the hair if it's a trauma or we just wash the hair with shampoo, rinse it (maybe 3 times) and then I ask one of them to braid the persons hair in a tight braid and it won't get matted

This is one of 100000 things out HCAs do that I couldn't do my job without.

It's a travesty that the nhs now pays 1p above the minimum wage

IJoinedJustForThisThread · 24/05/2022 02:04

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

I’m guessing she has the NPLQ.
you don’t have to confirm or deny.

Bubblesandsqueak1 · 24/05/2022 01:52

Unfortunately care staff will always be crap pay, they won't be able to pay 12 and hour because the resident's won't be able to afford care the weekly fees cover room gas electricity food all staff plus bigger bosses higher up in the chain having 1 carer 24 7 would cost 1596 in wages alone then ni pension ect in to insurance, training

GoodJanetBadJanet · 24/05/2022 01:42

I could never be a care worker - that sort of pay for life and death work is a disgrace, and the roots of why is it so low paid is because it was seen as women's work
So true, and sickening
Extremely important work (where would be without cleaners or care workers?!)
they're still paid like shit though.

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 24/05/2022 01:30

We have an elderly population that we don't have the staff to care for

Reap what you sow I guess. Baby boomers as a generation chose to prioritise private wealth and growth at the expense of societal needs. If there's not enough carers to look after them now or when they need them tough.

caringcarer · 24/05/2022 01:10

All I can suggest is to get a job where son works and earn more. My son used to have one of these picking order jobs though and he regularly walked 12,000-18,000 steps per shift.

dangermouseisace · 24/05/2022 00:55

Absolutely. You ARE undervalued and underpaid.
I work for adult services- we are in crisis and nothing is happening. Care work needs to be properly valued and properly paid. It needs to be seen as a valid career in its own right. It requires constantly updated training, resilience, patience, empathy, trustworthiness and intelligence.
Every single organisation I know is having recruitment and retention issues, even the “best” places with the best pay and conditions. Why would you do such a demanding job when you get paid more in a supermarket?
The result is, we have people eligible for care, who need care…but we can’t always find people to provide it. And that is a terrible situation. Families are at breaking point. Carers can’t afford to keep working for so little. We need change and we need it NOW!!

KenAdams · 24/05/2022 00:27

Leave then. Genuinely. This cycle will continue if people keep working for these salaries. We're seeing droves of care workers leaving to go to places like Aldi that pay £10.10p/h and require significantly less training.

Yes, I understand that you should be paid more but there is no incentive to do so for the people that are raking it in unless their backs are against the wall.

Employee power is huge atm as there aren't enough people to fill roles so vote with your feet. They'll soon change their tune when it starts to hit their wallets.

Swipe left for the next trending thread