Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Should grandparents help out with grandchildren?

187 replies

Magicfeet11 · 23/05/2022 16:27

I've always been of the school of thought that DH and I chose to have our children so looking after them was 100% our job and we shouldn't have any expectation of family to help. All of our parents are retired and we felt they were entitled to freedom to enjoy their retirement rather than stuck helping us out.

Added to that the fact we live a couple of hours drive from each side of the family so much support would have been impractical anyway.

We've always paid for full time childcare, arranged babysitters for the odd night out and generally muddled through illnesses etc between us. It's been ok but both working full time throughout has presented some challenges - we're tired most of the time, have been at breaking point on occasion and enjoy life much less than we used to pre kids.

Then I was reading an article today about having children and how it takes a village to raise them. Lots of the comments were about what it used to to be like before the nuclear family when extended families all lived in close proximity to each other and the kids would be in and out of grandparents and aunts houses and there'd always be someone to watch your kids for an hour if you needed to run an errand etc.
It really got me thinking. Before the baby boomer generation (our parents) presumably there just wasn't an expectation of a long and affluent retirement? Presumably when you retired you just expected to stay at home and help out with the family?
Therefore, have I been wrong all along and actually I shouldn't have felt so reticent to ask for free help from family? My mum made clear she didn't want to help but my MIL has always been willing yet I've always felt guilty about letting her even do bath time and bedtime because I've felt like it makes me look like I'm skiving/shirking my responsibilities...

YABU - grandparents should be off on world cruises rather than getting involved with babysitting grandchildren

YANBU - it does take a village and it's nice when grandparents ease the load by doing the odd bit of babysitting etc

OP posts:
2Rebecca · 23/05/2022 19:10

Most adults I know move away from their parents so it's an academic question. My parents lived 3 hours away from their parents, my dad is now 8h away inlaws 1 hour. Children are 1-7 hours away.
Most people I know are also still working in their 50s and 60s

GoodThinkingMax · 23/05/2022 19:09

No but they should really.

Why @anotherNCsorryfolks ?

whumpthereitis · 23/05/2022 19:07

I don’t think you can judge it by previous generations. The world has changed, people live longer, have more opportunities, and more expectations.

Imo there’s no should about it. If grandparents want to help then that’s one thing, but there should be no expectation.

GoodThinkingMax · 23/05/2022 19:06

I know a lady whose in her 70s and had her 3 grandchildren (baby, pre schooler and primary age) 5 days a week.

My mother had my Brother & SiL's two primary aged DC 3 days a week after school till around 7pm for 2 years at age 75. My brother worked crazy hours and my SiL didn't work, but isn't good at coping. My mother aged considerably in that time.

I still haven't really forgiven my B & SiL for exploiting my mother that way. My SiL used to say how much my mother "loved it" - but my SiL has known my mother about 8 years at that time whereas I'd known my mother for 50. She was doing it partly to keep my SiL happy, and to help my brother in a tricky marriage. My SiL oblivious to all of this ...

DogsAndGin · 23/05/2022 19:04

No. I don’t think there should be any expectation for anyone other than the parents to look after their children. The grandparents should be free to go and live their lives without having to be childminders into their old age.

Also, remember, the more responsibility you give to the grandparents, the more rights they’ll feel to impose their way of doing things. Personally, I’d rather be left to make my own decisions and my own arrangements.

dammit88 · 23/05/2022 19:02

Im not sure how much help you can expect if you live a couple of hours away to be honest. Its a long way to travel for an evenings babysitting. You sound like you think you are hard done by but id say its normal if you are a couple of hours from each other that babysitting is a bit impractical. it is very lucky your MIL is happy to with such a journey really.

cptartapp · 23/05/2022 18:55

My DM didn't particularly want to help with childcare. So we paid for most of it.
I wouldn't want to provide elder care either. That's what her life savings were for.
No one beholden to anyone doing things they don't want. Everybody happy.

BestDove · 23/05/2022 18:48

We get zero help from grandparents. I’m really bitter about it 😂 My very lucky sister has an amazing MIL who loves having my niece for a weekend every month, as well as ad hoc days/afternoons/sleepovers.

On the plus side, I have zero intention of doing any elder care. MIL frequently “jokes” about moving into our annexe. My thought “like fuck is that ever happening. You’ve enjoyed your early retirement in perfect peace and looking out for just yourself, you won’t be spoiling mine”!!!

Actually I want to be exactly like my sister’s MIL. She’s awesome and super helpful to my sister. Hopefully I can be exactly like that for my DC and their children 😊

morescrummythanyummy · 23/05/2022 18:46

And btw that wasn't a dig at women daring to work. More a recognition that my mum was lucky to have several friends she knew well enough to entrust her kids to.

I think that the better solution to expecting your network to look after your kids is to live in an enlightened country that ensures that generous parental leave is available for both parents and good quality childcare is provided.

MaggieFS · 23/05/2022 18:45

I haven't RTFT but don't forget for our parents' generation, their mothers almost certainly had to give up work upon marriage or having children so the grandparents helping out weren't elderly nor having to choose between work or helping out.

Peonyperfect · 23/05/2022 18:44

orangeisthenewpuce · 23/05/2022 17:09

Some grandparents, like myself, love looking after grandchildren and being involved in their lives. If your MIL has offered to help she might be very happy when you take her up on the offer and let her do bedtime etc. Another point is not all of us baby boomers have affluent retirements. Don't believe everything you read in the press.

Absolutely this. I love my grandchildren and I think we all benefit from the relationship. The only drawback for us as grandparents is the loss of stamina that comes with advancing age.

Remainiac · 23/05/2022 18:43

I have two pre-school DGC who I adore. I also have a full-on full-time professional job. I’d love to do more childcare for them, but as it stands my DS and DDIL know that I will babysit evenings and weekends whenever asked, will have them overnight and would drop everything to help out if they were stuck because their arrangements fell through /illness/whatever. I’m fairly senior so wouldn’t have any issues at work if I had to step in at short notice.
What I can’t do is commit to cutting down my working hours to do, say, one day a week childcare because I can’t afford that. At this stage in my career, I need to boost my pension as much as possible and I still have a mortgage.
DDiL’s mum is in the same position and she’s a bit older than me.

morescrummythanyummy · 23/05/2022 18:40

Hmmm, well I read the article that you are talking about and I wouldn't say I totally agree with her. She seemed to think that the ideal number of adults with a newborn was 4 or 5 when her husband was on leave, which seems too many to me as someone who quite liked it with me and my husband with occasional visitors when he was on leave. And just a couple of weeks ago she wrote an article that was very close to "I don't know why anyone moans about motherhood, it has been a breeze and they should shut up, apart from breastfeeding". I think she is still realising that actually the truth is that everyone's experiences of every part of motherhood (birth, recovery, feeding, loneliness, sleep etc etc) are on a spectrum depending on their circumstances - some things are better than expected, some worse, but you can't really compare with anyone else. And that the situation can change from week to week. I do agree with her that, yes, childcare is ruinously expensive.

But to your question, I don't think grandparents should be obliged to provide childcare. My mum's mum did occasional babysitting for us growing up and my dad's parents didn't bother, their choice (though we were closer to mum's side as a result). My mum's mum gave up her job when my aunt's husband left her with two kids (and was totally absent after that) and looked after my cousins - I think even as a child I could see that this wasn't a brilliant nirvana for all concerned; my grandmother didn't really have the energy for consistency and boundaries with young kids and really wanted to do the fun stuff without the responsibility. There was definitely a period where the kids ran riot. It's all turned out fine in the end though and both kids were well loved by two loving parental figures.

The key difference in my childhood was that fewer women worked or worked full time, so my mum was able to do a childcare swap with friends when my sister was small and I was at school. So she had 4 kids one afternoon after preschool and then 3 days off. Standards were lower then in terms of car seats etc....

Borisblondboufant · 23/05/2022 18:37

No. But there’s now a definite divide between those getting help and those not.
I have a neighbour who looks after her GC, which she wants to do. But it’s the only time she sees them. As they get older and they need to use her less (and it’s already happening) and she becomes not useful I wonder what will happen.

TypicallyTopically · 23/05/2022 18:36

I know a lady whose in her 70s and had her 3 grandchildren (baby, pre schooler and primary age) 5 days a week. Dropping them off all over and doing activities. You will not find me doing that. I think I'd like to do semi regular childcare and would offer to give breaks but regular ie certain day each week no.

again2020 · 23/05/2022 18:32

No, but it's nice if they do.
My parents made it clear they didn't want to help with grandchildren long before I had DD. My father has no patience with children- to be honest he never really did- and they want to enjoy retirement and holidays.
In my group of friends they definitely are in the minority and it does make me sad that lots of kids go to grandma for a sleepover or after school for tea when DD doesn't. It's a definite factor in why she will be an only, and I'd like to think if I ever became a grandparent I'd do things differently.

GoodThinkingMax · 23/05/2022 18:24

I think the whole “In the past …” is a dig at women daring to have jobs and careers nowadays.

I think your OP needs to be quite sex- specific. It’s not “people” or “grandparents” so much as “women” and “grandmothers.”

and I’ve been quite shocked at the animosity shown by some MN posters towards their mothers/MiLs for not offering to do childcare.

ButtockUp · 23/05/2022 18:18

This question pops up frequently.
I suspect it's to do with the fact that childcare is so very expensive whereas 'in the olden days' women didn't need childcare or much of it.

Up until 80s it was ' normal' to stay at home when you had children.
Mortgages were based on the wage earner.. usually a man.. and it would have been 3 times his salary.
Women, rightly, complained that it was sexist to assume this and so banks were forced to include a woman's salary.
Result... much higher mortgages were offered , hence, extortionate rise in house prices.

DarleneSnell · 23/05/2022 17:56

I believe that ‘doing my bit’ as a mother also extends to supporting my children in raising their own children - my grandchildren

I agree with this. Luckily my mum does too, as did both sets of MY grandparents when I was young. I'll do the same for my kids if I can, and so it goes on.

I think there's a spectrum to this question. There's a huge difference between fixed, frequent, reliant childcare, and "now and then" to give parents a hand. And lots in between. Also whether a GP is physically able and/or available.

My ILs are able, retired, local and NEVER help. Not even as a one-off for an hour, they literally avoid at all costs. I accept that's their prerogative so we don't ask anymore - but tbh it'll impact the effort I'll make for them as they age, and their relationship with the DC compared to my parents.

lemmein · 23/05/2022 17:48

Blimey this is a tough rap! I didn't mention them because one is dead and the other cleared off 25 years ago never to be seen again!

It's not just this thread OP; every single time it comes up on here it's 'is my DM out of order for not wanting to look after my children?' I've been on here for years and have never seen any criticism of grandfathers, not once, there's just no expectation there.

My post probably sounded more hostile than I intended, I apologise, I've probably been guilty of the same in the past (not asking my DF or FIL to babysit - mainly cos they're both wankers Grin) I just feel for all those knackered GMs feeling guilty because they don't want to look after all their children's offspring 40+ hours a week.

I look after my GS 3 times a week - I genuinely love it and have a close relationship with him, but I'm in my 40s, I can't imagine doing it in my 60s, 70s like some on here expect.

ICanSmellSummerComing · 23/05/2022 17:44

Of course.we.cant presume and expect people to do things for us

But my goodness! I will certainly help out my DC if they want me too.i would only do what I can , I would see it as an honour.

anotherNCsorryfolks · 23/05/2022 17:43

No but they should really.

I'd kill to have a break from DC. I haven't had a night to myself in four years. Nobody offers to have them not even DA or DU even though I'll have DNS to stay! 🤯

Can you tell this is a touchy subject? 😂

Pleasegodgotosleep · 23/05/2022 17:42

Should be up to GP not assumed but should be consistent across all grandkids. Not always helping some but not others....

Soontobe60 · 23/05/2022 17:41

I believe that ‘doing my bit’ as a mother also extends to supporting my children in raising their own children - my grandchildren. Im lucky in that I don’t live too far away, so can look after them one day a week. It gives me great pleasure and I think has enabled us to have a great relationship with them.

Magicfeet11 · 23/05/2022 17:41

SnackSizeRaisin · 23/05/2022 17:38

Also I wouldn't promise your mother that she won't have to go into a home. It's a full time job looking after someone with dementia. Like a 3 month old baby only much heavier and lasting potentially years rather than a few months. It will ruin your life for the time that you do it.

I don't know how I can do it anyway with young children, a full time job and living 2 hours away. How do people manage?

OP posts: