Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Should grandparents help out with grandchildren?

187 replies

Magicfeet11 · 23/05/2022 16:27

I've always been of the school of thought that DH and I chose to have our children so looking after them was 100% our job and we shouldn't have any expectation of family to help. All of our parents are retired and we felt they were entitled to freedom to enjoy their retirement rather than stuck helping us out.

Added to that the fact we live a couple of hours drive from each side of the family so much support would have been impractical anyway.

We've always paid for full time childcare, arranged babysitters for the odd night out and generally muddled through illnesses etc between us. It's been ok but both working full time throughout has presented some challenges - we're tired most of the time, have been at breaking point on occasion and enjoy life much less than we used to pre kids.

Then I was reading an article today about having children and how it takes a village to raise them. Lots of the comments were about what it used to to be like before the nuclear family when extended families all lived in close proximity to each other and the kids would be in and out of grandparents and aunts houses and there'd always be someone to watch your kids for an hour if you needed to run an errand etc.
It really got me thinking. Before the baby boomer generation (our parents) presumably there just wasn't an expectation of a long and affluent retirement? Presumably when you retired you just expected to stay at home and help out with the family?
Therefore, have I been wrong all along and actually I shouldn't have felt so reticent to ask for free help from family? My mum made clear she didn't want to help but my MIL has always been willing yet I've always felt guilty about letting her even do bath time and bedtime because I've felt like it makes me look like I'm skiving/shirking my responsibilities...

YABU - grandparents should be off on world cruises rather than getting involved with babysitting grandchildren

YANBU - it does take a village and it's nice when grandparents ease the load by doing the odd bit of babysitting etc

OP posts:
larkstar · 23/05/2022 17:41

It's a badly phrased AIBU question IMHO. Both are true. GP's aren't under any obligation to do anything - it's nice if they want to much in and enjoy the GCs but they should be off trying to make the most of their own lives - having overly involved GP's can be smothering.

SnackSizeRaisin · 23/05/2022 17:38

Also I wouldn't promise your mother that she won't have to go into a home. It's a full time job looking after someone with dementia. Like a 3 month old baby only much heavier and lasting potentially years rather than a few months. It will ruin your life for the time that you do it.

OberthursGrizzledSkipper · 23/05/2022 17:38

I'm nearly 60. DM's parents lived 2 hours away so although we saw them as often as we could they weren't around to babysit. DF's parents lived relatively locally and grudgingly watched me for an hour on a Saturday between my dance class finishing and my dad picking me up. That was only for a couple of terms and even then I had to walk to their house.

DM only worked over Christmas so she didn't need daycare for us, but as someone else said we weren't sitting at home anyway. We were out in the street or in the park or elsewhere. Care was pretty much benign neglect.

As for the it takes a village. I don't think that means what you think it means. We grew up in an area where we also went to school and church. Everyone knew all the children, where they lived and who their parents were. If you were up to no good, not only would the neighbours tell you off, but they'd also report on you to your parents. Similarly if you were in trouble you could always find a known adult to help you. There were eyes and ears everywhere.

My parents retired at 60 and my ILs at 65. Chances are we are stuck at work until 67 so we won't be able to help out with childcare.

bigbluebus · 23/05/2022 17:36

I'm 58 with older siblings. My parents didn't get any childcare help - they didn't live near either set of my Grandparents. Baby sitters were hired and paid for. My DM didn't work so childcare wasn't needed. But my parents also didn't do any care for their parents.

My parents/ILS only helped us out in emergencies as they also didn't live near to us. My DM and my FIL both needed care but this was in the form of paid carers in their homes. DF died suddenly so didn't ever need care and MIL is still going strong at 94 and will undoubtedly pay for her own care if/when needed.

I don't think free childcare should be expected but neither do I think expecting your offspring to provide care for you in your old age should be a given. I'm not sure much has changed.

CaptainMyCaptain · 23/05/2022 17:35

I often look after mine but it is my choice and I always wanted to be involved.

Bluevelvetsofa · 23/05/2022 17:35

I always said that I would help to look after my grandchildren. When they were small, I worked full time, so it was evening and weekend babysitting. When I worked part time, I shared collecting from school and nursery with other grandparents. I’ve had them to stay for weekends, overnight and once for ten days.

They’re teenagers now and don’t need looking after and to be honest, we’re that much older and have less energy. It certainly isn’t a question of cruising holidays, although we do a bit of gardening.

IncompleteSenten · 23/05/2022 17:35

Should is the wrong word. It gives the impression they have some sort of enforceable obligation.

It would be nice if family wanted to help each other out as much as they were able.

Magicfeet11 · 23/05/2022 17:34

lemmein · 23/05/2022 17:28

It's not really about grand'parents' though is it OP? When people talk about GP's helping with childcare, they really mean grandmothers. Even in your OP you don't mention your DCs GF's.

Females are expected to help out with younger siblings in their teens, then they do the majority of the childcare for their own children, then are expected to look after their grandchildren, presumably until the sweet release of death 🙄

Why do we assume that women have fuck all else better to do (or god forbid do nothing) than raise other peoples kids?

Blimey this is a tough rap! I didn't mention them because one is dead and the other cleared off 25 years ago never to be seen again!

OP posts:
Kite22 · 23/05/2022 17:34

Like others, I think your parameters are not true.
I haven't voted, as the question, the OP, the title, etc all don't match up.

So - title : No, there is no "should" about it....suggesting YABU
But end of your opening post, I'm much closer to YANBU, in that it is nice if Grandparents do some babysitting occasionally and help out if they can.
That is a million miles from childcare though.
Plus, as has been said, there are many different circumstances, and I don't think many of us have parents who spend their whole retirement cruising the world (or certainly not anyone I know).
I also think you are confusing the expression about it "taking a village to raise a child". That isn't about Grandparents, but is about 'community' IMO. Again, it isn't about regular childcare.

I also agree with pp that there is some mythical view about "a time" when all adult dc lived in close proximity to parents and siblings and Grandparents all looked after the Grandchildren. Again, circumstances have always been as different from each other as they are now.

Waxonwaxoff0 · 23/05/2022 17:33

Benjispruce4 · 23/05/2022 17:26

I’d vote a bit of both. It’s not fair that they take on full time childcare but it’s nice when they help out with sleepovers and babysitting. Mine are grown now but they had a lovely relationship with DM who picked them up from scratch one day a week and babysat occasionally. She was also the only person I was happy with them sleeping over when they were under 10.

This basically. There's a line between a bit of help and taking the piss. My mum takes DS to school and picks him up one day a week. And she'll babysit on a weekend the odd time if there's something I really want to do, that occurs 3 or 4 times a year.

Crankley · 23/05/2022 17:32

Before the baby boomer generation (our parents) presumably there just wasn't an expectation of a long and affluent retirement? Presumably when you retired you just expected to stay at home and help out with the family?

Not the case. Back in 1950, life expectancy was approx 68. So if they retired at 60, most expected only a couple of years before they died.

I was a child of the late 40s/50s and have no recollection of being cared for much by my grandparents apart from offs.

WhatHaveIFound · 23/05/2022 17:30

It should be the grandparent's choice. It's been nice to have help but has not been expected. My children's lives have been better for having spent lot of time with and having a very close relationship with my MIL and we have older friends who are part of their lives too. I feel my own parents miss out on this but it's their choice.

Holly60 · 23/05/2022 17:29

I don't know of any friends of mine who AREN'T helping out with their grandchildren. It's so tough for parents these days, and we all love the kiddos (adult and little ones) so we do it because it's a joy

lemmein · 23/05/2022 17:28

It's not really about grand'parents' though is it OP? When people talk about GP's helping with childcare, they really mean grandmothers. Even in your OP you don't mention your DCs GF's.

Females are expected to help out with younger siblings in their teens, then they do the majority of the childcare for their own children, then are expected to look after their grandchildren, presumably until the sweet release of death 🙄

Why do we assume that women have fuck all else better to do (or god forbid do nothing) than raise other peoples kids?

ChrisReasBathEggs · 23/05/2022 17:28

No it shouldn't be expected, but grandparents shouldn't moan if they don't have a good bond with the grandchildren because they don't get to see them much, and they shouldn't expect parents who work full time to give up their weekend each week so they can see the grandkids (which if it is anything like mine, consists of shopping and errands for some of it anyway). I think for most people they have a good arrangement, but I think you do get the odd occasion where one party expects too much of the other.

Benjispruce4 · 23/05/2022 17:27

School not scratch

Benjispruce4 · 23/05/2022 17:26

I’d vote a bit of both. It’s not fair that they take on full time childcare but it’s nice when they help out with sleepovers and babysitting. Mine are grown now but they had a lovely relationship with DM who picked them up from scratch one day a week and babysat occasionally. She was also the only person I was happy with them sleeping over when they were under 10.

SnackSizeRaisin · 23/05/2022 17:25

I think you should let them help you if they offer. And it's fine to ask as well although it should remain their choice. We don't have much help due to where we live. But I will ask occasionally and they will help if they can.

The village thing is long past now. Life then was much harder, there was much more manual labour. People died younger, those surviving were not necessarily in good health. Childcare standards were not the same, children were expected to work from age 5 and left to get on with it the rest of the time. Any help with childcare would be in exchange for the younger fitter mother taking on heavy chores such as laundry or farming or other work and financially supporting the older generation.

Getting regular help from grandparents with nothing in exchange as many seem to have now would not have happened.

In previous generations people who were too old to work had no income so would have been supported by the younger generation or gone into the workhouse.

There was a brief period in the last few decades when many older women didn't work and got a pension so had the freedom to offer help without any material reward

AhNowTed · 23/05/2022 17:24

wolfiemutt · 23/05/2022 17:11

how on earth people can expect them to give up their own jobs/pension additions, etc to look after their children for free is quite selfish and entitled imo.

Does anyone actually expect that though?

Oh yes!!

Have a read of this, it's shocking

So worried and just want to keep the peace 😥 http://www.mumsnet.com/Talk/amiibeingunreasonable/4321209-So-worried-and-just-want-to-keep-the-peace

LivingNextDoorToNorma · 23/05/2022 17:23

I don’t think ‘it takes a village’ means that grandparents, should ‘help out’ with grandchildren. I think it more means that everyone who comes into regular contact with a child, plays a role in shaping who they are.

My mil doesn’t provide regular childcare (although she would always help if we needed her). But she was here this morning rocking and singing to my 4 month old, while she and I had coffee. She is an important and wonderful part of our village. My mum works full time, she doesn’t have the time (or energy) to provide regular childcare. But spend a few hours every other Saturday all together.

‘It takes a village’ is more than that, though. It’s the TA who took her time to really get to know my eldest, and made all the difference to him starting school. It’s the lady who cuts his hair, who lets him talk her ear off every time he has a trim. It my husband’s friend, who always has a random superhero fact to reel off when we see him. It’s our neighbour who lets him stroke her dog when we meet her out walking.

The old school village (in and out of each other’s houses etc) doesn’t really exist anymore, simply because our lifestyles have changed. But the people positively influencing our children are still there, they just aren’t necessarily doing so by babysitting.

Magicfeet11 · 23/05/2022 17:21

orangeisthenewpuce · 23/05/2022 17:09

Some grandparents, like myself, love looking after grandchildren and being involved in their lives. If your MIL has offered to help she might be very happy when you take her up on the offer and let her do bedtime etc. Another point is not all of us baby boomers have affluent retirements. Don't believe everything you read in the press.

Thank you for this, it's good advice. She often offers and I've recently started taking her up on it a bit more. She seems to really enjoy spending time with the kids and even said she'd have them overnight for us if we wanted to go away etc. Don't think she'd offer if she didn't genuinely want to would she?

OP posts:
Mary46 · 23/05/2022 17:20

No never had help. My friend was say son expects alot help now thats not fair either. We help our mam. But have our own families too so people should be realistic....

Hbh17 · 23/05/2022 17:20

You absolutely have a choice with your mother and are under no obligation to care for her. This is regardless of any help she may or may not give with your children. I suggest your time would be well spent in learning to say "no"!

AhNowTed · 23/05/2022 17:19

The odd bit of babysitting sure.

Regular childcare absolutely not.

Ponderingwindow · 23/05/2022 17:17

if grandparents can help out occasionally, that can make life easier for the parents and provide a good opportunity for bonding with the grandchildren. The emphasis there is on occasionally. That shouldn’t interfere with grandparents living full lives. The occasional night of babysitting or helping out in an emergency is very different than providing regular all day care so the parents can work without paying for child care.