Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask when you should just buy a new car

84 replies

OldLadyInPolyester · 23/05/2022 20:17

My car is 10 years old and has been costing me loads of money in repairs over the last couple of years. Bits of it just need replacing because of age / mileage. I've also broken down a fair few times which is annoying.

I'm not bothered about having a new, flashy car but I don't want to keep paying out loads of money. I keep hearing people say that they're just going to run their current car into the ground. What does this mean? Keep replacing bits until you can't any more? Or once expensive bits need replacing they get a new car?

So I suppose I'm asking at what point does it become better to buy a new car rather than getting the old one repaired?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
WombatChocolate · 13/12/2023 13:27

We buy cars that are about 3 years old and then drive them for 12-15 years usually.

We have decided that it is the bight time to change them based on the following over the years;

  • one when the local garage MOT’d it and passed it with a series of advisories and told us that they didn’t want to see it the next year. They advised us that it had scraped through and would need lots of money spending on it soon. It was 16 years old. We took it with its new MOT and traded it in for a used approved second hand car and got a decent sum off the list price for the new car.
  • One which was 17 years old and had done over 150k miles and was driving fine and had passed MOT with no advisories, but garage had said it was overdue a new cam belt and couple of other items. This coincided with one of our DS’s passing his driving test and we needed a newer, smaller and cheaper to insure car. Did another trade in.
  • One which was 14 years old and a rust bucket and had already had a £500 job done of it earlier in the year. Just decided it’s time was up. It had done over 120k miles and we were losing faith in it.

Once we had an old car that eventually broke down and wouldn’t go. At that point we decided to get a new car. Getting rid of an old car that won’t go isn’t so easy. Couldn’t trade it in and had to get it taken away and felt under more pressure to quickly choose new car. Pre-empting the timing of getting rid rather than having it forced upon you feels less stressful and allows you more choices. However, there’s a,ways a risk with old cars that something serious will go wrong and it will effectively ‘die’.

Lots of people buy new or on lease etc because they fear a big bill and don’t have many savings. If you’ve got some cash behind you and are prepared to spend on some jobs as they are needed, plus can afford to go out and purchase a new car when you feel you want to, you quite simply have lots more choices about these things. You can choose how long to hold onto old car for and when to get a new one. And respond to circumstances as they arise. Fear of the unknown and surprise coats is what causes many people to our chase using options which ultimately cost them much more.

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 25/05/2022 08:45

Why do you think the cost of diesel petrol is almost £2 per litre and many petrol stations aren’t even selling it? Because it is the type of petrol with the highest % of oil in it. And we are phasing out oil. If you hang on to a diesel car, it will be worthless very soon.
This is hilarious. I must have missed all the announcements from fuel retailers saying they won’t be selling diesel fuel any more.
Current high prices and supply problems are due to sanctions against Russia affecting the world supply, not us “phasing out diesel” - that will be more long term.
Some people seem very adept at constructing “facts” to fit their agenda - Trump has a lot to answer for, and his follower Johnson.

5foot5 · 24/05/2022 16:53

I had this quandary with my last car. It got to 16 years old but had very low mileage for its age so was generally quite cheap to run.

However when the coat of keeping it on the road started to increase I did start to do the calculations. Then I thought "Oh I might as well keep it until it drops to hits, then replace it!"

Trouble is, that happened. I was driving along one day, fortunately not too fast or on too busy a road, when there was a horrible noise and the car stopped dead and wouldn't move at all. The "wishbone" had snapped causing one of the wheels to fall off. I had to have it towed away and scrapped.

I dread to think what could have happened if I had been on a motorway or in the middle of lights waiting to turn right or something.

I now think I won't keep a car that long again. And yes I did have it serviced regularly

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 24/05/2022 16:00

My last car was 21 years old! And still going strong, but I’d got nervous in case it died on me on a frequent 60 mile drive - 3 busy motorways inc. a 6 lane stretch of the M25.

Bought a 2 year old with only 5k miles on the clock. I don’t think I’d ever buy a brand new one - they depreciate a lot the moment you drive them away. A newish 2nd hand is usually much better value.

Brightermornings · 24/05/2022 15:58

Thanks for everyone that's replied. My current car runs fine. Probably shouldn't say that. I think I am going to just have to buy one. Current car is coming up 13 years old less than 90k on the clock but it won't run forever

JesusMaryAndJosephAndTheWeeDon · 24/05/2022 15:53

I keep saying that I am going to run my car until it dies but they nearly all ended up having a resale value or were eventually written off.

My last one had over 180,000 miles on the clock and I was just starting to think about when to replace it when it was written off (not my fault). I got a pretty generous pay out because due to the circumstances it couldn't be inspected so the insurance just paid book value.

DH's last one went back under the 10 year warranty when it was about 9yrs 10mths old, again we got a decent payment for it.

The previous one was sold on at 14 years old because he needed something bigger but it still had plenty of miles in it.

BalloonsAndWhistles · 24/05/2022 15:33

We had a Qashqai that we loved. However, it had one big piece of work which was fine, for about £1200. Then when something else went, the mechanic said it would be about £1800-2200 to be fixed. We sold it for £1600 for spares and got a brand new Tuscon. We’d had our money’s worth out of the Qashqai but it just wasn’t worth fixing it.

Lunar27 · 24/05/2022 15:23

Brightermornings · 24/05/2022 13:36

Does anyone know when second hand prices will drop?? I have a very basic car no central locking no electric windows my boot doesn't stay up etc. I really want to upgrade but how long do I wait??

Totally unscientific but IMO they'll remain high for some time. Obvs keep an eye on things but with waiting lists of 18 months + I'd say we're in for elevated prices for the next few years at least.

I recently sold a mouldy old Corsa for £2000. It was worth £500 pre pandemic. The trader has since out it in his forecourt for £3500. Ridiculous.

I think you just have to suck it up, if you need to change your car. It pains me as I usually haggle like mad but I've recently had to take the hit. At least it should retain its value and ultimately all cars end up losing money so have to do your best to ignore it.

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 24/05/2022 14:20

Brightermornings · 24/05/2022 13:36

Does anyone know when second hand prices will drop?? I have a very basic car no central locking no electric windows my boot doesn't stay up etc. I really want to upgrade but how long do I wait??

It's hard to predict because it's not just one cause - there are multiple supply chain issues affecting new car production.

housemaus · 24/05/2022 14:19

Fizbosshoes · 24/05/2022 13:37

I'm tempted by a kia because of the 7 year warranty...but then I've several which are a year old which makes me wonder why people are getting rid after a year!

Probably an ex-hire car/fleet car :)

CoastalWave · 24/05/2022 13:39

OldLadyInPolyester · 23/05/2022 20:27

So I've spent probably around £1500 this year on repairs not including normal MOT and service costs. The car is worth about £3500. It's time isn't it? Family sized cars are bloody expensive though 😭

That's £125 a month. You can't get a new car for that. It's still fairly good going.

Get a mechanic that will be honest with you about whether you are wasting your money fixing things. If you car has has a new cam belt, a new clutch (for two starters!) I would keep it until the engine blew! But it also depends what type of mileage you are doing (local or motorway)

We've probably spent out about the same on our old 05 car. But we pay £220 a month for our new car. Yes you get peace of mind, but you're still paying out nearly £3k a year for the pleasure of that/ And mind is only a bog standard smallish car.

Fizbosshoes · 24/05/2022 13:37

I'm tempted by a kia because of the 7 year warranty...but then I've several which are a year old which makes me wonder why people are getting rid after a year!

Brightermornings · 24/05/2022 13:36

Does anyone know when second hand prices will drop?? I have a very basic car no central locking no electric windows my boot doesn't stay up etc. I really want to upgrade but how long do I wait??

smith19784 · 24/05/2022 13:25

I'm in a car quandary myself so this thread is interesting. I have an Smax automatic which is currently a non runner as the gear box has gone. It's going to cost £2500 to fix. I've had quotes from 2 garages & both have told me to move it on before the warranty runs out in 12 months. I reckon I'd get about £4k on a part ex for mine but I don't know if i should just hold onto it and hope it keeps going. It's the perfect size for us as a family & we use it for hols & put a trailer on for camping. It's also a 7 seater which I need for work.
Im toying with swapping it for a manual smax. I just don't know what's best.

Lunar27 · 24/05/2022 09:46

OldLadyInPolyester · 23/05/2022 20:35

The problem is I have no idea if my car is now going to keep going for another few years or keep costing me thousands. I'm clueless about cars!

Sadly you need a crystal ball for that one but a decent garage should be able to give you an appraisal for some parts of the car. Not all of it but maybe enough for you to decide. The make and model may also factor into it as there will definitely be a database of general repairs at certain ages of a car. The internet can also help.

What is the make and model, if you don't mind me asking?

I've personally tended to jump ship when the repair cost approaches the value of the car but it can still be cheaper to keep repairing. You really need to compare this with the cost of a replacement over 5 to 10 years (including depreciation).

If you are going to buy a newer car, it's worth going for something Japanese IMO. Toyota are now offering 10 year warranties if you get the car serviced with them every year. Their service costs aren't hideous and you can pay by direct debit so makes payment more predictable. Otherwise Kia offer 7 year warranties.

Lunar27 · 24/05/2022 09:33

phishy · 24/05/2022 08:50

Interesting thread, as I have been contemplating a new car.

I have a 12 year old Mazda with only 40k mileage. It has had very little done to it in the last few years, and I've only had it serviced 3-4 times (I know Blush )

I could afford another second car (around £10k).

But is it worth it? Do I just keep driving a car that runs well even though I am SO bored of it?

Can I ask why you're bored of it?

A Mazda will last aeons if you look after it. I agree that many Mazda's aren't particularly exciting but that's similar with many Japanese cars. But they will last forever as long as you service it more frequently (tut, tut 😂).

I'd say it's definitely worth keeping, unless you're sick of looking at it. There's nothing wrong with that and if that's where you are then change it. However, I'd stick with a Japanese brand as they're definitely the most reliable.

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 24/05/2022 09:32

Dontfuckingsaycheese · 24/05/2022 09:14

I’d be factoring in the ‘better the devil you know’ thing. You know all the car’s previous, its little foibles etc. Second hand is ridiculously expensive at the moment - you may buy one that then ends up way more pricy to raise it to your present car’s level. You don’t know its history etc. I’d stick. Ride it out maybe a couple of years. Also you could pay out a lot one year then that lasts you for a few more years…

I agree - a replacement could need expensive repairs unless still under warranty.

Dontfuckingsaycheese · 24/05/2022 09:14

I’d be factoring in the ‘better the devil you know’ thing. You know all the car’s previous, its little foibles etc. Second hand is ridiculously expensive at the moment - you may buy one that then ends up way more pricy to raise it to your present car’s level. You don’t know its history etc. I’d stick. Ride it out maybe a couple of years. Also you could pay out a lot one year then that lasts you for a few more years…

NightmareSlashDelightful · 24/05/2022 09:09

Different people correcting your inaccuracies, @Discovereads

I haven’t claimed to have a 10-year-old car.

Discovereads · 24/05/2022 09:05

NightmareSlashDelightful · 24/05/2022 08:59

It’s not quite that simple. My (diesel) car is a 64 plate registered in 2014, and that’s Euro6/ULEZ complaint because the manufacturer was ahead of the Euro5 standards at the time. I know this because I have driven it through London multiple times — used to live in Zone 2 — and haven’t been charged the ULEZ.

Some Mercs, BMWs, Nissans/Infinitis and a handful of others were Euro6 compliant from about 2012, although it’s a model-by-model thing.

So your “10yr old diesel” car is actually 8yrs old and dates from 4th quarter 2014. Yes some late 2014/early 2015 cars were compliant before the September 2015 deadline, but there is no possible way a 2012 car could be compliant with euro 6 because the measures were first introduced in September 2014.

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 24/05/2022 09:05

Obviously you have no idea who Rousseau was.

This is comedy gold, please keep it up, along with the crazy assertions.

Discovereads · 24/05/2022 08:59

They are all 100% made from oil.

While diesel and petrol are both made from crude oil, petrol is not made from just crude oil. The refining process for petrol includes additives such as benzene, ethanol, toluene, xylene, various lubricants anti-rust chemicals proprietary to the petrol companies.

NightmareSlashDelightful · 24/05/2022 08:59

Discovereads · 24/05/2022 08:48

Euro 6 dates from September 2015 so there is no possible way a 2012 car can meet it. Yours is likely euro 5 compliant.

It’s not quite that simple. My (diesel) car is a 64 plate registered in 2014, and that’s Euro6/ULEZ complaint because the manufacturer was ahead of the Euro5 standards at the time. I know this because I have driven it through London multiple times — used to live in Zone 2 — and haven’t been charged the ULEZ.

Some Mercs, BMWs, Nissans/Infinitis and a handful of others were Euro6 compliant from about 2012, although it’s a model-by-model thing.

Discovereads · 24/05/2022 08:50

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 24/05/2022 07:59

What did he have to say about “diesel petrol”?

Obviously you have no idea who Rousseau was.

phishy · 24/05/2022 08:50

Interesting thread, as I have been contemplating a new car.

I have a 12 year old Mazda with only 40k mileage. It has had very little done to it in the last few years, and I've only had it serviced 3-4 times (I know Blush )

I could afford another second car (around £10k).

But is it worth it? Do I just keep driving a car that runs well even though I am SO bored of it?

Swipe left for the next trending thread