Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Should grandparents help out with grandchildren?

187 replies

Magicfeet11 · 23/05/2022 16:27

I've always been of the school of thought that DH and I chose to have our children so looking after them was 100% our job and we shouldn't have any expectation of family to help. All of our parents are retired and we felt they were entitled to freedom to enjoy their retirement rather than stuck helping us out.

Added to that the fact we live a couple of hours drive from each side of the family so much support would have been impractical anyway.

We've always paid for full time childcare, arranged babysitters for the odd night out and generally muddled through illnesses etc between us. It's been ok but both working full time throughout has presented some challenges - we're tired most of the time, have been at breaking point on occasion and enjoy life much less than we used to pre kids.

Then I was reading an article today about having children and how it takes a village to raise them. Lots of the comments were about what it used to to be like before the nuclear family when extended families all lived in close proximity to each other and the kids would be in and out of grandparents and aunts houses and there'd always be someone to watch your kids for an hour if you needed to run an errand etc.
It really got me thinking. Before the baby boomer generation (our parents) presumably there just wasn't an expectation of a long and affluent retirement? Presumably when you retired you just expected to stay at home and help out with the family?
Therefore, have I been wrong all along and actually I shouldn't have felt so reticent to ask for free help from family? My mum made clear she didn't want to help but my MIL has always been willing yet I've always felt guilty about letting her even do bath time and bedtime because I've felt like it makes me look like I'm skiving/shirking my responsibilities...

YABU - grandparents should be off on world cruises rather than getting involved with babysitting grandchildren

YANBU - it does take a village and it's nice when grandparents ease the load by doing the odd bit of babysitting etc

OP posts:
10HailMarys · 23/05/2022 16:50

My mum has vague memories of her grandmother keeping an eye on her during the school holidays when she was a little girl (unusually for the time, her mum had a full time job). But that was because her grandmother lived with them. The whole extended family helping out thing goes both ways. You would be expected to look after your parents and by living with you, they were available to watch the kids. Also, it wouldn't have been very often because in those days it wasn't anywhere near as common for mothers to work, so there was a lot less childcare required from other people anyway.

My own grandparents did not live with us and didn't provide regular childcare at all (we're talking 1970s-80s here). They might occasionally babysit for an evening or an afternoon when we were old enough not to need constant attention, but there was certainly no expectation that they'd be available on a regular basis. I don't think it would have occurred to my mum to ask them for regular childcare.

However, it would also not have occurred to them to demand to come and live with us when they got old, and my parents would never ask that of my siblings and I either.

Bearsan · 23/05/2022 16:49

One set of my grandparents died before I was born and the other used to babysit once a year when it was my parents wedding anniversary.
So not sure what era this post was about. Our parents babysat a dozen times a year gladly when asked.
We babysit so that our dc can go out if we're not away or out ourselves. Regular childcare not a chance, I've just retired and DH is soon. We have many plans including but not exclusively seeing more of the GC.

ThatPosterIsSoRight · 23/05/2022 16:49

Just read that your DM expects you to look after her in her old age…. That should also be a choice. Not weighing up the childcare but a free choice.

Goldencarp · 23/05/2022 16:49

I will care for my disabled son for the rest of my life. There is absolutely no way I’ll be looking after any grandchildren the others may have.

ButtockUp · 23/05/2022 16:49

So many of us don't live near our parents due to moving away for jobs, not being able to afford to live near parents or parents moved away to retire.
It's very different from the 50s and 60s.

I live in the SE and my mum is in the midlands, so no help there. ILs lived about 1.5 hours away so, again, no help there.
My children live 80 and 200 miles away .
We won't be able to help them.

However, if grandparents feel that they could and want to help, that's great, but must never be expected to or relied upon.

I've seen so many very tired grandparents on the school run and it's so sad. They often struggle with keeping up with the boundless energy that young children have, particularly at home time and these grandparents have probably got another three hours of entertaining , feeding and caring to do.

Don't forget that , 'in the olden days' there was an awful lot of
"Out you go and play with your friends " that happened. Now kids are cocooned in front of tellies, screens and phones so children are always there . Still need attention, feeding, some running after as well as doing homereaders and doing homework.

Different days.

TheOriginalClownfish · 23/05/2022 16:48

Is it as quid pro quo as that though? My DM has made clear I'm 100% responsible for her and her care in her elderly years and she absolutely will not go into a home. On your measure I should say I'm not helping her because she never lifted a finger with my kids... I just don't know if that's right

DM like I said, made it clear she wouldn't help me, and didn't even when I badly needed support. She hasn't quite stated that she wants me to look after her in old age but I'm really her only obvious option other than a nursing home.

And I've very mixed feelings on that if I'm perfectly honest. The best outcome is that DM gets her wish and goes to bed agile and capable and just pops off in her sleep because I think I'd be very resentful that she was willing to help my siblings with their kids but not me, and yet, I'd be the one who she would expect care from if she needed it but also hating that it's me that does it and not her golden children...

Waxonwaxoff0 · 23/05/2022 16:47

No one is obligated to.

However, I do think it's odd not to want to help out where and if you can. I am from a close family where we all chip in with childcare - grandparents, aunts and uncles, cousins. Personally I can't imagine watching a family member struggle knowing I could help but choosing not to.

Fairislefandango · 23/05/2022 16:47

It's not a question of whether one view is wrong and the other is right. It depends on too many variables- e.g. the age, health, energy, proximity and willingness of the grandparents. It makes no sense at all to think you can have a blanket rule about whether grandparents should or shouldn't.

As for the matter of how it was in previous generations before the nuclear family, that's irrelevant imo. Life isn't like that now, so the same expectations should not apply.

InChocolateWeTrust · 23/05/2022 16:47

It really got me thinking. Before the baby boomer generation (our parents) presumably there just wasn't an expectation of a long and affluent retirement? Presumably when you retired you just expected to stay at home and help out with the family?

Well no. Before our parents generation life expectancy was lower, most people would have lived less than 10 years after stopping work before dying (if they stopped work at all) and may have been in quite poor health for some/all that time.

There would have been some helping with family maybe. But I've always assumed that in the past it was more that children coexisted with work etc - being expected to help with family farming/trade from an early age, working alongside parents in the home or in service etc.

ThatPosterIsSoRight · 23/05/2022 16:44

In the ‘olden days’ it wouldn’t have been just you living your life as you do now, but with your extended family living on the same street looking after your DC so you could go to work.

It would have been you at home doing the drudgery of a housewife, with your sisters and sister in laws doing similar. And the children running between the houses, and everyone sort of keeping an eye on them (but not really). Baby on elderly grandma’s knee. Toddler underfoot. Elderly grandpa already dead (having done a manual job, and not living past any kind of retirement).

Of course you are also doing all the housework drudgery for your elderly mother and spinster aunts.

So… I know which life I’d prefer. And your original view - that looking after grandchildren should be a choice not an expectation- is right.

But maybe let the grandma who’s willing to do more do so, without you feeling guilty.

Idhatetolookintothoseeyes · 23/05/2022 16:44

Clymene · 23/05/2022 16:33

I think you have rose tinted glasses on. My grandparents didn't do any childcare and I'm nearly 60.

I’m 50. My grandparents didn’t do childcare either, both sets lived over an hour away anyway, but DM was a SAHM until she got a part time job when we were well into primary school. This was also the case with most school friends mums too tbh so grandparents weren’t needed for childcare.

I didn’t have any family childcare, the odd day or overnight stay for an appointment or wedding but not a regular occurrence, DM lived an hour away (older PIL even further away) & DM worked full time anyway.

At school pick up for my DC I can only think of 2 GP who did regular childcare so not the norm for our DC’s friends either.

user1474315215 · 23/05/2022 16:44

SunshinePie · 23/05/2022 16:35

I think it should be an extended family thing, I’ve already let my children know when/if they have kids I will be there at their beck and call to help out! I know what it’s like to struggle with no family help, and I wouldn’t want my kids to suffer the way I have.

I agree completely. I love being closely involved in the lives of my DGC and made it clear to my DC that they should always feel free to ask. I'm very conscious of not interfering, but I get far more satisfaction from our close family bonds than I would from any other retirement activities.

sunshinesupermum · 23/05/2022 16:43

As a single grandmother in my 70s I no longer have the stamina to cope with my 9 and 6 year old grandsons! I wish I did
However I don't think today's parents should have the expectation that we should look after their children other than in an emergency. The days of a village bringing up children are mostly in the past.

BiscoffSundae · 23/05/2022 16:43

I’m a single mum to 4, my mum never has my children ever. I must admit to feeling a bit jealous of those who have involved parents and get lots of help

Knittingnanny2 · 23/05/2022 16:43

We do both!
seriously though it’s completely down to personal choice. Everyone is different. I absolutely love spending time with my grandchildren, either a school pick up, an icecream at the beach, come round to play for a couple of hours, babysit sometimes. I do one day a week childcare for one of them.
Big but though, they never take advantage, always have a back up for the days childcare if we are on holiday, Ill etc. And I’m able to be honest with the parents if I’m finding it too much.
In contrast my parents and in-laws turned down any and every small ( think half hour whilst I went to the dentist) request as “ we’ve done our bit”. That did make me a bit disappointed if I’m honest and made me determined to help out at difficult times if I could.
I think it’s given me a closer relationship with them than mine had with their grandparents if I’m honest. I hope my grandchildren look back with good memories.
Mind you, I don’t subscribe in any way to the mumsnet view I often read on here that parenting ends the day they turn 18!

Sswhinesthebest · 23/05/2022 16:42

Mine didn’t want to commit to regular childcare but were happy to help with one offs or emergency care.
I plan to do the same.

SemperIdem · 23/05/2022 16:41

I voted YANBU because it is nice if grandparents want to help out.

But they shouldn’t be expected to and if they fancy taking a cruise when they usually help out, that should be accepted with grace and enthusiasm.

I’m very lucky that my parents help out (parental grandparents are deceased) but they also go on holidays whenever they wish to etc because that is their right. They’re grandparents who enjoy spending time with their grandchild, not unpaid, uncontracted child care.

yesthatisdrizzle · 23/05/2022 16:41

'It takes a village to raise a child' is one of my least favourite sayings. In my experience, most often used by smug busybody relatives who take great pleasure in telling you what you're doing wrong.

In any case, how many of us spend our lives in a small community surrounded by extended family and friends these days?

LifeExperience · 23/05/2022 16:40

As a grandmother, I love watching my grand child but feel no obligation to do so. Nor should I. The obligation to raise a child rests entirely with the mom and dad who conceived him/her. I'm older now and have less energy than I did when mine were young, something that younger people fail to realize about us older folks. To use your example, caring for a child is NOT like a cruise. Cruises have down time, someone else cooks and cleans for you, and you can be as active or inactive as you wish. Motherhood is relentless, and most women my age simply don't have the physical resources to take care of children for hours and hours at a time.

Pettypettypatty · 23/05/2022 16:40

My mother and my DH parents have never helped with childcare. They were young when our children were born,lived close to us, PIL are a 3 minute walk away, mil never worked and my own mother worked very part time hours. I don't agree with the comment that "grandparents have done their bit". Mil had so much help from her own mother when she was rearing her children as did my own mother.

When the time comes if either set of parents needs help in their old age they can sort themselves out. My priority will be myself my DH and our children.

Noisyprat · 23/05/2022 16:39

I think there has been a long standing expectation that women would help with childcare. My GPs were a 2 hour drive away but I remember my mother moaning that they did a lot of childcare for her sister's children.

I think now that women are working, often up to retirement, are comparatively 'younger' and often have more disposable income as well as travel being a lot easier, many are still living their lives when their children are having children.

I don't think it's a case of should help nor should it be an expectation that they help, I think it's up to the individual. That said I do think that if, as a grandparent, you don't want to get involved/help at all you cannot expect your children to help you in your old age. IMO the support network works both ways.

breatheintheamazing · 23/05/2022 16:38

I didn't have children to then set them adrift in their adult years. I absolutely will help if I can. My mother has helped a lot through the years for me - MIL on the other hand not seen her for dust. I think it does depend on the type of parent you are

ClocksGoingBackwards · 23/05/2022 16:38

I don’t there’s any ‘should’ about it, it all depends on individual circumstances, wants and needs.

In years gone by families were more likely to have mothers that didn’t work outside the home and if they did it was part time, and everyone had their children younger so grandparents were younger and more capable of running around after little ones.

Kindofcrunchy · 23/05/2022 16:38

I've got a 2.5 yo and my retired parents help me with him every day, pick him up from nursery, look after him one morning a week while i work, plus more. I do have a chronic condition but they seem to enjoy helping and say it gives their lives meaning... So that's the flip side. I think it depends on your circumstances tbh.

drpet49 · 23/05/2022 16:38

There shouldn’t be an expectation. But I don’t know any Grandparents who have never helped babysit or with childcare.